If he withdraws into a city: the significance of retreating into a city is that cities were distinguished from villages by the fact that they were surrounded by fortifications. For this reason Contemporary English Version translates “a walled town.” In some languages this may be translated “if he goes inside the walls of a city….”
We shall drag it into the valley: while it was not an easy task, one way to defeat an army protected within a city was to destroy its walls as in the story of Jericho (Josh 6.20). On some occasions ropes were used to throw large hooks up to attach to the walls so that they could be pulled down. The image provided by Hushai is an exaggerated one, but he tries to give the impression of total defeat to the point that the city walls are dragged down into the surrounding valley.
Pebble: the most frequent meaning of the noun so translated in Revised Standard Version is “bundle” or “bag.” But it is also used for a kernel of grain and for a small stone. In this context it is a part of the exaggeration used by Hushai to convince Absalom of the wisdom of his proposal. In languages where it is essential to specify the size of stones, it is unnecessary to focus on its smallness. Adequate translations are “a piece of it” (New International Version) or simply “a stone” (Revised English Bible).
Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .
