Translation commentary on Genesis 4:11

Verses 11 and 12 take up the punishment of Cain. And now marks a consequence of Cain’s action.

You are cursed from the ground: the opening words in Hebrew are in the form of the recognized formula seen in 3.17 for the beginning of a curse against someone. In Adam’s case the ground was cursed, although the effect of the curse was directed against Adam himself; however, in this case it is Cain who is cursed directly. Many languages have curse formulas that are equivalent to the Hebrew “cursed [are] you” and which are suitable here. From the ground means that the soil will not produce crops for Cain. Good News Translation has made this thought clear by saying “You are placed under a curse and can no longer farm the soil.” It is also possible to interpret from the as meaning “more than,” and so the expression can mean “You are cursed more than the ground was cursed.” However, the first part of verse 12, as well as verse 14, makes it probable that the first interpretation is to be preferred. This whole clause may also be translated “I curse you, and nothing you plant in the soil will grow” or “I put a curse on you so that the soil will produce no more food for you.”

Which has opened its mouth to receive your brother’s blood: its mouth refers to the mouth of the ground. This poetic figure is also used of Sheol in Isa 5.14. Good News Translation translates “soaked up you brother’s blood” and then adds a simile, “as if it had opened its mouth to receive it.” In some languages it may be better to translate this clause as a separate sentence; for example, “This is the soil that has soaked up your dead brother’s blood.” In some languages it may be possible to retain the force of the metaphor by saying, as in Biblia Dios Habla Hoy, “that has drunk the blood of the brother you killed.” If such expressions are not possible, it may be adequate to translate, for example, “It is the ground on which your brother’s blood has fallen” or “… which was wet with your brother’s blood.”

From your hand refers to the hand of Cain used to murder his brother and cause him to bleed. This expression is one in which a part of the body actually stands for the whole person, and it emphasizes Cain’s responsibility for his brother’s death: “You did it!” This is well translated by Good News Translation “… you killed him,” and New English Bible “… blood which you have shed.”

This verse may need to be restructured in some languages. The reason or basis for the curse on Cain is hidden away at the end in the expression your brother’s blood from your hand; but this may come more naturally at the beginning, or immediately following the opening curse formula. Examples from two translations are: “Because you killed your brother and his blood flowed down onto the ground, big trouble will take hold of you:…” and “This is the strong word I have for you: you killed your brother and made the ground drink his blood; so now I am putting a taboo on the ground against you….”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 4:12

The first part of this verse extends the meaning of the curse, while the second part adds something more to the curse.

When you till the ground: till is as in 2.5. No longer yield to you its strength means “it [the ground] will not produce or grow anything.” According to Anchor Bible this is a poetic use of strength for “produce”; Revised English Bible has “its produce” and New International Version “its crops.” Good News Translation combines both of these senses: “… crops, the ground will not produce anything.” Negatively we may say “the soil will be sterile, infertile, unproductive.” One good example from an existing translation says “The ground will withhold its goodness, and food will not be able to grow in it.” Another says “The ground will not fruit its fruits for you any more.”

You shall be a fugitive and a wanderer on the earth: a fugitive and a wanderer translates two similar-sounding Hebrew participles linked by “and,” a construction that suggests, according to some, a single idea, and so “homeless wanderer” (Good News Translation and Anchor Bible). Others treat the two words as separate ideas. For example, Revised English Bible “a wanderer, a fugitive on the earth.” Fugitive here suggests fleeing or escaping from God and from people. The word rendered wanderer refers in other contexts to a person’s unstable movements, as in “to totter” or “to stagger.” On the earth refers to the whole world and emphasizes the extent of Cain’s punishment: he will have no home anywhere, and he will have to wander everywhere. This part of the curse means that Cain will be cut off from his family and relatives. Bible en français courant says “You will be uprooted, always roaming over the earth.” This may also be translated “You will be without a home and always drifting everywhere.”

In trying to express the meaning of this Hebrew phrase, many translations include three elements:
(1) Cain will have no place or home of his own;
(2) he will be a “traveler,” always on the move;
(3) he will keep on going round and round, all over the world or to every place in the world.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 3:21

And the LORD God made for Adam and for his wife …: made is the same as in 1.25, 26. Adam translates the Hebrew Ęľadam, which lacks the article and is recommended as “Adam” by Hebrew Old Testament Text Project.

Garments translates a word referring to a knee-length or longer covering, probably without sleeves. It is referred to in English sometimes as a “tunic,” but “a long shirt” may give a better picture. Of skins means made of animal hides and not of cloth made from the hair or wool of those skins.

And clothed them means that God put these shirts made of hide on the two of them, or made clothes for them to wear. The causative verb clothed may be expressed in different ways in translation. For instance, one translation has “… and he made them-two wear those clothes,” while another says “… he gave [the clothes] to Adam and his wife, and they-two put them on.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 3:6

In this verse the woman recognizes three advantages in the forbidden tree: the fruit is good, the tree is beautiful, and eating would make her wise. So without further discussion with the snake she takes some fruit and eats it.

So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food: So marks the following clause as introducing a consequence. Revised Standard Version structures the first part of verse 6 as a “when” clause with three “that” clauses, which in English stylistically overload the front end of the long sentence. Good News Translation, on the other hand, makes three sentences. Translators may find that verse 6 needs to be further restructured into shorter sentences. For example,

• The woman saw how beautiful the tree was, and how good the fruit would be to eat. She thought, “How wonderful it would be to become wise.” Because she was thinking this, she took some of the fruit and ate it. Then she gave some to her husband, and he also ate it.

Good News Translation is like this model in switching the order of the first two clauses to give a better English style.

The tree was good for food refers to the fruit of the tree, as in 2.9. For delight to the eyes see the similar “pleasant to the sight” in 2.9, which is also another way of saying “beautiful” (Good News Translation).

The tree was to be desired to make one wise is a close literal translation of the Hebrew, in which was to be desired represents a passive participle. In some languages this will be more clearly rendered “a person desires the fruit of the tree because [eating] it makes that person become wise.” New English Bible says “tempting to contemplate,” and Bible en français courant “and they [the fruits] gave [the person] an urge to eat in order to acquire a broader knowledge.” Wise translates a word meaning “insight, understanding.”

After the woman had eaten she also gave some to her husband. Husband translates the word for “man” in 2.23 and is here grammatically possessed.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 3:22

Good News Translation inserts a heading before verse 22: “Adam and Eve are sent out of the garden.” In some languages it will be necessary to express this actively: “God sends Adam and Eve out of the garden.” “Send” here indicates a forceful removal.

Then … said: Then marks a new event in the sequence of events.

For Behold see 1.29. The man translates Ęľadam with the article.

Like one of us: see 1.26. Here this is a comparison to God, or to God and his heavenly court, or to God and other spiritual beings. There is no certain way to know. The comparison is that now the man also knows what is good and what is bad, or more generally “knows everything.” In verse 5 the snake told the woman “when you eat it … you will be like God,” which can also mean “like gods.” See comments on Gen 3.5.

Knowing good and evil: see comments on 2.9.

And now, which translates the Hebrew connective together with an adverb, introduces a new condition or circumstance.

Lest he put forth his hand and take: lest translates the same particle used in verse 3 “lest you die,” and means “so that he will not….” The literal translation of the Hebrew in Revised Standard Version is not natural English at all, and other translations give different expressions of lest in acceptable English. Some, like Good News Translation and New International Version, make it refer to action to prevent something happening: “He must not be allowed to….” Others, including New Revised Standard Version, Revised English Bible, and Anchor Bible, take it as speaking of the possibility that something undesirable might happen: “He might…” or “What if he…?” In this second case it is the action described in verse 23 that prevents the undesirable thing happening.

The particle is followed by four events, put forth his hand and take…, and eat, and live …. The Revised Standard Version construction is heavy, and it is often possible to restructure this to say, for example, “He must not take fruit from the tree that gives life, because if he does, he will eat it and live forever.” For tree of life see 2.9. And live for ever refers to future time, a time that never ends, unlimited duration. There is no attempt here to distinguish between physical and spiritual living.

The dash in Revised Standard Version and live for ever— is used to mark a broken or unfinished sentence in the Hebrew. God is speaking in the first person up to this point, but he does not complete the sentence by declaring what he will do to prevent the man from living forever. Instead, the narrative goes on by referring to God in the third person and then telling what God did. Most other English translations smooth out this transition, and translators are advised to do the same in their languages.

Two examples of the way the last half of this verse has been rendered are: “We can’t let him go near this Tree of Life. He must not eat the fruit of this tree too and live forever”; and “We must not let him eat the fruit of this tree that gives life. If he eats this fruit, he will never die.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 3:7

Then the eyes of both were opened: although Then is the ordinary Hebrew connective, it marks an abrupt development in events and has the sense of “immediately, right away, just then.” Good News Translation makes the transition fuller, with “As soon as….” A number of translations use similar expressions, like “Straight away” and “At that moment.” For eyes … were opened see verse 5.

They knew that they were naked: knew translates the common Hebrew verb meaning know, but in this context the man and the woman acquire the knowledge instantly, and so some expression like “realized, found out, discovered” is more suitable. Naked is the same as in 2.25.

And they sewed fig leaves: sewed suggests fastening things together with needle and thread. In translation it may be more appropriate to use a more general term meaning to “fasten, attach, hook together.” The fig tree grows in abundance in the lands of the Bible and was well known to the narrator. Its leaves are large compared with its fruit. In languages in which the fig is unknown, it is customary to say, for example, “a tree called fig” or “fruit tree that produces a fruit called fig.” It is not always necessary to say that the leaves are from a fig tree. Since the fruit does not play a part in this verse, it may be possible to use the name of a local tree, particularly if the leaves are used for loincloths or are large enough to be so used. Another good possibility is to avoid naming the type of tree and just say “large leaves.”

Made themselves aprons: aprons translates a Hebrew word also used in Isa 3.24 and translated “belt” there by Good News Translation. It refers to something worn around the waist or hips. The word “apron” is not really a good translation in English, since an apron is a partial covering that is usually worn for a particular purpose or in particular situations, rather than being a general item of clothing. In some languages it is necessary to say “a man’s loincloth” and “a woman’s loincloth” since the words are different. The exact nature of these aprons is not known, and so it may be best to use a general term like “covering” or “put leaves together to cover their private parts.” One translation expresses the whole sentence as “So they-two sewed together fig leaves and put them on like a skirt to hide their bare skin.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 3:23

Therefore the LORD God sent him forth from the garden of Eden: therefore introduces a conclusion. Sent him forth translates the usual word “send,” which does not indicate the manner of action. However, in the context of punishment it seems clear that the idea is “ordered him out, commanded him to leave.” A stronger term is used in verse 24. Note that him applies to the couple, as rendered by Good News Translation.

For till see 2.5, 15.

The ground from which he was taken: that is, “from which God had formed him,” as in 2.7. This expression may need to be restructured in languages that have no passive, and in those that find the “from which” construction too unnatural. For instance, one translation has “Before, God made the man from the ground, and now he made him go and work that same ground to make his food garden.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 3:8

And they heard the sound of the LORD God walking in the garden: they may have to be replaced by “the man and his wife.” In some languages heard the sound … walking is more naturally expressed as “heard the footsteps of…” or “heard the LORD God’s feet walking.”

Cool of the day is similar in sense to the expression in Song 2.17 and 4.6, “the day breathes.” Both expressions refer to the late afternoon and early evening, when the sun has gone down and a breeze cools the air. Good News Translation translates “that evening” and places this at the beginning of the sentence as a time setting. Bible en français courant is similar but retains the picture of the breeze blowing: “That evening when a breeze was stirring.” Revised English Bible has “at the time of the evening breeze.”

The man and his wife hid themselves: some languages require that hid themselves be expressed as a double event, first the action of moving and then the action of hiding; for example, “went and hid” or “ran away and hid.”

From the presence of the LORD God among the trees of the garden: from the presence is often better translated simply as “from,” as in Good News Translation, New International Version, and others. However, the expression in Hebrew is literally “from the face,” and in this context the meaning may be taken as “from his sight.” In some languages this is naturally expressed as “… hid, where they thought God would not see them.” Among the trees may be taken as “behind the trees” or “where they thought God could not see them because of the trees.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .