Translation commentary on Zechariah 12:9

For on that day, see the comments above on this whole section.

I will seek to destroy: I is the LORD speaking again in the first person. The Revised Standard Version wording I will seek may sound as if the LORD will attempt to destroy the armies attacking Jerusalem without being sure of success. This is not the intended meaning, and the Hebrew is better translated as “I will/shall set about destroying” (New English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible), or even “I am determined to destroy.” The Hebrew word translated destroy is a strong term, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh renders it with the strong English term “annihilate.” Another possibility is “wipe out” (Contemporary English Version).

All the nations that come against Jerusalem refers to the same people already referred to in verses 2, 3, and 6. See the comments on those verses. Come against is expressed more clearly as “attack” (Good News Translation, New International Version, Revised English Bible).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 14:21

And every pot in Jerusalem and Judah shall be sacred to the LORD of hosts: Not only will the pots used in the Temple for humble purposes become holy, but so will every pot in the land. It is as though the sanctity of the Temple area will expand to include the whole country. The expression that Revised Standard Version here renders sacred to the LORD is the same in Hebrew as the one in the previous verse, which it rendered “Holy to the LORD.” The link between the two verses is shown more clearly if the expression is translated in the same way both times. Almost all modern English versions except Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, and Contemporary English Version do so, and this is to be recommended. Translators should note that this time the divine name has its longer form the LORD of hosts. For LORD of hosts, see Hag 1.2.

So that all who sacrifice may come and take of them: Several commentators point out that with so many foreigners coming to attend the Festival of Shelters, there would be a shortage of sacred vessels for ceremonial use. The extension of the special status of holiness to include all the pots in the land would solve the problem. In that way all who sacrifice would find a suitable vessel to take and use.

And boil the flesh of the sacrifice in them: In most sacrifices the worshipers shared in the eating of the animal. The flesh had to be cooked by boiling (see 2 Chr 35.13), and the pots could be used for this purpose.

And there shall no longer be a trader in the house of the LORD of hosts on that day: The word that Revised Standard Version translates trader is actually the word for “Canaanite” as in 11.7, 11. (see the notes on “trafficked” in 11.7, and compare Job 41.6; Pro 31.24 [Revised Standard Version “merchant”]; Zeph 1.11). There is some debate about whether the word in this context carries its primary meaning of “Canaanite,” or its derived or associated meaning, trader. Most modern English versions have “trader” or “merchant.” Only New International Version and Beck say “Canaanite,” and New International Version offers “merchant” as an alternative in a footnote. It is possible that the prophet was consciously making a pun. In the new era when all pots are holy, there will be no need for traders “to sell ritually pure vessels” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh footnote). Likewise there will be no place for “Canaanites” as representatives of false religion. In the light of this possibility, it is recommended that translators follow the example of New Revised Standard Version, and put “traders” in the text and “Canaanites” in a footnote as an alternative.

This verse may have been in the minds of the writers of the Gospels when they recorded Christ’s cleansing of the Temple (Matt 21.12-13; Mark 11.15-17; Luke 19.45-46; John 2.13-16).

The final words on that day function as a time phrase emphasizing that the events described belong to the end time. Obviously they cannot in this position function as a marker for the opening of a new discourse unit.

An alternative translation model combining verses 20 and 21 is as follows:

• 20-21 At that time people will inscribe the words “Sacred to the LORD” on the bells worn by the horses. The ordinary pots in the Temple, and indeed every cooking pot in Jerusalem and the whole of Judah will be just as sacred to the LORD Almighty as the bowls used before [or, at] the altar. Any of them will be acceptable for anyone who comes to sacrifice an animal to use for boiling the meat, and at that time there will be no need for merchants to sell special pots and bowls.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 3:4

Then the offering of Judah and Jerusalem will be pleasing to the LORD: Once the priests are carrying out their duties with sincerity and ritual correctness, then the offerings of “the people of Judah and Jerusalem” (Good News Translation) will again be acceptable to the LORD. For comments on Judah and Jerusalem, see the notes on 2.11. The Hebrew word order puts some emphasis on pleasing. The word here translated pleasing is not the same term as occurred in 2.17 and 3.1, where Revised Standard Version has “delight in.” Here the meaning is more like “sweet.” Other renderings include “welcome” (Moffatt, Jerusalem Bible) and “accept/acceptable” (New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, New Living Translation). This word is also used in the context of sacrifices in Jer 6.20.

As in the days of old and as in former years: These two phrases are parallel with each other and say essentially the same thing. The days of old is used elsewhere both of the period of Moses (Isa 63.11) and that of David (Amos 9.11). In all likelihood Malachi is thinking of the time when the Levites were zealous in their duties (see for instance Num 25.6-13), that is to say primarily the time of Moses. The former years is a vague and general expression without clear reference to any particular period. In some languages it may be more natural to run these two phrases into one and say “in the past” (Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version), “in former times” (New Living Translation), or “in ancient times” (compare Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Haggai 2:8

The silver is mine, and the gold is mine: Coined money was known in the late sixth century B.C., but was not yet in common use. At this time it was still the normal practice to weigh out amounts of precious metal in business transactions (compare Zech 11.12 in Revised Standard Version). Thus in speaking of the “treasures” of the nations (verse 7), it was natural to refer to silver and gold rather than money in the form of coins.

The Hebrew makes separate statements about the silver and the gold, but Good News Translation puts them together into one: “All the silver and gold of the world is mine.” The words “all” and “of the world” are included to make the connection between this verse and the previous one clear: because all the silver and gold belongs to the LORD, he is well able to ensure that the gentiles will offer it in his Temple when he so desires. Thus the new Temple will be no less splendid than the old one (1 Kgs 6.20-22). For a partial fulfillment of this promise, see Ezra 6.8-12. Translators may of course say “silver and gold” or “gold and silver,” whichever is more natural in their language.

Translators may use two clauses, as Revised Standard Version, or one, as Good News Translation, and should choose whichever structure sounds more natural and more rhetorically effective in their language.

The closing words says the LORD of hosts are omitted by Good News Translation, as in verses 4, 6, and 9. See the comments on verse 4. Here they indicate the end of a discourse unit.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 1:21

And I said: The verb that is usual in English to introduce a question in direct speech is “asked,” as in Good News Translation. If other languages have a term equivalent to “asked” for introducing questions, it would be good to use it here.

What are these coming to do?: Instead of these, Good News Translation uses the pronoun “they” for natural English. In some languages it would be more appropriate to repeat the term used in the previous verse: “workers,” “craftsmen,” or “smiths,” or else to say “these men” as in earlier editions of Good News Translation. The words coming to do suggest that there was something about the appearance of the smiths which indicated to Zechariah that they were ready for work. We cannot say what it was. Since the men were already present, Good News Translation is clearer with a past tense, “What have they come to do?”

When the angel answered, he first of all referred back to the horns which scattered Judah, so that no man raised his head (see verse 19). At the end of the verse he mentions them again as the horns of the nations who lifted up their horns against the land of Judah to scatter it. This repetition of what is basically the same idea sounds clumsy in English, and Good News Translation has therefore stated the idea only once at the end of the verse. In many languages translators will find it more natural to follow this example.

The horns which scattered Judah, so that no man raised his head: The effect that the enemy nations’ action had on the people of Judah is described figuratively. One of the results of the enemy oppression was that the people were scattered. As in verse 19, this is a reference to the dispersion of the Jews in the exile. Another result of the oppression was that no man raised his head. In some languages there may be a figurative expression like this to represent oppression, and if so, translators should consider using it here. Good News Translation expresses this meaning in a different picture, and says, “the nations that completely crushed the land of Judah.” Note that Good News Translation also replaces the symbol of the horns with “the nations.” New English Bible adds “and Jerusalem” after Judah, but there is no adequate reason for this, and Revised English Bible drops the addition.

These have come to terrify them, to cast down … the nations: The main focus of the angel’s reply is on the activity of the workmen. They are agents who carry out the LORD’s punishment against the nations, that is, the enemies who oppressed his people (see verse 15). Terrify means to “make very afraid.” In certain languages this clause with terrify may be translated “These men have come to make the hearts of … fall,” “… to make the souls of … flee and their bile stir up,” or “… to make their hearts turn to water.” Cast down means “overthrow” (Good News Translation), “crush” (Contemporary English Version), or “destroy” (New Living Translation).

The horns of the nations who lifted up their horns against the land of Judah to scatter it: As mentioned above, this essentially repeats the information given in the earlier part of the verse. In this repetition, however, the information is given in a way that would sound extremely clumsy in most languages. The notion of horns … who lifted up their horns is odd and confusing, and translators will do well not to retain it (so Good News Translation).

A helpful restructuring of the whole verse can be based on Bible en français courant and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente:

• I asked, “What have they come to do?”
He replied, “These blacksmiths have come to terrify and overthrow the powerful nations who attacked the land of Judah, scattering its inhabitants, and crushing all resistance.”

Another possibility is:

• I asked, “What have they come to do?”
The LORD replied, “These horns stand for the nations that have scattered and oppressed the people of Judah. The blacksmiths [or, workmen] have come to terrify those nations and destroy their power.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 4:12

And a second time I said to him: It appears that the prophet adds a second question before the angel has an opportunity to answer the first one. Since Zechariah remains the speaker, these introductory words are an interruption in the flow of the speech that may be awkward in some languages. Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version omit them and continue straight on with the second question (similarly New Living Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente), and translators may do the same if this would result in a better style in their own language. Most translations, however, keep the quotation formula, which can be expressed as “And I also asked him.” The question that follows raises various problems, both in terms of the words used and in terms of its relation to the description in verses 2-3.

What are these two branches of the olive trees: For What are…? Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version render “what is the meaning of…?” (compare verses 4, 11). The Hebrew word here translated branches elsewhere always has the meaning “grains of wheat growing at the top of the stalk.” Scholars think that here it must mean “the extreme ends of fruit-laden boughs,” so New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh translates it as “the two tops of the olive trees.” Since English has no special term for this particular part of a tree, several translations use a more general term like branches (Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, Good News Translation, Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible, Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente) and translators with a similar problem may do the same. These branches have not been mentioned before and we must assume that they are simply prominent boughs, probably one on each tree.

Which are beside the two golden pipes from which the oil is poured out: These pipes have not been mentioned before either, and it is not certain where they were. The most probable interpretation is that they connected the trees to the bowl of verse 2, and supplied olive oil as fuel for the lamps. Of course, oil does not pour from an olive tree in everyday life: the olives have to be gathered and pressed to get the oil. But in a vision such details may be omitted. The tree was the ultimate source of the oil, and that is what the vision shows.

The word translated oil is the normal word for “gold,” and this causes a problem for interpreters. Some commentators assume that the “gold” stands for the color of the oil by a figure of speech called metonymy. Others assume that some words have been lost from the Hebrew, and that there was originally a reference to the golden bowl of verse 2. Others have suggested that the Hebrew word, though the same word for gold, is actually from a different root, and means “oil.” Whatever the truth may be, English versions generally render it as oil (Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, Good News Translation), “golden oil” (New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, New International Version, New Living Translation, Bible en français courant), or even “golden olive oil” (Contemporary English Version), and this is what we recommend that other translators should do. Contemporary English Version offers a helpful model for this verse:

• And what is the meaning of the two branches from which golden olive oil flows through the two gold pipes?

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 7:5

Say to all the people of the land and the priests: The message is not addressed directly to the visitors who had asked the question in verse 3, but they are probably to be included among those addressed.

In Revised Standard Version this is followed by a second degree quotation, but Good News Translation restructures it as indirect speech: “Tell the people of the land and the priests that….” See the comments above in the introduction to this paragraph.

When you fasted and mourned … was it for me that you fasted?: Although this sentence has the form of a question, the context clearly expects a negative answer. The overall effect is therefore that of a negative statement. Good News Translation has restructured it as a negative statement: “when they fasted and mourned … it was not in honor of me” (similarly Bible en français courant). Many translators will find it helpful to do the same. Contemporary English Version restructures, but keeps a question: “you have gone without eating … But did you really do it for me?” This is also an acceptable model.

In the fifth month and in the seventh: The fast in the fifth month commemorated the destruction of Solomon’s Temple by the Babylonians (see the comments on verse 3). The fast in the seventh month, not mentioned in verse 3, commemorated the murder of Gedaliah, the man appointed as governor of Judah by the Babylonians after the capture of Jerusalem (2 Kgs 25.25; Jer 41.1-3). This information may be added in a footnote, as in Bible en français courant and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente.

For these seventy years: This is a round figure. The exact time was two or three years less, but translators should keep to the round figure.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 9:1

This verse contains a variety of problems for the translator involving both text and interpretation. The first is to decide how to break up the string of words into smaller units. The first three words of the Hebrew (massaĘľ devar YHWH) occur together not only here, but also in 12.1 and Mal 1.1, and nowhere else in the Old Testament. In terms of the discourse structure, it seems best to treat these words as an introductory formula in all three places, though it is not certain whether it consists of one phrase or two. Unfortunately Revised Standard Version (with a large number of other modern versions) separates only the first word massaĘľ both here and at 12.1, and treats it alone as a heading. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh (with the support of the Septuagint) treats the three words together as a formula and translates “A pronouncement: The word of the LORD,” and this is a clearer reflection of the discourse function of the formula. However, it does create a problem in that the following clause is then left with no clear subject. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh solves this problem by continuing with “He will reside in the land of Hadrach and Damascus,” where “He” is the LORD.

Other versions both ancient and modern take the three Hebrew words together as one phrase, and interpret it as the subject of the following clause. For instance, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente has “This message from the LORD concerns the region of Hadrach and the city of Damascus” (compare Vulgate). This solution is good provided that the translator can use a similar expression at least at Zech 12.1, and thus preserve the discourse connection between 9.1 and 12.1, as Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente does. Contemporary English Version is similar, but has a colon at the end of this introductory statement (“This is a message from the LORD:”). Translators are advised to follow this interpretation. Although the most desirable choice would be to translate massaʾ devar YHWH the same way in all three places where it occurs, the different grammatical contexts may make this impossible. Translators should at least try to make the three places similar enough that readers can recognize that there is a link between them.

An Oracle: This means an authoritative message from God. The word of the LORD is often rendered as “the LORD’s message” (Good News Translation; similarly Contemporary English Version, Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). Good News Translation has a separate sentence with a colon (“This is the LORD’s message:”), and the message that follows begins on a new line (similarly Contemporary English Version).

Is against the land of Hadrach: It is doubtful whether the Hebrew preposition translated against in Revised Standard Version and some other versions really carries this meaning. The Hebrew word usually means “in,” and is so translated by Revised English Bible. If against were the meaning intended, it is likely that another preposition which carries this meaning more clearly would have been used. The use of against here is particularly unfortunate because it conveys the impression that this paragraph is solely a message of judgment, which it is not. Although the word against does not occur in Good News Translation, Good News Translation shows that it shares the same interpretation by saying that the LORD “has decreed punishment for the land of Hadrach.” The verdict of Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament and Hebrew Old Testament Text Project is that a more neutral interpretation is desirable, and we agree with this, especially in the light of the second part of the verse. Translations such as Jerusalem Bible “Yahweh has passed through the land of Hadrach” and New English Bible “He has come to…” are based on changes to the Hebrew text which are unnecessary, and have been abandoned by New Jerusalem Bible and Revised English Bible. The land of Hadrach is not mentioned anywhere else in the Bible, and its exact location is unknown. Archeological evidence suggests that it was somewhere in the same general area as the city of Damascus, that is, to the north of Israel.

And will rest upon Damascus: The Hebrew word translated rest upon is actually a noun, and is rendered as such in Jerusalem Bible “Damascus is his dwelling place.” It does not suggest a hostile encounter between the LORD and the city, and this helps to confirm that the LORD is not hostile to Hadrach in the previous phrase. The Hebrew word may indicate a temporary rather than a permanent stay, and this idea is shown in New American Bible “Damascus is its resting place” and Revised English Bible “it alights on Damascus.” Possible alternative translation models for the first part of the verse are: “A declaration of the LORD’s message: He will stay in the land of Hadrach and the city of Damascus” and “This is a message from the LORD:….”

For to the LORD belong the cities of Aram, even as all the tribes of Israel: This clause also contains problems both of text and of interpretation. Revised Standard Version, as its footnote indicates, makes two changes to the Hebrew text to get its rendering. For the cities of Aram, the Hebrew text actually has words that mean either “the eye of Adam” or “the eye of man,” since the Hebrew word Ęľadam may be either the name of an individual or a common noun meaning “man” (Revised Standard Version footnote) or “humankind” (New Revised Standard Version footnote). Revised Standard Version takes the text as cities instead of “eye”; and it renders Aram (that is, Syria) instead of “Adam.” The difference between the letters “d” and “r” in Hebrew is very small. Revised Standard Version makes good sense with the overall message that Syria belongs to the LORD just as much as Israel does. However, there is no support for its changes in manuscripts or in ancient versions, and this rendering does not fit well with against in the earlier part of the verse. New Revised Standard Version retains only one of the two changes to the Hebrew (“Aram” for “Adam”). New Revised Standard Version and Revised English Bible keep the Hebrew word “eye,” but interpret it figuratively to mean “the capital of Aram,” that is, Damascus (so Good News Translation). Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament and Hebrew Old Testament Text Project reject both proposed changes, and discourse considerations support this, as the word “eye” occurs again at the end of the paragraph in verse 8.

Even if translators retain the Hebrew word for “eye” here however, they still have to decide how to interpret the whole clause in which it occurs, literally “to the LORD the eye of Adam/mankind.” This is often taken to mean that “all people will look to the LORD” (Revised Version text, New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, New Living Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 2. Edition, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament, Hebrew Old Testament Text Project). However, it could also mean that the LORD looks on all mankind (Revised Version footnote, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, 1. Edition). This meaning is paralleled by the idea of the LORD looking at his people in verse 8, and is probably the best option, though the interpretation that has people looking to the LORD offers both an acceptable sense in the immediate context and a reasonable balance to verse 8. So there are two possible translations: “for the LORD has his eye on humankind” or “for people everywhere look to the LORD.”

The words even as do not correspond to anything in the Hebrew, but almost all translations supply them or something similar. New Jerusalem Bible has “… belongs to Yahweh no less than all the tribes of Israel.” Bible en français courant has “… not only on the tribes of Israel but also all human beings.”

In the light of the above discussions, translation models for this verse are:

• A declaration of the LORD’s message: The LORD will stay in the land of Hadrach and in Damascus. Indeed, he has his eye on all mankind as on all the tribes of Israel.

• An announcement of the LORD’s message: The LORD will stay in the land of Hadrach and in the city of Damascus. Indeed, people everywhere, not just all the tribes of Israel, look to him.

The first possibility seems somewhat preferable.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .