Hades / Sheol

The Hebrew, Latin, Ge’ez and Greek that is often translated in English as “Hades” or “Sheol” is translated in the German Luther Bible 2017 (and pre-1912) as Totenreich or “realm (or: kingdom) of the dead” in these verses. (Source: Jost Zetzsche)

In Chuj it is translated as “among the dead,” in San Mateo Del Mar Huave as “the place where are the dead,” and in Coatlán Mixe as “the grave.” (Source for this and above: Viola Waterhouse in Notes on Translation August 1966, p. 86ff.)

Learn more on Bible Odyssey: Sheol .

complete verse (Ecclesiastes 9:10)

Following are a number of back-translations as well as a sample translation for translators of Ecclesiastes 9:10:

  • Kupsabiny: “When a person still has the chance let him do what he is able to do with all his might because when a person has gone to the grave, there is nothing more that he can think of to do. Knowledge and wisdom have died/ended.” (Source: Kupsabiny Back Translation)
  • Newari: “Whatever work you have in your hand, do it with all your might, for when you go to the world of the dead there will be neither any work to do nor plans to make, there will be neither insight nor wisdom.” (Source: Newari Back Translation)
  • Hiligaynon: “Do whatever you (sing.) are-doing with your (sing.) capability, for there in the place of the dead-ones, where you (sing.) are-going, there is no work anymore. There is no planning there too, and there is also no wisdom or knowledge.” (Source: Hiligaynon Back Translation)
  • English: “Whatever you are able to do, do it with all your energy, because some time you will die, and in the place of the dead where you are going, no one works or plans to do anything or knows anything or is wise.” (Source: Translation for Translators)

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 9:10

The third imperative do it urges readers to get on with the task of living and working enthusiastically.

Whatever your hand finds to do is placed first, before the imperative, for emphasis. The phrase finds to do is an idiom for being able to do something, as in 1 Sam 10.7. Whatever means “everything.” Qoheleth uses the noun phrase your hand to mean “you.” He is thinking not only of what a person can do using the hands, but of all that can be done in general. We can translate as “whatever you are able to do.” Good News Translation “whatever you do” lacks the sense of being able to do things. New American Bible is close to the Hebrew with an English idiom, “anything you can turn your hand to.” Similar idioms may exist in other languages. In some cases such general statements are expressed in conditional clauses: “If you have some thing to do, do it….”

Do it with your might calls for intense and enthusiastic action. The adverbial phrase with your might is literally “by [or, with] your strength” and means the use of all your energies, intellectual and physical. Both aspects are found in the examples that follow. We can express its meaning as “Whatever you are able to do, do it wholeheartedly.” The translator should be able to find an idiomatic expression to indicate this wholeheartedness.

For there is no work or thought or knowledge or wisdom in Sheol: this statement turns us back to verse 5, where it is noted that the dead “know nothing.” The motive for working energetically is that after death there are no further opportunities for work. This reminds us again of how work is central to Qoheleth’s definition of a meaningful life. Once in Sheol, four things are no longer possible. These are introduced by the negative “there is no….” The first is described by the term work. Though in other examples this is a general term, in this context it probably has a narrower meaning, referring to the kind of work the wise person did. However, in translation the general term “work” can also be used.

Thought is similar to what the philosopher does. See comments on 7.25, where the same word is translated “the sum of things.” New American Bible uses “reason.” We can also say “drawing logical conclusions” or “making logical deductions.” Knowledge is the term for “information,” while wisdom is the standard term for what the wise men taught.

These last three nouns summarize the concerns of the wise. Although Hebrew uses nouns here, each is actually an activity, so verbs can be used in our translation. If we take this approach we will have to name the agent: “the dead…” or “dead people….” We can render the sense as “For the dead don’t work, they don’t think things through, they don’t gather information, nor do they hand on the teachings of the wise….”

In Sheol: the Old Testament speaks of a person going down after death “to Sheol,” the place of departed spirits; see, for example, Psa 88.3-4. Sheol is also known as “the Pit,” “Abaddon,” “the grave,” “the land of forgetfulness,” “the darkness” (see Psa 88.11-12). Translators may have trouble translating the idea here if there is a clash of ideas between their world-view and the broad biblical understanding. Good News Translation suggests “the world of the dead,” while New American Bible has “the netherworld.” Both are alternatives to borrowing the Hebrew term “Sheol” in our translation, as Revised Standard Version does. Another possible solution is to avoid all reference to both the place and the name, and refer directly to death itself by saying “after death” or “after you die.” (In this case some adjustment may be needed in the next clause also.)

To which you are going is a reminder to the living that there is only one destination toward which every living being is moving. The use of the Hebrew participle going and the ending on the Hebrew adverb translated “there” stress this movement toward death or the place of the dead. We can use the verb “to head for” or some such verb expressing movement.

Revised Standard Version reflects the Hebrew order of clauses in this part of the verse, which has quite a dramatic effect. However, in other languages it may be much more effective to change this order; for example,

• Because in Sheol, where you are going, there’s no more working, no more reasoning, no more knowing, no more being wise!

• For in the place of the dead, nobody works, they don’t think, they aren’t wise, they don’t know anything—and that is where you’re headed!

New Jerusalem Bible provides another acceptable model for the whole verse:

• Whatever it is in your power to do, do with all your might. For there is no action, no reasoning, no learning, no wisdom in Sheol, where you are going.

As a further alternative we can suggest:

• So everything that you are able to do, do it with all your heart, because where you’re headed, you will not be able to do anything—to think, to find out anything, or to become wise.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

SIL Translator’s Notes on Ecclesiastes 9:10

9:10a Whatever you find to do with your hands, do it with all your might,

Whatever you decide to do, do your absolute best,
-or-
Every time you find work to do, do it the best you can. (English Easy-to-Read Version)

9:10b for in Sheol, where you are going,

because you will ⌊eventually⌋ be in the grave.
-or-
One day you will die and you will go into your grave. (EEB)

9:10c there is no work or planning or knowledge or wisdom.

There you will not be able to work or plan ahead. Your knowledge and wisdom will not ⌊be useful to you then⌋ .
-or-
Then it will not be possible for you to work. You will not think about future events. You will not know anything. (EASY2015)

© 2006 by SIL International®
Made available under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License (CC BY-SA) creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0.
All Scripture quotations in this publication, unless otherwise indicated, are from The Holy Bible, Berean Standard Bible.
BSB is produced in cooperation with Bible Hub, Discovery Bible, OpenBible.com, and the Berean Bible Translation Committee.

Commentaire sur la traduction de l'Ecclésiaste 9.10

Malgré la note négative du Ecc 9.9 concernant les activités humaines sur terre, ce verset encourage le travail dur et consciencieux. En hébreu le complément d’objet Tout ce que ta main trouve et le circonstant de manière se placent avant le verbe, qui se trouve à la fin de la phrase. Les mots ta main représente la personne adressée. tout ce que ta main trouve veut dire « tout ce que tu trouves à faire », « tout ce que tu as à/dois faire », ou « Tout ce que tu fais ».

fais-le par tes propres forces : le nom כֹּחַ kôaḥ, « puissance » ou « force », est au singulier en hébreu. La Nouvelle Bible Segond suit l’ordre en hébreu : « avec ta force, fais-le ». Bien que le mot puisse parler d’un effort physique, ici il implique un engagement mental et/ou moral. On pourrait dire en français : « Fais-le avec tout ton cœur ». La La Bible du Semeur dit « Fais-le avec l’énergie que tu as ». La Bible en français courant inverse l’ordre dans ces propositions, en commençant par l’impératif, « Utilise ta force à réaliser… » mais l’ordre en hébreu Tout ce que ta main trouve…, conviendra dans bien des langues.

La dernière explication de cette section Ecc 9.7 commence par la conjonction כִּי kî, rendue comme car dans la Traduction œcuménique de la Bible et Parole de Vie et « en effet » dans la Bible en français courant. L’idée ici est similaire à celle énoncée en Ecc 9.5, car le verset parle du séjour des morts où toute activité cesse. Qohéleth fait une liste d’éléments qui ne se trouvent pas dans le Shéol : ni œuvre, ni bilan, ni savoir, ni sagesse dans le séjour des morts où tu t’en iras.

œuvre rend le participe du verbe « faire », qui pourrait parler généralement du travail ou des différentes activités. La Parole de Vie rend ce mot par une expression verbale : « Car dans le monde des morts où tu vas aller, on ne peut rien faire… »

La deuxième chose qui ne se trouve pas dans le séjour des morts, c’est חֶשְׁבּוֹן ḥèšbôn, une description de ce que fait le sage ou le philosophe. On pourrait parler de « réflexion ». La traduction de la Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, bilan, ainsi que celle de la Nouvelle Bible Segond (« raison ») ne semblent pas appropriées ici. C’est en fait l’acte de raisonner qui est en vue. Ainsi la Parole de Vie dit « on ne peut pas réfléchir ».

La troisième chose citée est la connaissance, le mot hébreu דַּעַת daʿat, que certains rendent par savoir. Le mot apparaît sept fois dans ce livre, souvent de pair avec le mot חָכְמָה ḥokmâh, sagesse. Voir Ecc 1.16. Les traducteurs devraient décider s’il faut utiliser des noms ou des expressions verbales : « On ne fait rien, on ne réfléchit pas, on ne connait rien, etc. » et comment lier ces éléments. Dans certaines langues on va formuler la phrase à partir de conjonctions négatives, comme en français, « ni œuvre, ni savoir », etc.

Bien que Qohéleth parle très souvent de la mort, c’est la seule fois dans ce livre où il parle explicitement du Shéol, שְׁאוֹל šéôl, « le séjour des morts ». Dans certaines langues on translittère le mot hébreu, mais dans plusieurs langues cet endroit est connu et a un nom, par exemple, « village des morts ». Il ne faudrait pas utiliser le nom pour « ciel » ou « paradis » utilisé dans le NT, car la conception de la vie après la mort n’est pas la même dans les deux testaments.

Source: Zogbo, Lynell. L’Ecclésiaste – Manuel de traduction – Commentaire linguistique et exégétique de la Bible. Alliance biblique universelle, 2021.