Some commentators consider the particle Therefore as introducing a new theme (so Phillips, Living Bible [Living Bible]). More likely, however, is the view of most, that it is to be taken as a conclusion to the subsection (1.19-21); in this case it can be rendered as âSo thenâ (Barclay), âIn conclusion,â or even âSo, keeping in mind what I have just said….â
The words put away are a participle in Greek, but this has an imperative force because it is related to the imperative receive, and so is rendered as an imperative by most translators. The Greek word can be used of removing dirt from one’s body, but in the New Testament the most commonly used sense is that of stripping off or laying aside clothing (Acts 7.58). It is often used metaphorically of putting off a person’s old self and pattern of behavior (Rom 13.12; Col 3.8; 1 Peter 2.1). It expresses the idea of turning away from evil and turning to God, a complete change of lifestyle. Because of this some scholars believe that the saying has its origin in a conversion or baptismal context. There are a variety of ways to translate this expression; for example, âstop [or, quit] doing…,â âdon’t practice … any more,â âgive up,â âput aside,â or âleave behind.â
What should be stripped off is all filthiness and rank growth of wickedness. There are several possible ways of understanding this expression. First, we can take the two phrases connected by and as two distinctive parts. In this case the force of all can go with both filthiness and wickedness. The expression can then be rendered as âall filthiness and all rank growth of wickedness.â This understanding is reflected in the following translations: âeverything … every…â (Goodspeed, Revised English Bible), âeverything … all…â (Barclay), âall … all…â (Knox), and âevery … all…â (Good News Translation).
Secondly, it is possible to take filthiness and rank growth of wickedness as expressing a single idea, meaning âall filthiness caused by rank growth of wickedness,â or âall filthiness caused by overflowing wickedness.â
Thirdly, it is also possible to take rank growth of wickedness as an explanation of filthiness. In this case the expression may be rendered as âall filthiness, that is rank growth of wickedness.â This is apparently the way Knox understood it: â… of all defilement, of all the ill will that remains in you.â
These are all possible interpretations, but on the whole the first is the easiest one to follow and translate.
The word filthiness is used only here in the New Testament. Its adjective form is used in 2.2 to refer to the shabby clothing of a poor man. In the context of âstripping off,â it seems obvious that the author intends to continue the clothing metaphor. The intent is clear; it describes any moral defilement, anything that makes a person unclean and therefore unacceptable to God. It refers to a person’s âfilthy habitâ (Good News Translation), âmoral filthâ (New International Version), something that âwould soil lifeâ (Barclay), or even âindecent behavior.â
The meaning of the expression rank growth of wickedness is understood in various ways.
(1) Some take rank growth, which is one word in Greek, in the sense of âexcessâ or âsurplusâ and translate the phrase as âsuperfluity of naughtinessâ (King James Version), âthe malice that hurries to excessâ (New English Bible), or âwicked excessâ (Revised English Bible). This interpretation has the danger of allowing the misunderstanding that wickedness that is not excessive may be tolerated.
(2) A related interpretation is to take rank growth as something both extra and offensive, a kind of cancerous growth. This apparently is the sense favored by Barclay when he renders the expression as âmalice that is like an alien growth on life.â
(3) The word is sometimes taken to mean âthat which survives,â or âthat which is left over.â On this understanding the exhortation is to take off every trace of wickedness that remains, and this is reflected in some translations; for example, âthe remains of wickednessâ (New American Standard Bible), âof all the ill-will that remains in youâ (Knox), and âremnants of evilâ (New Jerusalem Bible). This makes some sense, but the meaning is a bit forced.
(4) More scholars and translators have therefore taken rank growth in its basic sense of âabundance,â âprofusion,â or âoverflowing,â and rendered the phrase as âoverflowing of wickednessâ (American Standard Version), âevery other evil that overflows…â (Phillips), âthe malice which is so abundantâ (Biblia Dios Habla Hoy), âthe evil that is so prevalentâ (New International Version), or âall wicked conductâ (Good News Translation). Translators are advised to follow this interpretation.
The word wickedness is rendered in various ways. The rendering ânaughtinessâ (King James Version) as used nowadays is a bit too weak and even misleading, since it often refers to the mischievous behavior of children. The word can also have the general sense of âevilâ (so Goodspeed, Translatorâs New Testament, New Jerusalem Bible), although in the present context, where there is an admonition to avoid âanger,â the more precise meaning of âill-willâ (so Knox) or âmaliceâ (Barclay, New English Bible) may be desirable.
An alternative translation model for the first part of this verse may be:
⢠So, keeping in mind what I have just said, you must stop [or, quit] all your indecent [or, filthy] behavior and all the wicked things you do.
Receive with meekness the implanted word: the exhortation now switches from a negative to a positive tone. In the UBS Greek text the phrase with meekness goes with the previous clause, modifying put away. Although there is at least one version that follows the Greek text and renders it â… put away with meekness…,â the majority take it as qualifying the verb receive. The metaphor is now shifted from that of clothing to one of planting. The attitude required is meekness, the kind of disposition needed in hearing and doing the word. Here the contrast is most likely not with âwickednessâ or âmaliceâ as some scholars have suggested, but with âanger,â especially if the anger mentioned in the previous verses is understood to be an arrogant and hostile temper against others as the result of overconfidence in the word of God. Meekness is a very difficult word to render, as shown by the different renderings in various translations; for example, âa teachable spiritâ (Barclay), âbe patientâ (Knox), âin a humble spiritâ (Goodspeed), âbe humbleâ (Contemporary English Version), âsubmit to Godâ (Good News Translation). It is that kind of disposition or temper always under perfect control, a combination of being gentle, modest, humble, patient, submissive, and having a teachable spirit. In some languages it will be good to render this term with a negative expression; for example, âAs you receive … don’t do it in a proud wayâ or âAs you receive … don’t act as if you are somebody big.â
It is with this kind of spirit that a person should receive … the implanted word. The verb receive is an aorist imperative, indicating that the action is not progressive but one-time and decisive, pointing perhaps to the first reception. The fact that readers are advised to receive means that what is to be received is a gift, something that comes from God. There is a problem in the logical consequence here: How can someone receive what has been inborn or implanted? To resolve this problem some suggest that the word receive is best understood in the sense of âobey.â Others, however, render it as âwelcome [what has been given]â (so New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, New Revised Standard Version).
The adjective implanted has two meanings. It can have the sense of âinnate,â âinborn,â and therefore ânatural,â as opposed to what is acquired from outside. In this case word is often understood to be referring to the inborn reason or principle in every human being, the faculty that makes it possible for a person to understand and be receptive to a revelation. There are some difficulties with this understanding. For one thing, as already mentioned above, it is odd for people to be urged to accept what is already within them. For another, in a context where James places such an emphasis on the word as the gospel message, on hearing it and practicing it, it is unlikely that he would introduce a Stoic understanding of the word as inborn reason.
For these reasons most scholars prefer the second sense of implanted, that is, like a seed that is planted in the soil. In this case the gifts cannot be inborn and natural, but they are given or planted: âwhich roots itself inwardlyâ (Moffatt). Here we recall the parable of the sower (Matt 13.1-23), which tells how the seed (word, gospel) is sown into the hearts of people. In this sense the verb receive is best understood as meaning âwelcomeâ or âaccept inâ (in Japanese translations), that is, first taking in what the person accepts and then turning it into action. The place where the word is planted is not stated in the text, but some translations have identified it as âin youâ (Luther 1984, La Sainte Bible: Nouvelle version Segond rĂŠvisĂŠe, Traduction ĹcumĂŠnique de la Bible, New Jerusalem Bible) or âin your heartsâ (Translatorâs New Testament, Good News Translation, Revised English Bible). The latter appears to be more common and appropriate, in that the âheartâ is considered in many cultures to be the seat of the emotions and the will, where actions are initiated. The agent who plants is God, and this can be made clear (so Good News Translation, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch). The object or thing that is planted is the word, which most scholars agree to be the same as âthe word of truthâ in verse 18, meaning âthe message of the Gospel,â and which is sometimes rendered as âthe messageâ (Goodspeed, Biblia Dios Habla Hoy, Revised English Bible).
Alternative translation models for this sentence are:
⢠You must be humble and accept the message that God has planted [or, placed] in your hearts.
⢠Don’t be proud, but accept [or, welcome] the message [or, the true word] that God has planted in your hearts.
⢠When you accept the message that God has planted in your hearts, don’t act as if you are somebody big.
The message that is planted deep in the hearts of Christians is able to save your souls. The âsowingâ of the âseed,â that is, the gospel message, will yield as its fruit âsalvation.â The reference to âsalvationâ appears elsewhere in the letter at 2.14; 4.12; and 5.20. It is most likely that it is a reference to future salvation at the last judgment. The souls here should not be interpreted as a reference to a higher part of a person, as against the body, but to the whole person. The phrase is best rendered âis able to save youâ (Good News Translation), âhas the power to save youâ (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch; similarly Revised English Bible), or âis capable of saving your lifeâ (Bible en français courant). In a number of languages it will be helpful to begin a new sentence here and say âThis word [or, message] has the power to save youâ or â… is capable of saving your life.â
Quoted with permission from Loh, I-Jin and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on The Letter from James. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.