Translation commentary on Zechariah 9:14

In verses 14-17 the prophet enlarges on the theme of God giving his people victory over their enemies, and develops it to include the subsequent celebrations and peaceful prosperity. The language used here is the language associated in other parts of the Old Testament with theophanies (that is, appearances of the LORD), usually defending his people or helping them defeat their enemies. This picture often links the appearance or activity of the LORD with dramatic natural events such as thunderstorms or earthquakes (compare for instance Exo 19.16-20; Jdg 5.4-5; Psa 18.7-15; Psa 144.5-6; Nahum 1.3-5; Hab 3.4-11).

Then the LORD will appear over them; that is, he will appear in the sky above “his people” (Good News Translation) in order to defend them (Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). In languages where it is difficult to speak of the LORD appearing, translators may say, “His people will see the LORD above them to protect them.”

And his arrow go forth like lightning: Lightning is represented as the arrows of God in Hab 3.4, 11. Here the comparison is reversed, though the picture is essentially the same. Compare Psa 18.14.

The Lord GOD will sound the trumpet: The Hebrew expression for Lord GOD includes both the word ʾadonay (“lord” or “master”) and the divine name YHWH. This is why Revised Standard Version has GOD rather than Lord in capital letters. If possible, translators should distinguish this combination from “LORD” on its own, and from “LORD of hosts.” For instance, Good News Translation here translates Lord GOD as “Sovereign LORD,” whereas for “LORD of hosts” it usually has “LORD Almighty” (Hag 1.2 and many other places). The trumpet was made of an animal horn, usually a ram’s horn, not of metal like a modern musical instrument. A trumpet blast was a sign of the LORD’s presence at Sinai (Exo 19.16, 19) and is associated with the return of Christ (1 Cor 15.52; 1 Thes 4.16). In languages where it sounds strange to speak of the LORD blowing a trumpet, it may be better to say “the Lord GOD will cause a trumpet to be blown” or “… cause a trumpet to sound.” In Matt 24.31 the sense may be that the heavenly trumpets are blown by angels (compare Rev 8.2, 6-7), but translators should avoid mentioning any agent here in Zechariah.

And march forth in the whirlwinds of the south: The LORD is several times pictured in the Old Testament as traveling on a storm cloud, and coming from the south, literally from Teman, a place in the land of Edom, to the south of Judah (see Jdg 5.4; Psa 18.7-15; Hab 3.3-4). Severe whirlwinds or dust storms were well known in the desert areas of the Sinai peninsula, as mentioned in Isa 21.1, and may well be the basis of the comparison. March forth conveys the sense of an aggressive military type of movement. Other versions use the words “advance” (Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, Revised English Bible) or “attack” (Contemporary English Version).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 10:8

As in verse 6, it will probably be helpful in most languages to begin a new paragraph at this point.

I will signal for them and gather them in: The word translated signal is literally “hiss” (King James Version, Revised Version) or “whistle” (New American Bible, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). Revised Standard Version is following the example of the ancient Greek version in using a more general term. Most scholars interpret “whistle” as a picture drawn from the way a shepherd calls to his sheep to gather them together (compare Jdg 5.16). A similar picture is found in Isa 5.26 and 7.18, where the LORD is calling foreign nations to punish his people. Here the opposite is the case—the LORD is calling his own people back from exile. In cultures where sheep are kept, it may be helpful to say “I will whistle for them as a shepherd calls his sheep,” but in areas where sheep are little known, it may be more appropriate to use a more general term like signal or “call” (Good News Translation; compare Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). In some areas people may have customary ways of communicating over long distances other than speech, such as the use of whistles, smoke signals, or talking drums. In such situations these customs may provide terms that could be used to translate signal here.

I have redeemed them: In Hebrew the verb is a perfect form, but this may be an example of the so-called prophetic perfect, in which events still future are referred to as if they have already happened. Thus some versions translate it as a future: “I will rescue them” (Good News Translation; compare the Septuagint, New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Others, such as Bible en français courant and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, say “I have decided to rescue them,” and this may be a helpful model.

They shall be as many as of old: Inevitably the upheaval of going into exile led to a reduction in the numbers of the LORD’s people. Now the LORD promises that these numbers will be restored. Jewish scholars have often seen in these words a reference to the earlier period when the people were in Egypt and multiplied rapidly (Exo 1.7, 12). As they increased in a foreign land then, so they will increase in their current countries of exile. Compare Ezek 36.10-11. Contemporary English Version has a helpful model: “And there will be as many as ever before” (similarly Good News Translation).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 12:12 - 12:14

These verses give a more detailed description of the organization of the mourning mentioned in 12.10-11. Basically the mourning would be done in family groups with the sexes separated. This separation may be due to some special role that women fulfilled in ritual mourning (compare Jer 9.17-22). Similar customs are still found in some parts of the world.

The land shall mourn, each family by itself: The land is here a figure of speech called a metonymy, and stands for its inhabitants. Family does not refer to a small family consisting only of parents and children, but to an extended family group having a common ancestor. In some languages it would be better translated “clan.” It is, however, a smaller unit than a tribe, as this term is used in the Bible (compare Josh 7.16-18). By itself is repeated several times in this passage. It is not certain whether it means “in its own place” or “at its own time.” If the first is meant, then the families are thought of as mourning simultaneously in different places. If the second, then they are thought of as mourning in sequence, one after the other, perhaps in a single place such as at the Temple. If there are different terms in their language, translators may choose whichever seems more culturally appropriate. A few English versions (King James Version, Revised Version, Moffatt, New American Bible) use the term “apart,” which indicates separation in space rather than time.

The family of the house of David by itself: This refers to the descendants of King David, still leading citizens after the exile. In this context the focus is on physical descent from the royal line rather than on status as rulers.

And their wives by themselves: In Hebrew the word for wives is the same as the word for “women.” In this context it is not just married women who are referred to and a more general term like “womenfolk” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) is preferable.

The family of the house of Nathan by itself: Some scholars understand the reference to be to the prophet Nathan (2 Sam 7.2), but in this context it seems much more likely to be to a son of David called Nathan (2 Sam 5.14; 1 Chr 3.5; 1 Chr 14.4). This son is also mentioned in Luke’s list of ancestors of Jesus (Luke 3.31). Thus a minor line descended from David is mentioned as an example. This would be parallel to the mention of both Levi and Shimei below.

The family of the house of Levi by itself: This refers to the descendants of Levi, that is the hereditary priests, who were also influential after the return from exile.

The family of the Shimeites by itself: This name is the only one in the list to have a definite article rather than the phrase “house of” before the name. There is no discernible significance in this variation, and indeed the ancient Syriac and Aramaic versions have the same phrase here as occurs with the other names. Translators need not try to make a distinction. Shimei is not the person who insulted David in 2 Sam 16.5-8, but rather a grandson of Levi (Num 3.17-18; 1 Chr 6.16-17). Thus he stands as an example of a branch of the priestly line just as Nathan stands as an example of a branch of the royal line.

And all the families that are left: This probably refers to the other families in the royal and priestly lines not mentioned by name above.

Each by itself, and their wives by themselves: See the notes above. In some languages the repetition of the first phrase six times and the second one five times may be very poor style. In such cases, it is appropriate to restructure these three verses so as to eliminate the repetition. Good News Translation offers a good example of how this can be done, and Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch offers another. But if the repetition can be kept without sounding unnatural, it may prove a useful way of emphasizing how solemn and sincere the mourning was.

If the identification of Nathan and Shimei above is correct, it may be of some significance that the mourners consist of royal and priestly families, with no mention of prophets. Perhaps this indicates that the person that they had pierced, and were now mourning, was a prophetic figure of some kind. See also the notes on 13.3. Some translators may wish to add footnotes identifying Nathan and Shimei since these names are not likely to be correctly understood otherwise.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 1:4

This verse continues with the Response element of the dispute. But whereas verses 2c-3 are a direct quotation of the LORD’s words, embedded into the utterance of the prophet, verse 4 begins with the words of the prophet himself: If Edom says …. The Hebrew here uses Edom instead of Esau, and thus makes it clear that the reference is not to the historical figure, but to the nation descended from him. So Good News Translation has “If Esau’s descendants, the Edomites, say…” and Contemporary English Version has “Esau’s descendants may say….” We may assume that they are addressing the LORD, since it is the LORD who replies in the second half of the verse.

We are shattered but we will rebuild the ruins: We here is exclusive and stands for the cities of Edom. This is brought out in Good News Translation “Our towns have been destroyed…” (compare Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). In some languages it will be necessary to use the active and say, “Our enemies have destroyed our towns….” We will rebuild or “… build … again” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) is the rendering in all available modern versions. The Hebrew is literally “we will return and build” (King James Version, Revised Version). The verb “return” is often used in Hebrew in combination with another verb to mean “to do something again,” and that is how most translators have understood it here. However, it is possible that in this case it retains its basic meaning of “return” (as in 3.7), so that the Edomites who had been expelled from their traditional land are claiming that they will return to it and build. It is taken this way in the ancient Greek and Latin versions, and modern translators may accept this possibility if they prefer it.

The LORD of hosts says: The expression the LORD of hosts (New International Version “the LORD Almighty”) is the most common way in which God is referred to in the book of Malachi. Here the Hebrew actually has the expression that is often translated “Thus says the LORD of hosts” (for example, Hag 1.2; Zech 1.3). This expression normally marks the beginning of a new unit or subunit of the discourse (as for instance in Hag 1.2, 7; 2.11; Zech 7.9; 8.2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 19, 20, 23). Revised Standard Version is not justified in dropping the word “thus.” If possible, an expression such as “this is what” should be incorporated here, as it is in New International Version. New International Version offers the best model at this point, with a new paragraph beginning “But this is what the LORD Almighty says.” Good News Translation has shortened the LORD of hosts to “the LORD,” but that is not appropriate at the first occurrence of the expression in the book, and translators should not follow this example.

They may build, but I will tear down: The pronouns They and I are emphatic in Hebrew to show the sharp contrast between what the people of Edom may intend and what the LORD will permit. The expression tear down is common in American English, but is replaced by “break … down” in the Australian edition of Good News Translation. British translations prefer to say “pull down” (Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/Revised English Bible). This variation is merely a dialect difference, and no distinction of meaning is intended. A possible model using indirect speech is: “But I, the LORD All-Powerful, promise to tear down whatever they build” (Contemporary English Version).

Till they are called the wicked country, the people with whom the LORD is angry for ever: These two labels for Edom are parallel with each other, and declare that people will recognize that God’s anger has been shown both against the land and against the people of Edom. In many languages they are called will be better expressed as “People will call them,” as in Good News Translation. The phrase the wicked country may sound odd in some languages because land is not capable of moral action. In such situations it may be helpful to restructure it as “the land where evil reigns” (compare Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente), “the land full of sinful people,” or even “the land God has forsaken” (compare Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch).

Angry presents problems in some languages when used to describe God. The term chosen should indicate justifiable indignation against something that is wrong, rather than irritation arising from circumstances. For ever has the sense of “for all time” rather than “for eternity.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 3:7

The first two sentences of the verse in Revised Standard Version form the Assertion element of the dispute.

From the days of your fathers refers back not just one generation but to ancient times. It is expressed in more natural modern English as “ever since the time of your ancestors” (Contemporary English Version; compare New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, New Living Translation). Translators should avoid giving the impression that the people of Malachi’s day were alive in the days of their ancestors. To prevent this mistake, it is possible to use a simile: “Just as your ancestors did, so you too have….”

You have turned aside from my statutes: The verb translated turned aside is the same verb as occurred in 2.8. The accusation made there against the priests is now extended to the people in general. The word translated statutes is one of the many terms used to refer to the laws of God. No doubt the Law of Moses is primarily intended. Other renderings are “turned away from my laws” (Good News Translation) and “evaded my statutes” (Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible).

And have not kept them: This clause states the same fact as the previous one, but expresses it negatively. The Hebrew does not have anything equivalent to them, but this is supplied translationally without depending on any change to the Hebrew text. Contemporary English Version links this clause neatly with the previous one and says, “you have ignored and disobeyed my laws.” New Living Translation catches the force vividly with “you have scorned my laws and failed to obey them.”

Return to me, and I will return to you, says the LORD of hosts: These words are almost identical with those in Zech 1.3 (see the comments there). Translators may wish to move the quotation formula says the LORD of hosts to the beginning of the verse in order to identify clearly that the prophet is quoting the words of the LORD. Compare the comments on verse 1. The direct quotation extends to the end of verse 12.

But you say, ‘How shall we return?’: This sentence is the first Objection element in the dispute. It is introduced by But you say … as previous Objection elements have been (compare 1.2, 6, 7; 2.14, 17; 3.8, 13). Since the content of what is said is again a question, translators may prefer to render this as “But you ask.” The words of the objectors here and in verse 8 are second degree quotations.

The words of the quotation How shall we return? may be taken as a sincere question in which the speakers inquire by what means they can show repentance. Good News Translation “What must we do to turn back to you?” sounds as if it is intended to carry this meaning, as do many other versions. Some commentators, however, regard these words as an expression of surprise that the speakers should be called to repent at all (for instance, Vuilleumier, Verhoef). Understood in this way, the question amounts to a protest of innocence (J. M. P. Smith, Merrill). This interpretation fits the context well: the people have nowhere shown any willingness to repent, and there is no reason to suppose they are doing so now. Translators are advised to translate in such a way that they do not rule out the understanding of these words as a declaration of innocence. Moffatt “How do we need to come back?” is a suitable model. Translators could also say something stronger, such as using the idiomatic expression “What on earth should we repent of?” which conveys a feeling of indignation (so Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition). Whether the questioners really wanted an answer to their question or not, they are given one, but not until verse 10.

Note that Jerusalem Bible and New Jerusalem Bible consider the following question at the beginning of verse 8 to be a continuation of the words of the objectors. See the comments below.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Haggai 1:14 - 1:15

And the LORD stirred up the spirit of Zerubbabel the son of Shealtiel, governor of Judah, and the spirit of Joshua the son of Jehozadak, the high priest, and the spirit of all the remnant of the people: For comments on Zerubbabel the son of Shealtiel, governor of Judah and Joshua the son of Jehozadak, the high priest, see the notes on verse 1. In the present context it is more important to repeat their offices (governor and high priest) than to repeat their fathers’ names. For comments on all the remnant of the people, see the notes on verse 12.

The expression the LORD stirred up the spirit of is fairly common in the later parts of the Old Testament; see 1 Chr 5.26; Jer 51.1; compare Ezra 1.5. It is well translated by Good News Translation in natural modern English as “The LORD inspired.” Other ways to express this idea are “roused” (Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), “stimulated,” or “motivated.” Translators may also say, “The LORD worked in the hearts of … so that they…,” or use some idiomatic expression, such as “The LORD caused their hearts to get hot.” Contemporary English Version has a helpful model: “So the LORD God All-Powerful made everyone eager to work on his temple, especially Zerubbabel and Joshua.”

And they came and worked on the house of the LORD of hosts, their God: For comments on the house of the LORD of hosts, see the notes on verse 2. For comments on their God, see the notes on verse 12. Came and worked on the house may simply be rendered “began to build the Temple.”

The people began work on the twenty-fourth day of the month, in the sixth month: that is on September 21, 520 B.C. (based on Parker and Dubberstein). This was twenty-three days after Haggai delivered his original message (see verse 1). Since this was the time of year when the harvest was gathered in, we may assume that the people were busy completing their harvesting during those twenty-three days. In some languages it may be more convenient to write twenty-fourth in figures rather than in words. For comments on the sixth month, see the notes on verse 1.

In the second year of Darius the king: For comments on this phrase, see the notes on verse 1. Since verse 15 ends with a date, and the next verse (2.1) begins with a date, it is not certain whether these words should be taken with the first date (as Revised Version, Good News Translation, New International Version, New Living Translation, Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente) or with the second (as Moffatt, Revised Standard Version, New Revised Standard Version, Bible de Jérusalem, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/Revised English Bible, Beck, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Since both dates are quite clearly in the same year, there is no significant difference of meaning involved. In 1.1 the year of the emperor’s reign is given at the beginning of the date, but in 2.10 it is given at the end, so both positions are possible. However, in terms of the discourse structure of the book, a date is the highest ranking marker of a new section. Therefore on discourse grounds, it seems more likely that the pattern is year-month-day, the same as in 1.1, and that the second year of Darius goes with the date that follows in 2.1.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 1:13

And the LORD answered gracious and comforting words to the angel who talked with me: The answer to the question of verse 12 is given by the LORD himself. It is not given to the angel on horseback who had asked it, but to the angel who talked with me. An alternative translation for this angel may be “the angel [or, the LORD’s messenger] who was my interpreter.” See the notes on verse 9.

The expression gracious and comforting words (compare New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, Revised English Bible, New Living Translation “kind and comforting words”) is translated in Good News Translation simply as “comforting words.” Most translators will prefer to use two adjectives. A further possibility would be to say “very comforting words,” “very consoling words” (Jerusalem Bible), or “good words to comfort him.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 4:1

The angel who talked with me came again: This angel is the same figure as appeared in earlier visions (1.9, 13, 14, 19; 2.3). The fact that he came again suggests he had been absent during the previous vision. This may possibly be a reference back to 2.4. If the interpreting angel was the person addressed there, then he had departed to speak to the young man with the measuring line. Another way to express this is “The angel who had been explaining the visions to me came back.”

And waked me, like a man that is wakened out of his sleep: At first sight it may not be clear whether Zechariah had actually been asleep or not. But the use of the simile like a man … strongly suggests that he had not. Since the word waked in English conveys the sense that he had, it would be better not to use it. In all probability, the prophet was absorbed in his own thoughts, meditating on the meaning of the previous visions. The angel is merely rousing him from his meditation and calling his attention to a new vision. This sense is conveyed more clearly in Good News Translation, “roused me as if I had been sleeping” (similarly New Jerusalem Bible, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). However, if the use of the equivalent of words such as wakened and sleep would in some languages signal that Zechariah was actually sleeping, then translators may express this verse in a similar way to the following: “The angel who had talked with me returned and brought me out of my deep thoughts” or “The angel who had been speaking with me returned, interrupted my thoughts, and attracted my attention.” Another possible restructuring is “The angel who had talked with me returned and shook me like someone waking a sleeper.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .