Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 13:32

But translates the common Hebrew conjunction. In this context it expresses contrast between the fact that only Amnon has been killed and the report (verse 30) that all of David’s sons had been killed.

The son of Shime-ah: or better, “the son of Shammah,” as discussed in verse 3.

The son of … David’s brother: in some languages it will be more natural to speak of “David’s nephew” at this point. However, the meaning of a literal rendering will be more precise, since it will exclude the possibility that Jonadab was the son of David’s sister.

Let not my lord suppose: literally “Do not say, my lord.” Since my lord is a polite way of speaking to the king, it will have to be replaced by an equally polite formula that is also natural in the receptor language. Note that Good News Translation has “Your Majesty.” The rest of this clause may be rendered something like “you shouldn’t believe the report that…” or “don’t accept the hearsay….”

That they have killed: the pronoun subject is indefinite and these words may easily be rendered by a passive construction where such forms are natural. Some may prefer “that someone [or, some people] have killed.” Another possibility is to say “that all your sons have died.”

All the young men the king’s sons: the words the king’s sons are in apposition to all the young men. Compare New Jerusalem Bible, “all the young men, the king’s sons.” Revised English Bible and New American Bible say “all the young princes.” Since Jonadab is speaking directly to David, it will be more natural in most languages to say “all of your sons” instead of all … the king’s sons. Compare verses 23, 27, 29, and 30.

For by the command of Absalom this has been determined: or, more literally, “this has been decided by the command [literally ‘the mouth’] of Absalom.” The difficulty in understanding the meaning of these words lies in the word rendered determined in Revised Standard Version. This word occurs only here in the Old Testament. Some interpreters understand the Hebrew word to be a noun meaning “scowl,” that is, as referring to an expression on the face of Absalom (Revised English Bible and Moffatt). Others understand this to be a rare passive participle of the verb meaning “to determine” (so Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, New American Bible). Probably it is best to understand it as showing Absalom’s determination that was a result of his anger. Some possible alternatives renderings are “Absalom has been promising himself to do this” (New Jerusalem Bible); “Absalom planned this…” (New Century Version); “This has been Absalom’s expressed intention…” (New International Version). Anchor Bible follows a slightly different text meaning “this happened because of Abishalom’s anger….”

From the day he forced his sister Tamar: the first part of this is often translated “ever since….” The pronoun references may have to be clarified in this clause. It was, of course, Amnon who forced Tamar to have sex with him, but the pronoun in the expression his sister almost certainly refers to Absalom. On the word translated forced, compare verses 12, 14, and 22. Moffatt makes the referents quite clear, with “for ever since Amnon violated Absalom’s sister Tamar, there has been a scowl on the face of Absalom.” It is doubtful, however, that Moffatt has correctly translated the word rendered determined in Revised Standard Version.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 14:27

There were born … three sons, and one daughter: in some languages the following restructuring will sound more natural: “Absalom had four children: he had three sons and a daughter. The daughter’s name was Tamar and she was very beautiful.”

According to 18.18 Absalom did not have any sons. Possibly the three sons born to him at this time had died by the time the events described in chapter 18 took place. But there is no information about this in the Bible.

Tamar: this child was obviously named after her aunt, Absalom’s sister, who was raped by her half brother Amnon. She is described as being a beautiful woman, literally “a woman of beautiful appearance,” using the word found in the description of the girl’s aunt in 13.1 and another word that is used in the description of Bathsheba (11.2). The word translated beautiful is also used to describe Absalom in verse 25. But in some languages a different term is required for men and women.

Some manuscripts of the Septuagint have the name “Maacah” here instead of Tamar. The name “Maacah” probably is the result of a scribe’s attempt to make this verse agree with 1 Kgs 15.2, which says that Absalom’s daughter is named “Maacah.” There are different ways in which this seeming contradiction is explained, but here translators should follow the Hebrew text (Tamar), to which Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament gives a {B} rating.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 15:27

Also: once again, this reflects the common Hebrew conjunction, which at this point indicates the continuation of David’s conversation with Zadok. The translation of the verb that follows may easily contain the meaning of the conjunction here. For example, if it is rendered “he continued” or something similar, there is no need for further translation of the conjunction. And in some languages it may be more natural to omit entirely the words that interrupt the flow of what David is saying to Zadok (as in Contemporary English Version).

Look: this does not reflect the Hebrew focusing particle but is rather a form of the verb “to see.” The imperative form of Revised Standard Version follows the understanding of the ancient Greek version, but the Hebrew is actually a rhetorical question and means “Do you see?” (compare Goldman, “Seest thou?”) or “Are you not a seer?” (Revised English Bible). This has also been rendered “Do you understand?” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh) and “you are a good judge of things” (Contemporary English Version). Taking this to mean that he is to act as a spy, Anderson translates “Are you not an observant person?” The understanding of the ancient Greek version is, however, preferable at this point, since the Hebrew rhetorical question affirms that Zadok does understand the situation. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament gives a {B} rating to the Hebrew text. But since the Hebrew is a rhetorical question, this may be translated “You [singular] understand the situation. Go back to the city….”

Go back to the city in peace: the expression “go in peace” was a common Hebrew way of saying goodbye. It was used, for example, by Eli to Hannah (1 Sam 1.17), by Jonathan to David (1 Sam 20.42), and, earlier in this chapter, by David to Absalom (15.9). But the wording is different here, and in this context it probably suggests that they are to slip quietly into the city without drawing attention to themselves, or that they should go back to Jerusalem where they would be safe. Contemporary English Version, for example, translates it “and don’t cause any trouble,” and New Jerusalem Bible “go back quietly into the city.” New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh says “you return to the safety of the city…” (Revised English Bible is similar).

In some languages the direct discourse in this verse will be more naturally rendered as an indirect quotation. A possible model like the following may be helpful: “… went on to tell Zadok that he should take his son Ahimaaz and Jonathan, the son of Abiathar, and return to Jerusalem quietly.”

Revised Standard Version follows those interpreters who change the Hebrew words go back [singular] to the city to “you and Abiathar return to the city” (so also New Revised Standard Version, Revised English Bible, New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible). Hebrew Old Testament Text Project gives an {A} rating to the Hebrew text. But for reasons of translation Revised Standard Version may be followed in the receptor language. The last part of verse 27 in Hebrew says “Go back [singular] … and Ahimaaz your son and Jonathan the son of Abiathar, your [plural] two sons with you [plural].” And verse 29 clearly indicates that Abiathar also returned to Jerusalem.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 17:1

Moreover: the use of this transition word in English may give the impression that the Hebrew has something stronger than the common conjunction, but in reality that is all that is found in the text. The flow of the story, however, may require a transition word or expression showing that the advice quoted in verses 1-3 was something that Ahithophel said to Absalom soon after the events described at the end of chapter 16. But in some languages the absence of any transition marker will serve this purpose, as, for example, in New International Version and New Jerusalem Bible. New American Bible makes the transition by using the verbal expression “went on to say….” Some versions do not even make a paragraph break at this point (Anchor Bible, Anderson). And some (Contemporary English Version) place the new section heading at verse 4 rather than here.

Let me choose …: Ahithophel’s advice here actually includes a particle often used to introduce a petition or plea, but it is left untranslated in many English versions. Some, however, have rendered it “I pray you” (An American Translation), “please” (New American Bible and New American Standard Bible), or “now…” (King James Version and Goldman). New International Version, which is very similar to Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, has “I would choose…” and continues with this kind of verb form throughout the description of the proposed course of action. This sets the stage for the whole recommendation from this point through the end of verse 3. The translations in New International Version and Traduction œcuménique de la Bible imply that Ahithophel is suggesting what Absalom should do. The Hebrew, however, seems to mean that this is what Ahithophel wants to do.

Ahithophel’s plan includes an important element in military strategy, that of swiftness or surprise (tonight). The size of the fighting force proposed (twelve thousand men) is relatively small by comparison with what Hushai later suggests.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 18:6

So: the common conjunction here may be taken as a logical connector and translated as in Revised Standard Version. But several versions take it as being sequential and translate “Then” (New American Bible, Moffatt, An American Translation) or leave it untranslated (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Revised English Bible, New International Version).

Army: literally “people” as in verses 1-5 above. Good News Translation makes the reference more precise by saying “David’s army.” This may be a better model for certain other languages.

The field: in the context of this passage, the word used here refers to unpopulated areas as opposed to areas where there were towns. The remainder of the verse indicates that the region contained a forest.

The battle was fought: in languages where this passive form is not used, it will be much more natural to say “the armies fought each other” or something similar.

The forest of Ephraim: some Greek manuscripts have “the forest of Mahanaim” (New American Bible translates “the forest near Mahanaim”), but it is unlikely that this was the original reading, even though it may be considered more logical. Since the battle was fought on the east side of the Jordan River, as 17.24 and 19.15 make clear, it seems strange that the forest was named after Ephraim, but some scholars feel that the area may have been settled at some time by people from the tribe of Ephraim. According to 1 Maccabees 5.46, there was a village named “Ephron” east of the Jordan River in Gilead. Since this name is spelled similar to “Ephraim,” some interpreters correct the text to read “the forest of Ephron” (Revised English Bible). Hebrew Old Testament Text Project gives no advice on this textual problem and therefore implicitly recommends the reading followed by Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 19:7

Now therefore: more literally “And now.” But there is certainly a logical connection between what Joab has just said and his admonition to David in this verse.

Arise, go: used in series with a second verb as in this case, the verb arise does not necessarily imply getting up from a sitting or prone position. It emphasizes that the person should immediately begin the action of the second verb. Revised English Bible attempts to show this emphasis with “at once.” See the comments on this use of the verb arise in the introduction, “Translating the Books of Samuel,” page 20.

Speak kindly to: literally “speak to the heart of” (so Fox). This is translated by the verb “reassure” in Moffatt and New Jerusalem Bible as well as Good News Translation. Revised English Bible has rendered it “give … some encouragement,” and Contemporary English Version says “thank them for what they did.” The same expression is used in Gen 50.21; Isa 40.2.

Your servants: that is, “your troops,” the people who had fought in the battle against Absalom’s rebellious forces. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh translates “your followers,” while New Jerusalem Bible has “your soldiers.”

I swear by the LORD: this is a way of emphasizing the solemnity of what is about to be said. In some languages it may be better to leave this to the very end of the statement.

Not a man will stay with you: Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente expresses the meaning positively and clearly, although somewhat less emphatically, with “they will abandon you.” The soldiers will immediately cease to be loyal to David if he does not reassure them. In order to retain the emphasis of the original, translators may consider this model: “[before dark] every one of your soldiers will desert you.”

All the evil that has come upon you: or “all the bad things that have ever happened to you.” The misfortunes of David’s life up to this point included the death of his child by Bathsheba (12.15-23), the rape of his daughter Tamar by his son Amnon (13.1-21) and vengeful murder of Amnon by Absalom’s men (13.23-38), and the rebellion and death of Absalom (chapters 15–18). Joab had been closely involved in all these matters, but he was now warning David that things would be much worse if he failed to encourage the troops that had made him victorious over the rebels in his kingdom.

From your youth until now: there may be many different ways of expressing the idea contained in these words. Some English renderings are “in all your life” (Good News Translation) and “since your earliest days” (Revised English Bible). Contemporary English Version restructures the last part of this verse as “You may have had a lot of troubles in the past, but this will be the worst thing that has ever happened to you!”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 19:43

As in the previous verse, the writer focuses on each individual from the tribes of the north and the south. A literal translation of the first part of this verse reads “And answered the man of Israel the man of Judah and said, ‘Ten hands [or, shares] to me in the king, and also in David I more than you [singular]. Why then do you [singular] despise me? And was not my word first for me to bring back my king?’ ”

We have ten shares in the king: literally “Ten hands to me … I have….” The Hebrew noun usually rendered “hand” has a less common usage here in the sense of “a part” or “a share.” The singular pronoun represents all Israel and is legitimately translated by the plural. Interpreters understand this statement in two rather different ways. It may be a very general kind of statement in which the Israelite soldiers are simply saying to their counterparts from Judah that they have ten times more reason to feel that David belongs to them than do the people of Judah. On the other hand it may be a more specific reference to the fact that Israel had ten tribes while Judah counted for only one. New Century Version attempts to make this meaning quite clear by translating “we have ten tribes in the kingdom, so we have more right to David than you do.” It is, however, probably best to translate in the more general sense and then add a footnote explaining that there were ten tribes in Israel as compared with one from Judah, as Traduction œcuménique de la Bible and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente have done.

And in David also we have more than you: in place of these words the Septuagint has “and what is more, I am older than you.” The sense of these words may be that expressed in 1 Chr 5.2, “though Judah became strong…, yet the birthright belonged to Joseph” (from whom the northern tribes of Manasseh and Ephraim descended). This is the reason for the following translations: “and, what is more, we are your elder brothers” (New Jerusalem Bible, similarly Osty-Trinquet); “besides we are the first-born” (Nueva Biblia Española), “and, what is more, we are senior to you” (Revised English Bible). Or the sense may be that the Israelites, that is, the northern tribes, were the ones who took the initiative to restore David (see verses 11-12 and the rest of this verse), so they are “older” in the sense that they were trying to bring David back before the people of Judah joined with them.

Most versions, however, retain the reading of the traditional Hebrew text, which is recommended by Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament with a {C} rating. In this case there is a kind of parallel structure in which David corresponds to the king, and more than you is more or less parallel to the idea of having ten shares. These two lines have been collapsed into a single statement in Good News Translation, and this may be a helpful model for certain other languages to follow.

It will be important in many languages to ensure that readers do not understand the king and David as referring to two different people. This is merely a kind of parallelism where the two terms refer to one individual.

Despise: the verb here gives the idea “take lightly” or “consider of no value” rather than hatred. The Hebrew verb is a causative form of the verb meaning “to be small” or “to be of little account.” Both New Jerusalem Bible and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh translate “why have you slighted us?” And New Century Version says “you ignored us,” transforming the rhetorical question into an affirmative statement.

The question Were we not the first to speak of bringing back our king? is yet another rhetorical question that is really intended as a strong affirmation. The men of Israel were trying to emphasize the fact that they had indeed been the first to bring up the subject of returning King David to Jerusalem. It is therefore possible to translate “We were the ones who spoke first about bringing back our king” or “The first to speak about bringing David back were from our group.”

The words … were fiercer: the verb used here is also found in the story of the controversy between Rehoboam and the northern tribes at Shechem (1 Kgs 12.13). Its root meaning has to do with heaviness or density, but in the context of speaking, the idea is that of harshness. Some commentators observe that the side with the weaker argument is the one that speaks more harshly (Goldman). New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh however, takes this to mean that the people of Judah won the argument, “… prevailed over the men of Israel.” Most, however, understand the verb to mean “to be severe” here. Compare New Jerusalem Bible “The men of Judah’s words were even more intemperate….”

The dissension highlighted in this passage eventually leads to the division into the northern and southern kingdoms.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 21:7

But: the common Hebrew conjunction here marks contrast, in that the sparing of Mephibosheth is contrary to what some readers might expect. However, the reason for this exception is clearly given. It was because of the oath that David and Jonathan had taken (see 1 Sam 18.1-4; 20.14-17, 42).

The order of this verse has been altered by Good News Translation. Translators will have to consider the different possibilities and decide which one sounds more natural in their own language. Translators should also be consistent here in the name used for Mephibosheth, using the same form that is used earlier in this writing.

The verb translated spared sometimes means “to be sorry [for],” as it does in 2 Sam 12.4, where Revised Standard Version renders it “he was unwilling.” But another meaning of this verb is “to spare” or “to save back.” This is the meaning here, as also in 1 Sam 15.15, where it is said that the people “spared” the best of the animals.

Because of the oath of the LORD which was between them: the word used here for oath is not the same as found in 1 Sam 18.3, which has the more common term for “covenant” (Revised Standard Version) or “agreement.” But David considered his promise to Jonathan divinely sanctioned. This whole expression may be more naturally translated “because they had made a promise to each other before the LORD” or “because of the promise he had made to Jonathan in the LORD’s name” (New Century Version).

The repetition of the idea found in which was between them and between David and Jonathan … is really unnecessary, and the two may be reduced to a single statement in most languages, since the meaning of the pronoun them is clarified in the second statement.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .