Translation commentary on Hosea 2:18

And I will make for you a covenant on that day …: Revised Standard Version does not have a paragraph or stanza break here. However, since there is a major shift in perspective in this verse, a break is needed. The Hebrew phrase for on that day is identical with the one rendered “in that day” in 2.16 (see comments there). In this verse it marks the second promise, that God will make a new covenant for Israel. Good News Translation therefore begins a new paragraph at this point. This verse uses nonfigurative language about Israel rather than the image of a renewed relationship with the wife.

The Hebrew word for covenant refers to an “agreement” (Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch), almost like a contract (usually spoken rather than written), that guides and determines the relations and obligations between two parties. Here it is God who will draw up, or determine, what the agreement will state. The unusual other party in the covenant are the different types of animals, symbolizing all nature. This should obviously not be taken literally, but is a poetic way of expressing that even nature will take part in God’s intervention for Israel. In this section A-c′ nature is involved in Israel’s restoration, just as nature was involved in section A-c in opposing Israel. I will make … a covenant is literally “I will cut a covenant,” an expression commonly used in the Hebrew Bible. The translator should find an expression that fits the receptor language and culture. For example, in Pokot (Kenya) the usual expression is “to eat a covenant.” This expression conveys the binding nature of a covenant.

As the Revised Standard Version footnote states, for you is “for them” in Hebrew. The widening of the scope from the wife to Israel is clear from the switch to the plural pronoun “them,” which Good News Translation renders “my people.” “For them” means that the covenant is prepared on behalf of Israel, so that the covenant will be between Israel and the animals, even though it is God who arranges the covenant. The translator will have to determine whether to have God speak to Israel (for you) or about Israel (“for them”). Good News Translation expands this phrase, saying “so that they will not harm my people,” which makes the meaning explicit. De Nieuwe Bijbelvertaling retains the husband-wife-children metaphor by beginning this verse with “On that day I will make a covenant for my children.” In any case, it should be clear the plural (representing the people of Israel) is intended here by the text.

With the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, and the creeping things of the ground: Previously wild animals had destroyed Israel’s vineyards and orchards (2.12), but now God promises that the animals will not harm Israel (compare Isa 11.6-9). The three types of animals here are mentioned along with the kind of space in which they are normally active. Beasts of the field include animals that roam over the open spaces, some of which are dangerous or troublesome (see 2.12). New Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation say “wild animals.” Birds of the air is simply the poetic Hebrew idiom for “birds” (Good News Translation). Creeping things of the ground include reptiles and small animals that may dig into the ground, also troublesome especially for farmers. Good News Translation combines them with beasts of the field, saying “all the wild animals.” The animals are grouped and listed in the same order as in the creation story in Gen 1.30.

And I will abolish the bow, the sword, and war from the land: The Hebrew word for abolish is literally “break,” as the second Revised Standard Version footnote indicates. Only a bow or a sword can be broken, not war, but this is a Hebrew rhetorical device that uses the same verb for all three direct objects, even though it is suitable for only two. Translators will need to use a verb that is appropriate in their languages but that communicates the basic information, such as abolish or “remove” (Good News Translation). In many cultures the symbolism of breaking bows and swords will be well understood and can therefore be translated literally. In the series of the three things destroyed, the bow and the sword are mentioned first, with war mentioned last as a kind of summary of how the first two items are used. Good News Translation follows normal English style by mentioning “weapons of war” first and then the two examples of such weapons, “all swords and bows.” Some translations may prefer to state that war as such will no longer occur. See Psa 76.3[4] for a similar use of these terms. For bow and sword, see 1.7. From the land refers to the land of Israel, not to the whole world, nor merely to certain agricultural lands.

And I will make you lie down in safety: Here God’s promise of security is shown in the way in which people may safely go to sleep at night. But this promise implies more than that, so Good News Translation gives its wider meaning by saying “and [I] will let my people live in peace and safety.” Since a causative verb is used here in Hebrew, it is important to make it clear that Yahweh makes this possible. New Living Translation fails to do this by saying “so you can live unafraid in peace and safety.” In safety expresses one aspect of the Hebrew term here. Good News Translation tries to give a fuller picture of its meaning with “in peace and safety.”

A translation model for this verse is:

• When that happens, I will strike a covenant for [you,] my people
with the animals in the field,
with the birds in the air,
and with the creeping creatures on the ground.
I will break the bow and the sword,
removing all weapons of war from the land.
I will let you stay in safety.

Quoted with permission from Dorn, Louis & van Steenbergen, Gerrit. A Handbook on Hosea. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2020. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

SIL Translator’s Notes on Hosea 2:18

2:18a

On that day: This is the same phrase that was used in 2:16a, and it refers to the same future time. For that reason, some versions do not repeat it here but leave it implied. That is an acceptable option as long as it is clear that the time period is the same.

I will make a covenant for them: The word covenant is an important theological word that is used many times in the book of Hosea. Usually it refers to an agreement between God and people. Here it refers to an agreement that the LORD made with the animals for the benefit of the Israelites. If your key term for covenant does not allow this use, you may need to use a different term. For example:

I will make an agreement (New Century Version)
-or-
I shall make a treaty (New Jerusalem Bible)
-or-
I will cause…to agree

for them: In this context, the Hebrew word that most versions translate as for means “for the benefit of” or “on behalf of.” For example:

on Israel’s behalf (Revised English Bible)

Some versions leave the phrase for them implied. Most of these versions use other phrases to clarify the kind of benefits that Israel will enjoy. For example:

I will make a covenant with all the wild animals and birds, so that they will not harm my people. (Good News Translation)

them: Here in 2:18a, the pronoun them refers to the Israelites. The Good News Translation uses the phrase “my people.” The Contemporary English Version continues to use “you.”

with the beasts of the field and the birds of the air and the creatures that crawl on the ground: In this context, these three phrases represent all animals that could cause harm to people or crops. The same three phrases occur in Genesis 1:30, although the context is different. See how you translated the same phrases there.

the beasts of the field: This phrase refers to untamed animals that are often dangerous to people.

Here is another way to translate this phrase:

the wild animals (New Jerusalem Bible)

the birds of the air: This phrase refers to flying creatures. In English, the words of the air are redundant, because the word birds includes this idea. So some English versions leave the words of the air implied. For example:

the birds (God’s Word)

the creatures that crawl on the ground: This phrase refers to small animals, including reptiles. In English, the category “wild animals” can include small animals. That is perhaps why some English versions, as the Good News Translation, leave this phrase implied.

In other languages, it may be necessary to use two categories to express the meaning of this phrase. For example:

crawling things and slithering things

Use categories that are natural in your language for describing the same kinds of living creatures. You may need to use more or less than three categories.

2:18b

And I will abolish bow and sword and weapons of war in the land: This clause expresses an additional promise from the LORD. It is not related to the covenant with the animals in 2:18a. In some languages, it may be necessary to clarify that this is a separate promise. For example:

I will also remove… (Good News Translation)

abolish: In Hebrew, this word is literally “break.” It means “to break” the weapons in order to end warfare.

Here are some other ways to translate this word:

remove (Good News Translation)
-or-
destroy (God’s Word)

bow and sword and weapons of war: The bow and the sword were the two main weapons of war during the time of Hosea. Here these weapons are used as a figure of speech (synecdoche) that represents all weapons of war. The phrase weapons of war then summarizes and extends the figure to mean “warfare” or “battle” (New International Version, English Standard Version, Revised Standard Version)

Here are some other ways to translate this phrase:

weapons of war (Contemporary English Version)
-or-
all weapons of war from the land, all swords and bows (Good News Translation)
-or-
the bow, the sword, and war from the land (English Standard Version)

2:18c

and: The Hebrew conjunction waw that the Berean Standard Bible translates as and can have many different functions. Most English versions translate it here as and. But in this context, it probably introduces the purpose or intended result of the LORD’s previous actions. The purpose/result is that the people of Israel can live in safety.

This conjunction probably refers back to two actions: making the covenant (2:18a) and abolishing war (2:18b). Use a natural way in your language to introduce the purpose or intended result of the LORD’s previous actions.

Here are some other ways to translate this phrase:

so that (New International Version)
-or-
The result will be that (Translation for Translators)

them lie down in safety: This statement tells what happens after the LORD makes the covenant with the animals and abolishes war. To lie down in safety means to sleep without fear of danger. It is a figure of speech that represents a safe life, not only safe sleep. In some languages, it may be clearer to translate this meaning directly and not keep the figure of speech. For example:

and will let my people live in peace and safety (Good News Translation)
-or-
so people can live safely (God’s Word)
-or-
so that they will have no cause to fear

© 2021 by SIL International®
Made available under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License (CC BY-SA) creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0.
All Scripture quotations in this publication, unless otherwise indicated, are from The Holy Bible, Berean Standard Bible.
BSB is produced in cooperation with Bible Hub, Discovery Bible, OpenBible.com, and the Berean Bible Translation Committee.