Translation commentary on Genesis 21:20

And God was with the lad: the sense is that God protected, guarded, blessed Ishmael.

And he grew up: that is, “God protected the young boy as he was growing up,” “… as he matured,” “… as he became older.”

He lived in the wilderness: for wilderness see verse 14.

Became an expert with the bow: the Hebrew has a double expression that Hebrew Old Testament Text Project takes to mean “a shooter, an archer” and believes the Hebrew intends to say “a shooter of the bow.” There is little difference between this and Revised Standard Version‘s rendering. Note, however, that Good News Translation translates “skillful hunter.” This rendering is based on Speiser’s suggestion that the first of the two Hebrew words is to be associated with “great.” However, even this understanding makes little difference in these translations, and there is no clear reason to prefer one over the other. Accordingly we may translate, for example, as Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation. Bible en français courant says “a skillful shooter of the bow,” and Biblia Dios Habla Hoy “a good shooter of the bow.” Note also Revised English Bible “became an archer.” If the bow is not known, translators may use the more general expression such as “became a hunter” or “became a skilled hunter.”

It should be noted that Good News Translation, like some other modern translations, restructures verses 20 and 21, so that Ishmael becoming a skillful hunter is stated after his living in the wilderness of Paran. This makes it possible to avoid the repetition of he lived in the wilderness in verse 20 and He lived … Paran in verse 21. Translators should consider doing something similar.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:21

He lived in the wilderness of Paran: see 14.6 for discussion of wilderness.

His mother took a wife for him means “Hagar arranged a marriage for him,” “chose a wife for him,” or “arranged for him to marry….” This was the responsibility of the father, but in Ishmael’s case that was not possible. A wife: that is a bride, a woman.

Land of Egypt: in 10.6, 13 Egypt is a person, but in 12.10 it is a country. Here also Egypt refers to the nation or country, which is often translated “the country called Egypt.” Egypt was of course the country that Hagar had come from; and in some cultures where marriage within a person’s own tribe is important, this may be brought out: “Hagar got a wife for him from her own country Egypt.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:22

At that time probably has no relation to the events in verses 9-21 but rather refers back to the events related in the story about Abraham and Abimelech in chapter 20. In translation it will probably be best to avoid making a connection with the end of chapter 20 and to use a general transition before verse 22; for example “Later,” “One day,” “It happened one day like this.” Biblia Dios Habla Hoy says “More or less about that time,” and Bible en français courant “At about that period.”

Phicol the commander of his army: Phicol appears here probably in the role of personal bodyguard or as an official witness. He figures again in the same capacity in chapter 26, when a similar oath is made with Isaac. Commander is an adequate term in English for the head of an army. In languages in which there is no army, a more general term such as “leader” or “officer” may be required. Where an organized body of soldiers does not exist, army is sometimes rendered as “soldiers,” “fighters,” “ones who carry weapons.”

Said to Abraham: the Hebrew construction can be read as in Revised Standard Version, with both men speaking to Abraham. However, in verse 23 Abimelech alone is the speaker, and so it is best to make Abimelech the speaker in this phrase: see Good News Translation.

The text does not actually say that Abimelech and Phicol came to where Abraham was, but it will be necessary to include this information in some languages. Note Good News Translation “Abimelech went”; other translations say, for example, “King Abimelech with Phicol … they-two came to see Abraham, and the king said to him….”

God is with you in all that you do: Abimelech recognizes that Abraham has special power and fortune attributed to God, and consequently fears Abraham. Therefore he wishes to assure himself of Abraham’s loyalty. With you means “helps you,” “protects you,” “blesses you.” In some languages it is natural to introduce this statement with “I have noticed…” or “I have seen that….”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:23

Now therefore swear to me here by God: now therefore translates a word marking a consequence; that is, “because God is with you” or “because God protects you in everything, therefore….” As a consequence of knowing that God helps Abraham, Abimelech wants Abraham to be loyal to him. Although the Hebrew text has the form of an imperative here, the sense is more of a request than a command. Therefore in translation it will often be more appropriate to use a form of polite request here; for example, “I want you to promise….”

Swear to me: in 14.22 “I have sworn” translated an expression that literally meant “I have raised my hand.” See there for discussion. The verb meaning “swear an oath” in this verse (Hebrew shabaʿ) sounds like the word “seven” (shebaʿ) and may have the sense of giving or naming seven things as a way of making a solemn oath. (The BDB Hebrew Lexicon gives the basic meaning of shabaʿ as “bind oneself by seven things.”) Abimelech is asking Abraham to take an oath, to promise. Swear … by God (ʾelohim) means to do so while calling on God to punish him if he breaks the oath or fails to do what he promises to do. The full expression may sometimes be rendered, for example, “Promise me before God that you will…” or “Take an oath and may God punish you if you fail to keep your word.”

Here may refer to the location of Beersheba. However, many translations do not attempt to name the place. Good News Translation takes here to be equivalent with God’s presence in which the oath is taken. We may also say “here before God,” “here where God is,” or even “now in God’s presence.”

That you will not deal falsely with me: deal falsely translates a verb meaning to “deceive,” “betray,” “lie.” Abimelech demands that Abraham not behave in this way with him. He also asks that Abraham not deceive or betray my offspring … my posterity. In Hebrew these two words have similar sounds, and so Speiser attempts to match them with English “kith and kin.” Good News Translation and Revised English Bible express the thought clearly with “children … descendants.” In translation most languages have terms that mean “behave deceitfully” and which will be suitable in this context.

But as I have dealt loyally with you: loyally translates Hebrew chesed, meaning “kindness,” “faithfulness,” “loyalty.” Literally this is “as the loyalty that I have made with you….” We may translate “As I have been loyal in dealing with you, now you do the same with me” or “I have been loyal to you and so you must be loyal to me.” In some languages the sense of being loyal or faithful can only be expressed in general terms with something like “behaved well toward” or “done only good to”; or it may be expressed negatively, “not behaved deceitfully.” The construction as I have … with you, you will … with me is expressed in some translations as “give back to me the love [loyalty] I have shown to you.”

And with the land where you have sojourned: the land refers to the country or kingdom ruled by Abimelech. In getting Abraham’s promise of loyalty to the land, the king obtains loyalty to himself as its ruler. In many languages a person can be loyal to another person or to people, but not to an inanimate object such as land. It may therefore be necessary to say something like “and be loyal to the people of this country.” And since Abimelech is the ruler of the country, in some translations this becomes “my people.” One restructuring of the last part of the verse is “I have been kind to you while you have been a stranger in my country. Well, now, you have to treat me and my people in a kind way too.”

For discussion of sojourn see 12.10.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:24

And Abraham said, “I will swear”: this is not to be taken as a swearing that Abraham will perform in the future, but rather as something he does immediately. New Jerusalem Bible and Revised English Bible have “I swear it,” Good News Translation simply “I promise” (following the term as translated in the previous verse). We may also say “I give my oath,” “I promise to be loyal to you.” In some languages it is normal to use some term of assent or agreement before these words; for example, “All right. I promise…” or “Very well. Before God I promise that I will not deceive you.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:9

But Sarah saw the son of Hagar the Egyptian: But is not an adequate discourse opener for English and many other languages. Accordingly it may be necessary to begin this episode with something like “One day when,” “It happened later that,” “After the feast was over.” If verse 8 is taken as opening this episode, the best transition here may be “During the course of the feast”; or it may be quite satisfactory to follow Revised Standard Version as it stands. Saw is used here in the sense of “notice,” “observe.” The narrator avoids Ishmael’s name and focuses on Ishmael’s mother and her origin. Good News Translation, however, names the son.

Playing with her son Isaac: a note in Revised Standard Version says that “with her son Isaac” is lacking in the Hebrew text but is found in the Greek Septuagint and the Vulgate translations. The verb translated playing was rendered by the Septuagint translators by a verb meaning “mocking,” and this has been followed by some recent versions. However, the Hebrew word is not followed by a preposition, as it is in other cases where the sense is clearly “mocking,” and so the meaning is better taken as “playing,” which is supported by Hebrew Old Testament Text Project. The Hebrew verb expresses the intensive form of the root from which Isaac’s name is derived. This is another example of a play on the name Isaac. It is highly unlikely that this play on words can be reproduced in translation. It is the sight of young Ishmael playing as an equal with Isaac that causes Sarah to become jealous and angry.

In some languages translations of this verse simply say “Sarah saw that other son of Abraham, the son of Hagar the Egyptian woman, playing.” But in other languages playing is an activity that two or more children do together; a common rendering is “Sarah saw that other son of Abraham … playing with her son Isaac.” One translation expresses this as “One day Sarah saw her son Isaac and Ishmael the son of … Hagar playing together.”

Translators may find that the whole of verse 9 may be translated as a time clause and verse 10 as the main clause. For example, Speiser translates “When Sarah noticed that the son whom Hagar the Egyptian…, she turned on Abraham, ‘Cast out….’ ”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:25

Verse 25 may be viewed in two ways: as introducing a further topic in the treaty negotiations between Abimelech and Abraham (verses 22-24), or as a new and subsequent discussion. Good News Translation tends to favor the second of these. Revised Standard Version may be interpreted in either way. New International Version, “Then Abraham complained…,” and New Jerusalem Bible favor the first view.

If we assume that the well had been seized before the discussions in verses 22-24, as the Handbook does, then verse 25 is to be taken as part of the treaty discussion. In this case it will be natural in many languages to begin verse 25 with a transition such as “Then Abraham went on to complain…” or “After Abraham had sworn, he then complained….” Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch makes it clear that verse 25 is part of the treaty talks, by beginning a new paragraph at verse 24, which contains verses 25 and 26 also. Translators may follow these models.

Abraham complained to Abimelech: the word translated complained may also be rendered “protested,” “objected,” “called Abimelech’s attention to.” Other expressions found in some languages are “Abraham had an argument with…,” “Abraham had something to talk to Abimelech about [meaning a complaint].”

For well of water see verse 19.

Abimelech’s servants had seized: had seized means at some time in the past they had taken it over, possessed it, and probably would not allow others to use it. We may assume that these servants or herdsmen of Abimelech had taken the well from Abraham, since he now claims ownership of it. In many languages it is necessary to say whom they had taken the well from. Some translations express the taking of the well as “… had made themselves the bosses [owners] of….”

In some languages it is more natural to express complaining about something in a direct quotation. A translation that does this here says “King, I have seen that your people have done something that isn’t right: they have taken a well that belongs to me, and blocked my people from getting water from it.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 21:10

So she said to Abraham: she refers to Sarah. So introduces the consequence of verse 9 in Revised Standard Version; but it also suggests to the reader something of the emotion that led Sarah to make this demand of Abraham. It may be necessary to show the emotion in Sarah’s words by saying something like “… Sarah was jealous, and she said….”

Cast out translates a verb meaning “drive out,” “expel,” “get rid of,” “send away.”

Slave woman is the same word as used in the plural in 20.17. See there for comments. Sarah’s demand is that Abraham send away or expel Hagar, whom she calls this slave woman, along with her son.

For the son of this slave woman shall not be heir with my son Isaac: by avoiding the names of Hagar and Ishmael—a rhetorical device of the narrator to show disdain—Sarah expresses the reason for her demand. Be heir, the same word as used in 15.3-4, translates the verb “to inherit.” For discussion of heir and “inherit” see 15.2.

This clause is translated by Good News Translation as a negative “must” clause: “the son of this woman must not get any part….” The sense is “the son of this slave woman must not inherit your wealth [when you die]. Only my son Isaac must inherit it.” Other expressions of this sense are “it is not right at all for the son of … to take part of what belongs to you; everything belongs to my son” and “her son can’t take over anything of yours [when you die]; Isaac my son has got to take over everything.”

Translators may wish to note the New Testament reference to this passage in Gal 4.29-30.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .