Translation commentary on Philemon 1:9

Because I love you represents the Greek “on account of love,” which might be rendered impersonally “on the basis of (Christian) love,” or mutually, “because we love another” (Barclay). The rendering of love in this context should suggest friendship and sincere appreciation.

I make a request translates parakaleƍ (also verse 10), here with the meaning of “to plead, appeal,” perhaps “to beg a favor.” An appeal is often expressed figuratively, for example, “I ask you with my heart exposed” or “I ask you from my abdomen.”

What follows in the verse comes as a concessive clause, even though I am, which implies that what Paul is gives him the right to do otherwise than make a request. The concessive clause I do this even though … may be restructured in some languages as “I could do it differently, for I am…”

Ambassador translates the Greek presbutēs, which is usually “an old man” (see Luke 1.18, Titus 2.2; “old women” in Titus 2.3). But this word sometimes appears as a variant spelling of presbeutēs, and on this basis Good News Translation Revised Standard Version New American Bible Barclay New English Bible Translator’s New Testament Barclay Goodspeed Twentieth Century New Testament and others take it here to mean ambassador, which seems much more appropriate in the context (so Lightfoot, Moule). (The noun presbeutēs does not appear in the NT, but the cognate verb presbeuƍ is used in 2 Cor 5.20, Eph 6.20.) Others (Vincent, Lohse) think “an old man” is meant, and that is how it is translated in Jerusalem Bible Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible Bible en français courant Biblia Dios Habla Hoy New International Version Moffatt Phillips. It is impossible to decide precisely how old Paul would be; according to the sixth-century B.C. Greek physician Hippocrates, this word applied to an individual between 49 and 56.

Ambassador may be rendered as “one who represents” or “one who carries a message on behalf of” or “one who travels in order to speak for.”

A prisoner for his sake: see Philemon 1.9.

Quoted with permission from Bratcher, Robert G. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to Philemon. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1977. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

SIL Translator’s Notes on Philemon 1:9

9a

I prefer: The phrase I prefer indicates that Paul wanted to appeal to Philemon on the basis of love instead of ordering him what to do.

to appeal: Paul was asking Philemon to do something. This was not the same as telling him to do it. And he was not asking a question.

on the basis of love: Rather than ordering Philemon to obey a command, Paul wanted Philemon to help Onesimus because of love. But it is not clear who loved whom. There are three interpretations:

(1) Philemon should do what Paul wanted simply because he loved Paul.

(2) Philemon should do what he ought to do, not because of a command, but because he loved all of God’s people.

(3) Paul did not use his authority to tell Philemon what to do. The reason was: Paul loved Philemon. Good News Translation follows this third interpretation.

All three interpretations are possible, and perhaps Paul was thinking about all these meanings when he wrote this passage. But the first interpretation seems most likely because of the following words in 9b. Verse part 9b implies that Philemon should show that he was thankful to Paul, an old man in prison. And he also should be thankful for Paul helping him to trust in Christ.

9b

I, Paul: Paul was giving reasons why Philemon should agree to do what Paul asked him to do. For example:

‱ He was Philemon’s friend, Paul.

‱ He was an old man.

‱ He was suffering because he trusted in Christ.

am now aged: The Greek word presbutēs has two possible meanings in this verse:

(1) “old man” (Berean Standard Bible, New International Version, Jerusalem Bible, Phillips’ New Testament in Modern English, New Living Translation (2004), King James Version)

(2) “ambassador,” a man who speaks for important people (Good News Translation, New English Bible, Revised Standard Version)

The phrase am now aged probably represents the right meaning in this verse because Paul had just said that he was not giving an order to Philemon, as a man of authority (verse 8) would do. Paul, as an aged man in prison for Christ (verse 9), was appealing to Philemon.

a prisoner: See notes on verse 1a.

© 1996, 2020 by SIL InternationalŸ

Made available under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License (CC BY-SA) creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0.

All Scripture quotations in this publication, unless otherwise indicated, are from The Holy Bible, Berean Standard Bible.

BSB is produced in cooperation with Bible Hub, Discovery Bible, OpenBible.com, and the Berean Bible Translation Committee.

Commentaire sur la traduction de la lettre à Philémon 1.9

Dans le verset prĂ©cĂ©dent Paul dit qu’il aurait pu ordonner Ă  PhilĂ©mon de faire ce que l’apĂŽtre veut. Ici il explique sa dĂ©marche actuelle : au lieu d’imposer sa volontĂ©, comme apĂŽtre, vieillard ou prisonnier pour Christ, il fait sa demande par amour. Cela signifie que Paul donne Ă  son interlocuteur, PhilĂ©mon, l’occasion d’agir librement.

c’est de prĂ©fĂ©rence rend un mot grec qui veut dire « plutĂŽt » et celui-ci offre une alternative. La Parole de Vie fait ressortir l’idĂ©e avec « Pourtant, j’aime mieux » On pourra aussi dire « je prĂ©fĂšre » (Bible en français courant, Bible de JĂ©rusalem).

au nom de l’amour : les mots au nom de rend une prĂ©position grecque qui introduit la cause ou la raison de la requĂȘte de Paul. Elle peut ĂȘtre traduite comme « sur la base de l’amour (chrĂ©tien) ».

Pour amour, voir verset 7. Ici l’idĂ©e d’amitiĂ© et d’une sincĂšre apprĂ©ciation prĂ©domine. On pourra l’exprimer d’une maniĂšre plus inclusive : « Ă  cause de notre amour mutuel ».

que je t’adresse une requĂȘte : il s’agit d’une demande faite de façon convenable mais avec insistance. Il a ici le sens de « plaider », « faire appel, » « supplier » ou « demander une faveur ». On pourra dire « je te prie de… » La Parole de Vie parle de « prĂ©senter cette demande ». L’appel peut ĂȘtre exprimĂ© au sens figurĂ©, par exemple, « je t’expose tout mon cƓur » ou « je te demande Ă  partir de mon ventre ». Voir aussi verset 10.

Oui, moi Paul, qui suis un vieillard : l’hommage et le respect dus aux personnes ĂągĂ©es amĂšnent Paul Ă  mentionner qu’il est un adulte avancĂ© en Ăąge, un vieillard. Il est impossible de dire avec prĂ©cision quel Ăąge Paul avait, mais ce terme laisse entendre qu’il avait au moins 50 ans. Les traducteurs devraient choisir un mot pour vieillard sans connotation nĂ©gative. Dans certains manuscrits, il y a une variante orthographique qui donnerait un autre sens Ă  ce mot : « ambassadeur ». Certains biblistes trouvent cette lecture plus appropriĂ©e dans ce contexte, bien que cette utilisation soit rare dans le Nouveau Testament. Les versions françaises ont plutĂŽt un vieillard ou « un vieux », ce qui est recommandĂ© ici.

moi … un vieillard, moi qui suis maintenant prisonnier de JĂ©sus Christ : le grec n’atteste pas ces deux moi emphatiques, mais comme il cite son propre nom, Paul, cet insistance semble justifiĂ©e.

L’utilisation de l’adverbe maintenant montre que Paul est en prison lorsqu’il Ă©crit cette lettre.

Pour prisonnier de JĂ©sus Christ, voir verset 1.

Source: Aroga Bessong, DieudonnĂ©. La lettre Ă  PhilĂ©mon – Manuel de traduction – Commentaire linguistique et exĂ©gĂ©tique de la Bible. Alliance biblique universelle, 2011.