Translation commentary on Malachi 3:8

Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me: The majority of translators and other scholars treat both the question and its answer as the words of the prophet, which together form the first Response element in the dispute. However, Jerusalem Bible and New Jerusalem Bible consider the question only (“Can a human being cheat God” in New Jerusalem Bible) to be a continuation of the words of the objectors at the end of verse 7. This view is attractive in that it would give the question a sarcastic tone that fits well with the interpretation of “How shall we return?” as a protest of innocence in verse 7. Nevertheless, there are two reasons for not accepting it. The first is that it has no support among ancient versions, and the second is that the Hebrew particle translated Yet in Revised Standard Version suggests a close link between the answer and the question. This is more appropriate if they are both the words of the same speaker, namely, the prophet.

Another issue arises from the rendering of New Jerusalem Bible, which uses “cheat,” where Revised Standard Version has rob. The traditional Hebrew text has a form of the root q-b-ʾ. This root occurs elsewhere in the Old Testament only in Pro 22.23, where it is translated “despoil” and is used in parallel with a verb in the previous verse which means “rob” (Revised Standard Version). The meaning is evidently something like “to seize forcefully,” and thus here in Malachi Revised Standard Version translates it as rob. (The verb is common in rabbinic literature.) The Septuagint on the other hand apparently used a Hebrew text with a slightly different root: ʿ-q-b, that is to say, the same three consonants, but in a different order. The meaning of this root is “to deceive” and it is the root from which the name Jacob (Hebrew yaʿaqob) is formed. If this were indeed the verb used, there would be an ingenious pun on the name of Jacob, which has already occurred in 1.2; 2.12 and 3.6. Textually it is easy to see how the consonants of a rare verb could be changed to those of a common one (that is to say, a change from q-b-ʿ to ʿ-q-b), but it is much more difficult to account for a change in the opposite direction (compare Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament and Hebrew Old Testament Text Project). The explanation given in the New Jerusalem Bible footnote that there was a deliberate change from ʿ-q-b to q-b-ʿ in order to remove a derogatory reference to Jacob is not convincing, and has no textual support.

The traditional Hebrew text is therefore more likely to be original, and moreover makes somewhat better sense: in the context of the tithes, which are mentioned in verses 8 and 10, it is easier to think of robbing God than of deceiving him. Nevertheless, a number of modern versions prefer to follow the Septuagint, and translate here as “cheat” (Moffatt, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, Good News Translation, New Living Translation) or “deceive” (Bible de Jérusalem, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, Bible en français courant).

A neat solution to the problem is found in New English Bible/Revised English Bible and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, where the translation is “defraud.” This means to rob by deception rather than violence, and thus covers both of the possible meanings given above. In languages that have a word with similar meaning, translators should feel free to use it. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh in a footnote indicates that the translators retained the q-b-ʾ root of the traditional Hebrew text, but they still see a possible reference to Jacob, carried presumably by similarity of sound rather than repetition of the identical root. The verb occurs three more times in verses 8-9, and should be translated the same way each time.

The word translated man in Will man rob God? is not a word meaning a male, but a general term. Thus it is translated as “a person” (Good News Translation), “a human being” (New Jerusalem Bible), or “people” (Contemporary English Version, New Living Translation). The expansion of the question in Good News Translation to “I ask you, is it right for a person to cheat God?” hardly seems necessary. The expected answer to the question is “No,” and Good News Translation expresses this with “Of course not.” Some translators may need to do the same. Other possible models are “Could a human being rob God of [or, not let God have] what actually belongs to him?” and “Could a human being steal things from God’s hand?”

In Hebrew both the pronouns you (plural) and me are full forms and not just verbal affixes in the answer Yet you are robbing me. This puts emphasis on them. In many languages it will be difficult to emphasize both the pronouns you and me, but if a mechanism for doing this exists, it should be used. If only one pronoun can be emphasized, it should be you; for example, “But it is you who are robbing me” or “Yet you people are robbing me.” See the notes on the similar passage in verse 9. The form of the verb are robbing indicates habitual action.

But you say, ‘How are we robbing thee?’: These words form the second Objection element in the dispute. For But you say, see the comments on verse 7 above. The question How are we robbing thee? should if possible be translated in such a way as to carry an overtone of defiance, just like the question in the first Objection element in verse 7; for example, “How could we possibly be robbing you?”

In your tithes and offerings: These words begin the second Response element, which continues down to the end of the dispute in verse 12. In Hebrew this answer is very short and blunt, and translators should try to maintain the effect of this. However, in some languages it may be necessary to repeat a main verb and say “You are robbing me in your tithes and offerings” or “You are not giving me your tithes and offerings fully.” The words translated tithes and offerings are technical terms. The tithe was one-tenth of the people’s produce, and included both crops and animals. It was an obligation to present the tithe to the LORD each year (Lev 27.30-33; Num 18.21-24; Deut 14.22-29; 26.12-15). In cultures where such a practice is not known, there will be no technical term available, and translators may have to construct a longer expression (compare Contemporary English Version “the ten percent that belongs to me”). If translators have already translated books like Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy, they should be careful to use the same term here as was used in those books.

The word translated offerings is used in such places as Exo 29.27-28 and Num 18.11, where Revised Standard Version translates it “wave offering.” It was separate from the tithes, and seems to have been a voluntary offering. It consisted of special portions of sacrificed animals. Since the exact nature of these offerings is not in focus in Malachi, a general term is acceptable in translation. However, if a satisfactory technical term has been found in books like Exodus and Numbers, it can be used here if it is not too long and complex. Many English versions have “offerings,” but other renderings include “contribution[s]” (New English Bible/Revised English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) and “dues” (Jerusalem Bible). Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch expands this to “the priests’ part of the offerings,” and some translators may find this example helpful.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Haggai 2:13

Then said Haggai: Next Haggai asks the opposite question, whether defilement can be transmitted indirectly. We are to assume that this question also was asked at the command of the LORD (compare verse 11), though the text does not say so. In this case, there is probably no need to fill in the ellipsis, and Good News Translation does not do so.

Unclean means ritually impure and temporarily unable to take part in the worship of God. Other ways to translate this term are “religiously impure or bad,” referring to ritual defilement, and even “forbidden for use in the worship God.” Some languages express this as something like “having bad taboo.” Translators may also wish to compare the translation used in such places as Mark 7.2-5, 14-23; Acts 10.14-15.

For uncleanness caused by contact with a dead body, see Num 19.13. In this case, the priests ruled that the uncleanness could be passed on. Their answer agrees with Num 19.22, and establishes the principle that defilement is transmitted more easily than holiness. This principle is the foundation for Haggai’s comments in verse 14. A dead body here refers to the corpse of a human being as noted in Num 19.13, although the prohibition could just as well apply to the carcasses of dead animals. If in certain languages there are different words for the corpse of a human and the corpse of an animal, the expression for the human corpse should be chosen.

Touches any of these: Of these refers to the foodstuffs mentioned in verse 12.

Does it become unclean? may be rendered “would they [the foods] become unclean?” (Contemporary English Version) or .”.. have bad taboo?”

The priests answered, “It does become unclean”: The reply of the priests is given in Hebrew with a full verb form (It does become unclean). Natural English requires a shorter form here, and modern versions offer several possibilities: “Yes” (Good News Translation, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, New Living Translation), “Yes, it does” (Jerusalem Bible), “It will” (New English Bible/Revised English Bible), “Of course they would” (Contemporary English Version). In some languages a short form of the answer will be appropriate, but in others the full verbal form will be necessary. Some modern English versions have an even fuller answer than the Hebrew; for example, “Yes, it becomes unclean” (New Revised Standard Version). This may be a suitable translation model for some languages.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 2:4

And said to him: In the Hebrew it is not clear which angel addressed the other. Revised Standard Version takes the second angel to be the speaker, as do Moffatt, New American Bible, Revised English Bible, New International Version, New Revised Standard Version, Contemporary English Version, and Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente. Good News Translation takes the first one to be the speaker, as do New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, New Jerusalem Bible, Bible en français courant, and Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch. A majority of commentators (Driver, Mitchell, Cashdan, Delcor, Thomas, Amsler, Meyers & Meyers) take the latter view and translators are recommended to follow it. As Driver observes, the interpreting angel is not likely to have been sent away to deliver a message. However, if he had been sent away, the verb translated “came again” in 4.1 would have more significance. See the comments on 4.1. One way to say this is “The first angel said to the second.”

Run, say to that young man: A different Hebrew word is used here from the one translated man in verse 1. See the comments on verse 1. Good News Translation makes it clear that this is the same person by repeating some information from verse 1, and saying, “tell that young man with the measuring line.” Another way to express this is “tell that young man who is holding the measuring line in his hand.” Some scholars such as Merrill take that young man to refer to Zechariah himself, but this view is not convincing, and cannot be recommended.

Jerusalem shall be inhabited as villages without walls, because of the multitude of men and cattle in it: These words begin a quotation within a quotation in Revised Standard Version. Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version avoid this by putting the second half of the verse into indirect speech. In many languages translators will find this a helpful example to follow. The relationship between the two halves of this sentence is not altogether clear in a literal translation like Revised Standard Version. Good News Translation restructures to make it clearer, and says, “there are going to be so many people and so much livestock [or more neatly “so many people and cattle” in the earlier British editions] in Jerusalem that it will be too big to have walls.” This will be a satisfactory translation model in many languages, but some translators may need to simplify and say, “there will be so many people and cattle in Jerusalem that….” Cattle, as in Hag 1.11, refers to domesticated animals of all kinds, so translators may say “so many people and animals.” The words villages without walls translate a single Hebrew word. This word does not actually mention walls. However, the same Hebrew word is used in Ezek 38.11 in a context where the absence of walls is in focus, so it is reasonable to assume that their absence is implied here. The words without walls suggest a condition of peace and security such that no walls were needed for protection. This could be brought out clearly by saying, “Jerusalem will need no wall to protect it because of the large number of men and cattle in it.” This is further explained in the next verse. In certain languages villages without walls can be expressed as “small groups of houses without fences around them.” In such cases it will be better to delete the reference to villages, as Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version have done. Good News Translation has “that it will be too big to have walls.” Contemporary English Version has “Jerusalem won’t have any boundaries. It will be too full of people and animals even to have a wall.” In some languages walls will need to be singular because the plural would refer to walls around gardens or houses rather than around a city. A possible translation model is:

• The first angel said to the second one, “Run [or, Hurry] and tell that young man to stop. Jerusalem will grow and have very many people and cattle, and will not need any wall to protect it.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 5:2

And he said to me, “What do you see?”: See the comments on the same words in 4.2. He refers to the same angel as in the previous vision. Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version make that clear in English by saying “The angel,” and many translators will need to do the same.

The words I answered translate the same Hebrew expression as that translated “I said” in 4.2. In reporting a conversation, the word answered is more natural in English, and translators should be aware of stylistic points of this kind.

I see a flying scroll; its length is twenty cubits, and its breadth ten cubits: This reply makes it clear that the scroll was not rolled up, but completely unrolled; otherwise, the prophet would not have known its size. The size given, twenty cubits by ten cubits, is much larger than any normal scroll would be. These measurements are in fact the same as those of the entrance hall of Solomon’s Temple (1 Kgs 6.3), though it does not seem possible to draw any conclusion from the similarity. Good News Translation translates the measurements into modern units. The cubit was about seventeen and a half inches, so in the American editions of Good News Translation, the size is given as “thirty feet long and fifteen feet wide” (compare Moffatt, New International Version, New Living Translation, Contemporary English Version). In the British and Australian editions, which use metric measurements, the size is given as “nine metres long and four and a half metres wide.” Since the size in cubits is in round figures, some think this is calculated too precisely. Translators who use metric measurements may also consider following the example of Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente and give the size in round figures as ten meters long and five meters wide.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 7:9

The second introductory formula Thus says the LORD of hosts often follows the previous formula at the beginning of longer paragraphs (compare Hag 1.2; Hag 2.11; Zech 8.2, 19) and may be seen as a marker of subdivisions within the paragraph (see the comments on 8.1-17). For LORD of hosts, see the comments on Hag 1.2.

The words that follow are in fact a repetition of the ethical teaching typical of the eighth century prophets. Good News Translation makes it clear that these are not original ideas of Zechariah by translating Thus says the LORD of hosts as “Long ago I gave these commands to my people.” Contemporary English Version has “So once again, I, the LORD All-Powerful, tell you.” (The change to first person “I/my” is part of the stylistic restructuring that Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version carry through the whole paragraph. See the introductory comments on this section.)

Render true judgments, show kindness and mercy each to his brother: These are general statements of the principles underlying sound social and personal relationships. Good News Translation expresses the first in modern language as “You must see that justice is done.” Translators could also say, “Apply the law fairly” (Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible). The context here is a legal one. For this command compare Isa 1.17; Jer 21.12; Jer 22.3; Amos 5.14-15, 24.

For an emphasis on the quality of kindness, compare Hos 4.1 and Micah 6.8. The Hebrew word chesed here translated kindness was particularly associated with loyalty to the obligations accepted when a person entered into a covenant relationship. It was thus expected that the Jews, as a people having a covenant relationship with God, would show this quality in their attitudes both to God and to one another. Mercy is translated “compassion” in Moffatt, New American Bible, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, and New International Version. Each to his brother is the Hebrew way of saying “to one another” (Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version). Brother does not mean only close relatives, or only male relatives, and this should be made clear.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 9:5

In verses 5-8 the focus shifts from nations to the north to a nation to the west, namely the Philistines. Four of their five main centers are mentioned; the fifth, Gath, had been destroyed by the Assyrians in 711 B.C. These cities are pictured as being thrown into panic by observing the fate of Tyre, apparently their ally. In terms of structure, it is noteworthy that the first three cities are mentioned in a chiastic order Ashkelon-Gaza-Ekron-Gaza-Ashkelon. This pattern puts a focus on Ekron, the one at the turning point, so it is no surprise that Ekron is the one mentioned again in verse 7, where it seems to stand for the Philistines as a whole. The same four cities are mentioned in Amos 1.6-8 and Zeph 2.4, but in a different order.

Ashkelon shall see it, and be afraid: By a figure of speech called metonymy, Ashkelon (and indeed the other city names) stands for the inhabitants of the city. In certain languages it will be necessary to do away with this figure of speech and say, for example, “The people of Ashkelon will see it and be afraid.” There is another example of alliteration between the Hebrew words for see (tereʾ) and be afraid (tiraʾ). The Hebrew contains no equivalent to it (“this” in Good News Translation), which is included in English to make the flow of thought clearer. It refers of course to the fall of Tyre in the previous verse.

Gaza too, and shall writhe in anguish: The verb translated writhe in anguish refers to the pains of childbirth. Good News Translation “suffer great pain,” and modern versions generally, lose this figure. However, in many cultures it may be possible to keep it, perhaps by turning the metaphor into a simile: “The people of Gaza will also see it, and suffer agony like a woman in labor.”

Ekron also, because its hopes are confounded: The word also seems to refer back to shall writhe in anguish in the description of Gaza rather than to shall see it in the description of Ashkelon. Thus the next clause because its hopes are confounded explains why Ekron will also writhe in anguish. What is not stated here, but must be understood, is that the Philistine cities were allied with Tyre, and relied on its strong fortifications to delay any invader coming from the north. If Tyre was captured, then the Philistine cities were also bound to fall, and their hope of escape was gone. The Hebrew word translated its hopes is found in the same sense of political and military reliance in Isa 20.5-6, where it refers to the reliance of Judah on Ethiopia and Egypt. Other ways to express this sentence are “The people of Ekron will also be in agony because they have lost hope” and “Ekron also will suffer greatly and despair because it no longer has the support of Tyre.”

The king shall perish from Gaza: Gaza was the largest of the Philistine cities. Losing its king meant losing its independence, and being swallowed up by some other stronger nation. Shall perish means “will be killed.” For king see Hag 1.1.

Ashkelon shall be uninhabited: The people will be killed, captured, or driven away, and the city of “Ashkelon will be left deserted” (Good News Translation), or “There will be no people left in Ashkelon,” or “Ashkelon [will be] emptied of its people” (Contemporary English Version). Compare Zeph 2.4.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 11:9

So I said: The Hebrew does not contain a conjunction expressing consequence as clearly as the English So. Probably “Then” (Jerusalem Bible, Good News Translation, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, Contemporary English Version) is more appropriate. The Hebrew also does not indicate who the prophet is addressing. Those versions that take a clear position on this point all hold the view that he is addressing the sheep (Moffatt, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, Good News Translation, New Living Translation, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). A few are as unclear as the Hebrew (New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Contemporary English Version). Although vagueness is seldom a virtue in translation, in the present instance it does at least have the advantage of not ruling out other possible meanings. It is possible that the prophet is addressing the three shepherds of verse 8, though this seems very unlikely, especially if they are dead! If the interpretation proposed in the notes on verse 8 is accepted, then the prophet here is addressing the sheep dealers, and translators may begin this verse with “Then I said to the sheep dealers.”

I will not be your shepherd: The word your is a masculine plural suffix, whereas in the rest of the verse the sheep are consistently referred to with feminine affixes. The view that it is the dealers who are addressed here not only gives a better flow of thought through the paragraph as a whole, but also avoids the odd situation where a human being is addressing animals. There are many strange things in the book of Zechariah, but there is no need for the translator to manufacture more unnecessarily.

Some may argue here that the words I will not be your shepherd can carry the meaning “I will not work for you as a shepherd” in English more readily than in the underlying Hebrew. It is true that the preposition “for” which carried this meaning in verse 7 is not repeated in verse 9. But it is also possible to understand the particle usually taken as an object marker to be the preposition “with.” The meaning is then “I will not be a shepherd with you,” that is to say, “… under your authority [or, for you].” This interpretation involves reading one vowel differently from the traditional Hebrew text, but does not require any changes in the consonants. It seems more acceptable to alter one vowel than to assume that the prophet is using pronoun genders incorrectly. However, this is the assumption that has to be made by those who understand the prophet to be addressing the sheep, since the sheep are always referred to as feminine throughout this chapter. This Handbook therefore recommends the interpretation “Then I said to the dealers, ‘I will not be a shepherd for you’ ” or “… ‘I will not look after the sheep for you anymore.’ ” We may note further that this interpretation, in which the prophet suddenly quits his job, explains his hesitation in requesting his pay in verse 12.

What is to die, let it die: This clause translates just two words in Hebrew, both of which are feminine. It is the sheep (in particular the ewes, or female sheep) of the flock that are in view. The words are a comment to the dealers about the sheep rather than an instruction to the sheep. In translation it would be clearer to refer directly to the sheep: “Let the sheep that are going to die, go on and die” (Contemporary English Version).

What is to be destroyed, let it be destroyed: The Hebrew verb rendered destroyed here is the same verb used to describe what the prophet did to the three shepherds in verse 8. However, few English translations use the same word in both places. Here in verse 9 the most common term is “perish” (New American Bible, Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible, New International Version), though several prefer a somewhat different meaning: “lost” (Moffatt, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Beck), “stray” (New English Bible), or “missing” (Revised English Bible). The sense of “lost” seems somewhat preferable as this clause has more of a point if it does not repeat the exact content of the previous clause. The precise shade of meaning, however, is less significant than the repetition of the clause structure, emphasizing that the prophet is abandoning the sheep to their fate. Translators should use a structure in this clause parallel to that used in the previous clause; for instance, “Let those that are to get lost, get lost” or “Let those that are to perish, perish.” For this type of thought and structure, compare Jer 15.2.

Let those that are left devour the flesh of one another: Those that are left indicates that not all will die or get lost. Since sheep are not flesh-eating animals, devour the flesh of one another is a hyperbole, or exaggeration, which amounts to a curse. The sheep who do not die or get lost will destroy each other, as Good News Translation says. The fact that the forms are all feminine probably makes this statement seem even stronger in Hebrew than it does in English. The Hebrew expression translated one another is similar to an expression in verse 6. See the notes there on “his shepherd.” For devour the flesh, compare the cannibalism described in Jer 19.9.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 14:3

Then the LORD will go forth: The prophet now pictures the LORD intervening directly in the conflict. Meyers & Meyers note that the Hebrew verb translated go forth here and “come” in verse 5 are technical military terms for starting and finishing a campaign (compare for instance Josh 14.11). If similar paired words are available in a translator’s language, it will be good to use them. Some English versions make an attempt to use military terms. Jerusalem Bible has “take the field,” and Moffatt has “sally forth” (New Jerusalem Bible “sally out”). However, English lacks a suitable military term to use in verse 5.

And fight against those nations: Some ancient Christian commentators interpret the Hebrew to mean that the LORD fights on the side of the nations against Jerusalem. The only modern commentator to support this view is Lamarche, but the arguments in favor of it are weak. No modern version takes this view and we recommend that translators should follow the Revised Standard Version interpretation. Those nations are the same ones mentioned in the previous verse.

As when he fights on a day of battle: Many scholars take this to refer to the LORD’s actions on behalf of his people at the time of the exodus from Egypt. Thus Good News Translation has “as he has fought in times past” (also New Living Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente) and New Jerusalem Bible “as once he fought on the day of battle.” Others take the clause to be a general statement of the LORD’s willingness to act to help his people. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh for instance has “as He is wont to make war on a day of battle” (“wont” means “accustomed”), and Bible en français courant has “as he has always done in times of war.” Both senses are possible, and both are fully compatible with the context. The word translated battle is an Aramaic word that occurs only rarely in the Old Testament. It occurs elsewhere in combination with day only in Psa 78.9.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .