Translation commentary on Esther 5:10   

Nevertheless: in keeping with the events in the story, both Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation interpret the conjunction waw here as having concessive and contrastive meaning. The translator will need to translate according to the logic of the story.

Restrained himself: the Hebrew root verb expresses strength and emotion. The author depicts strong emotion on the part of Haman. The author informs the reader that Haman did not react violently to what he clearly took to be very strong provocation. Perhaps an image such as “he overcame himself,” or “he held his head,” or “he controlled his heart” may be appropriate.

Sent and fetched: Haman was a man who held authority. Whom he sent to bring his friends and his wife is not stated, nor is it clear whether his call was a simple “invitation” as Good News Translation implies, or perhaps a stronger command to come. Bible en français courant translates “he had his friends and wife Zeresh come.”

His friends: the same persons are mentioned again in 6.13, where they are identified as his advisors (see comments on “friends” at LXX 1.3, at ESG 1.20[3]).

Zeresh is a Persian name, occurring only in the book of Esther.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 8:11   

By these refers back to the letters of the preceding verse. The translator may need to be more explicit and say “In these letters the king gave the way” or “In the letters [mentioned], the king gave authority.”

To gather and defend their lives is translated in Good News Translation as “to organize for self-defense.” “Organize” may imply more than the original gather, so “gather for self-defense” will be closer to the original.

Defend their lives: this is literally “to stand upon their nefesh” (see comments on 7.3), and Traduction œcuménique de la Bible interprets it to mean “to be on the alert.” However, most versions translate similarly to Revised Standard Version. It may be necessary to restate as “to protect themselves” (New International Version) or “to fight for their lives” (New Jerusalem Bible).

With their children and women poses a difficult problem for translators. Most translators consider these words to be patterned after 3.13, in which non-Jewish people were given permission “to destroy, to slay, and to annihilate all Jews, young and old, women and children.” New Jerusalem Bible is unambiguous in 8.11: “they may destroy, massacre, and exterminate its armed force together with women and children, and plunder their possessions” (also Traduction œcuménique de la Bible). Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente actually restructures the verse and places “children and women” before “the armed force of any people”: “to gather and defend their lives, to destroy, kill, and annihilate, including children and women, all the armed force of any people.” Bible en français courant says “They can even kill their women and their children and plunder their goods” (see also New American Bible, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Biblia Dios Habla Hoy).

The Hebrew syntax of verses 3.13 and 8.11, however, is different; and it is possible to take the words with their children and women as the object of the participle “attacking” as in Good News Translation (see also New International Version and An American Translation), rather than as the object of the verbs destroy, slay, and annihilate. Verses 9.12, 15 say that “men” were slain by the Jews, but they do not mention women and children. Possibly the use of “men” in these two verses is not intended to exclude women and children, but the fact that women and children are not specifically mentioned may give some support to the interpretation followed by Good News Translation.

Gordis argues that the end of this verse and all of the next verse are a quotation from the decree of 3.13. His translation of verses 11-12 is as follows:

• … that the king was permitting the Jews in every city to assemble to defend themselves, and to destroy, kill, and annihilate the armed force of any people or province attacking “them, their children and their women, their goods to be taken as booty, on one day in all the provinces of King Ahasuerus, the thirteenth day of the twelfth month, which is Adar.”

Good News Translation and the translation by Gordis both reject the interpretation found in nearly all translations, that is, that the Jews are authorized to kill not only enemy soldiers but also children and women of the people who attack them. The most natural reading of the Hebrew, however, supports the Revised Standard Version translation. New Century Version, which follows the recommended interpretation, provides a clear translation:

• These were the king’s orders: The Jews in every city have the right to gather together to protect themselves. They have the right to destroy, kill and completely wipe out the army of any area or people who attack them. And they are to do the same to the women and children of that army. The Jews also have the right to take by force the property of the enemies.

Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente provides another model that may be helpful:

• In the letters it was written that the king authorized [or, gave the right to] the Jews wherever they lived to organize themselves for defense. In case of armed aggression by men of any population or province, the Jews have the right to defend themselves. They can fight the army and kill all their enemies, including women and children, and seize their possessions.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 10:2   

Following the Hebrew, Revised Standard Version links this verse to the preceding verse by using an initial conjunction And. Many translations, however, begin a new sentence in this verse (see Good News Translation), because there is no clear relationship between the event recounted in verse 1 and the rhetorical question that is posed in this verse. If the receptor language has a conjunction similar to the Hebrew waw or the Greek kai, it may be used here. Otherwise it may be preferable to allow this sentence to begin without depending upon the previous one.

All the acts of his power and might is literally “deeds of his power and of his might.” A literal translation may be misleading, suggesting that this refers to the acts of Mordecai. The New American Bible translation (“All the acts of his power and valor, as well as a detailed account of the greatness of Mordecai, whom the king promoted, are recorded in the chronicles of the kings of Media and Persia”) can be understood to mean that the chronicles contain both an account of the greatness of Mordecai and all the acts of Mordecai’s power and valor (so also New International Version). Since the king is the subject of 10.1, however, it is most natural in the English translations of New American Bible and New International Version to understand the pronoun “his” as referring to Xerxes and not to Mordecai. But to avoid ambiguity, some translations restructure. Good News Translation reads “All the great and wonderful things he did, as well as the whole story of how he promoted Mordecai to high office….” In this Good News Translation translation the second occurrence of the pronoun “he” makes clear that “great and wonderful things he did” refers to Xerxes. Similar is Revised English Bible, “All his acts of might and power, and the high dignities which he conferred on Mordecai….” The pronouns “he” and “his” clearly have Xerxes as the antecedent.

Acts of his power and might is remindful of the description of the king given at the beginning of the book, where it was his wealth and splendor that was cited (see 1.4). The meaning of this phrase is most likely that found in Nueva Biblia Española, “his military victories.” This first subject of the sentence is parallel to the second, which is the full account of the high honor of Mordecai.

The high honor: the author uses the noun “greatness” here, which is related to the verb that was used by Haman to describe how he had been honored by the king (see 5.11). The translator may say “great honor,” or an expression may be used such as “the greatness in which the king had placed Mordecai.”

The words are they not written in the Book of the Chronicles of the kings of Media and Persia remind the reader of similar phrases in 1 Kgs 14.19, 29; 15.7; 2 Chr 25.26; 32.32. For Book of the Chronicles, see comments on 2.23 above. Though stated in the form of a rhetorical question, the intention is to emphasize the historical trustworthiness of the writer’s story, which the reader may, in theory, verify by consulting this Book of the Chronicles. To avoid giving the impression that this is a question that expresses doubt, Good News Translation puts these words in the form of an affirmation: “All … are recorded in the official records” (so also Revised English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible).

On Media and Persia see comments on 1.3.

The translator may need to restate some of this verse, perhaps saying “All the things the king did in his power and strength, and the story of all he did, raising Mordecai to a place of great honor, haven’t they written it all…?” In some languages the contents of this verse may be expressed better in restructured form. Compare New Century Version: “And all the great things that Xerxes did are written down. They tell of his power and strength. They are written in the record books of the kings of Media and Persia. Also written in those record books are all the things that Mordecai did. The king had made Mordecai a great man.” Other models are possible for the rhetorical question: “They are all written in the official records…, are they not?” or “Of course [or, indeed, surely], they are all written…” (compare the Septuagint version of this verse), or the receptor language may prefer to use an emphatic particle at the end of the sentence that emphasizes the truth of what has been said or that it is a fact known by all. Since rhetorical questions are a common device in both oral and written literature, the translator should not be overly eager to restructure from a question to a declarative statement.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .