Translation commentary on Genesis 10:6

Verses 6-19 take up the names of the people who are said to have descended from Ham. This account lists four groups: Cush is said to give rise to five groups, and Raamah the son of Cush to two; Egypt produces seven groups, and Canaan eleven.

Sons of Ham: sons, as in “sons of Japheth,” refers to descendants or line of descent. If the punctuation used in Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation is not familiar, we may also say “Ham’s sons were Cush, Egypt….”

Cush is a geographic name applied to two very different areas in the Old Testament. See comments on Cush in 2.13.

Egypt is also associated with Ham in Psa 105.23, 27; 106.21, 22 (the Hebrew nameMizraim is a dual form, probably referring to Upper and Lower Egypt).

Put is found in Jer 46.9 and elsewhere. It has been associated with the Somali coast, but the connection with other areas south of Israel makes its identification with Libya much stronger.

Canaan, according to Speiser, is the name for a people speaking a language closely related to Hebrew. Some identify Canaan with the Phoenicians or the pre-Israelite people of the territory between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean, especially along the coastland. The ancient Phoenicians applied the term to themselves.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:4

In 2.16-17 the man was permitted to eat of every tree in the garden except the fruit of the tree of knowledge. In a similar manner a restriction is now placed on the freedom to eat animals.

Only you shall not eat flesh with its life, that is, its blood: Only translates a restrictive particle that may be rendered “But,” “Nevertheless,” “On the other hand.” Flesh refers here to the meat of the animals. With its life is literally “in its nefesh,” which is followed by its blood in apposition with nefesh, and so Revised Standard Version translates that is, its blood.

The thought expressed here is that the life (nefesh) has its existence or center in the blood. (See Lev 7.26-27; 17.11, 14.) When the blood is removed the life flows out of the animal. Therefore to eat meat with the blood still in it is just the same as eating the animal alive. The meaning is well expressed in Good News Translation: “The one thing you must not eat is meat with blood still in it; I forbid this because the life is in the blood.” In a number of languages the natural way to say this is “… because the blood is the source of life” or “is the same as life.”

Although it is not stated, the command that God gives in these words has a positive meaning as well as a negative meaning: that the blood is to be drained out of an animal that has been killed, and then it may be eaten. In some languages this will need to be included in the translation, otherwise this verse will be understood as a prohibition against eating all meat, contradicting the previous verse. For example, one translation expresses the verse “But you are not to eat meat with blood still in it. I forbid this because the life is in the blood. You must let the blood run out first, then you can eat it.”

There are two other major problems in translating Gen 9.4. In the first place the idea that the life is in the blood may appear very strange, since in many languages the center of life may be thought to be located in another part of the body such as the head, chest, liver, kidneys, intestines, or spleen. In such cases it may be necessary to explain in a note that the Hebrew belief was that the life of the person or animal was in the blood. In some cases it may be added that this is similar to the local belief that the life is located in … (and then name the body organ).

The second problem is that some languages do not have a noun-like word for life. Therefore it may be necessary in such languages to make some adjustments by saying, for example, “Nevertheless you must not eat meat with blood still in it, because it is the blood that makes the animal live” or “… that keeps the animal alive.” The same thought may be expressed through an opposite; for example, “This is because the animal dies when the blood is removed.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:5

This verse is made up of three conditions in which God will demand an accounting of the offender. The verse is complicated by the shifting from the second person your at the beginning of the verse to other persons with no clear transitions. Most translations will require considerable adjustment to make the meaning clear.

For your lifeblood: your is plural with reference to Noah and his family, and to their descendants in future generations. The expression is literally “the blood of your [plural] nefesh.” Although there is no verb in the construction, one is clearly understood, that is, “the taking of your life,” “the shedding of your blood, which takes away your life.” “Blood” represents the life force in human beings as well as in animals. In some translations this is expressed in the same way as in the previous verse: “… your blood, that is, your life.”

Require a reckoning translates a verb meaning to call someone to account, that is, to make someone responsible, or to make someone answer to a charge. New English Bible says “I will demand satisfaction.” The sense of the verse up to this point may be translated “If anyone takes another person’s life, I will demand an account” or “You will have to answer to me if you murder someone.” But as the rest of this verse and the next verse indicate, the meaning is that punishment, and not just an explanation, is what is required. So a number of translations say straight out “… I will punish him” or “I will pay him back for….” One translation says idiomatically “If any animal or person ends your life, I will make him [or, it] understand” (that is, “I will punish…”).

Of every beast I will require it means that punishment will be required for an animal that kills a person: the animal will be killed. See Exo 21.28-29. And of man is a shortened repetition of the previous clause and means that the person who kills another human being will be put to death; that is, the same law applies to the human murderer as to the animal that kills a person.

Of every man’s brother parallels the expression of every beast. Brother in this context means “a fellow human being,” “a neighbor,” “another person,” “anyone.” I will require the life of man expresses the same thought as above, concerning the punishment of the animal that kills a human. So here, if anyone takes another person’s life, murders him, God will require the murderer to pay with his life. Good News Translation has placed this thought at the beginning of verse 5: “If anyone takes human life, he will be punished.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:6

The first part of this verse is in the form of a chiasmus, or A-B-B′-A′ structure, in which the second line essentially reverses the order of the first. This may be seen in the rendering of Revised Standard Version:
Whoever sheds the blood of man
by man shall his blood be shed;

Furthermore, each line contains the same number of stresses. It is not surprising therefore that many translations place verse 6 in indented lines to call attention to its poetic form. The Hebrew Bible prints verse 6a as two half-lines and verse 6b as two half-lines.

Verse 6 affirms that human life is not to be taken; but if it is, the life of the murderer is to be taken. This verse does not say how that is to be done.

Sheds the blood of man: sheds, a verb meaning to cause to flow, is used frequently in the Old Testament with blood as the object. However, it is also used speaking of tears in Psa 119.136. When used with blood the sense is “to cause death,” “to kill.” Since the causing of death or killing is assumed here to be intentional, Good News Translation renders it “whoever murders a man.” Man is Ęľadam with the article and so refers to “anyone,” “a person,” “a human being.” Man in the expression by man again contains the article and so has the same sense as above. Shall … be shed translates the passive of the verb “to shed” used in the first line.

Since man here refers not to any particular man, or even to males exclusively, it may be more suitable to use inclusive language and say, for example, “Human beings were made like God, so whoever murders a person will be killed by someone else.” In languages that do not use the passive, we may say “God made human beings like himself, so somebody will kill the person who murders another human being.”

Even though the text itself does not say how the life of a murderer is to be taken, in some languages and cultures it will not be sufficient to use the indefinite “somebody” as the subject of the verb when it is transformed from the passive. Such a rendering suggests that the murderer will meet his death by chance rather than in accordance with the laws or customs of the human community. It may not be wise to go as far as naming a relative of the murdered person as the one who kills the murderer, even though we know this was the practice among the people of Israel in some periods, and even though it may still be the custom in some cultures today. Generally a term like “the people” can be used, which means that people act together or in accordance with custom. For example, “The person who kills another person, he himself must die at the hands of the people” and “The person who kills another person, the people of his community must kill him….”

The second half of the verse, printed as two half-lines in the Hebrew Bible, does not have the same chiastic structure as the first half, but each half-line appears to have the same number of stresses, and so is poetically bound to verse 6a and often printed in indented lines the same as 6a.

for in the image of God
made he man.

For God made man in his own image: for introduces a clause of reason, making this sentence the reason why human life is not to be taken. Man again means human beings; however, the term has a collective sense in this case: “people” or “human beings [plural].” In his own image is the same as 1.26, 27. See there for comments.

Some languages prefer for stylistic reasons to place the reason before the statement, and so in such cases verse 6b will be placed before verse 6a. See Good News Translation. On the other hand Biblia Dios Habla Hoy translates “If anyone kills a man, another man will kill him, since man was created in God’s likeness.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:7

Verse 7 closes the “warning” section of this subdivision with a repetition of the blessing from Gen 9.1. See the outline at the beginning of this subdivision (8.20–9.17).

And you: you is again plural, referring to Noah and his sons.

Be fruitful and multiply: see comments on 1.22 and 9.1.

Bring forth abundantly on the earth: bring forth translates the same verb used in 1.20, where it was translated “bring forth swarms.” New English Bible says “swarm throughout the earth,” but this is unsuitable for human beings, and Revised English Bible has revised it to say “people the earth….” We may also say “populate the earth” or “fill the earth.”

And multiply in it repeats the verb used in the first part of the verse. Some translations (New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible, Revised English Bible, Bible de Jérusalem) have “subdue it” or “rule over it” on the basis of an alternative verb found also in 1.28. However, Hebrew Old Testament Text Project gives the Hebrew text a rating of {B}, suggesting there is some slight doubt but recommending no change, and it recommends “and multiply [plural] on it.” Many modern translations do not repeat multiply in it, since this has been stated earlier in be fruitful and multiply.

Although this verse is a repetition of the content of verse 1, it is a fuller command than verse 1; and in particular the expression bring forth abundantly is added. For those languages in which repetition is not contrary to good style, the idea of giving birth continually can be the new focus in this context. For example, one translation has “Have many children, and become very plentiful; give birth again and again, so that you will become very numerous.” Another understands this expression to refer to successive generations and says “You must have many children, and your children must have many children of their own, so that….”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:8

In verses 8-11 God establishes his covenant with Noah and his descendants. Verse 8 is introductory. In verses 9-10 the covenant is said to include Noah, his descendants, and all the animals that were on the boat. Verse 11 gives the content of the covenant.

Then God said to Noah and to his sons with him represents a break in the speech that began at verse 1b. God is still the speaker, and Noah and his sons the listeners.

Then introduces a new sequence and a new discourse in God’s speech. The Hebrew form is “Then God said to Noah and his sons with him saying,” but this is best conveyed in English as “Then God said to Noah and his sons.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:9

Behold: see comments on 1.29

I establish my covenant is basically the same wording used in 6.18. However, there is an emphatic repetition of the personal pronoun “I” here, and the verb form is different from the narrative form used in 6.18. This construction makes for a very deliberative statement that is fitting for the formal declaration of the covenant. In many languages a shift to a level of language that is appropriate for such a formal declaration will be called for. In English Speiser and New International Version attempt to get this style with “I now establish….” In one new translation the formal speech opening, “Now I intend to make a contract…,” is used to give the formal tone.

The first use of covenant in 6.18 introduced the word without reference to the way it is to be applied and without content. Here in 9.9, however, the term covenant occurs in a context beginning with 8.20 and continuing to 9.17. The content of the covenant as expressed here is:
(1) never to destroy the earth again, but to continue the seasons of the year (8.21b-22; 9.11);
(2) the blessing of fertility (9.1, 7);
(3) to give human beings dominion over the animals and the right to eat them while abstaining from the blood (9.2-4);
(4) to put to death people who murder (9.5);
(5) to put to death any animal that kills a person (9.5).

The participants of the covenant are as follows:
(1) it is initiated entirely by God (9.11, 12, 15);
(2) it applies to all present and future: Noah, his descendants, the birds and the animals (9.9, 10).

The covenant is to last for ever (9.11, 16), and it is guaranteed by a sign (9.12, 13, 17). Noah, like the animals, is not an active party in an agreement. He and they, as well as future generations, are the recipients of God’s promises. For other covenants see 15.18-20; Num 25.10-13; 2 Sam 7.

You and your descendants is literally “You [plural] and your seed.” “Seed” is grammatically singular but collective in meaning. See comments on 3.15. After you is often considered redundant, since it is included in the meaning of descendants.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:10

And with every living creature that is with you: living creature is as in 1.20, 24 and is furthermore divided here into three categories: the birds, the cattle, and every beast of the earth. Cattle refers to domestic animals, and beast to wild animals. Nothing is said about the creeping animals. Good News Translation uses dashes to show that “all living beings” is to be understood as “all birds, and all animals.” Good News Translation has put domestic and wild animals together as “all animals.”

As many as came out of the ark, as the Revised Standard Version footnote shows, follows the Septuagint. The Hebrew text repeats “every beast of the earth,” adding this phrase at the end. Hebrew Old Testament Text Project, which gives the Hebrew text an {A} rating, explains that the Hebrew prepositions “from” (all that go out of the ark) and “to” (every beast of the earth) means there are two categories: “first those which came out of the ark, and then those which live thereafter on the earth.” Accordingly Hebrew Old Testament Text Project recommends “all those coming out of the ark as well as all beasts of the earth.” Neither Revised Standard Version nor Good News Translation follows the Hebrew Old Testament Text Project recommendation, but many other modern translations do, and translators are encouraged to do likewise. Some models to follow are Bible en français courant, “and everything that lives around you: birds, domestic and wild animals, those that came out of the boat, and all that will in the future live on the earth,” and Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch “and with all the animals that were with you in the boat and that will live on the earth in the future.” In some languages the action of coming out of the boat is not stated directly but is understood from the fact of the animals and birds having been on the boat with Noah; for example, “… animals and birds … everything that was with you on the boat…” and “… the animals and birds that you took with you in the boat.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .