Text:
After tÄs erÄmĹseĹs âof desolationâ Textus Receptus adds to rÄthen hupo DaniÄl tou prophÄtou âthat was spoken by the prophet Daniel,â which is omitted by all modern editions of the Greek text.
Exegesis:
hotan de idÄte âbut when you seeâ: refers to a single definite event.
to bdelugma tÄs erÄmĹseĹs âthe abomination of desolationâ: the Greek phrase is the Septuagint translation of the Hebrew shiquts shomem in Dan. 11.31, 12.1 (cf. also 9.27) âthe detested thing causing horrorâ (Brown, Driver and Briggs). It is generally held that the phrase in Daniel referred to the heathen altar erected in the Temple in Jerusalem by Antiochus Epiphanes in 168 B.C. (cf. 1 Macc. 1.54). In the O.T. shiquts refers generally to a heathen idol or false god, or any other symbol of heathenism. The verb shamem means âto appal,â âto cause horror.â
The Greek phrase means literally âthe detested thing causing desolation.â The cryptic language of Mark does not make clear what is desolated by the âabominable thing.â Various translations are proposed for the phrase: âthe dreadful desecrationâ (Goodspeed), âthe appalling Horrorâ (Moffatt), âthe destructive desecrationâ (Williams).
hestÄkota âstandingâ: the accusative case of the masculine participle hestÄkĹs, meaning properly âhe who stands.â Whereas to bdelugma âthe detestable thingâ to which the participle refers is neuter, either âthe detestable thingâ is personified (cf. Swete), or else it is thought of as being a man (the Antichrist â so many commentators). Against Revised Standard Version it would be preferable to translate âstanding where he should notâ rather than âit.â
histÄmi âstandâ: as in 9.1 the emphasis here is more on the idea of âbeingâ or âexistingâ than on âstandingâ as such.
hopou ou dei âwhere (he) ought not to beâ: for dei âit is necessary,â âit is fittingâ cf. 8.31.
ho anaginĹskĹn noeitĹ âhe who reads is to understandâ: as Revised Standard Version parentheses indicate, this is a note added by the author (cf. a similar instance in 7.19) calling the reader’s attention to what he is reading. It is probable that âthe readerâ is the man who would be reading the passage aloud to the assembled congregation, not to the individual reading alone. It is not agreed what is the specific thing to which the author calls the reader’s attention: many take it to refer to the enigmatic phrase âthe abomination of desolation,â admonishing the reader to understand the phrase in light of its use in the O.T., while others take it to refer to the vague designation of the place where âthe abomination of desolationâ would stand. It has also been suggested that the note, possibly a marginal note at first, called the reader’s attention to the masculine hestÄkota âstandingâ which the reader would be tempted to read as a neuter, agreeing with to bdelugma âthe abomination.â
anaginĹskĹ (cf. 2.25) âread,â âread aloud.â
noeĹ (cf. 7.18) âunderstand,â âcomprehend.â
hoi en tÄ Ioudaia pheugetĹsan eis ta orÄ âthose who are in Judea are to flee to the mountainsâ: in the hill country to the west of the Jordan they would find refuge from the desolation sweeping Judea.
pheugĹ (cf. 5.14) âflee.â
eis ta orÄ (cf. 3.13) âto the hills,â âto the hill country.â
Translation:
Desolating sacrilege is not an easy expression to translate, for the words include complex concepts which are not clearly defined, either in their immediate forms or in the larger context. The only alternative in most languages is to attempt to use some descriptive phrase which will approximate the meaning of the Greek, but not reproduce it in any word-for-word relationship, e.g. âthe hated (thing) which does terrible destructionâ (Yucateco), âthe foul object which desolates the town,â in which âdesolateâ must occur with a direct object (Chicahuaxtla Triqui), âthat which is bad which destroysâ (Central Mazahua, Tzeltal), âfearful thing which destroysâ (Yaka), and âloathsome thing which destroysâ (San Mateo del Mar Huave).
See the desolating sacrilege set up involves a construction which requires two clauses in many languages, since the object of the first verb see is also the subject of the second verb set up, e.g. âsee the desolating sacrilege: it will be set up where it ought not to be.â
If the interesting shift in the Greek from the neuter to the masculine, implying evidently a personification of the desolating sacrilege, can be reproduced in another language, this should be done, but in most instances this cannot be accomplished without considerable confusion to the reader.
Let the reader understand is in the form of a third person imperative, which is paralleled in other languages by a statement of obligation, e.g. âthe one who is reading should understand.â The same type of adaptation may be required in the case of the last clause, e.g. âthose who are in the Judea country should flee to the mountains.â
Quoted with permission from Bratcher, Robert G. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on the Gospel of Mark. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1961. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .
