Translation commentary on Haggai 1:13

Then Haggai, the messenger of the LORD, spoke to the people with the LORD’s message: The expression the messenger of the LORD is not applied elsewhere to a prophet, though it is applied to a priest in Mal 2.7. Good News Translation has just used an identical expression in the previous verse, and does not repeat it here. It is probably better not to follow the example of Good News Translation at this point.

The change of heart by the people enabled the prophet to give them next a word of encouragement. Its content was simple: I am with you, says the LORD. The you here is of course plural. It is not clear why Good News Translation has expressed this in the future “I will be with you.” No other modern English version does this, and translators are recommended to use a present tense. The message itself was one that had often been given by the LORD to encourage his people, such as Jacob (Gen 28.15), Moses (Exo 3.12), Joshua (Josh 1.5), Gideon (Jdg 6.16), and Jeremiah (Jer 1.8).

The last part of the message says the LORD is translated in an emphatic way by Good News Translation as “that is my promise.” Other ways of expressing emphasis could be “declares the LORD” (New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) or “I, the LORD, say this” (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition). Translators may also say, “I give you my firm promise that I am always with you.” In this case the quotation formula is part of a second degree quotation, and so it does not have a discourse level function in terms of the structure of the paragraph.

An alternative translation model for verses 12 and 13 is:

• Then Zerubbabel and Joshua the High Priest, along with all the other people who had returned from Babylonia, did what the LORD their God commanded them to do. They realized that God had sent the prophet Haggai, so they were afraid and obeyed him. Then Haggai, the messenger of the LORD, told the people that the LORD promised, “I am with you.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 1:12

Then the angel of the LORD said: On the understanding that there are two angels, verse 12 refers to the figure on horseback introduced in verse 8. He had last been described in verse 11 as “the angel of the LORD who was standing among the myrtle trees,” so the words here, the angel of the LORD, most naturally refer to the same figure. If we have translated it as “the first angel” in verse 11, then to repeat just “the angel” here will probably be a clear reference to the same person in most languages. If there is any ambiguity, translators could repeat “the first angel,” or even both phrases “the first angel, the angel of the LORD.” This angel now takes the role of representative of the people of God, and addresses God on their behalf. In languages where angel is translated as something like “the LORD’s messenger” or “heavenly messenger,” translators may say, “Then the first messenger of the LORD, the one among the myrtle trees….”

The Hebrew words here translated LORD of hosts are the same as in verses 3 and 4. The change of word order in Good News Translation from “LORD Almighty” (verse 2) to “Almighty LORD” here does not indicate any difference in meaning. It simply sounds good to put the adjective “Almighty” first when the LORD is being addressed directly. For comments on LORD of hosts, see Haggai 1.2.

In the rest of the verse, Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version have two sentences where the Hebrew and most English versions have only one. In Hebrew this one sentence consists of a question followed by a long subordinate clause, as in Revised Standard Version. Good News Translation has made a separate sentence of the subordinate clause, and has put it first: “you have been angry with Jerusalem and the cities of Judah for seventy years now” (similarly Contemporary English Version). The question sentence (“How much longer…?”) then comes as a climax at the end of the verse. Many translators will find it helpful to use two sentences here, but the question may be put either first or last according to what sounds best in the translator’s language.

How long wilt thou have no mercy…?: Some translators may need to fill this out and say, “how many more years will pass before you have mercy…?” The Good News Translation expression “… before you show them mercy” is rather vague and general, probably deliberately so. In some languages translators may need to be more definite and say, “… before you bless your people again,” or even “… before you again show your people that you love them.” However, they should not give more detail than this or make historical references that are more precise than Zechariah intended.

Jerusalem and the cities of Judah: In this expression translators may need to say “Jerusalem and the other cities of Judah.” This would avoid the possible misunderstanding that Jerusalem itself was not one of the cities of Judah. In certain languages translators may need to say “the people of Jerusalem and the other cities….” In certain cultures there are no human settlements that are the equivalent of cities, but people live in villages or small groups of houses, often without encircling walls for protection. In such cases translators can refer to a city as “a large group of houses surrounded by a strong wall/fence,” or perhaps as “the large [or, chief] village.”

Against which thou hast had indignation is translated into modern language in Good News Translation as “you have been angry with.” For “angry” see the notes on verse 2.

These seventy years: The words refer to the prophecies of Jeremiah (Jer 25.11; Jer 29.10) that the land would be in ruins, and the people would serve the king of Babylon, for seventy years. The seventy years is best understood as a round figure. The period of total captivity in Babylon lasted only forty-eight years from 586 to 538 B.C. Scholars have made various attempts to fit the seventy years more closely to recorded historical events. Perhaps the most likely interpretation is the period from the destruction of Solomon’s Temple in 586 to the dedication of the second Temple in 516. Be that as it may, translators should retain the figure of seventy years, and not make any adjustments to fit historical facts. If the period Zechariah had in view was the seventy years beginning in 586, then his visions took place almost at the end of the period in 519. The comforting words of verses 14-17 would then be a clear encouragement to the returned exiles to complete the building of the second Temple (compare verse 16). In this way, Zechariah would be supporting the earlier message of Haggai.

A possible alternative translation model for this verse is:

• Then the first messenger of the LORD who was among the myrtle trees said, “You LORD, who are all-powerful, have been angry with [or, have had a hot heart toward] the people in Jerusalem and the other cities of Judah for seventy years now. How many more years will it be before you show them again that you love them?”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 3:10

In that day refers to the time when the people’s sins are taken away. So Good News Translation has “When that day comes.” The phrase In that day often serves to mark the beginning of a new subunit, and in the present case it may well be marking the last unit within the direct speech of the LORD that covers verses 7-10.

Says the LORD of hosts: In many languages it will be good style to put these words at the end of the verse, as New International Version does. There they would mark both the end of the speech by the angel of the LORD (verse 6), and also the end of this particular vision.

Every one of you will invite his neighbor under his vine and under his fig tree: The Hebrew word translated neighbor has a wider meaning than the English term suggests. It is not just people living nearby, but any other members of the community. Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente has “you will invite one another as guests.” The vine and the fig tree were commonly used as symbols of peace and prosperity, as in 1 Kgs 4.25; 2 Kgs 18.31; Micah 4.4. Since this will not be understood by many modern readers, it may be necessary to include some explanation of the meaning. Good News Translation has done this by saying, “each of you will invite his neighbor to come and enjoy peace and security, surrounded by your vineyards and fig trees.” Contemporary English Version has “each of you will live at peace and entertain your friends in your own vineyard and under your own fig trees.” These are good examples to follow. In areas where vines and figs are not known, translators may need to make a more general statement. They could say something like “… sitting among your farms and gardens.” It is not advisable to substitute the names of particular local crops such as rice, yams, mangoes, and bananas, which were not grown in ancient Israel. A nonfigurative way of expressing the last part of the verse is “each of you will invite your neighbor into your home to share your peace and prosperity” (New Living Translation).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 6:11

Take from them silver and gold, and make a crown: Translators should be careful not to make the words Take from them sound as if the men named in verse 10 were unwilling to give. This could be avoided in English by saying “accept from them,” or as Good News Translation says, “the silver and gold they have given.”

The word translated crown has given rise to much discussion. In Hebrew it has a form that is apparently plural, so it is translated as “crowns” in King James Version, Revised Version, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh. The difficulty with this is that the traditional text speaks of only one person being crowned, so that only one crown is needed.

Ancient crowns were commonly made of circular-shaped pieces of metal, often more than one of these being used. The mention of both silver and gold here has made some scholars think that the crown in this case consisted of two circular-shaped pieces, one of silver and one of gold, and that this accounts for the plural form of the word. However, in verse 14 the same Hebrew word is used and is followed by a singular verb. The Septuagint translated it as plural in verse 11 and singular in verse 14, but the ancient Syriac translated it as singular in both places. Although the Hebrew word has an ending that is normally a plural marker, it is possible that in this case it is not a plural but an unusual and old-fashioned singular. The same word occurs in Job 31.36, where it must be singular, and so on balance, translators are advised to treat it as singular both here and in verse 14.

And set it upon the head of Joshua, the son of Jehozadak, the high priest: Many scholars have considered it unlikely that Zechariah would speak of crowning the high priest rather than the civil governor. Accordingly, some have said that the word crown should be regarded as plural, and the name of the civil governor, Zerubbabel, added to the text. Others have preferred to treat crown as singular and to substitute Zerubbabel’s name for that of Joshua, and this is what Moffatt has done in his translation. Although from a historical point of view, it may seem more likely that Zechariah would speak of crowning Zerubbabel, nevertheless both the Hebrew text and the ancient versions name only Joshua, and translators should retain this name. If, like Redditt (1995), they believe that Zerubbabel was originally intended, then they could mention this possibility in a footnote, as do Jerusalem Bible and New English Bible. For Joshua, the son of Jehozadak, the high priest, see the notes on Hag 1.1.

It is possible to combine verses 10 and 11 as follows:

• Heldai, Tobijah, and Jedaiah have returned from Babylonia. You yourself must go at once to the house of Josiah the son of Zephaniah, and they will give you silver and gold. Make a crown, then put it on the head of the high priest Joshua, the son of Jehozadak.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 8:14

For thus says the LORD of hosts: This continues the sentence begun with the command “Let your hands be strong” in the previous verse, and translators should make this clear. For introduces the reason why the people were to do this, just as it did in verses 10 and 12. This time the reason is in the form of a promise from the LORD of hosts. Although the words thus says the LORD of hosts are the same as the formula in verses 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, and 9, they are not merely introductory this time. Rather, they are part of the argument of the passage. On this occasion therefore, they should not be omitted. Good News Translation does not omit them, but Good News Translation is nevertheless not a good model because it overlooks the word For and thus misses the close connection with the end of the previous verse.

The content of the LORD’s promise is a comparison between the past and the present, with the two parts of the comparison introduced by as … (in this verse) and “so…” (verse 15; compare Jer 31.28). The first part consists of three clauses. The order in which they are presented in Revised Standard Version is rather complicated, with the second clause when your fathers provoked me to wrath separating the other two clauses, which are actually more closely linked in sense, so the second clause will be discussed first.

When your fathers provoked me to wrath: Good News Translation reorders to put this second clause first, and in this way makes it possible to present the flow of thought in a simpler manner. New International Version and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh achieve the same aim by putting the second clause last. The clause is expressed in modern terms in Good News Translation as “When your ancestors made me angry.”

The first and third clauses, As I purposed to do evil to you … and I did not relent, are brought together in Good News Translation, and also put into current English as “I planned disaster for them and did not change my mind.” Good News Translation adds “but carried out my plans,” which is the same thought as the negative “did not change my mind” expressed positively. It may not be necessary to state this in other languages. Contemporary English Version restructures in a similar way.

The verse concludes with says the LORD of hosts. This is the same wording in Hebrew as in 7.13, but not the same as in 8.11. Here it seems to mark the climax of the first part of the comparison before the transition to the second part in the next verse. Good News Translation omits the words here, and in other languages translators will have to decide whether the style will be better with or without them. See the comments on verse 11.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 10:7

Then Ephraim shall become like a mighty warrior: Ephraim is another way of referring to the descendants of the exiles from the northern kingdom (compare 9.10), and speaks of the same people as those called “the house of Joseph” in verse 6. “People of Israel” (Good News Translation) is a good alternative model. The word here rendered mighty warrior is the same in Hebrew as that rendered “mighty men” in verse 5. New Revised Standard Version uses “warriors” in both places and Good News Translation “soldiers,” and there is some advantage in consistency, as it helps to link the whole section together.

Their hearts shall be glad as with wine: This clause does not state that the returned exiles would drink too much, but that they would be as happy as if they had! Hearts may need to be translated as “livers” or some other body part in some languages, but in other languages it may be necessary just to say “they.”

Their children shall see it and rejoice: It is not entirely clear what the children will see. Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible and Contemporary English Version seem to take it that the children will see their parents’ happiness, and will come to share it. Good News Translation, on the other hand, takes the verb see to refer back to the strengthening of the people in verses 6-7a, and says that “Their descendants will remember this victory.” New English Bible and Revised English Bible avoid the question by staying close to the Hebrew and saying only that the children will see, with no object expressed. It is probably better to decide what they will see, and make that clear in the translation. Both of the interpretations above are acceptable, but perhaps the view that the children will see their parents’ joy fits the context better. A possible model is the following: “When their children see how happy their parents are, they will also be happy.”

Their hearts shall exult in the LORD: Again hearts may need to be replaced by some other body part, or by a pronoun. Exult in the LORD or “rejoice in the LORD” (New International Version, Revised English Bible, New Living Translation) may not be very clear, and may need to be expanded. Good News Translation, for instance, says that they will “be glad because of what the LORD has done” (similarly Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). Other possibilities are “they will be full of happiness because of the LORD” (Traduction œcuménique de la Bible), “thanks to the LORD, their hearts will be full of joy” (Bible en français courant), and “they will be filled with joy and will praise the LORD” (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 1. Edition).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 12:11

On that day opens a new subparagraph covering verses 11-14.

The mourning in Jerusalem will be as great refers to the sorrow over the one pierced, as described in verse 10. In some languages mourning in this clause needs to be translated with a verbal expression; for example, “the people of Jerusalem will mourn as much as…” or “… will cry as bitterly as….”

As the mourning for Hadad-rimmon in the plain of Megiddo: This clause constitutes a third comparison, again emphasizing the intensity of the mourning. The point of the comparison, however, is not entirely clear. The Hebrew is literally “as the mourning of Hadadrimmon…” (King James Version, Revised Version). As so often where a phrase including “of” is concerned, the relationship between the nouns it links is ambiguous. The traditional interpretation takes Hadad-rimmon as a place name, though it is a name that occurs nowhere else. Jerome identified it with a village near Jezreel in the plain of Megiddo. If this is correct, the mourning is probably related to the death in battle of Josiah, the last good king of Judah, in 609 B.C. at Megiddo (2 Kgs 23.28-30). From the longer account in 2 Chr 35.20-27, we know that there was some sort of regular commemorative mourning for Josiah even after the exile. Thus this verse could be referring to a practice still current in the writer’s own day. Translators who regard Hadad-rimmon as a place name should make it clear by translating “mourning at Hadad-rimmon” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Beck).

In more recent times, scholars have suggested that Hadad-rimmon is the name of a Canaanite god, a composite name incorporating the Syrian (“Hadad”) and Assyrian (“Rimmon”) names of a god of storm and rain (compare the Good News Translation footnote). There is some evidence of ritual mourning for such a god in connection with the annual cycle of vegetation, and there may be references to this practice in Jer 6.26; Amos 8.10 (compare Ezek 8.14). Most modern translations seem to prefer this view. Translators who regard Hadad-rimmon as the name of a god should make it clear by translating mourning for Hadad-rimmon (Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, New Jerusalem Bible) or “mourning over Hadad-rimmon” (New English Bible/ Revised English Bible).

Neither view can be proved or disproved, but in the context a reference back to the tragic death of Josiah seems more likely than a reference to a pagan ritual, and we would tentatively recommend that translators take Hadad-rimmon as a place name.

The plain of Megiddo is a fertile agricultural area in the north of Israel, also known as the valley of Jezreel (Jdg 6.33; Hos 1.5) and as the plain of Esdraelon (Judith 1.8; 3.9; 4.6; 7.3). Megiddo is a town at the southwestern edge of the plain. A plain is a flat area and may be translated here as “flat lands [or, flat place] near Megiddo.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 1:2 - 1:3

“I have loved you,” says the LORD: Here as in 1.6; 3.7 and 3.13, the Assertion element of the dispute is introduced by a quotation formula. In 1.6 and 3.7, it is the longer formula “says the LORD of hosts,” but here and in 3.13 it is only the shorter form says the LORD. Translators should be careful to maintain the distinction. In some languages it will be necessary to put the verb of speaking before the direct quotation, especially at the beginning of the section. Good News Translation makes it clear who the LORD is addressing by adding “[says] to his people.” Contemporary English Version uses direct speech without an introductory formula: “Israel, I, the LORD, have loved you.” Other languages may have a preference for indirect rather than direct speech, but in a book like Malachi which uses dialogue extensively, direct speech should be preserved if at all possible. In languages in which indirect speech is unavoidable, translators could say, for example, “The LORD says that he has loved you.”

The word translated loved is a broad general term appropriate to a covenant relationship. Translators should avoid words that have strong sexual overtones. You is plural and refers to the whole nation. Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 1. Edition makes this clear by saying “I love you Israelites,” while Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition says “I love you, you people of Israel.”

This sentence constitutes the prophet’s opening Assertion in his dispute with the people. Good News Translation expresses it very emphatically by saying “I have always loved you.” In some languages it may be more natural to express this with a present tense “I love you.” Translators should avoid giving readers the impression that the LORD used to love the people but does not love them anymore.

But you say, “How hast thou loved us?”: There is a strong contrast between the LORD’s Assertion and the people’s Objection, so if translators have a choice of terms for But, they should choose one that conveys the contrast forcefully; one such example is “On the contrary.” You is of course again plural.

The formula you say is used to introduce the Objection element in each dispute. See also 1.6, 7; 2.14 (Revised Standard Version “you ask”), 17; 3.7, 8, 13. In all these places, what follows is a question and translators may prefer to render it as “you ask.” The form How hast thou…? gives an old-fashioned feeling to the Revised Standard Version. This is not in the Hebrew, where the second person singular is normal use when one person is addressed. New Revised Standard Version uses the current English form “How have you…?” as do Good News Translation and most other modern English versions. In languages that make a distinction between inclusive and exclusive first person plural, us should be translated as exclusive.

Good News Translation and many other versions expand the question as befits the context to “How have you shown your love for us?” (similarly Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/Revised English Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Contemporary English Version). The people’s doubt arises from their lack of prosperity and political power.

“Is not Esau Jacob’s brother?” says the LORD: This sentence begins the Response. It has the form of a negative rhetorical question, and is framed in such a way as to show that the expected answer is “yes.” Thus it has the force of a statement, “You know that Esau was Jacob’s brother,” and so it will be translated that way in a number of languages. The prophet was aware that he could rely on his audience’s knowledge of the history of their ancestors (Gen 25.19-26). Esau and Jacob were in fact twin brothers, and some languages may require this to be stated. Good News Translation restructures the question as a statement: “Esau and Jacob were brothers” (compare New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Contemporary English Version, New Living Translation), and in cultures where readers are not so familiar with the Old Testament, translators may choose to follow this example. In Hebrew there is no verb in the clause, and Good News Translation has used a past tense “were” rather than the present tense is. A similar change may be necessary in other languages to avoid giving the impression that Esau and Jacob were still alive in Malachi’s own day. The words translated says the LORD are not the same in Hebrew as the words translated in the same way earlier in the verse. The expression that occurs here is not found anywhere else in the book of Malachi. Its discourse function is probably to help mark the beginning of the Response element of the dispute. It is helpful to begin a new paragraph at this point, as do Good News Translation, New International Version, Beck, New Living Translation, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente.

Yet I have loved Jacob but I have hated Esau: Although the names Jacob and Esau are the same as in the previous sentence, they now stand both for the individuals and for the nations descended from them, as is made clear in verse 4. Good News Translation shows this by saying, “Jacob and his descendants … Esau and his descendants.” The descendants of Esau are the Edomites, that is, the people of Edom.

The main problem in translating this sentence lies in the verbs loved and hated. Most English versions use these words, and run the risk of representing the LORD as acting in an arbitrary and unpredictable way. Although the words are used in other contexts of ordinary human emotions, the important feature here is that they are used together to give a sharp contrast, and carry the meaning “I have loved Jacob [and his descendants] more than Esau [and his descendants].” Compare the description of Leah as “hated” in Gen 29.31, when the previous verse has made it clear that she was simply less loved than Rachel. (Compare also the parallel passages in Luke 14.26 and Matt 10.37, the first of which says “hate” and the second “loves … more than.”) This sentence is expressed in New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh as “I have accepted Jacob and have rejected Esau,” and in Contemporary English Version as “I chose Jacob instead of Esau.” Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente expresses this meaning more blandly as “I chose Jacob and not Esau.” In languages where the use of hated is likely to be misunderstood by readers, we recommend that translators should express the meaning in some way similar to New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Contemporary English Version, or Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente. Paul quotes this sentence in Rom 9.13.

Translators should note that in Hebrew there is a stylistic feature called a chiasmus, in which the order of elements within the two clauses is reversed to give an A-B-B-A pattern. The Hebrew order is “I-have-loved (A) Jacob (B), but Esau (B) I-have-hated (A).”

In many languages such a change of order would simply be confusing, but in others it may be retained and may produce a strong rhetorical effect. Translators must consider the stylistic patterns of their own language in deciding whether or not to retain the chiasmus.

I have laid waste his hill country: Laid waste is an old-fashioned expression, which is replaced in New Revised Standard Version by “I have made his hill country a desolation.” Other terms used for “desolation” are “wilderness” (Jerusalem Bible), “desert” (New Jerusalem Bible, New Living Translation), and “wasteland” (New International Version, Beck). Translation models for this clause are “I have devastated the mountainous region occupied by the descendants of Esau, the Edomites” (Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente) and “I have caused the … to become a barren wasteland.”

And left his heritage to jackals of the desert: The phrase his heritage refers to the land occupied by the Edomites, and Good News Translation translates it simply as “the land.” Translators should avoid any term for heritage that means that the Edomites literally inherited that land. They could say, for instance, “ancestral land.” Jackals are animals similar to foxes, wolves, or wild dogs. The phrase jackals of the desert shows that these animals live in inhospitable places. The fact that these creatures have taken over the Edomite land indicates the extent to which the land has been ruined (compare Jer 9.11; 10.22; 49.33; 51.37). The phrase is similar in structure to the expressions “the birds of the air and the fish of the sea” in Zeph 1.3. Just as there the descriptive phrases “of the air” and “of the sea” may be redundant in some languages, so here the phrase of the desert may be left out if necessary (as in Good News Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Contemporary English Version has a restructuring of the last two clauses that may be a helpful model to some translators: “I turned Esau’s hill country into a barren desert where jackals roam.” In languages where it is necessary to state the sex of the jackals, translators should note that the Hebrew form is feminine. In cultures where jackals or even wolves are unknown, translators may use a general term; for example, “wild animals.” New English Bible and Revised English Bible do not mention jackals at all. Their renderings are based on the ancient Greek translation, but there is no need to follow this, as the Hebrew makes perfectly good sense.

In point of historical fact, the people of Edom were pushed out of their traditional homeland by invading Nabataean Arabs, probably between 500 B.C. and 450 B.C. It is striking that the prophet does not rely solely on events from the distant past to prove the reality of the LORD’s love for his people. Rather he chooses an event from his own days to show that the LORD’s love is still valid in his hearers’ lifetimes.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .