Translation commentary on 2 Kings 5:1

Naaman: This name, which means “fair” or “gracious,” is used in Gen 46.21; Num 26.40 and 1 Chr 8.4, 7 for a member of the tribe of Benjamin. But the person in this story is not an Israelite. He was a Syrian. Israel and Syria were at peace with each other at this time (see verse 7).

Commander of the army of the king of Syria: Naaman was the commander in chief in charge of the entire army of Syria. The Hebrew text is rendered literally in Revised Standard Version. The Septuagint, however, says “the commander of the army of Syria.” It is possible that the Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version translations, “the commander of the Syrian army,” are based on the Septuagint, but more likely these renderings are simply a loose translation of the Hebrew text here. Commander of the army is the same expression used in the previous chapter (4.13). See also 1 Kgs 1.19.

The Old Testament name for Syria is “Aram,” which is what the Hebrew text has here. It is transliterated in many English versions (New Revised Standard Version, New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, Revised English Bible, Moffatt). But in the New Testament, the Greek name “Syrian” is used with reference to Naaman (Luke 4.27). Because there are two different names for the same political entity, the translators of Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation decided to avoid confusion by using the same name throughout the Bible. This will probably be a good idea for most other languages to follow as well. See also 1 Kgs 10.29.

A great man: This is comparable to the Hebrew expression translated “a wealthy woman” in 2 Kgs 4.8. Naaman was a man of great influence. The text adds with his master or “before his master.” Apparently this is intended to emphasize the fact that his greatness was recognized by the king of Syria himself.

In high favor is literally “lifted of face.” This kind of expression is often used to speak of a person’s “having honor,” “being favored,” or “having a good reputation” with other people (see Job 22.8 and Isa 9.15, for example). It repeats the same basic idea as a great man, but it is probably intended to be a broader statement about how Naaman was regarded by people in general. Some may want to translate it “everybody thought very highly of him.” New Revised Standard Version takes the words with his master as modifying both a great man and in high favor and thus restructures this part of the verse to say “a great man and in high favor with his master.” Compare also “a man who enjoyed his master’s respect and favour” (New Jerusalem Bible) and “was important to his lord and high in his favor” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh).

By him the LORD had given victory to Syria: It is somewhat surprising that the LORD, the God of Israel, is said to have given victory to the army of Syria. But there are other cases in the Old Testament where the LORD is said to be in control of the destinies of other nations (Isa 10.13; Amos 9.7). Some possible models for this part of the verse are “the LORD had caused Syria to win battles because of him” or “he had led the Syrian army to victory by the power of the LORD.” International Children’s Bible is quite similar: “the Lord had used him to give victory to Aram.” The writer does not indicate whom the Syrian army defeated. It may have been the Assyrians, but more likely it was the Israelites (see verse 2). In any case, this information is not given in the Hebrew text and should not be given in the receptor language either. Some take the word victory in a collective sense and speak of “great victories” (New Living Translation).

A mighty man of valor: See the comments on this same Hebrew expression used in 1 Kgs 11.28, where Revised Standard Version translates it “very able.” The writer continues to build up Naaman as a person of great importance, but here the focus is more specifically on his military ability and bravery in battle. Therefore translations such as “a valiant warrior” (La Bible Pléiade, Nouvelle Bible Segond) and “a mighty warrior” (New Revised Standard Version, Revised English Bible) are appropriate here. One manuscript of the Septuagint, followed by New Jerusalem Bible, Osty-Trinquet and Moffatt, omits these words. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament gives a {B} rating to the Masoretic Text, which is followed by most translations.

But he was a leper: The Hebrew text actually has only the participle meaning “having leprosy.” The sharp contrast between the greatness of Naaman and his illness is correctly introduced in English by the conjunction but, which highlights the difference between his high rank and great reputation on the one hand and his having a disease that made him a social outcast.

A great deal has been written in recent years about the translation of the Hebrew word tsaraʿ, which is often rendered “leper” or “leprosy.” The terms “leper” and “leprosy” occur frequently in both the Old and New Testaments (see especially Lev 13–14, where the laws concerning this disease are given). There is general agreement that the disease with which the Bible is concerned in these terms is not the same as what modern medicine calls “leprosy” today (that is, “Hansen’s disease”). Even those versions that translate the Hebrew word here as leper almost always provide a footnote or a glossary entry explaining that “leprosy” in the Bible is not the same as what we call by that name today. It referred rather to a group of skin disorders that cannot be positively identified today. For this reason Good News Translation says “dreaded skin disease” and New Jerusalem Bible similarly has “virulent skin-disease.” See also 2 Sam 3.29. Since Naaman was not an Israelite, he was not subject to the laws of Lev 13 and he was apparently not isolated because of his disease.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on 1-2 Kings, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2008. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

SIL Translator’s Notes on 2 Kings 5:1

Section 5:1-27

Elisha healed a foreign military commander

5:1a Now Naaman, the commander of the army of the king of Aram,

Aram was an ancient kingdom centered around Damascus in the southern part of what is now Syria.

The commander/general of the army of the king of Aram was a man called Naaman.

-or-

At this time⌋ the army of the king of Aram/Syria was led/commanded by a man named Naaman.

-or-

The king of Aram had placed/made a man called Naaman in charge of his army.

5:1b was a great man in his master’s sight and highly regarded,

His master ⌊the king⌋ respected and honored him,

-or-

He was highly valued/regarded by his lord ⌊the king of Aram/Syria⌋ and given much honor/favor.

-or-

He thought very well of Naaman. He honored him

5:1c for through him the LORD had given victory to Aram.

because with him as leader/commander Yahweh had made Aram victorious/successful ⌊over its enemies⌋ .

-or-

The king respected him⌋ because Yahweh had caused him to win ⌊many⌋ battles for Aram/Syria.

-or-

because Yahweh had allowed Naaman to lead ⌊the army of⌋ Aram to victory ⌊over its enemies⌋ .

5:1d And he was a mighty man of valor,

The meaning of the Hebrew phrase that the Berean Standard Bible translates as “a mighty man of valor” can include both physical power and political influence.

Naaman was a great man and warrior,

-or-

Naaman was a powerful/important man.

5:1e but he was a leper.

but he had the leprosy ⌊skin disease⌋ .

-or-

However, he had ⌊a bad/serious skin disease called⌋ leprosy.

5:1a-e (reordered)

The army of Aram was led by a great warrior named Naaman. The king of Aram thought very highly of him/Naaman. The king gave him many honors, because under his leadership Yahweh had caused the army of Aram to defeat its enemies. But Naaman had the leprosy disease.

-or-

At this time the commander of the army of the king of Aram was named Naaman. The king of Aram valued and honored him, because Yahweh had willed/chosen to give the army of Aram victory through him. Naaman was powerful and successful, but he had a skin disease.

© 2020 by SIL International®

Made available under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License (CC BY-SA) creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0.

All Scripture quotations in this publication, unless otherwise indicated, are from The Holy Bible, Berean Standard Bible.

BSB is produced in cooperation with Bible Hub, Discovery Bible, OpenBible.com, and the Berean Bible Translation Committee.