Translation commentary on Luke 9:30 – 9:31

Exegesis:

kai idou ‘and behold,’ focussing the attention strongly on what follows, cf. on 1.20.

andres duo sunelaloun autō ‘two men were talking with him,’ durative imperfect. For sullaleō cf. on 4.36.

hoitines ēsan Mōüsēs kai Ēlias ‘who were Moses and Elijah’; relative clause instead of apposition is more emphatic.

(V. 31) hoi … elegon tēn exodon autou ‘who … spoke about his departure,’ relative clause which has Mōüsēs kai Ēlias as its antecedent. It takes up sunelaloun autō in v. 30 and specifies the subject of the conversation.

exodos ‘departure,’ here euphemistically, ‘passing away,’ ‘death.’

ophthentes en doxē lit. ‘having appeared in glory,’ aorist tense, referring to an event which, in temporal sequence, precedes v. 30. For ophtentes cf. on 1.11; for en doxē cf. on v. 29.

hēn ēmellen plēroun en Ierousalēm ‘which he was to fulfil in Jerusalem.’ ēmellen means here ‘he was destined.’ 1.c.δ. For plēroō cf. on 1.20. Its use here implies that Jesus’ death is in some way a fulfilment of his mission.

Translation:

Talked with him, often a reciprocal form of ‘to speak.’

Moses and Elijah. One may have to add titles, e.g. ‘prophet,’ and/or indicated that the reference is to persons that are no longer among the living.

(V. 31) Who appeared in glory, or, as a new sentence, ‘they, or, these (two) men, had appeared in glory.’ If the linguistic sequence has to parallel the sequence of events, the clause must be shifted, e.g. ‘two men had appeared in glory; these were M. and E. They were talking with him, and spoke of….’ Appeared, or, ‘made their appearance,’ ‘showed themselves.’

His departure, which he was to accomplish at Jerusalem may have to be adjusted rather radically, e.g. ‘the death of Jesus which he had-to die in J.’ (Kituba), ‘his last days, how he would take death in J.’ (Sranan Tongo), “his departure, the destiny he was to fulfil in J.” (New English Bible); or more explicitly expressing the implication of Gr. plēroō, ‘his dying there in J., for that was the whole purpose for which God sent him’ (Tboli), “how he would soon fulfil God’s purpose by dying in J.” (Good News Translation); or again, shifting from verbal noun to verb, ‘how he would depart/die, as (or, something that) he was destined to do in J., or, which was the task he had to perform in J.’— His departure. Some other euphemisms for ‘death’ used are, ‘his end’ (Toraja-Sa’dan), ‘his last going/journey’ (Bahasa Indonesia KB), ‘his going-home’ (Balinese), ‘he will go-away’ (Pohnpeian, similarly Uab Meto). Often, however, one must simply say, ‘his dying’ (Tboli), ‘his future death’ (Tae,’ Ekari). Which he was to accomplish, or, ‘to fulfil,’ “to go through with” (An American Translation), “to achieve” (The Four Gospels – a New Translation), verbs that often do not go naturally with ‘departure,’ or, ‘death,’ because they imply activity and initiative on the part of the subject not compatible with the concept ‘dying’; hence adjustments are usually necessary, see above.

Quoted with permission from Reiling, J. and Swellengrebel, J.L. A Handbook on the Gospel of Luke. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1971. For this and other handbooks for translators see here . Make sure to also consult the Handbook on the Gospel of Mark for parallel or similar verses.

SIL Translator’s Notes on Luke 9:31

9:31a

They appeared in glory: The phrase appeared in glory indicates that Moses and Elijah shone brightly. They were surrounded with a dazzling light, as Jesus was. Another way to translate this is:

appeared in heavenly glory (New Century Version)

9:31b–c

and spoke about His departure: Moses and Elijah spoke with Jesus about His departure from the world. The Greek word that the Berean Standard Bible translates as departure is exodos. It refers mainly here to Jesus’ death. However, it could also include his rising from the dead and ascending to heaven. If you can translate it in a way that includes both meanings, you should do so. For example:

Jesus’ leaving this life
-or-
how/when Jesus would depart from this world

If it is not possible to imply both meanings, you should use an expression that refers to Jesus’ death. For example:

Jesus’ approaching death (God’s Word)

which He was about to accomplish at Jerusalem: The Greek word that the Berean Standard Bible translates as accomplish implies that Jesus would accomplish what God had sent him (into the world) to do. Jesus would cause God’s plan to happen, just as God had said.

In some languages it is not natural to speak of accomplishing or fulfilling a departure/death. The meaning here is that Jesus was about to fulfill God’s plan through his death. It may be necessary to make this meaning more explicit. For example:

he would soon fulfill God’s purpose by dying in Jerusalem (Good News Translation)

General Comment on 9:30–31b

The Berean Standard Bible has changed the order of the phrases in verse 30. Other versions, such as the New International Version and the New Living Translation (2004), include some part of 9:31 in 9:30 for clarity. The English Standard Version follows the Greek order. Compare the order of the phrases in the New International Version and English Standard Version below.

30Two men, Moses and Elijah, 31aappeared in glorious splendor, 30talking with Jesus. 31bThey spoke about his departure… (New International Version)
-or-

30And behold, two men were talking with him, Moses and Elijah, 31awho appeared in glory 31band spoke of his departure… (English Standard Version)

The New Living Translation (2004) has used a different order from either the New International Version or English Standard Version. It says:

30Suddenly, two men, Moses and Elijah, 31aappeared 30and began talking with Jesus. 31aThey were glorious to see. 31bAnd they were speaking about his exodus from this world… (New Living Translation (2004))

You should arrange the phrases in 9:30–31b in a way that is natural in your language. You may especially wish to reorder the Greek phrases if it would be unusual for you to describe Moses and Elijah speaking with Jesus before saying that they appeared.

© 2009, 2010, 2013 by SIL International®
Made available under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License (CC BY-SA) creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0.
All Scripture quotations in this publication, unless otherwise indicated, are from The Holy Bible, Berean Standard Bible.
BSB is produced in cooperation with Bible Hub, Discovery Bible, OpenBible.com, and the Berean Bible Translation Committee.