Translation commentary on Zechariah 11:5

Those who buy them slay them; that is to say, the merchants who buy the sheep kill them for their meat. It is not clear who these buyers represent symbolically.

And go unpunished: This phrase in English is used in many modern versions (Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, Good News Translation, New International Version, Contemporary English Version). It conveys the hint that those who kill the sheep ought to be punished. This idea is expressed also in the phrase “with impunity” (New American Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). However, it is not so clear that the Hebrew has the same overtones. Among ancient versions the Septuagint and the Vulgate both seem to understand the words to mean “and they suffered no remorse.” Some versions are more neutral in their wording: “and incur no guilt” (New English Bible/ Revised English Bible). Compare the Revised Standard Version translation of the same verb in Jer 50.7, where it has “We are not guilty.” On the whole it seems better not to suggest that those who killed the sheep ought to have been punished. Translators may say “without remorse,” “without compunction,” or “without feeling any regret.”

Those who sell them say, ‘Blessed be the LORD, I have become rich’: Those who sell them are other merchants, but again it is not clear who they represent symbolically. Good News Translation treats the buyers and the sellers as a single group, “Their owners,” but this is an oversimplification that is not helpful. Blessed be the LORD is a formula for thanking the LORD, and may be rendered “Thanks to the LORD,” “I give thanks to the LORD,” or even “Praise the LORD.”

I have become rich refers to the profit made in selling the sheep.

And their own shepherds have no pity on them: With a further example of the carelessness frequent in the book of Zechariah, the prophet does not make entirely clear who their refers to. In Hebrew a flock of sheep is regarded as feminine because most of the animals in it are ewes (females). Thus the pronoun suffixes translated them four times in this verse are feminine in Hebrew. However, the Hebrew suffix translated their is masculine. By the strict application of the rules of pronoun reference, the masculine suffix must refer back to the people who buy and sell the sheep, and it is taken this way by Delcor. However, since the sense of the passage seems to require that it should be the sheep who have shepherds, most scholars assume that there is a textual error, and read the suffix as feminine. There is only one letter different between the masculine and feminine suffixes (-hem as against -hen), and a few Hebrew manuscripts actually have a feminine at this point. But in fact the Hebrew text as it stands with the masculine suffix can make perfectly good sense. In the light of verses 7 and 12, it is clear that the shepherds are hired by those who buy and sell the sheep (the “traffickers” in Revised Standard Version at verse 11). Translators are therefore recommended to translate as follows: “the shepherds they hire have no pity on the sheep” or “the people they hire to look after the sheep have no pity [on the sheep].”

There is no mention of shepherds other than the prophet himself up to this point, but the text seems to assume that the flock had other shepherds before the prophet was appointed. Verse 8 may be taken to indicate that he was one of several shepherds. These other shepherds did not develop affection for the animals that people who look after animals often show, but had no pity on them; that is to say, they did not care that the animals would be slaughtered. Presumably the prophet himself is not included among those who have no pity. It is possible, as the Revised Version margin indicates, to take the Hebrew as “their shepherd” (singular), and indeed the verb translated have … pity is singular. But this would make an already difficult verse even more complex, and it is noteworthy that the ancient versions have both the noun and the verb in the plural.

A possible alternative model for this verse is:

• Those people who buy the sheep kill them and feel no regret. As for those who sell them, each one says, “I give thanks to the LORD that I have become rich.” Even the people the buyers and sellers [or, dealers] hire to look after the sheep have no pity on them.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 13:8

In Hebrew the verse begins with a word rendered in King James Version and Revised Version as “And it shall come to pass.” In Revised Standard Version and most modern versions, it has no equivalent in English, because a literal translation sounds so stilted. The word does however have the discourse function of marking the beginning of a new subparagraph, and translators should be aware of this even if they do not mark it in setting out their translation. In this new subparagraph the focus moves from the shepherd (probably a symbol for a ruler) to the people as a whole.

In the whole land refers to the territory occupied by the LORD’s people, without saying exactly what or where. At the least it would include Jerusalem and the surrounding area.

Says the LORD is a Hebrew noun phrase as in verse 7, and again it functions at the discourse level to reinforce the opening of a new subunit. For stylistic reasons, namely to avoid repetition that is rather clumsy in English, Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version omit it. Translators may include or omit it according to the stylistic requirements of their own language, but they should be aware of its function.

Two thirds shall be cut off and perish: Two thirds means “two thirds of the people” (New English Bible/ Revised English Bible). The Hebrew expression is literally “mouth of two,” and elsewhere the phrase carries the sense of a double portion (Deut 21.17; 2 Kgs 2.9). Here those killed will be double the number of those who survive. In some languages there are set expressions to refer to fractions, such as “two in three” or “from three, two.” Be cut off may perhaps refer to going into exile, but this verb is a common Hebrew metaphor for dying and probably carries that meaning here. In many languages it may be replaced by a local metaphor. For instance in English, several versions say “be struck down” (New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, New International Version). Perish is merely a higher level word with the same meaning as “die.” Good News Translation runs the two ideas of be cut off and perish together and renders them by the single term “die.” This is clear and simple, but it loses the poetic impact and rhetorical effect of the Hebrew. Translators are advised to retain two verbs if possible.

And one third shall be left alive: This statement says the same as the previous one, but from a different point of view, and is in a sense redundant. Good News Translation absorbs it into the following verse, but this again sacrifices some of the rhetorical effect of the Hebrew, and is not recommended. The general idea behind this verse is probably suggested by the action of Ezekiel in dividing the hair he cut from his head and beard into three parts (Ezek 5.1-4, 12), though the notion of a remnant that survives God’s punishment is common in the prophets who lived and wrote before the exile. See for instance Isa 1.8-9; Amos 3.12; Micah 5.7-8; 7.18.

Possible translation models for the verse are:

• The LORD says that in the whole land, two people out of every three will be struck down and die, and only one will survive.

• The LORD says, “In the whole land most of the people will be struck down and will die, and only a few will remain alive.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 1:12

But you profane it: The pronoun you is plural and refers to the priests, as in verses 6-10. It is emphatic in Hebrew and underlines the contrast between the way the heathen conduct their worship as described in verse 11 and the attitudes of the priests of Israel toward the worship of the LORD. The pronoun it refers grammatically to “my name” in verse 11, which stands for the LORD himself. Several versions translate it as “me” and this is perfectly acceptable (Good News Translation, Revised English Bible, Contemporary English Version, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 1. Edition, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). The statement you profane it echoes the thought of 1.7, though the Hebrew verb is not the same. Good News Translation expresses the meaning in more common language when it says “you dishonor me.”

When you say that the LORD’s table is polluted: These words also echo the thoughts of the last part of verse 7, though not in the same words. The Hebrew word here translated when you say is translated “By thinking” in verse 7 and could be rendered “when you think” here. Again the prophet is criticizing the attitudes of the priests rather than their words.

Translators should note that Revised Standard Version contains a printing error here when it puts LORD‘s in capital letters. The Hebrew text does not have the divine personal name YHWH here, but rather the ordinary word for LORD, which is Ęžadonay. This error is corrected in New Revised Standard Version, which has “the LORD’s table.” As in verse 7, the LORD’s table refers to the altar, and is translated that way in Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version, Bible en français courant, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente. Again, “my altar” (Good News Translation) is a possible translation.

Polluted is better translated “defiled” (Moffatt, Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/Revised English Bible, New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), or even “nothing special” (Contemporary English Version). Compare the notes on verse 7. The first part of this verse may then be alternatively translated as “But you priests dishonor me [or, make me lose face] when you think, ‘There’s nothing special about the LORD’s altar.’ ”

And the food for it may be despised: There is a problem in the Hebrew text underlying this clause. As the Revised Standard Version footnote indicates, the Hebrew contains a rare word that may be understood to mean “its fruit.” This word makes the Hebrew grammar awkward without adding anything significant to the sense of the clause, and Revised Standard Version therefore omits it. The footnote in New Revised Standard Version indicates that the ancient Syriac translation and the Aramaic Targum appear to have followed a Hebrew text that did not include the problem word. The ancient Greek and Latin versions also had difficulties at this point, but do not offer any good evidence for deciding what the original Hebrew text was.

Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament recommends retaining the problem word, and Hebrew Old Testament Text Project recommends translating the Hebrew text “its produce was despised as food.” The argument behind this rendering is that the priests, who had formerly depended on their share of the sacrificial offerings for their livelihood, had by this time become so wealthy that they no longer needed their share of the sacrifices. They had therefore become very casual about the quality of the sacrificial animals, and in this way dishonored the LORD. While this view cannot be ruled out, it seems unnecessarily complicated, and the immediate context does not offer any reason to suppose that wealth was the cause of the priestly slackness. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament refers only to other parts of the Old Testament to support its view. Verhoef retains the problem word, but takes the simpler view that it is to be understood as referring to the other noun (food in Revised Standard Version). A view similar to this appears to be behind the rendering of New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh “the meat, the food can be treated with scorn.”

Translators should accept the traditional Hebrew text, but since the two nouns that occur together are very close in meaning, they may be translated by a single noun, perhaps with a descriptive phrase added, such as “and the food offered on it [that is, the altar] can be treated carelessly.” Other possibilities are “you may offer on the altar second class food” (Bible en français courant), “… food of inferior quality” (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 1. Edition), or “… food that you don’t think much of” (Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 3:15

Henceforth we deem the arrogant blessed: The same people are speaking as in verse 14. The word translated Henceforth shows the link between the two verses: on the basis of their disappointment after following the LORD outwardly, the people are now moving toward open rejection of him, and saying he is not concerned about ethical conduct. Good News Translation has lost the logical link between the verses, and “As we see it” is not an adequate rendering. The simplest links are provided in New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh with “And so,” and New Living Translation with “From now on.” Other options are “Now we have reached the point when” (Jerusalem Bible) and “Now we assert that” (Bible en français courant). The pronoun we is emphatic in Hebrew, and is inclusive since the speakers are talking to one another.

We deem the arrogant blessed sounds old-fashioned and rather unnatural, and New Revised Standard Version puts it in modern words as “we count the arrogant happy.” However, the focus should be on the arrogant, and Good News Translation catches this well with “… proud people are the ones who are happy.” Moffatt keeps the right focus too with “It is the worldly … who are well off.” People who are arrogant or “proud” are those who put their own interests above those of the LORD or of others. For a similar view of the success of such people, compare Psa 73.3-12. Blessed represents the same Hebrew root as in verse 12, and there may be an intended contrast with what is said there. In this context blessed probably carries a sense that is more secular than religious, so that words like “happy” (Good News Translation and many other English versions) or “fortunate” are in order.

The speakers make two further statements to support this opinion. In Hebrew they are linked because each begins with the same particle. In languages like English which have no exact equivalent, the parallel could be indicated by saying “both … and…” or “not only … but also…” (compare Good News Translation).

Evildoers not only prosper: The word evildoers translates an expression in Hebrew in which the verb form indicates regular, habitual action. The people referred to as evildoers are the same as the arrogant in the previous clause. Prosper translates a verb that literally means “are built up” (compare Jer 12.16; 31.4). In some languages it may be possible to keep this metaphor. In others it may be more natural to say “become rich” (compare New Living Translation); for example, “Evil people [or, Everyone who does wrong] not only become rich, but also….”

But when they put God to the test they escape: This refers to testing God in a wrong way, and forms a contrast with the testing mentioned in verse 10. See the notes there. Other ways of expressing this are “but they test God’s patience with their evil deeds” (Good News Translation; similarly Jerusalem Bible), “even those who challenge God” (New International Version; similarly Beck, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition), and “they provoke God” (Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). They escape represents a verb used of soldiers fleeing in war (for instance in 1 Sam 30.17), but here referring to escaping punishment (compare Amos 9.1). Other ways of saying this are “they … get away with it” (Contemporary English Version; similarly Beck), “they … come to no harm” (New English Bible/Revised English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible), “they don’t have to pay for it” (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition), and “they stay unpunished” (Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Haggai 1:1

This introductory verse consists of a single sentence in most English versions, and may indeed be combined with verse 2 into one sentence, as in Revised Standard Version. In many languages it would be better to follow the example of Good News Translation and translate as two or even more sentences. (See also the alternative translation model given at the end of the comments on verse 2.)

Darius the king is Darius Hystaspes, who ruled over Persia 522-486 B.C. Good News Translation makes this clear by saying that “Darius was emperor of Persia.” Darius was really a high king or “emperor” as Good News Translation shows. An “emperor” ruled over a large number of countries and had many lesser rulers under him. Some languages refer to this type of ruler as “supreme ruler [or, supreme chief],” “chief ruler,” or “ruler over many kings [or, chiefs].” Other languages may need to borrow a foreign word such as the English word “emperor,” and also include a footnote or explanatory note in the glossary.

In the second year of Darius the king may also be rendered as “During the second year that Darius the emperor ruled.” In some languages there may be an idiomatic expression for ruled, such as “was on the drum.” Darius’ second year was 520 B.C.

The sixth month is equivalent to August/September in our modern calendar. After the exile, the Jews adopted the Babylonian calendar in which the year began in the spring. In languages where the sixth month will be understood to mean June, translators should provide information to help the reader understand that the Jewish calendar during that period was very different from the one used today in most cultures. Such information can be provided through a table that shows the different calendar systems that were used in the Old Testament.

The first day of the month: This was the day of the new moon. According to Parker and Dubberstein, in 520 B.C. it fell on August 29th. Some translators may wish to refer to the modern date in a footnote. That day would have been a holy day, and therefore a good opportunity to deliver the LORD’s message to the people who assembled for worship. In certain languages it will be helpful to place the phrases in the sixth month, on the first day of the month at the beginning of the verse; for example, “During [or, on] the first day of the sixth month of the second year that Darius ruled as emperor over Persia….” Or it may be better to make a separate sentence and say, “During the second year that Darius ruled as emperor of Persia, the LORD spoke…. This message came to Haggai on the first day of the sixth month in that year.”

The word of the LORD came by Haggai the prophet: There is no indication of how the word of the LORD came, and no suggestion of any dream or trance. Good News Translation expresses these words in natural modern English as “the LORD spoke through the prophet Haggai,” but another possible model is “the LORD used [or, caused] Haggai the prophet to give [or, deliver] the following message.” Haggai is mentioned elsewhere only in Ezra 5.1; 6.14, where he is linked with Zechariah and is again referred to as a prophet. Prophet translates a common Hebrew word and means “one who proclaims the LORD’s message.” In most languages an expression similar to this will be the best solution for translating prophet; for example, “one who speaks the things of God,” “one who is an interpreter for God,” and so on. However, translators should try to find a short, concise expression, as this word appears many times in the Bible. The following advice, found in A Translator’s Handbook on the Book of Amos may help in the translation of this word:

There are also problems related to the translation of LORD. Many translators will already be familiar with the term used in the New Testament where “Lord” applies both to God and to Jesus Christ. Here in Haggai, and elsewhere in the Old Testament, it applies to God alone.

The message that the LORD gave Haggai was intended for the civil and religious leaders of the Jewish community, the governor of Judah and the high priest. The governor was Zerubbabel the son of Shealtiel, a grandson of Jehoiachin, the king of Judah taken into exile in 597 B.C. (2 Kgs 24.15). He was therefore a descendant of King David. According to 1 Chr 3.19, Zerubbabel was son of Pedaiah, a younger brother of Shealtiel, who appears to have had no children. It may be that Shealtiel adopted his nephew Zerubbabel, and if so, it would explain the description of him here as the son of Shealtiel. It is not clear whether Zerubbabel is to be identified with the person called Sheshbazzar in Ezra 1.8. Governor here refers to an official appointed by the Persian emperor to rule over a province of his empire, in this case Judah. Governors were different from local kings or chiefs and were directly responsible to the emperor. If translators follow the ordering of the two phrases in Revised Standard Version Zerubbabel the son of Shealtiel, governor of Judah, readers in many languages may think that Shealtiel, not Zerubbabel was governor of Judah. In such cases it will be better to reorder the phrases as Good News Translation does: “The message was for the governor of Judah, Zerubbabel son of Shealtiel.”

The high priest was Joshua the son of Jehozadak. Jehozadak was the high priest who had been taken into exile when Jerusalem was captured by the Babylonians in 586 B.C. Joshua is also mentioned in Zech 3.1; 6.11; and in the books of Ezra (2.2 and elsewhere) and Nehemiah (12.1, 26), where his name is spelled in Hebrew “Jeshua” (Revised Standard Version). In some languages, translators may wish to keep the spelling “Jeshua” in the books of Haggai and Zechariah, in order to distinguish this man from the better known Joshua the son of Nun, who led the people of Israel into the promised land. This is done for instance by New Living Translation. The primary duty of a priest in the Hebrew culture was to be an intermediary (a person who was a channel of communication) between the LORD and his people. The means used was sacrifice. So, in some languages translators have used terms meaning “sacrificer” or “intermediary.” We should note, however, that it was not the priest who actually killed the sacrificial animal but rather the worshiper. Translators must take care not to use a term that refers to pagan sacrifices radically different from those offered by the people of Israel. If a translation is already using borrowed terms such as “priest” or “padre,” it will be helpful to have a note in the glossary explaining the duties and role of a priest in the Jewish culture. High priest may be translated in many languages as “chief priest” or “big priest.” Again the ordering of the two phrases in Revised Standard Version might seem to indicate that Jehozadak was the high priest. Translators should be careful and follow the model of Good News Translation.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Haggai 2:20 - 2:22

The word of the LORD came a second time to Haggai: The Hebrew expression for The word of the LORD came … to Haggai is the same as in verse 10. See the comments on that verse. In the present context, the phrase a second time is added. In some languages this may be translated simply as “again” (Contemporary English Version).

On the twenty-fourth day of the month: Good News Translation makes it clear that the date of this last message is the same as that of the previous one by saying “On that same day” before repeating the date, “the twenty-fourth of the month” (compare verse 10). This was December 18, 520 B.C.

“Speak to Zerubbabel, governor of Judah, saying…”: We may note that as in verses 10-11, the Hebrew here has a quotation within a quotation. Double quotations of this kind are unnatural in many languages, and Good News Translation has restructured so as to have only a single quotation. Contemporary English Version uses a colon () at the end of verse 20 to avoid any quotes, “20 That same day the LORD spoke to Haggai again and said: 21 Tell Governor Zerubbabel of Judah that….” Either model may be helpful for translators in terms of the structure. However, Good News Translation is not very helpful in its wording “the LORD gave Haggai a second message for Zerubbabel.” As it stands, this suggests that the first message of that day had also been addressed to Zerubbabel, but actually verse 10 does not say this or even suggest it. In fact, verse 14 makes it clear that the earlier message was for the population of Jerusalem and Judah as a whole. It would therefore be better to make two sentences here and say something like “On that same day … the LORD gave Haggai a second message. This time it was for Zerubbabel…” For Zerubbabel, governor of Judah, see the comments on 1.1.

I am about to shake the heavens and the earth: These words translate the same words in Hebrew as those that occurred in verse 6. See the comments there. Again they seem to indicate that Haggai expected the Messianic kingdom to be established before very long. This time he speaks more directly about the position of Zerubbabel in fulfilling the LORD’s purposes (verse 23). The expression I am about to … may be difficult in some languages. Another way to say this could be “It is almost time for me to…” or “Soon I will….” In some translations it may be necessary to make it clear that the LORD is the agent by saying “I, the LORD, am about to shake…,” “I, the LORD, am getting ready to shake…,” or “I, the LORD, am girding up my loins so that I may shake….”

I am about … to overthrow the throne of the kingdoms; I am about to destroy the strength of the kingdoms of the nations: These opening clauses of verse 22 in Hebrew say much the same thing twice in slightly different words. Because this is repetitive, Good News Translation expresses its meaning only once as “I am about to … overthrow kingdoms and end their power.” While this is more natural English, it appears to omit anything equivalent to of the nations. This could be restored by saying “foreign kingdoms” (as in New International Version and New Living Translation). New English Bible and Revised English Bible say the same sort of thing in higher level English with “heathen realms.” Other ways to express these clauses are “I am about to overthrow the authority and power of foreign kingdoms,” “Soon I am going to cause the kings [or, high chiefs] of foreign nations to lose their power,” and “I am getting ready to take away the power of the kings of foreign nations.”

Haggai is here referring to the various revolts and uprisings throughout the eastern parts of the Persian Empire, which Darius had to deal with before he was firmly established as emperor. They were actually taking place around the time of this message, and probably seemed to Haggai to be signs that the time was near when the LORD would step in and set up the kingdom of the Messiah.

And overthrow the chariots and their riders: The rest of verse 22 states in more detail how the LORD will break the power of the foreign kingdoms. Chariots were in those days one of the more advanced forms of military hardware, but even they would not be able to resist the LORD’s power. In some languages chariots will be rendered as “horse-drawn war carts.”

The horses and their riders shall go down, every one by the sword of his fellow: The literal translation of Revised Standard Version makes it sound as if the horses also killed each other with swords. Good News Translation has restructured to avoid this possibility and says “the horses will die, and their riders will kill one another” (similarly Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). This does not state who kills the horses, but the context makes it fairly clear that the fallen riders do so. The Hebrew does not actually state that the horses will be killed, but the verb go down strongly suggests going down to the place of the dead, not just falling over (compare Isa 5.14; Jer 48.15; 50.27; Ezek 32.19).

There is a further point which is not absolutely clear and that is whether the riders of the chariots and the riders of the horses are the same people or not. The parallel structure of the clauses in Hebrew suggests that they are not. Several versions such as Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/Revised English Bible, New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh and Contemporary English Version also seem to assume that they are not, though none says this directly. Generally speaking, charioteers and horsemen formed separate sections of ancient armies, and it seems more likely that different groups were in Haggai’s mind. A translator could remove the ambiguities of the verse by saying “I will overturn chariots and tip their drivers out of them. The cavalry horses will fall, and their riders will kill each other, and each other’s horses” or “I will cause the chariots to overturn and the drivers to fall out. The war horses will fall down [or, over] and the men who ride them will kill each other and each others’ horses.”

The idea of the enemies of God’s people killing each other is an ancient one (see Jdg 7.22) and became part of the traditional language associated with the LORD’s final intervention in history (compare Ezek 38.21; Zech 14.13; Matt 24.7; Mark 13.8; Luke 21.10).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 2:11

A major question for translators to decide in this and the following verses is where the direct speech of the LORD finishes. Moffatt and Good News Translation finish the LORD’s words at the end of verse 10 (supported by Petersen). Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente carry them to the middle of verse 11 (supported by Merrill). Revised Standard Version carries them down to the end of verse 12. New International Version, New Living Translation, Contemporary English Version, Beck, and Traduction œcumĂŠnique de la Bible carry them down to the end of verse 13 (supported by Amsler, R. L. Smith). Many other versions do not use quotation marks and so are not clear on this point. No available commentary discusses the question in any detail, but we may make the following observations:
(1) The Hebrew states clearly that verse 10 is the words of the LORD, so this is not in dispute.
(2) The occurrence of “says the LORD” at the end of verse 10 could possibly be interpreted as an indication that the LORD’s words finish there, but it does not have to be.
(3) In the Hebrew of verse 11, the LORD refers to himself in the first person, my people … I will dwell, which strongly suggests that he continues to be the speaker.
(4) The words at the end of verse 11, you shall know that the LORD of hosts has sent me to you, may be the words of the prophet, though they could equally well be treated as an aside that interrupts the LORD’s words (compare with verse 9).

When these points are taken into consideration, we can add the following comments:
(5) On the whole it seems best not to follow the Greek in verse 11, and end the LORD’s words at the end of verse 10. This is the choice of Moffatt and Good News Translation, and is probably the intended choice of Bible de JĂŠrusalem, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh.
(6) If the traditional Hebrew text is followed, as Hebrew Old Testament Text Project and Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament propose, the LORD’s words could be taken to extend as far as in the midst of you in verse 11. Versions taking this view include Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente. The problem is that this view leads to an abrupt change of speaker in the middle of the verse.
(7) There is no evidence in the Hebrew text that the LORD’s words could not include verse 12. Therefore translators are recommended to follow the punctuation of Revised Standard Version.

Many nations shall join themselves to the LORD: This indicates that the LORD’s blessing will extend beyond the limits of the Jewish nation. In more natural English, Good News Translation expresses this as “many nations will come to the LORD.” Compare Isa 2.2-4; Micah 4.1-3. Translators may also say, “People from many countries will become the LORD’s people.”

In that day refers to a period of time longer than 24 hours. Good News Translation translates with the more general “At that time.” Compare the notes on Hag 2.23. Translators could also say “from that day [or, time] onwards.”

And shall be my people: The foreign nations will turn to the LORD and share the same kind of relationship with him as the Jews.

And I will dwell in the midst of you: In Hebrew these words are identical with those in verse 10, and you refers back to “daughter of Zion” there. This clause may indicate a position of special privilege for the LORD’s people when the gentile nations turn to him. If so, then it may be better to translate the opening conjunction as “but” rather than and. In this clause there is an abrupt change from the previous two clauses in the way the LORD is referred to. He now speaks of himself in the first person, as in verse 10. Some translators may prefer to keep this abrupt change in their translation. Others, however, may decide to follow the example of Good News Translation, and change my people and I will dwell to “his people” and “he will dwell.” Another possibility is to use the first person in the first half of verse 11, and say, “Many nations will come to me [rather than “to the LORD”] and will become my people.” But if this possibility is accepted, it may cause some confusion with the use of me in the last part of the verse to refer to the prophet.

You shall know that the LORD of hosts has sent me to you: These words are not identical with those of verse 9. In verse 9 “you” was masculine plural, whereas here it is feminine singular. Here also the words to you (again feminine singular) are added at the end. In this context you can refer back only to “daughter of Zion” in verse 10. But since “daughter of Zion” is a way of speaking collectively about the people of Jerusalem, it may be necessary to translate you as plural in many languages.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 5:9

Then I lifted my eyes and saw, and behold: Compare the comments on verse 1. In the previous verse Zechariah was gazing at the barrel that was apparently near him. Now it seems that he looks up to the sky. So translators may render as Good News Translation does, “I looked up and saw.”

Two women coming forward!: It is impossible to identify any special significance in the number two, or in the fact that these figures were female. For translators who must indicate a direction of movement, it was presumably toward Zechariah.

The wind was in their wings; they had wings like the wings of a stork: The expression the wind was in their wings means much the same as “they were flying.” New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh tries to catch something of the emotive effect of the unusual Hebrew expression by translating, “I … saw two women come soaring with the wind in their wings.” Contemporary English Version is also helpful with “I saw two women coming through the sky like storks with wings outstretched in the wind.” A stork is a large bird with a wing span of about two meters (between six and seven feet). Good News Translation tries to give some indication of its size by saying “powerful wings like those of a stork.” In areas where storks are not known, translators could say “powerful wings like those of a large bird” or just “large and powerful wings.” The Hebrew word for stork sounds like another word that can mean “loyalty.” This wordplay may be intended to suggest that it is those who are loyal to God who remove evil from among his people.

In these two clauses, Revised Standard Version follows the Hebrew order, which is clumsy in English. Many translators will need to restructure the first part of the verse so as to mention the wings earlier. One possibility would be “I saw two women with powerful wings like storks’ wings [or, like the wings of a large bird] come flying toward me.”

They lifted up the ephah between earth and heaven: Storks are birds that fly high (compare Jer 8.7) and the expression between earth and heaven probably suggests high flight. The next verse makes it clear that the two women took the barrel away, but in many languages it would be good to make that information clear at this point (compare Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Translators could say something like “They lifted the barrel high in the air and flew away with it.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .