Translation commentary on Esther 9:6   

In Susa the capital refers not to the city of Susa but to the citadel (so New Jerusalem Bible, “In the fortress Shushan”; Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, New American Bible; see comment on 9.11). This verse tells that five hundred men, or “people,” were killed in the fortress of Susa on the thirteenth of Adar; and verse 15 indicates that on the fourteenth of Adar three hundred more men were killed in the unfortified lower city of Susa. In Hebrew the words “and in Susa the citadel” are in an emphatic position at the beginning of the verse. Both Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation show this emphasis with the addition of the word “itself,” that is, “in Susa the capital itself.” This emphasis anticipates the king’s question below (see comments on verse 12) and should be conveyed in translation in a way that is appropriate to the receptor language.

In keeping with the author’s stylistic use of repetition and pairs of near synonyms, this verse repeats two of the same words used in the preceding verse. There the noun forms were used. Here they occur as verbs, and Revised Standard Version faithfully translates slew and destroyed.

The Hebrew says literally that five hundred men were killed. Since the Old Testament sometimes uses “men” to include both men and women (see Exo 16.16; Deut 24.16), possibly both are meant here. “Five hundred people” as in Good News Translation and New Revised Standard Version is less specific than the Hebrew but may be correct, though nearly all translations say “five hundred men,” including Revised English Bible (see also verse 12 below).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 1:6   

The exact meaning of much of verse 6 is not clear, although it obviously emphasizes the splendor of the banquet. Not connected grammatically with the preceding verse, it is a list or catalog of items describing the royal setting.

The beginning of the verse is literally “white stuff [either cotton or linen], finely woven material [either cotton or linen], purple wool, held fast with cords of fine linen and purple wool on rings of silver and pillars of precious stone and alabaster.” The image described appears to be that purple and white curtains were used as awnings to provide shade from the sun. A descriptive phrase such as “cloths that were spread out and hung from pillars” may be used. The curtains were attached by cords to rings fastened to marble pillars.

The invited guests reclined on the couches while they ate (see Amos 6.4). The Hebrew word for “bed” sometimes refers to a mat placed on the ground and sometimes to the frame on which the mat was placed. Here it is probably the frame itself. The Persians had couches and tables of gold and silver, which may have been covered or plated with gold and silver, or which may have been made from gold and silver.

A mosaic pavement: the ground in the courtyard was paved, that is, it was covered with stones to make the surface hard and beautiful. The surface of the courtyard was a mosaic. It was made of four kinds of colored stones that were arranged in beautiful patterns or designs. Several of the Hebrew words for stones occur only here in the Old Testament, and their meaning is not certain, as the differences in translations indicate.

The first stone is called porphyry in Revised Standard Version. This is a rock that has feldspar crystals, that is, large crystal-like minerals contained within a dark red or purple mass of fine-grained rock. Good News Translation translates this stone as “red feldspar”; Revised English Bible calls it “malachite.”

The second stone is called marble in Revised Standard Version and “white marble” in Good News Translation. Marble is a form of limestone that can be cut and polished for building, or that can be carved by artists for making sculptures.

The third item in the list is apparently mother-of-pearl, which is not a stone. It is the inside of the shell of the clam that produces pearls. The inside of these shells has soft colors like a rainbow. The mother-of-pearl was probably used for making delicate patterns by being inserted into the other stones.

The fourth item also is a word of uncertain meaning. Revised Standard Version and New Jerusalem Bible simply use a generic expression, precious stones; New American Bible and New Revised Standard Version use a similar general expression, “colored stones”; Good News Translation and Revised English Bible say “blue turquoise,” a stone that is found in Persia. New Jerusalem Bible reads “mosaics.”

Even though equivalents for the various names of stones given in the different versions may be difficult to find, it is important to indicate that valuable stones of different colors were used to make a pavement, or “floor,” for the courtyard. Since the names and colors of several of these stones are not known with certainty, the translator may be advised to follow the model of Bible en français courant, which says “a mosaic of red, white, pearly, and black slabs.” In place of mosaic a technical verb such as “laying” or “finishing” a floor may be used.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 2:18   

On princes and servants see comments on 1.3.

It was Esther’s banquet: literally the Hebrew says “Esther’s banquet,” and the words are not connected grammatically with the rest of the verse. The meaning appears to be that the king “gave a banquet in Esther’s honor” (so Good News Translation, Bible en français courant, Biblia Dios Habla Hoy), not that Esther gave the banquet. Different languages will express in their own ways the idea of giving a feast in honor of someone; for example, “he did a great feast because of [or, for] her.”

He also granted a remission of taxes: the word translated as “a remission of taxes” in Revised Standard Version occurs only here in the Old Testament, and the meaning is disputed by scholars. It probably is related to an Aramaic word meaning “a causing to rest.” Though most interpreters understand the word to mean “a holiday,” that is, a rest from work (so Good News Translation, New Revised Standard Version, New American Bible, Revised English Bible), other possible meanings are “tax relief” (Revised Standard Version, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, Biblia Dios Habla Hoy), “exemption from military service” (Traduction œcuménique de la Bible margin), “amnesty” (New Jerusalem Bible and New Revised Standard Version margins), “emancipation of slaves” (New International Version margin), and “truce” (Segond). Since interpreters most often understand the meaning to be either “rest from work” or “rest from paying taxes,” translators are encouraged to choose either of these two possible meanings.

Gifts: since this same word is used in Amos 5.11 with reference to wheat or grain, in this passage it may refer to gifts of wheat. Most translations, however, take the word in the more general sense of “gifts.”

With royal liberality: the same Hebrew expression occurs in 1.7, “according to the bounty of the king.” Some translations understand this to mean that the king acted with generosity (Revised Standard Version, Bible en français courant), but it may simply mean “in royal fashion” (Traduction œcuménique de la Bible). The sentence may then be restated to read “He gave things as kings do” or “in the manner of kings.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 4:15   

Continuing the plural from verse 12, Revised Standard Version here says Esther told them. In the Hebrew the messengers are not even alluded to by pronoun reference. The Hebrew is literally “And Esther said to send to Mordecai” (see verse 13 above).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 7:9   

Good News Translation has slightly restructured the last part of verse 8 and the beginning of verse 9. Though the Hebrew introduces the eunuchs in verse 9, Good News Translation makes their presence explicit in verse 8 by indicating that it was the eunuchs who covered Haman’s head. It should be noted that verse 8 does not have an explicit subject for the verb “covered,” but Good News Translation (also Bible en français courant, Nova Tradução na Linguagem de Hoje, Biblia Dios Habla Hoy) is probably correct in assuming that these eunuchs were the persons who covered Haman’s face.

On eunuch see comments on 1.10. The Hebrew says that Harbona was one of the eunuchs who served the king, but Good News Translation says only “the eunuchs” (see verse 8), without stating whether they served the king or the queen. Translators should maintain the information that these were the eunuchs who served the king, and not those who served the queen.

Moreover: not only was Haman guilty of apparently making improper sexual advances toward the queen, he was Moreover guilty of trying to kill the very person who had saved the king’s life (see 2.21-23). Though many translations omit any word or expression that corresponds to Moreover (Revised Standard Version) or “even went so far as” (Good News Translation), the Hebrew word, which means “too, also,” shows that Harbona is providing the king with another reason why Haman should be executed (see Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). This adverb is followed by hinneh (see comments on 6.5), which emphatically introduces the information that Harbona will offer.

The translation of Revised Standard Version, the gallows … is standing in Haman’s house, fifty cubits high may seem to suggest that the gallows was inside the house. Good News Translation more correctly translates “at his house.”

On the gallows see comment on 2.23; on fifty cubits high see 5.14.

The words for Mordecai mean “in order to kill Mordecai.”

Whose word saved the king: this of course is a reference to 2.21-23. Revised Standard Version restates the original, while Good News Translation interprets in idiomatic language. Chouraqui translates quite literally, “who spoke for the good of the king.” Traduction œcuménique de la Bible says “whose word was so useful to the king.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 9:22   

This verse is full of both lexical and stylistic repetition from earlier verses. First the days are described, then the month. Next, pairs of opposites are cited in parallel clauses to describe what has taken place. Finally, referring back to their first celebrations, it is spelled out how the Jews are to fulfil the obligation placed upon them in verse 21. The verse states very explicitly the theme of reversal that is central to the book of Esther (see introduction, “Translating the Book of Esther,” A-4, page 3), that the Jews’ situation had changed from sorrow into gladness and from mourning into a holiday.

On choice portions see 9.19. Here the detail is added that they are also to send gifts to the poor, that is, to “poor people,” to “people who are in need” or “in want.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 1:18   

This very day: these words stand at the beginning of the verse in Hebrew and express the urgency of the situation. By restructuring into more natural English word order, Good News Translation seems to have lost something of this urgency.

On the identity of Persia and Media, see the comments on 1.3.

The ladies of Persia and Media in the Hebrew refers to the noblewomen (Good News Translation “the wives of the royal officials”; New Revised Standard Version “the noble ladies”) and not to women in the Persian Empire in general as in 1.17, where Gordis translates “all the ordinary womenfolk.” Though some versions translate these words rather literally as “the ladies of Persia and Media” (New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible), most versions make clear that they are “wives of the Persian and Median officers-of-state” (New Jerusalem Bible; so also Bible en français courant, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible).

This verse is difficult for interpreters, since the verb “they shall say” (will be telling) has no direct object. The Hebrew word order is literally “This very day they will say the ladies of Persia and Media who have heard of the conduct of the Queen to all the king’s princes….” Revised English Bible is quite literal here, since it gives no direct object for the verb “to quote”: “The great ladies of Persia and Media, who have heard what the queen has said, will quote this day to all the king’s officers….” While the Revised English Bible translation is literal, it is not good English; the verb “quote” normally requires an object to specify what is quoted.

Because of this grammatical difficulty, some interpreters change the Hebrew verb “they shall say” by omitting one letter so that the verb becomes “they shall rebel against [all the king’s princes]” (see New American Bible, New Revised Standard Version, and Anchor Bible). However, most versions consider the object of “they will say” to be what the wives will have heard of the Queen’s behavior (Good News Translation). Following this last interpretation, Revised Standard Version, New Jerusalem Bible and An American Translation supply the word it, referring to the Queen’s behavior, after the verb will be telling.

The contempt will be directed against the husbands by the wives, and the wrath will be directed against the wives by the husbands. Good News Translation makes explicit the agents of these two words: “Wives everywhere will have no respect for their husbands, and husbands will be angry with their wives” (see also Bible en français courant and Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible). Other interpretations are also possible: (1) New American Bible reads that the wives “will rebel against all the royal officials, with corresponding disdain and rancor.” This suggests either that both “disdain” and “rancor” are descriptive of the husbands’ attitudes, or that there will be general discord between husbands and wives (so the New English Bible [New English Bible]: “and there will be endless disrespect and insolence!”); (2) Moffatt understands both nouns to refer to the attitudes of the wives only, who are “talking proudly and petulantly.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 3:8   

In making his accusation against the Jews, Haman carefully avoids identifying them by name. This pattern of accusation without identification is repeated several times in the book of Esther until the climactic accusation by Esther of Haman (see 7.4-6).

The Jews were scattered abroad and dispersed among the peoples in all the provinces. The Jews were scattered, that is, they were living in exile.

The word dispersed is often understood as a synonym of scattered (so Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation), meaning that the Jews were separated from one another. But the Hebrew word translated as dispersed in Revised Standard Version should probably be understood to mean “separated from other peoples” (so New Revised Standard Version), meaning that the Jews did not eat with or intermarry with the Gentiles among whom they lived (also Bible en français courant). This latter interpretation is found in New American Bible, “Dispersed among the nations throughout the provinces of your kingdom, there is a certain people living apart, with laws differing from those of every other people,” and New Jerusalem Bible, “There is a certain unassimilated nation scattered among the other nations throughout the provinces of your realm.” Other models for this interpretation are “a certain people scattered and unassimilated among the peoples” (FOX) and “There is one people scattered and distinctive among the nations” (Gordis).

Provinces: see 1.1.

Their laws: Haman’s indictment of the Jews rests on their laws and the king’s laws. The laws obeyed by the Jews are different from everyone else’s, and they do not obey the king’s laws. The word for laws is the same as that found in “the laws of the Persians and the Medes” (1.19; see also 1.8, 13; 2.8) and is used for both the laws of the Jews and the king’s laws. Some versions interpret the first to be “customs” (Bible en français courant, New International Version), but this lessens the impact of the contrast presented by the author.

And they do not keep the king’s law: these words are connected to the preceding words with the conjunction and (waw), which joins together nouns and clauses. The precise function of this conjunction is often determined by the surface grammar of a passage within its context. In this instance interpreters differ on the exact relationship between this clause and the preceding clause. According to Revised Standard Version (and), the second criticism of the Jews is no more severe than the first, that is, that their laws are different (so also New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible, Bible en français courant). Good News Translation, however, understands the second clause to be a heightening of the accusation and translates the Hebrew conjunction with the word “moreover.” Similar to Good News Translation are Nova Tradução na Linguagem de Hoje and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, “but in addition.” The context is sufficiently ambiguous that translators must decide between these two interpretations without any more evidence to help make the decision.

It is not for the king’s profit to tolerate them: this means that it is of no use or of no benefit to the king to let them be. “It will not help the king” to let the Jews continue to exist as they have been, or “to let them continue living in your kingdom” (Biblia Dios Habla Hoy).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .