Translation commentary on Esther 5:14   

Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation reflect two different styles and, by implication, two different settings. Revised Standard Version presents family and friends offering counsel, while Good News Translation depicts the giving of casual advice. The translator needs to be consistent in the style that is adopted.

On gallows and hanged see comments on 2.23. The gallows that Haman built was fifty cubits high. A cubit is the length from the elbow to the tip of the middle finger, or about forty-five to fifty centimeters (about eighteen inches). The gallows was therefore about twenty-five meters high (seventy-five feet).

Tell the king: the Hebrew says literally “tell the king,” but many versions render it “ask the king” (so Good News Translation, New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible).

In today’s English merrily suggests childish behavior. Other translations express a similar idea: “gaily” (New Jerusalem Bible, Bible en français courant); “without a care in the world” (New Jerusalem Bible). But the basic meaning of the Hebrew word is “joyful, rejoicing, happy.” Haman is an important person and he will accompany the king to a dinner prepared by the queen. He should not be described in frivolous terms. His wife and friends give him advice so that he can go to the dinner “in good spirits” (New Revised Standard Version), “happy” (Good News Translation, New International Version), or “joyful” (Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible).

This counsel: literally “the word,” davar. Good News Translation states in idiomatic language “Haman thought this [suggestion] was a good idea.” The contrast between the tragic fate that is being planned for Mordecai and Haman’s selfish joy is very apparent in this verse.

He had the gallows made: literally “he built the gallows.” Since Haman would not have built the gallows with his own hands, Revised Standard Version restructures and uses a causative construction. Other languages may do the same, perhaps specifying that “he caused his servants to build the gallows.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 8:15   

It is not clear whether verse 15 introduces a new scene at some indefinite later time, or whether the same scene continues from verse 8. If the latter, all of the material in verses 9-14 is simply a continuation of events surrounding the writing and proclamation of Mordecai’s edict before returning to verse 8 to resume the story from that point. These verses then stand in marked contrast to 3.15b, which describes the scene after the first decree was issued.

Mordecai was dressed in royal robes of blue and white, the same colors as the cotton curtains and the hangings in the royal banquet scene in 1.6. And he wore a mantle of fine linen and purple, words that also remind the reader of the cords of white linen and purple in 1.6. Mordecai’s new position is clearly revealed by the “clothing of royalty” that he wore (compare 5.1). His status is now markedly different from that of the days when he sat at the gate of the palace.

The Hebrew says “clothing of royalty,” and some versions use similar general terms; for example, “a royal garment” (Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible), “royal garments” (New International Version), “royal dress” (Bible en français courant). Others like Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation interpret Mordecai’s clothing to be royal robes (compare 5.1). The translator may restate to say “dressed in the great clothes of a king” or “dressed in blue and white clothes like a king.” The second item of clothing is usually understood to be a “cloak,” a mantle (Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible, Bible en français courant, Chouraqui). This is a garment that was wrapped around oneself or that hung over one’s shoulders. The translator may wish to use a descriptive phrase.

The great golden crown that Mordecai wore was not the royal crown that the king or the queen wore. The Hebrew word for the royal crown in 1.11; 2.17; 6.8 is different from the word here in verse 15, which refers to the turban worn by high officials. If there is no technical term for a turban, one may describe it as “cloth wrapped around head [of important men]” or “head wrapping.” If it was cloth, it was decorated with gold or it had gold stitching. It was not, of course, a scarf.

The Hebrew says that the city of Susa shouted and rejoiced. This is the opposite of 3.15, where Susa was “thrown into confusion.” Some languages may have to say “the people of the city” rather than “the city.” Restructuring may also be used, such as “the city was filled with happy shouting and rejoicing” or “the city rang with the sounds of happy shouting and rejoicing.” The word “shouting” should be used with care, because in some languages it may have connotations of negative emotions such as fear and anger that are not appropriate in this situation.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Esther 7:1-2

So the king: both Revised Standard Version and Today’s English Version use the conjunction So to link this verse with the final verse of the preceding chapter, in which the new episode began.

To feast is literally “to drink.” The implied object is wine (see verse 2).

The Revised Standard Version translation And on the second day seems to suggest that this second feast continued for a second day. An American Translation likewise suggests that the second feast continued for at least two days: “and the king said again to Esther on the second day of the banquet of wine.” More probably, though, the words on the second day mean the second day that was mentioned in 5.8, following the first day of 5.4-6. Some translations say “and again on that second day” (Revised English Bible) or “again, on this second day” (New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible), adding the words “this” or “that” for clarity. Other translations such as Today’s English Version and Bible en français courant restructure and say “And so the king and Haman went to eat with Esther for a second time.” Today’s English Version thereby makes clear that “the second day” means the day of the second banquet.

As they were drinking wine: for comments see 5.6 above. The king here repeats his double question of the first day. His questions and promises take the identical poetic form of the first time, except that this time he addresses Esther by her title of Queen (see comments at 5.6).

My kingdom: as in 5.3, the king specifies that the kingdom is his. Today’s English Version makes the fact of possession implicit by saying “the empire.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .