Translation commentary on Malachi 1:14

This verse speaks about people who make vows (that is, voluntary promises) to sacrifice the best animals, and then do not fulfill their promises. Most such people were lay people, and so some scholars think this verse is addressed to lay people rather than priests, and is therefore out of place in a section addressed to priests. This view however, is unconvincing. First of all, it was not only lay people who could make vows. If priests made them, their lax attitude could easily lead them to allow one another to substitute inferior animals. Once they had done this, it would be all too easy to extend the practice to lay people. In the context of verses 11-14, the verse can well be understood as describing a result of this priestly slackness: it brings a curse on the hypocritical worshiper instead of a blessing (contrast Num 6.22-27).

Cursed be the cheat: In the ancient world a curse was regarded as having the power to bring about its own fulfillment, and was taken very seriously (refer to the notes on Zech 5.3). See for instance Jdg 17.1-4. In some languages this may need to be expressed as a statement, such as “The LORD will punish the cheat….” The cheat is the person who promises to do something and fails to do it. In the American edition of Good News Translation, the word used is “cheater.” This is simply a dialect difference from the form “cheat” used in the British and Australian editions, and does not reflect any difference in meaning.

Who has a male in his flock: According to Lev 22.17-25, an animal voluntarily promised to the LORD had to be a male, and in perfect condition. Neither Good News Translation nor Contemporary English Version make it clear that a male animal is involved, but in some languages it will be helpful to do this; for example, “the man who has a perfect male animal in his flock.” This could be a ram (male sheep) or a bull (male cow).

And vows it: An Israelite could choose to make a vow to offer a sacrifice to the LORD. It was not an obligatory part of the ritual of worship, but was voluntary. Once the person had made the vow, however, it was binding and had to be fulfilled.

And yet sacrifices to the Lord what is blemished: The situation in view is that the worshiper substitutes an imperfect (and therefore less valuable animal) for the one he had promised. As in verse 12, the Hebrew text has ʾadonay rather than the personal name YHWH, and Revised Standard Version correctly prints Lord rather than “LORD.” However, some Hebrew manuscripts do have “LORD” (YHWH) or “me,” and a few modern translators have chosen to follow them. New American Bible and some printings of New English Bible (such as that reproduced in the 1977 Cambridge Bible Commentary by Mason) have “LORD,” though this must be a misprint. Bible de Jérusalem and Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible have “me,” presumably on translational grounds, and translators may follow this example since the Lord is the speaker, and is referring to himself at this point. But there is no good reason to depart from the majority Hebrew text, and translators should follow the example of Revised Standard Version with Lord if their language distinguishes the names with and without capital letters.

What is blemished refers to animals that were not in perfect condition, and were therefore not acceptable for sacrifice in fulfillment of a vow. Some scholars think the Hebrew term refers specifically to a castrated animal (forbidden as a sacrifice in Lev 22.24), and so New American Bible translates it as “a gelding.” However, a more general term seems to fit the context better. The Good News Translation term “worthless” is not a very wise choice, since even imperfect animals were not without some financial value. Other versions have such terms as “damaged” (New English Bible/Revised English Bible), “injured” (Beck), “defective” (New Living Translation), and “unhealthy” (Contemporary English Version), but probably a less restricted expression like “inferior” or “of lower value” (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch) would be better.

In this verse the first sentence as a whole is complex, and in many languages translators will need to restructure it considerably. One possibility is to treat it as a conditional sentence, with three conditions followed by a conclusion. It could be expressed as follows: “If a man has a perfect animal in his flock, and if he promises to sacrifice it to the LORD, and if he substitutes an inferior animal, then the LORD will punish him!”

For I am a great King: This clause in effect gives the reason why worshipers will be punished if they break their promises to the LORD—he is a great King. They would not dare to treat the Persian emperor as they treat the LORD, yet the LORD is much greater than any human ruler. In societies where there are no terms to describe monarchs, translators may say “the great chief” or “the supreme ruler” (see Hag 1.1). The description of the LORD as a King balances and contrasts with the description of him as a father and a master in verse 6. If translators have translated the LORD as “me,” they may wish to restore the reference to the LORD by saying here “I the LORD am a great King.”

For says the LORD of hosts, see the notes on verse 8. Here the formula probably marks the climax of the statement, and perhaps of the whole of the first part of the dispute.

And my name is feared among the nations: As in verses 6 and 11, the name stands for the person. If translators have rendered it as “me” in the earlier verses, they should do so again here, as Good News Translation has. In Hebrew the word translated feared forms a link with “fear” at the beginning of the section in verse 6, thus helping to bring the unit to an effective conclusion. Translators should try to find a term that can be used in both places, such as “honour” (Moffatt), “awe” (New Jerusalem Bible), or “reverence” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). In many languages it will be necessary to avoid a passive construction, and say, “people of all nations honor me” (compare Good News Translation).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 3:17

Before examining the text, it is once more necessary to comment on punctuation, because Revised Standard Version is again odd in this respect. At the beginning of this verse, Revised Standard Version opens quotation marks that are not closed till the end of the book. Strictly, this suggests that the whole of 3.17–4.6 is a single speech, including the quotation formulas “says the LORD of hosts” in 3.17; 4.1 and 3. No other version has such confusing punctuation, and translators should definitely not follow Revised Standard Version in this matter. Many other versions treat the rest of the book from 3.17 on as direct speech, but they either put the quotation formulas outside the quotation marks (Moffatt, New International Version, Beck, New Living Translation) or restructure them in 4.1 and 3 into first person statements (Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). New American Standard Bible and New King James Version are broadly similar, except that they exclude 3.18 from the direct speech. A number of versions that use quotation marks in other contexts do not have any in this section. Since the Hebrew text does contain quotation formulas, and direct speech is certainly involved, it is confusing not to mark its limits clearly.

This Handbook recommends that translators should make their decisions about punctuation in the light of (1) the occurrences of quotation formulas in the Hebrew text, and (2) the discourse structure of the dispute. This sixth dispute extends from 3.13 to 4.3, and 4.4-6 may be regarded as a conclusion to the whole book. These last three verses are in the first person as words spoken by the LORD, even though no quotation formula occurs within them. It is therefore legitimate on translation grounds to identify the LORD as the speaker, probably at the beginning of 4.4 (see the comments on 4.4-6).

This approach leaves 3.17–4.3 as the other unit of direct speech. Within this unit the first quotation formula is probably best placed at the beginning of 3.17, and the third one at the end of 4.3 (so Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). This arrangement will show clearly the opening and closing of the unit. The second occurrence of the formula, in the middle of 4.1, is harder to handle well. The first words of 4.1 (“For behold” in Revised Standard Version) indicate both a logical link with 3.17-18 and the start of a new subunit, with the quotation formula probably marking a climax. In this case it may be best to do as Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente have done, and restructure the formula into a first person statement that becomes part of the direct speech. This will retain its function of marking a climax without breaking up the flow of thought through 3.17–4.3 as a single unit. For more details, see the comments on 4.1.

They shall be mine, says the LORD of hosts, my special possession on the day when I act: As noted above, it is probably best to move the quotation formula to the beginning of the verse (as do Contemporary English Version, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). In that position, it could take a form like “The LORD Almighty declares…” (compare Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente).

The Hebrew grammar for They shall be mine … my special possession on the day when I act is awkward, because the word translated special possession is placed at the end of the clause. This makes it uncertain whether it is to be interpreted as qualifying mine (as in Revised Standard Version and most other versions) or as the object of the verb that Revised Standard Version translates I act. The second alternative seems more probable in the light of the Hebrew word order, but is represented only in King James Version, New King James Version , New American Standard Bible, and New International Version. New International Version for instance has “They will be mine … in the day when I make up my treasured possession.” Probably the reason why most versions have followed the same interpretation as Revised Standard Version is that the words on the day when I act occur also in 4.3, where there is no ambiguity. An expression like this probably has a discourse function when it occurs both near the beginning and near the end of an utterance, so it seems likely that it would have a similar meaning in both places.

Versions that adopt the same interpretation as Revised Standard Version still have to decide whether the day is or is not the object of the verb that Revised Standard Version renders as I act. Revised Standard Version has decided that it is not, and so uses the intransitive verb I act. Most other versions make a similar decision, but some treat the day as the object of the verb and so translate “the day that I appoint” (New English Bible/Revised English Bible) or “the day that I am preparing” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh; similarly Jerusalem Bible, Bible de JĂ©rusalem, Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible). This interpretation seems somewhat preferable, both because the verb is usually transitive and because it fits well with the context of the paragraph, especially with the mention of the coming day in 4.1 (compare 3.2).

The Hebrew word that Revised Standard Version translates special possession is used of the LORD’s people in Exo 19.5; Deut 7.6; 14.2; 26.18 and Psa 135.4 (compare 1 Peter 2.9). In 1 Chr 29.3 and Eccl 2.8 (where Revised Standard Version has “treasure”), it is linked with material wealth such as gold and silver, and this is probably the basis for the rendering “jewels” in King James Version and New King James Version . Though this is vivid imagery, it is probably not the intention of the prophet. However, some versions catch this aspect of the word with renderings like “treasured possession” (New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), “prized possession” (Moffatt, New Jerusalem Bible), or “precious possession” (Beck). These may be helpful models in some languages. Good News Translation has only “they will be my very own.” This carries the basic meaning but loses the impact of the Hebrew. Translators should try to use a more forceful expression than this if possible.

I will spare them: The term spare in English, though used in many versions, is rather unfortunate because it suggests the idea of sparing someone’s life, and that is obviously not the meaning here. It would be clearer and more natural to say “I will be merciful to them” (Good News Translation), “I will be tender toward them” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), or “I will have compassion on them” (New American Bible; similarly Bible de JĂ©rusalem). Other possibilities are “I will be gentle toward them” (Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente) and “I will be kind toward them” (Bible en français courant). The same Hebrew verb for spare occurred in a negative construction in Zech 11.5, where Revised Standard Version has “have no pity.”

As a man spares his son who serves him: The comparison of the LORD’s attitude toward those who are faithful toward him with the attitude of a father toward a dutiful son has echoes of the language of Exo 4.22-23. This is lost if the male terms are changed to “as parents spare their children” (New Revised Standard Version; similarly Contemporary English Version). The phrase who serves him probably looks back to “to serve God” in verse 14. There the context was of formal worship, whereas here the context is of obedient action. Thus Jerusalem Bible translates “who obeys him” (similarly Contemporary English Version, New Living Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). In many languages a different verb will be needed here from that used in verse 14.

A possible translation model for the whole verse is:

• The LORD Almighty says: “They will be my own valued possession [or, special people] on the day that I am appointing [or, preparing]. I will treat them tenderly, as a father treats an obedient son.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .