Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 12:31

This verse has been understood by some as meaning that David tortured the Ammonites with the tools mentioned in this verse. King James Version, for example, says that David “put them under saws, and under harrows of iron, and under axes of iron, and made them pass through the brickkiln.” Most interpreters, however, understand this to mean that David forced them to do different kinds of work, using these tools for that work (so Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, and nearly all modern translations including New King James Version ).

The people who were in it: in this case people probably refers to the general population of Ammonites who had been living in the city of Rabbah, and not just the soldiers.

Set them to labor with saws: literally “set with saws….” Forced labor of a defeated army was not unusual in Old Testament times (see Deut 20.11; Josh 16.10; Judges 1.28-35). The words with saws have parallels in 1 Chr 20.2 and in the construction of the Temple in 1 Kgs 7.9. Contemporary English Version understands this phrase as meaning “tear down the city walls.” This is supported by Anderson’s commentary and Anchor Bible, though Anchor Bible is not based on the Masoretic Text at this point. But the great majority of sources prefer the idea expressed in Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation. The instrument involved here was used to cut stone as well as wood. Many languages will have to use a borrowed word for “saw.”

Iron picks: the word for picks occurs only here and in the parallel in 1 Chr 20.3. It comes from a verb meaning “to cut” and refers to a “cutting thing” or “sharp instrument.” The same word is used for “cuts of milk” or “cheeses” in 1 Sam 17.18, but this should not affect the translations here.

Iron axes: the word translated axes is found only here in all the Old Testament, but most scholars are agreed that it refers to a blade or cutting instrument. In some languages the picks and axes may have to be translated by a single term in the receptor language, since there may not be equivalents to distinguish the two terms. However, many languages do have different words for “hoes” and “axes,” and these may be used here.

Made them toil at the brickkilns: these six words in English translate three Hebrew words. Exactly what the correct Hebrew text is and what it may mean have been considerably debated. First, the verb in the Masoretic Text is “caused them to pass through.” The verb made them toil is a proposed correction to the Masoretic Text and requires only a very small change in spelling from the verb “made them pass through.” It must be noted, however, that no Hebrew manuscripts read “made them toil.”

Secondly, the meaning of the noun translated brickkilns must be established. The consonants of this noun as written in the Masoretic Text are mlkn. Some have understood this to be equivalent to the name “Milcom” in verse 30. The margin of the Masoretic Text, however, suggests that the correct Hebrew noun should read mlbn, which has been taken to mean either “brickkiln” or “brick-mold.”

The Masoretic Text may be read “made them pass through Milcom,” that is, made the Ammonite people pass through the fires where they offered their own children as sacrifices to the god Molek, who is here called Milcom.

But if the noun mlbn is read, then the sense seems to be that the people were burned where they cooked the bricks that they made, or that their bodies were chopped up and poured along with the clay into the brick molds. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament suggests that the reading “made them toil in the brickkilns” may well be original, but since no Hebrew manuscript reads “made them toil,” Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament says the text “made them pass through the brickkilns” should be followed (so Fox).

Despite the lack of manuscript evidence, this Handbook recommends the correction of the Masoretic Text found in Revised Standard Version and in most modern translations. The best rendering may be that of Moffatt, “made them labor at brick-making.”

All the cities of the Ammonites: this refers to all the other places where Ammonite people lived. Some of these places were considerably smaller than Rabbah. For this reason Good News Translation says “all the other towns of Ammon.”

All the people: this refers to the Israelite army.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 13:33

Now therefore: these words serve as a transition from the logical explanation of the reason for what had happened to a repetition of the plea not to accept the rumor that all David’s sons had been killed. Some other possible renderings are “So” (New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh as well as Good News Translation) or “Therefore” (Bible en français courant and Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible). But note that several versions leave it untranslated (New International Version, Contemporary English Version).

My lord the king: in some cases this polite formula will be adequately translated by “please, sir….”

Take it to heart: see the comments on verse 20 above. And compare also Isa 42.25, where the same expression occurs. The context here shows that this means “don’t believe it” and does not mean simply “don’t worry about the report” (Contemporary English Version).

All the king’s sons: this expression once again refers to David’s sons. Since the speaker is addressing David directly, it will again be better in most languages to say “all your sons.” Compare verses 23, 27, 29, 30, and 32.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 14:28

So: the common Hebrew conjunction need not necessarily be translated here if a new paragraph is begun at this point.

Two full years: according to 13.23, this is the same period of time that Absalom waited before taking revenge on Amnon for what he had done to his sister, Tamar.

Without coming into the king’s presence: or more literally “and he did not see the face of the king,” as in verse 24. Regarding the technical nature of this idiom, see the comments on 3.13. This phrase may be translated in some languages independently, beginning with a conjunction marking contrast, “but he did not see the king” or “however, he was not allowed to see King David.” The technical aspect of this expression is kept in Nueva Biblia Española, “without being received [in court] by the king.” Some translators may feel it necessary to remind their readers of what the original readers knew very well—that David was Absalom’s father. Contemporary English Version has “without seeing his father.” Compare verse 24.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 15:28

See: once again this is not the focusing particle but the imperative form of the verb “to see”—the same verb as is used in the beginning of the quotation in the previous verse.

Fords of the wilderness: this is what the Hebrew text literally says, but there is a marginal note that what should be read is “plains of the wilderness” (Goldman). Most versions, however, accept the idea fords, since a more specific location was necessary for the passing on of information gathered by the spy network. A ford is a place where people and animals are able to cross a stream or river. The best translation in some languages will be a phrase like “the places where people cross the river on the road to the wilderness.”

Until word comes from you: since it is not natural in many languages to make word the subject of a verb like comes, it will be better to say something like “until you send word [a message]” or “until someone comes with information from you.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 17:2

The future tense verb forms in this passage may be unnatural in some languages, since they may suggest that a decision has already been made. Ahithophel is rather requesting permission to do something, as indicated by the initial words Let me … and the often untranslated particle mentioned in the previous verse. So some translators may find it more natural at the beginning of each new sentence to say “I propose to…,” “I would like to…,” or possibly “if you agree, I will….”

Come upon him: this expression means more in this context than simply “find him.” Here it carries the idea “overtake him” (Knox and Revised English Bible) or possibly “take him by surprise” (Bible en français courant). The verb may also be rendered “attack him” as in Good News Translation.

Discouraged: literally “weak of hands” (Fox says “slack of hands”). But most versions take this as figurative language for being “dispirited” (New Jerusalem Bible and Revised English Bible) or “disheartened” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh).

Throw him into a panic: a causative form of a verb meaning “tremble” or “shudder” is used here. The meaning is to “make him to be afraid” or “cause him to fear.” New Century Version seems a little weak, with “frighten him.” Traduction œcuménique de la Bible renders this verb “terrorize,” while New American Bible and Anderson have “cause him to panic.”

Strike down: the verb used here is a rather general one meaning “hit” or “beat,” but in this context the sense is clearly that of killing. The verb “kill” is used in Revised English Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, and Contemporary English Version as well as Good News Translation.

Ahithophel’s use of the term the king for David does not mean that he does not acknowledge Absalom as king. But since this may cause a possible misunderstanding in some languages, it may be better to refer to him in some other way. Contemporary English Version uses his name “David.” Others may prefer to say something like “their king” (referring to those who still followed David), “the one who claims to be king,” or “the man who used to be king.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 18:7

The statement containing the passive verb, were defeated, may easily be turned around if the passive causes problems: “David’s army defeated the Israelites….”

The servants of David: in the present context this expression refers to all those who were loyal to David—including officers and regular fighting men.

The slaughter there was great …: the structure of the last part of this verse is awkward and will probably need to be arranged differently in other languages. Some may prefer the following model: “That day twenty thousand soldiers died in the battle. The killing was very great.” The word translated slaughter is rendered “casualties” (New International Version and New American Bible) and “loss of life” (Revised English Bible). The rendering of Good News Translation as “defeat” may therefore be misleading. The same Hebrew term is rendered “plague” in 1 Sam 6.4 and “slaughter” in 1 Sam 4.17 and 2 Sam 17.9.

Twenty thousand men: it is uncertain whether this refers to the total number of soldiers on both sides or just the enemies of David. The parallelism between the two parts of this verse suggests that the figure twenty thousand refers to the enemies only, that is, to the Israelite soldiers. Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch makes this interpretation explicit, with “20,000 Israelites met their death.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 19:8

Then: the common conjunction here merely serves to join the description of King David’s action to the preceding account.

Arose, and took his seat: this may sound very strange if the implied action of David’s going to the gate is not made explicit in the receptor language. It will be prudent to add something like “went to the city gate” between the two verbs describing his getting up and his sitting down. The words took his seat translate a verb meaning “he sat down.” The English should not be misunderstood to mean that he carried a chair or some other kind of seat to the gate. The gate refers, of course, to the city gate (see the comments on 18.24).

The people were all told: literally “all the people were told, saying.” The passive construction may be translated actively as “all the people learned [or, heard]” or possibly “the news spread to all the people.” And the actual news, which is given as a direct quotation in Revised Standard Version, may sound more natural if it is transformed into an indirect statement. New Century Version renders this whole verse as “The news spread that the king was sitting at the gate. So everyone came to see him there.” Here, as often in 1 and 2 Samuel, the people refers specifically to “the army” (Revised English Bible), or “the soldiers” (Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente). All the people may be translated “the whole army” (New Jerusalem Bible).

The last part of this verse is included in the next section. So the new section heading comes in the middle of this verse in Good News Translation. Other versions and commentaries that divide the text similarly are New American Bible, New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, Contemporary English Version, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, Anchor Bible, and Anderson.

Now is appropriately translated as “Meanwhile” by Revised English Bible as well as Good News Translation. What follows is really a repetition of information given in 18.17, and the story is resumed here from that point and a different aspect taken up.

In this context the term Israel is again used to refer to the forces that had been loyal to Absalom. Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente translates Israel as “the followers of Absalom,” and such a translation may avoid any possible confusion, since those who followed David were also Israelites.

As in 18.17 the word home translates the Hebrew word “tent,” but “home” is an appropriate translation in this context.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 20:1

Now there happened to be: the Hebrew verb translated by this expression may have the meaning “Now there was summoned…,” but most modern versions take it as meaning that Bichri’s presence at the time was a chance circumstance. The same verb is used of the chance encounters described in 1.6 and 18.9.

There: the adverb of location here refers to the assembly of the army of Judah and the army of Israel at Gilgal after the crossing of the Jordan, where the argument in 19.40-43 took place. It was a perfect setting for an agitator to begin making trouble.

A worthless fellow: the term so translated seems to be a favorite of the writer of the books of Samuel. It occurs at least ten times and is translated in a variety of ways according to the context: “base woman” (1 Sam 1.16), “worthless men” (1 Sam 2.12), “ill-natured fellow” (1 Sam 25.25), and “godless men” (2 Sam 23.6). In this context it has been rendered “rebellious individual” (New American Bible), “base rascal” (An American Translation), “wretch” (Moffatt), “scoundrel” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Revised English Bible, and New Jerusalem Bible), and “troublemaker” (New International Version, New Century Version, and Contemporary English Version). See the comments at 1 Sam 1.16.

Bichri: this name is transliterated “Bikri” in Good News Translation and “Bicri” in New International Version, but these forms are all based on the same Hebrew text. Some scholars identify this name with “Becorath” in 1 Sam 9.1, which would make Sheba close kin to Saul, but this identification is far from certain and should be confined to a footnote if used at all. Others think that the spelling of the name Bichri indicates that this is the name of a clan rather than an individual. In any case it is clear from the text that the opposition to David does come from the tribe of Saul, since Sheba is described as a Benjaminite.

Blew the trumpet: in Hebrew grammar, when reference is made to an object that is used for some specific purpose, the definite article is frequently used. This is a different use of the article from that in English, and it does not necessarily mean that the writer is referring to a particular or specific object, in this instance a particular ram’s horn. A ram’s horn was often used to call together troops for combat and also to disperse troops at the end of a battle (as in verse 22; see 2.28).

We have no portion in David: the word for portion here is not the same as “shares” in 19.44, but it may be intended to contrast with the expression used there. The word rendered portion comes from a root meaning “to divide” and may be translated “a share” (New Revised Standard Version and New Jerusalem Bible). The word translated inheritance refers to that property and goods which a person or family inherits when the owner dies. The point of the statement was to deny any relationship between David and the people of Israel. The expression that follows, we have no inheritance in the son of Jesse, constitutes a parallel statement that is really saying the same thing. No portion and no inheritance have the same essential meaning, and David and the son of Jesse refer to the same person. Translators should ensure that readers do not think that two different things are being referred to by these two expressions. If necessary they may be translated as a single unit, using something like “We have nothing to do with David, the son of Jesse. We won’t join with him.”

Every man to his tents: by using these words, Sheba is encouraging those who would follow him to abandon David and go back home. A literal rendering of this expression is likely to be misunderstood in a number of languages. It may be better translated simply “Go back home!” This appeal recalls the similar expressions in 19.8 and 1 Sam 13.2, which are descriptions in the past tense.

O Israel: in most languages this vocative form, if used at all, will probably come at the beginning of the sentence rather than at the end. Others will be more likely to use a form of address such as “People of Israel…,” but this also is more likely to come at the beginning of the appeal rather than at the end. Since Israel here clearly refers to the northern tribes and does not include the Israelites from the southern tribe of Judah, it may be helpful to make this explicit: “People from northern Israel….”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .