Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 19:15

David was on his way to Jerusalem, so it may give a false impression to say literally that the king came back to the Jordan, since that was not his final destination. The point is that he had started back to Jerusalem, and when he reached the Jordan River, he met the people of Judah. Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch states “So the king began his way back toward Jerusalem….” It will be important in some languages to add the word “river” to Jordan and “town” to Gilgal to make the meaning clear. The Hebrew is literally “And the king returned and he came as far as the Jordan.” The sense is better expressed in Anchor Bible, “So the king started back and reached the Jordan…” (similarly Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente).

Judah: that is, the people of the tribe of Judah. Translators should be careful to avoid giving the impression that one individual is intended here.

Gilgal: this city, located at the beginning of the territory of Judah, was between the Jordan River and Jericho. The people of Judah had apparently gathered there in preparation for meeting David and his men at the Jordan River, which was only about eight kilometers (five miles) away. Compare Josh 4.19 and 1 Sam 7.16.

The repetition of the king may be intended to emphasize the fact that David was once again considered king of the whole of Israel and Judah. But in some languages it may be more natural to translate the second occurrence by a pronoun.

A model for this verse as a whole is as follows:

• King David started back to Jerusalem. And when he came to the Jordan River, the people of Judah met him there. They had [previously] assembled at the town of Gilgal because they wanted to accompany [or, help] him across the river.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 20:8

The great stone which is in Gibeon: Gibeon was located about ten kilometers (or about six miles) to the north of Jerusalem and was in the territory of Benjamin, which would have been friendly to Sheba. The mention of the great stone, using the definite article, shows that it was a well-known landmark. Another similar landmark is mentioned in 1 Sam 6.15 and 18.

Came to meet them: this may mean either “caught up with them” (Contemporary English Version) coming from Jerusalem or, as in New Jerusalem Bible, “met them, coming the other way,” implying that he had been with Sheba and was definitely a sympathizer with the rebellion. The events that follow make it quite clear that Joab considered Amasa a traitor, but perhaps this was only because he failed to assemble the army within three days as David had instructed him. Nevertheless, in languages that require translators to decide which direction Amasa was going, it may be better to state that he was coming from the opposite direction.

Now introduces an explanation by the writer that includes a description of his clothing and of the instrument he eventually used to kill Amasa. From here to the end of this verse the meaning of the Hebrew is not clear.

Was wearing a soldier’s garment: literally “was girded with his garment his clothing.” Though the exact sense is not clear, Revised Standard Version probably expresses the basic meaning according to the context. Another way of speaking of a soldier’s garment is to say that he had on “his apparel of war” (Goldman) or, putting it in more modern terms, that he was “dressed for combat.” The girdle was a kind of belt worn around the waist that could have held a sheath in which a sword or a dagger could be kept. On the word girdle see 18.11 and 1 Sam 18.4.

While most English versions use the word sword here, some indicate that it was a “dagger” (Contemporary English Version, New International Version, Knox, and Anderson). In view of the events described, it seems more logical that the instrument used may have been shorter than what people usually think of as a sword.

As he went forward it fell out: the meaning of the words so translated are debated by scholars. Some think the meaning is as in Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation. Apparently Joab deliberately let the instrument fall to the ground in order to put his enemy at ease so that he would not suspect what was about to happen. Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente states explicitly that the sword “fell to the ground,” but in light of the difficulties of understanding this verse, it will be better not to be so specific unless the receptor language requires it. Some interpreters change the Hebrew text here in light of the Septuagint to say “and it came out and fell” (Osty-Trinquet), but the Masoretic Text should be followed.

Some interpreters, however, do not think that the Hebrew means that the sword fell to the ground. Rather, Joab had his tunic pulled up and girded around his waist, and the sword fell out of its sheath into the folds of the tunic. If this interpretation is followed, then the weapon that Joab uses in verse 10 is the same sword mentioned here and is not a second sword that he was hiding, nor is it the fallen sword that he had picked up from the ground (see the comments on the New Jerusalem Bible translation of verse 10).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 21:16

Ishbi-benob: the traditional Hebrew text at this point actually reads “they remained at Nob” (see Traduction œcuménique de la Bible note). But there is a marginal note in the Hebrew text indicating that it should be read as in Revised Standard Version and most other modern versions. Possibly the original wording was simply “Benob” as in Revised English Bible. Others read “Dadu” (New American Bible) or “Dodo” (Anchor Bible), after extensive emendation of the text, based in part on Septuagint manuscripts. This textual problem is not dealt with by Hebrew Old Testament Text Project, but probably translators will be wise to imitate the majority of English versions in retaining the name Ishbi-benob.

One of the descendants of the giants: the expression so translated has been traditionally understood to mean that the men described in this way here and in the following verses were physical descendants of people of unusually large stature, the Rephaim, who are described in Gen 14.5; 15.20; Josh 12.4; 13.12; 17.15, and elsewhere. However, McCarter indicates that the word translated descendants may be understood to imply membership in a group in the same way that “sons of the prophets” refers to members of a prophetic guild (1 Kgs 20.35; Amos 7.14). It was used especially to refer to people of low estate who were dedicated to the military service of a master (Gen 14.14). In 1 Kgs 12.8, 10 this term refers to the young men who had grown up with Rehoboam.

The meaning of the word translated giants is not entirely certain either and is therefore sometimes transliterated “Rapha” (New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, New Century Version, Contemporary English Version, Anchor Bible), “the Raphah” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), “Haraphah” (Anderson and Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible), or “Rephaim” (Revised English Bible and New American Bible). So the whole expression may mean “one of those devoted to the service of the god Rapha” or, as Anchor Bible puts it, “the votaries of Rapha.” However, translators are advised to render the meaning found in Revised Standard Version (also Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente), adding an explanatory footnote if necessary. If the Hebrew means that Ishbibenob was a descendant of the giants (the Rephaim), then Good News Translation fails to indicate that the ancestors of Ishbibenob, and not just Ishbibenob himself, were also giants.

Spear: the meaning of the Hebrew word is not certain. It may mean “helmet” (Anchor Bible), but most interpreters take it to mean either “spear” or “spearhead” (Knox and Contemporary English Version).

Three hundred shekels of bronze: as indicated in the American edition of Good News Translation, this was about seven and a half pounds, using the English system of weights and measures. That was the equivalent of about “three and a half kilogrammes,” as the British edition of Good News Translation shows.

Was girded with a new sword: literally “he was girded a new.” The rather archaic sounding expression was girded has been rendered “was fitted out with” (New Revised Standard Version) and “was armed with” (New International Version). But in many languages it will have to be translated “was wearing” or “took for battle….”

A new sword: the word “sword” is not actually in the Hebrew text, but this seems to be what is implied. Some scholars, however, have suggested that in this context what is meant is “a new girdle” (An American Translation), that is, “a new [warrior’s] belt” (Anderson), “a belt of honour” (Revised English Bible), or “new armour” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh and Goldman). But the most likely intention of the writer(s) seems to have been “a new sword.”

Thought to kill David: literally “and he said,” but often this means “he said to himself” or simply “he thought.” The word thought is perhaps too weak to convey the intended meaning here. It was his definite intention to assassinate David, and very likely he was in the process of trying to kill him when Abishai came to the rescue. Translators may therefore prefer to say “tried to kill” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), “intended to kill” (Anchor Bible), or “was confident of killing” (New Jerusalem Bible).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 22:36

The pronouns shift back to the second person singular at this point. See the general comment at the beginning of this chapter.

The shield of thy salvation is a figure of protection and safety in battle. The phrase thy salvation refers to God’s saving David, not to God’s being saved. In languages where the shield is unknown or only partially known through a loan word, it will often be best to transfer to a nonfigurative expression as in Good News Translation. Even if shield is maintained, it will often be misleading to express salvation as a noun, as in Revised Standard Version. A verb phrase may be better; for example, “You give me your shield, which saves me” or, more fully, “You give me your shield, which saves my life.”

The parallel in Psa 18.35 includes the words “thy right hand supported me,” which are not found in this verse. Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente includes these words (“with your arm you have sustained me”), apparently assuming that they were original also here in 2 Samuel, but the textual evidence does not support such a translation.

The Revised Standard Version rendering thy help (New Revised Standard Version “your help”) is based on the reading of a Hebrew manuscript from Qumran. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament, however, recommends that the Masoretic Text be followed, “your response [or, subjugation] has made me great.” In other words, the Masoretic Text has a different word in place of help. That word may be understood to mean “response,” which would refer to God’s favorable answer to David’s prayers; thus Bible en français courant “you answer my calls and you make me strong.” New Jerusalem Bible seems to follow this reading, with “you never cease to listen to me.” The other meaning, “subjugation,” may refer to the subjugation of David’s enemies (“your conquest made me great”) or to God’s own self-abasement (“you stoop down to make me great” [Revised English Bible]). Translators are advised to follow the model of Bible en français courant and translate something like “you answered my prayers and made me strong” or “you made me strong by answering when I prayed.” Compare Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, “Your answer to my prayer makes me strong.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 23:23

Instead of the thirty, some texts have “the heroes.” The same is true of the following verse. But “thirty” is recommended in both cases by Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament. If translators read “thirty” in the previous verse, it is possible to use the pronoun “them” in this case.

Renowned: while this is similar in Hebrew to the statement in verse 19, Revised Standard Version does not use the superlative expression here.

But he did not attain to the three: see verse 19.

Set him over his bodyguard: in some languages it will be more natural to say “made him chief…” or “named him as leader….” On the word bodyguard see 1 Sam 28.2. It is not clear whether this refers to the Cherethites and Pelethites (8.18; 15.18; 20.7, 23; and compare also 1 Sam 30.14) or to a different group. But translators will be well advised to use a more general term or expression here. Some may say “the group of soldiers who guarded him [King David].”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 1:15

Though the Hebrew is literally “But Hannah answered and said,” in the interest of English style, Good News Translation substitutes the pronoun “she” for the name Hannah and omits the words “and said.”

My lord is a common biblical term expressing politeness. It should be rendered by an equally common and equally polite term in the receptor language. Like Good News Translation, Revised English Bible and New Century Version also use the English equivalent “sir.” Whether such a term is placed at the beginning of the address or later will depend on what is natural in the receptor language.

I am a woman sorely troubled: literally “a woman heavy [or, difficult] of spirit [am] I.” The sense is not so much that she was “desperate” (so Good News Translation) but that she was “a very unhappy woman” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) or “a heart-broken woman” (Revised English Bible). New American Bible (“an unhappy woman”) is similar to the New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh translation, but “very unhappy” or “feel miserable” (Contemporary English Version) seem to capture better the force of the Hebrew.

I have drunk neither wine nor strong drink is a literal translation. Strong drink translates the noun form of a verb that means “be or become drunk,” and in Hebrew the noun refers to an intoxicating drink. Such strong drinks were made from either grains or fruits, and most likely they were fermented drinks rather than distilled liquors. The Hebrew word is therefore better translated as “beer” (New International Version) than as “liquor” (New American Bible). New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh appropriately inserts the word “other,” that is, “I have drunk no wine or other strong drink.” Some common language translations compress the two Hebrew nouns wine and strong drink and say simply “I haven’t been drinking” (Good News Translation, Bible en français courant).

But I have been pouring out my soul before the LORD is a literal translation. The Hebrew word translated soul has a wide range of meanings. It may refer to the center of spiritual and physical needs and desires. It may also refer to the seat of emotions and experiences such as sadness, grief, pain, distress, and anxiety. In this context “pouring out my troubles” (Good News Translation, New American Bible) is an appropriate translation. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh’s “pouring out my heart” also expresses in contemporary English the meaning of the Hebrew, as does the expression “pouring out my feelings” (Revised English Bible).

As in verse 12 above, before the LORD (Revised Standard Version, New Revised Standard Version, Revised English Bible, Fox) is a literal translation of a common Hebrew expression. While the word before indicates location, the meaning is that the speaker is in the presence of the person being addressed and is capable of being heard. Many translations say “to the LORD” (Good News Translation, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Bible en français courant).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 2:23

Such things refers to the kinds of things that have already been mentioned in verse 22. In some languages it will be much more natural to move the second half of this verse to a position before the question. This will give the question much more sense and make the referent of such things clearer.

From all the people: some versions are based on proposed reconstructions of the original Hebrew text on the basis of various readings in the Septuagint tradition. New Jerusalem Bible, for example, says “Why are you behaving as all the people say you are?” (similarly Anchor Bible). Translators should, however, follow the Masoretic Text.

The final sentence in this verse is omitted in New American Bible, since the translators thought that a Hebrew scribe had accidentally repeated here the words from the beginning of verse 24. Translators should, however, follow the Masoretic Text and not omit this sentence, unless they do so for reasons of translation as Contemporary English Version does.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 3:21 - 4:1

And the LORD appeared again at Shiloh: the Revised Standard Version translation suggests that God appeared only once more. The Hebrew is better translated to indicate that God continued to appear (so Good News Translation, New Revised Standard Version, Nova Tradução na Linguagem de Hoje, Fox).

For the LORD revealed himself … by the word of the LORD: a literal translation of this clause sounds heavy in English. The style is improved and the sense is clearly expressed in the following translation: “he manifested himself to Samuel at Shiloh through his word” (New American Bible).

At the end of this verse, the Septuagint adds the following: “And from one end of the country to the other, Samuel was believed to be a prophet of the Lord to all Israel. And Eli was very old and his sons persisted in their evil behavior, and their way was evil before the Lord. Now in those days the Philistines gathered together to fight against Israel.” This addition in the Septuagint is the basis for the Anchor Bible translation, “But Eli was very old and his sons lived an evil life in Yahweh’s eyes.” New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, and Klein are also based in part on the longer Septuagint text. However, translators are encouraged to follow the Masoretic Text, to which Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament gives a {B} rating.

Translators will notice a difference in chapter division between Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation. In the Hebrew text the words And the word of Samuel came to all Israel stand at the beginning of the narrative that begins in chapter 4. According to this division of chapters in the Hebrew text, the Israelites went to war with the Philistines because of what God said through Samuel.

Most modern interpreters, however, place the words And the word of Samuel came to all Israel at the end of chapter 3 as the conclusion and summary statement of that chapter. Some translations include these words as part of verse 21 (so Good News Translation, Nova Tradução na Linguagem de Hoje). Many modern English versions (Contemporary English Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, New Revised Standard Version, Revised English Bible, New American Bible, and Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible) indicate that the words that correspond to the last sentence of Good News Translation are actually a part of chapter 4, but that they belong to the section on Samuel and not to the story of the capture of the ark from the Philistines.

The word of Samuel came to all Israel should not be taken in any mysterious or unusual sense. The meaning is simply that “Samuel spoke to all Israel” (New American Bible) or “Samuel would speak to the whole nation of Israel” (Contemporary English Version).

And the word of Samuel came to all Israel: see the comments on 3.21 regarding the numbering of verses and the textual problem at the beginning of this verse.

Now Israel went out to battle against the Philistines: according to the Masoretic Text, which is followed by Revised Standard Version, the Israelites took the initiative in the war against the Philistines. Good News Translation, however, gives a different impression because it follows the last of three additional sentences in the Septuagint (see the comments on 3.21–4.1a). New Revised Standard Version likewise follows the Septuagint, adding “the Philistines mustered for war against Israel,” as do most other modern English versions. Translators are advised, however, to follow the Masoretic Text as reflected in Revised Standard Version.

The Philistines came to occupy the southwestern coastal strip of Palestine near the end of the thirteenth century B.C. Their expansion in the twelfth century toward the east brought them into continual conflict with the Israelites, who were expanding their territory toward the west from the opposite side of Canaan. The Philistines were one of Israel’s main enemies until David finally defeated them (2 Sam 8.1; 1 Chr 18.1).

The exact location of Ebenezer is uncertain; but like Aphek it lay somewhere on the southern end of the plain of Sharon and west of the central hill country of Ephraim. The name Ebenezer means “stone of help” (see 7.12). Nueva Biblia Española translates the name Ebenezer here and elsewhere into Spanish as Piedrayuda, that is, “Helping-stone.” Bible en français courant translates the meaning similarly into French. And in English Moffatt has “Help-stone,” while Knox speaks of “the Rock of Deliverance.”

Aphek is mentioned again in 29.1. This name occurs eight times in the Old Testament and refers to at least four different cities. The reference here is to a city located on the coastal plain about sixteen kilometers (ten miles) east of the Mediterranean Sea and forty kilometers (twenty-five miles) northwest of Jerusalem.

The meaning of the name Aphek is disputed. It may be related to an Assyrian verb that means “be strong [or, firm].” This understanding lies behind the Nueva Biblia Española translation of this name as El Cerco, that is, “The Blockade [or, Fortress].” Other interpreters connect the name to a Hebrew verb meaning “valley bed” or “river torrent.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .