The story continues quickly, and both Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation translate the conjunction waw with the adverb Then to show the progression of the action. The king acts to comply with Esther’s wish. He does not reply directly to her, but instead he gives a command that is presumably addressed to his courtiers. The Hebrew does not indicate who is to bring Haman. Good News Translation gives the impression that the king spoke directly to Haman and ordered him to come quickly. More probably the king sent messengers to Haman (see 6.14). Revised English Bible may reflect the correct meaning: âthe king gave orders for Haman to be brought with all speed.â
That we may do as Esther desires is literally âto do the word of Esther.â Good News Translation fails to express correctly why the king and Haman went quickly. It was not so that they could âbe Esther’s guests.â Rather they went quickly in order to âdo Esther’s biddingâ (New Jerusalem Bible). Good News Translation changes the focus to the role of the king and Haman as guests, but the Hebrew states their desire to do what Esther had requested. Revised English Bible says âto meet Esther’s wishes.â and Traduction ĆcumĂ©nique de la Bible says âso that we may obey Esther’s invitation.â
Came to the dinner: the Hebrew verb does not distinguish whether the guests âcame to dinnerâ or âwent to dinnerâ (see comments on 4.2). Some versions use the verb âcomeâ as Revised Standard Version has done. This implies that the reader sees the king and Haman âcomingâ to Esther’s dinner. Other versions like Good News Translation use the verb âgoâ to suggest that the reader sees them âgoingâ to her dinner.
Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Noss, Philip A. A Handbook on Esther (The Hebrew Text). (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .
