Translation commentary on Zechariah 14:3

Then the LORD will go forth: The prophet now pictures the LORD intervening directly in the conflict. Meyers & Meyers note that the Hebrew verb translated go forth here and “come” in verse 5 are technical military terms for starting and finishing a campaign (compare for instance Josh 14.11). If similar paired words are available in a translator’s language, it will be good to use them. Some English versions make an attempt to use military terms. Jerusalem Bible has “take the field,” and Moffatt has “sally forth” (New Jerusalem Bible “sally out”). However, English lacks a suitable military term to use in verse 5.

And fight against those nations: Some ancient Christian commentators interpret the Hebrew to mean that the LORD fights on the side of the nations against Jerusalem. The only modern commentator to support this view is Lamarche, but the arguments in favor of it are weak. No modern version takes this view and we recommend that translators should follow the Revised Standard Version interpretation. Those nations are the same ones mentioned in the previous verse.

As when he fights on a day of battle: Many scholars take this to refer to the LORD’s actions on behalf of his people at the time of the exodus from Egypt. Thus Good News Translation has “as he has fought in times past” (also New Living Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente) and New Jerusalem Bible “as once he fought on the day of battle.” Others take the clause to be a general statement of the LORD’s willingness to act to help his people. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh for instance has “as He is wont to make war on a day of battle” (“wont” means “accustomed”), and Bible en français courant has “as he has always done in times of war.” Both senses are possible, and both are fully compatible with the context. The word translated battle is an Aramaic word that occurs only rarely in the Old Testament. It occurs elsewhere in combination with day only in Psa 78.9.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 2:2

The structure of this verse is quite complex. There are two linked statements. The first comprises two negative conditions and two consequences. The second asserts that one of the consequences is already fulfilled because one of the negative conditions is in fact true.

The two negative conditions are If you will not listen and if you will not lay it to heart to give glory to my name. For the phrase translated lay it to heart, compare the similar but not identical phrases in Hag 1.5, 7; 2.15, 18. The content of what the priests are required to do is to give glory to my name, which makes clearer the meaning of the “command” in verse 1. To give glory means to “praise” or “honor,” and my name is a common Hebrew way of referring to the LORD himself (compare 1.6, 11, 14). Thus Good News Translation has “You must honor me.” In using this construction, Good News Translation has transformed one of the conditions into a command. This may be a useful example in some other languages also.

The formula says the LORD of hosts has a function of emphasis at this point. In languages where it would be unnatural to include it here, it may be preferable to incorporate it into verse 1 as Good News Translation has (also Contemporary English Version, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Translators should note that the formula occurs again at the end of verse 4, where it concludes the first subsection of 2.1-9.

The two consequences are then I will send the curse upon you and I will curse your blessings. The first clause I will send the curse upon you is probably a conscious reference to Deut 28.20, where the “curse” referred to a “disaster” or “calamity.” The presence of the definite article the suggests that the reference is to a curse already known to the priests. The Hebrew verb translated I will send is rather strong, and in some languages it may be rendered as “I will hurl” or “I will fling” (compare Traduction œcuménique de la Bible je lancerai contre vous “I will throw against you”). I will send the curse upon you may alternatively be translated as “I will cause a terrible thing [or, calamity] to happen to you.”

In the second consequence clause I will curse your blessings, it is not certain what blessings are meant. Some scholars think the privileges of the priesthood are meant, including not only the honor of leading worship, but also the material benefits such as receiving tithes and portions of sacrificial animals. Others see a reference to the words of blessing (Num 6.22-27) which the priests used in public worship. While this is certainly included, translators would do well to choose a rendering that is not limited to just a set form of words, as is Contemporary English Version “when you give a blessing, I will turn it into a curse.” On the other hand, Good News Translation “I will put a curse on the things you receive for your support” probably focuses too much on the material aspect, though this was also in view.

The second statement in the verse is indeed I have already cursed them, because you do not lay it to heart. The existing disobedience of the priests, as described in 1.6-8 and 12-13, has already meant that their blessings are not endorsed by the LORD. If material goods are in view, then obviously when the priests accepted inferior animals for sacrifice, their own portions were also inferior. If words of blessing are in view, then the words of the priests to the worshipers were proving ineffective. The Hebrew suffix translated them is actually singular, but since blessings is the only possible noun the suffix could refer to, the plural them is justified in translation. The first clause of the second statement may also be translated in a way similar to Contemporary English Version “In fact, I have already done this,” where “this” refers back to “turn it into a curse.”

Because you do not lay it to heart: This clause makes it clear that the second of the two conditions earlier in the verse is actually fulfilled. The priests do not in fact honor the LORD as they should, and so the curse has already begun to take effect. In some languages there may be an idiom to translate lay it to heart; for example, “receive it with one heart.” In other languages it may be more natural to express this clause in a positive form, such as “you ignore [or, look down on] my commands.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Malachi 4:1

As noted in “Introducing Malachi,” the verses numbered 4.1-6 in most English versions are numbered 3.19-24 in Hebrew. Modern versions in other European languages, along with Catholic versions in English such as Jerusalem Bible/New Jerusalem Bible and New American Bible, follow the Hebrew numbering system. In this Handbook the Hebrew verse number will be placed in square brackets [ ] underneath the corresponding English verse number at the beginning of comments for each verse.

Although there is no justification for beginning a new chapter here in terms of the discourse structure, in areas where the tradition of numbering the last six verses of Malachi as 4.1-6 is dominant, translators are advised to follow it. There is no justification for including a section heading at 4.1. See the notes on the section heading at 3.13.

For behold: The Hebrew conjunction translated For indicates that there is no sharp break from the previous verses. This verse gives the reason for the statements in 3.18. The particle translated behold shows the beginning of a new subunit within the flow of the argument. Good News Translation lacks anything equivalent to either For or behold, and by inserting a new section heading, it is positively misleading about the structure of the dispute that covers 3.13–4.3. See the comments introducing 3.13–4.3 above. Translators are strongly advised to maintain a visible link with 3.16-18, especially if they are obliged to begin a new chapter at this verse. The manner in which the link is shown will vary according to the resources of the translator’s language. Among English versions the most imaginative approach is found in Beck, who renders For behold as “You see.” This expression at this point not only draws attention to what follows but also indicates that there is a link backwards to 3.18.

The day comes, burning like an oven: The definite article the before day (contrast Zech 14.1) indicates that this is a reference back to the day already mentioned in 3.17, and strengthens the way the whole dispute 3.13–4.3 holds together as a unit. The present tense comes suggests that the action will occur very soon, so in some languages it may be better to say “is about to come” or “will soon come” (compare Beck, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). It is unusual and striking to speak of a day as burning. If possible, translators should keep the picture, but if it would sound too unnatural, it would be possible to say “the day is coming when it will be as hot as a burning oven” or “the day is coming that will bring burning heat [or, fire] like that of an oven.” In languages where “day” and “sun” are the same, it may be necessary to restructure the first part of the verse as follows: “Look! That day/sun is coming soon. It will bring fire like the fire of an oven.”

The word translated oven may mean either a portable earthenware oven (compare Gen 15.17; Lev 11.35) or a baker’s oven, presumably a large, fixed item (compare Lev 26.26; Hos 7.4, 6, 7). Translators should try to avoid a term that refers only to a modern gas or electric oven. Languages that use ideophones may have one to describe intense heat or a blazing fire. Such a word would be very suitable here, especially if ovens are not well known.

When all the arrogant and all evildoers will be stubble: The terms rendered arrogant and evildoers are the same as in 3.15 and should be translated in the same way. See the comments there. The words will be stubble are a metaphor, continuing the picture of burning. In many languages it will be clearer to make this a simile, as do Good News Translation with “like straw,” and Contemporary English Version with “as though they were straw.” The word that Revised Standard Version renders stubble may refer to the stalks left standing in a field after the grain is cut (Isa 5.24; 40.24; Nahum 1.10), or to “straw” (Good News Translation, Moffatt, Beck, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Contemporary English Version, New Living Translation), that is, the cut stalks when separated from the head of the grain (Exo 5.12; Job 41.28-29), or to “chaff” (New English Bible, New American Standard Bible), meaning the dry husks from which the grains have been removed (Job 13.25; Psa 83.13; Jer 13.24; compare Verhoef). The point is that each of these burns up easily, quickly, and completely. In the context of an oven, the meaning here is likely to be chaff or straw rather than stubble. In languages that have different terms for these three items, translators may use whichever one sounds most natural in a figurative setting. Good News Translation restructures the first half of the verse to make the “proud and evil people” the subject of “will burn like straw,” and this may be a useful model in some languages.

The whole picture of burning symbolizes the LORD’s anger against the wicked, and is a frequent image in the Old Testament (compare Isa 30.27; Jer 4.4; 21.12; Zeph 1.18; 3.8). This may be stated directly if necessary, as in the second model given at the end of the discussion on this verse (compare Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch).

The day that comes shall burn them up: This clause continues the imagery of the day being the agent of the burning. In many languages it will be helpful to restructure to “when the day comes, they will burn up” or “when that day comes, the heat [or, fire] will burn them up.” If the arrogant and the evildoers were made the subject of the verb “burn” in the first half of the verse, then it will be likely that they remain the subject in this clause also.

Says the LORD of hosts: In the notes on 3.17, it was recommended that the quotation formula says the LORD of hosts should in the present verse be restructured as a first person statement, as in Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente. If this is done, it will probably be best to begin a new sentence, and to open it with “I, the LORD Almighty, say that when the day comes….”

So that it will leave them neither root nor branch: As is shown by so that, this clause describes the consequence of the burning. It is not entirely certain whether the phrase neither root nor branch changes the metaphor or not. If the nouns root and branch are to be understood literally, then they speak of a tree, and the figure of straw has changed (compare New Living Translation). However, it is possible that “root and branch” was a fixed phrase, simply meaning “completely” without reference to the literal sense of its components. In this case the figure has probably not changed. This particular phrase is not found elsewhere in the Old Testament, though a similar one (“I destroyed his fruit above, and his roots beneath”) occurs in Amos 2.9, and the combination of “fruit” and “root” is used with a positive sense in 2 Kgs 19.30 and Isa 37.31. The overall sense of the passage is that the wicked will be utterly destroyed. In the Aramaic Targum, root and branch are interpreted as “son and grandson” (Chary). While this interpretation is appropriate at the level of ideas, it is not a satisfactory example for translators to follow. In languages where a mixture of metaphors would not be clear or natural, it may be better to translate the phrase in a nonfigurative way. Again, languages that use ideophones may have a suitable one for something that is completely burned.

Alternative translation models for the whole verse are:

• See, this is because the day is coming when all the proud and wicked people will burn up like chaff in an oven. I, the LORD Almighty, say that when that day comes, they will be completely burnt up, and nothing at all will be left.

• This is because the day will indeed come when my anger will burn up all the arrogant and evil people like straw in an oven. On that day the fire will burn them to ashes, and not a stalk or a root will be left. I, the LORD Almighty, declare it.

• This second model maintains the same figure throughout the verse by changing branch to “stalk,” which goes more appropriately with “straw” (as in Jerusalem Bible).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Malachi. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Haggai 1:5

In Hebrew the words introducing the direct speech are identical with those in verse 2, but with the addition of the opening Now. Such repetition is unnatural in English and Good News Translation therefore drops these words here, and continues the words of the LORD’s message directly from the previous verse. Many translators will wish to follow Good News Translation, but they should nevertheless indicate that a new paragraph begins at this point. The force of the word Now is to show that the argument is moving to a new stage.

Consider how you have fared: The exact sense of the Hebrew is expressed more clearly by such renderings as “Consider your way of life” (Revised English Bible), “Give careful thought to your ways” (New International Version), and “Think carefully about your behavior” (New Jerusalem Bible). The focus of the whole section 1.3-11 is more on the way the people have acted than on their lack of agricultural success. This focus becomes sharper in verses 7-11. The crop failures are a result of the people’s casual attitude toward God, and it is this attitude that God calls upon them to Consider. The command to Consider or think carefully is repeated in 1.7; 2.15, 18. Good News Translation translates the command here as “Don’t you see what is happening to you?” A negative question like this is very natural in English, and leads on easily to the answer given in verse 6. However, in many languages a negative question would be very confusing, and translators would give the correct meaning by staying closer to the form of the Hebrew, and saying, for example, “See [or, Look] what has happened to you,” or better, “Look at your way of life.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Haggai. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 1:3

The three occurrences in this verse of says the LORD of hosts in Revised Standard Version actually represent three slightly different expressions in Hebrew, each with a slightly different discourse function. The first formula, Thus says the LORD of hosts (in Hebrew koh ʾamar YHWH tsevaʾoth), introduces a paragraph that extends to the end of verse 4. The second formula, says the LORD of hosts (in Hebrew neʾum YHWH tsevaʾoth), reinforces the first formula as an opening marker. The third formula, says the LORD of hosts (in Hebrew ʾamar YHWH tsevaʾoth), marks a climax, as it does also in Zech 4.6; Zech 7.13; Zech 8.14. In many languages, including English, the repetition of quotation formulas is poor style. Good News Translation therefore summarizes the three occurrences in the words “The LORD Almighty told Zechariah to say to the people,” which it has moved to verse 2. Few languages are likely to have quotation formulas with functions similar to the Hebrew ones, but translators should try to find some particle, word or order of words that will convey the functions of the Hebrew expressions. For the translation of LORD of hosts, see the comments on Hag 1.2.

As the paragraph proceeds it becomes clear that the message is addressed to all the people and not just to particular individuals. Good News Translation has made this clear at the beginning with the words “to say to the people.”

Therefore say to them: By the normal rules of pronoun reference in English, them would refer back to “your fathers” in verse 2; but this does not make sense, and the logic of the context means that them must refer to the people whom Zechariah is addressing. Zechariah is told to address the LORD’s message to the people of his own day. These words introduce the second degree quotation. Therefore is not in the Hebrew text, and is not logically necessary. Good News Translation replaces it with “but,” though “and now” would also be a perfectly acceptable link in English.

Thus says the LORD of hosts: This clause begins the second degree quotation (which continues at least to the end of verse 4 and possibly to the end of verse 6), and introduces the third degree quotation. It is a literal translation of the Hebrew. As part of its restructuring of the paragraph, Good News Translation has here “but now I say to you.” “I” refers of course to the LORD, and “you” is plural. Many translators will find it helpful to follow the example of Good News Translation in the way it handles the quotations in this paragraph.

Return to me, says the LORD of hosts, and I will return to you: These words begin the third degree quotation, which also continues to the end of verse 4, and possibly to the end of verse 6. They are quoted in Mal 3.7. The word return had been used often by earlier prophets in encouraging the people to take their religious duties more seriously (see for instance Jer 3.12-14; Hos 6.1; Hos 7.10; Amos 4.6-11). In the present context, when used of human beings, this word refers not just to a more regular observation of religious ritual, but to a basic change of attitude resulting in conduct obedient to the will of God. When used of God, as in the second occurrence in this verse, it refers to God ending the punishment of his disobedient people, and giving them his blessings once again.

In many languages it will not be possible to find a single term to cover both of these meanings. Also, in many languages it will not be possible to use an imperative form Return to me to carry what is really a conditional meaning. In such languages it may be necessary to adjust both the structure and the wording, and say something like “If you will again obey me, then I will again bless you” or “If you come back [or, repent] and worship me again, I will again take care of you.”

At the time at which Zechariah was prophesying, the most obvious way in which people could show a change in their attitude toward the LORD was by helping to rebuild the Temple (compare Hag 1.4-8). However, the language Zechariah uses here does not mention the Temple by name, and could be applied to the behavior of the people more generally; that is to say, it tells them to repent and obey the LORD.

An alternative translation model for verses 2-3 is:

• The LORD who is all-powerful told Zechariah to say to the people, “I, who am the LORD, was very angry with your ancestors. But now I say to you, ‘If you repent and worship me again, I will take care of you [or, help you].’ ”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 3:2

And the LORD said to Satan: The context here seems to require the speaker to be the angel of the LORD (compare verses 1 and 3) rather than the LORD himself. The ancient Syriac translation actually has “the angel of the LORD” here, and is followed by many modern versions such as New Jerusalem Bible, Revised English Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, and Traduction œcuménique de la Bible. The fact that the direct speech which follows refers to the LORD in the third person gives some support to this possibility and translators may well choose to accept it. In terms of the context, Satan and Joshua were standing directly in front of the angel, so it seems more likely that the angel was the speaker. However, Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament and Hebrew Old Testament Text Project recommend following the Hebrew text (as Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, New English Bible, New Living Translation, Contemporary English Version, and Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente have done).

The LORD rebuke you, O Satan! The LORD who has chosen Jerusalem rebuke you!: In some languages the vocative (address form) O Satan may have to come at the beginning of the quotation; for example, “O Satan, may the LORD rebuke you…” or “Satan, I ask the LORD to….” It will also be possible to bring out the element of censure by translating “The angel of the LORD reprimanded [or, censured] Satan, saying, ‘O Satan….’ ” In giving the rebuke, the angel of the LORD is acting as a counsel for the defense. The repetition shows the force of the rebuke. The second utterance is reinforced by the description of the LORD as the one who has chosen Jerusalem (compare 1.17; 2.12). As in 2.12, Good News Translation here expands this by saying, “the LORD, who loves Jerusalem” (similarly Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Bible en français courant and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente keep the verb “choose,” as does Contemporary English Version, and this is to be preferred. The effect of this rebuke is to silence Satan, the accuser, before he has a chance to say anything. In some languages it may be helpful to make this clear by saying something like “Silence, Satan!” or “Satan, keep quiet!” at the beginning (as in Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). Another possibility is found in Bible en français courant and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, which say, “May the LORD reduce you to silence!”

Is not this a brand plucked from the fire?: This is a rhetorical question, whose purpose is to make an emphatic statement. Many translators will find it helpful to express this in statement form, for example, “The LORD rescued this man as someone snatches a stick from the fire” (similarly Good News Translation, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Contemporary English Version, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). The demonstrative this is slightly ambiguous. It may possibly refer to Jerusalem, but most commentaries and translations understand it to refer to Joshua. Several versions make this interpretation clear by saying “this man” (Moffatt, Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version, New International Version, Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente), and translators are recommended to do the same. It is also possible to mention Joshua by name, as do Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente.

The phrase a brand plucked from the fire is similar to that in Amos 4.11. Here it refers to Joshua as a representative of the remnant who had returned to Jerusalem from exile (Ezra 2.1-2). The exile is likened to a fire from which the remnant has been rescued, as a half-burnt log may be snatched from a blaze. The description is aptly applied to Joshua, for his grandfather Seraiah had been executed by the Babylonians (2 Kgs 25.18-21), and his father Jehozadak had been carried into exile (1 Chr 6.14-15). It was against all natural expectations that Joshua had been able to return to Jerusalem and resume his priestly duties. In dealing with this metaphor, the translator may need to make the basis of the comparison clearer and say, “The LORD rescued this man as someone snatches a stick from a fire.”

An alternative translation model for this verse is:

• The angel of the LORD [or, The LORD] reprimanded Satan, saying, “Satan, I ask the LORD to rebuke [or, silence] you! May the LORD who has chosen [or, loves] Jerusalem condemn you. The LORD rescued this man as someone snatches a stick from the fire.”

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 6:2 - 6:3

The first chariot had red horses or, as Good News Translation says, “The first chariot was pulled by red horses.” As in 1.8, “brown” is probably a better translation than red in English (see the notes there). In some languages it may be grammatically necessary to state whether each chariot had two horses or more than two. Translators may assume they had two, since this was the usual number. This may be incorporated into the first verse (see the comment above).

The second black horses: This is a short way of saying “the second chariot had black horses.” The noun chariot and the verb had need not be repeated in English in this and the two following clauses, but will need to be repeated in some languages. The color term black did not occur in the description of the horses in 1.8, but its meaning is not in dispute here.

The third white horses: White was also the third color listed in 1.8.

And the fourth chariot dappled gray horses: The Hebrew word here translated dappled is not the same word as that rendered “dappled” in Good News Translation in 1.8. However, both Hebrew words seem to have much the same meaning, and several versions ancient and modern translate them both with the same term (Septuagint, Vulgate, New English Bible, Good News Translation). In other languages translators may well do the same. As in 1.8, we recommend that if technical terms for the colors of horses are not available or not well known, then translators should use a simple term like “gray.” In 1.8 we also suggested that if there is no term for “gray,” translators could mention the colors from which gray is made up, namely black and white. That solution is less desirable here, however, since black and white have already been mentioned separately. Perhaps some expression like “spotted” (New American Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) could be used, though in English “spotted” applies more readily to dogs or birds than to horses.

The real problem here is the meaning of ʾamutsim, the last word in Hebrew, which as the Revised Standard Version footnote shows, is uncertain. We would expect another color word at this point, and indeed ʾamutsim may be used in verse 7 as parallel with the color words in verse 6. However, elsewhere this Hebrew root carries the meaning “strong.” The difficulty is an ancient one: the Septuagint translates with another word meaning much the same as dappled, the Vulgate translates as “strong,” and the Syriac omits ʾamutsim. All three of these solutions can also be found among modern versions. The Septuagint approach is represented in Revised Standard Version and New Living Translation dappled gray, NJV “spotted–dappled,” and Contemporary English Version “spotted gray” (similarly Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, Biblen: Det Gamle og Det Nye Testamente). The Vulgate approach is found in New Jerusalem Bible “vigorous, piebald,” New American Bible “spotted … strong,” and New International Version “dappled … powerful” (similarly Bible de Jérusalem, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). The Syriac approach is followed in Moffatt, New English Bible/ Revised English Bible, and Good News Translation. No solution is fully satisfactory, but as Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament notes, the least unsatisfactory is the second, especially if the meaning “strong” is applied to all the horses and not just those on the fourth chariot. This view is supported by Meyers & Meyers. Such a solution is found in New American Bible “all of them strong horses” and New International Version “all of them powerful” (similarly Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch).

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Zechariah 8:6

Thus says the LORD of hosts has no equivalent in Good News Translation. See the comments on verse 2. The rest of the verse is somewhat more difficult than those before it. In Hebrew the sentence has the form of a rhetorical question, a question that does not expect an answer, but is really a way of making an emphatic statement. Revised Standard Version keeps the question form as do most modern versions, but in many languages it may be better to follow the example of Good News Translation, Bible en français courant, Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, and Contemporary English Version and turn it into a statement.

If it is marvelous: The Hebrew does not state what the it refers to, but most commentators take it to refer to the promises in the three previous oracles. Some translators may need to make this clear and say “If these promises seem…” or “These promises may seem….” Marvelous has the sense of “too marvelous to believe,” and Good News Translation and Contemporary English Version express this more briefly with “This may seem impossible.”

In the sight of the remnant of this people in these days: Again Good News Translation simplifies to “to those of the nation who are now left,” that is to say, to the people who were living at the same time as Zechariah. Contemporary English Version translates this expression as “for my people who are left.”

In these days is a phrase that is usually translated “in those days” (as in verse 23), and that in Hebrew usually refers to the future. Some translators take it that way here (New English Bible, New International Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh; compare Bible en français courant). The meaning of this interpretation is that when the promises of the previous verses are fulfilled, it will seem too wonderful to believe, even for the people who see it happen. Other translators, however, including Moffatt, Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, think that the context requires the words to refer to the present. Thus Revised Standard Version translates in these days rather than “in those days,” and Good News Translation has simply “now.” On this interpretation the oracle is a challenge to those who heard it. They might find the picture of happiness in the previous verses too good to be true, but that did not mean it was beyond the LORD’s power to bring it about.

The second interpretation seems more probable, and is the one recommended to translators.

Should it also be marvelous in my sight: This is the main clause of the sentence, and is put as a statement in Good News Translation “but it’s not impossible for me” (similarly Contemporary English Version). Another possibility is “But I will make it happen.”

Says the LORD of hosts has no equivalent in Good News Translation. It is not the same expression in Hebrew as that used at the beginning of verses 2, 3, 4, and 6. The words used here tend to come more often at the end of an oracle, and their use at this point may suggest that the prophet intended to make a bigger break at the end of this oracle than at the end of any of the previous three. If this is so, the effect is to link the four oracles of verses 2-6 together. Even if this is true for the Hebrew, it will be impossible to show it in translation in many languages. In some languages the effect might be maintained by beginning a new paragraph with verse 7 if translators have not done so at verses 3, 4, and 6. In other languages there may be ways of marking a break that is less important than a new paragraph, but more important than just a new sentence. If so, such a marker may be appropriate here. Good News Translation links verse 6 with verses 7-8 in a single paragraph, but this does not really reflect the structure of the Hebrew, and we advise translators not to copy it.

Quoted with permission from Clark, David J. & Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Zechariah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2002. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .