Exegesis:
kai parÄggeilen autois hina âand he commanded them that…â: as in previous cases (cf. 5.18) hina âthatâ does not indicate purpose, but the content of the command.
paraggellĹ (8.6) âgive orders,â âcommand.â
eis hodon âin the road,â i.e. âfor the journey.â
ei mÄ rabdon monon âexcept a staff only,â not âexcept (for) one staffâ: monon âonlyâ is an adverb (cf. 5.36), not an adjective, and modifies ei mÄ âexcept,â âbut.â
rabdos (only here in Mark) âstaff,â ârodâ used in traveling.
pÄran (only here in Mark) âknapsack,â âtraveler’s bagâ: here, more explicitly, a beggar’s bag. Lagrange points out it would be pointless to prohibit taking a bag for provisions when the taking of bread had already been forbidden.
mÄ eis tÄn zĹnÄn chalkon âno money in their belts.â
zĹnÄ (cf. 1.6) âgirdle,â âbelt.â
chalkos (12.41) âcopper,â âbrassâ; âcopper coinâ; âmoney.â
In verse 9 the construction changes: instead of clauses governed by hina âthatâ as in v. 8, there is one participial clause which is the direct object of the verb âhe commanded,â and one clause which is in the form of direct speech. For purposes of translation, however, there is no need literally to reproduce the Greek grammatical constructions; the content, not the form, is what matters.
alla hupodedemenous sandalia âbut to wear sandalsâ (i.e. rather than go barefooted).
hupodeomai (only here in Mark; cf. hupodÄma 1.7) âbind underâ: of sandals, âto put on,â âto wear.â
sandalion (only here in Mark) âsandalâ (a synonym of hupodÄma in 1.7).
kai mÄ endusÄsthe duo chitĹnas âand do not wear two tunics.â
enduĹ (cf. 1.6) âput on,â âwear.â
chitĹn (14.63; cf. himation 2.21) âtunic,â âshirt,â worn next to the skin: the command not to wear two tunics meant that one only was sufficient.
Translation:
Verses 8 and 9 present serious problems for translators because (1) the grammatical form shifts in the middle of the passage, from an indirect to a direct form, and (2) there are two awkward exceptions: the staff is an exception in what should be carried, and the extra tunic is forbidden in an otherwise positive command, i.e. to wear sandals and one tunic. This means that in a number of translations this passage must be recast to fit the requirements of the receptor language.
Charged them to take … may be altered in many languages into a form of direct command, for this greatly simplifies the syntactic problems in the rest of the passage, e.g. âhe commanded them, Do not take….â
In verse eight there is a shift from negative to positive and again to negative in the Revised Standard Version order: nothing … except a staff; no …. In many languages this would be clearer if the exception to the negation were placed at the end, e.g. âdo not take anything for your journey: do not take bread, a bag, or money in your girdles, take only a walking stick.â In some languages (Southern Bobo MadarĂŠ), however, the positive would normally precede the negative, e.g. âtake a stick in your hand, do not take anything else….â
Put on two tunics is equivalent in many instances to âwear two shirts.â As Arndt and Gingrich point out the wearing of two tunics was a sign of effeminacy.
Quoted with permission from Bratcher, Robert G. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on the Gospel of Mark. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1961. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.