Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 7:5

Go: in contrast with the use of this same verb in verse 3, here Nathan is actually told to go to David in order to pass a message on to him.

The formula Thus says the LORD is used hundreds of times in the Old Testament to introduce a solemn message directly from God—especially in the prophets. It is more than a mere introduction to an ordinary quotation. The Hebrew verb form here is the perfect, which is often translated by the English past tense, and in some languages it will be more natural to retain this form. Some other possible models are “These are the words of the LORD” (New English Bible) or “Listen to what the LORD has said.” While this is the first occurrence of the formula in 2 Samuel, it is found in 1 Sam 2.27; 10.18; 15.2.

The force of the question Would you build me a house to dwell in? is not often communicated by a question in other languages. The sentence contains two emphatic pronouns that are important to the meaning. The first, you, focuses attention on David and indicates that, although the plan to build a temple may be acceptable, he should not be the person to do it. Following English writing style, Fox places the pronoun “you” in italic font in order to show the emphatic use of the Hebrew pronoun. But the use of italics is not recommended as a way of conveying meaning in translation, since they are meaningful only to the reader and not to the hearer of Scripture.

There is a play on words in this passage. The word house is used here of the temple that David had envisioned. But in verse 11 the same word refers to the dynasty that God will establish for David’s family. So the idea of the whole passage is something like this: “YOU are not going to build a house [temple] for ME. I am going to build a house [dynasty] for YOU.” So in this verse it will probably be preferable to avoid the question format and to say something like “You are not the person to build a house for me to live in” (New Century Version). Or, if the question can be naturally retained, translators may say “Are you the right person to build a house for me?” And in some languages, when such a question is used, it is appropriate to give the implied answer immediately. In a few cases translators may prefer to change the Yes/No question to a rhetorical one beginning with “Why,” as in Contemporary English Version, “Why should you build a temple for me?”

Since this verse contains a quotation within another quotation, it will be better in some languages to change one of the two to indirect speech. One way of doing this is to follow the previous verse by saying:

• … and told him to go and tell God’s servant David this message from the LORD: “Do you think you are the one to build a temple for me to live in? No….”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 8:10

Toi: it may be unnecessary in many languages to repeat the name at this point. As in Good News Translation, the pronoun may be sufficient.

His son Joram: some textual evidence has “Hadoram his son” at this point, and this is adopted by New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, Moffatt, and An American Translation. Joram means “Yahweh is exalted,” while Hadoram (probably a shortened form of Hadadram), which is found in 1 Chr 18.10, signifies “Hadad is exalted” (concerning the name “Hadad,” see the comments on the name “Hadadezer” in verse 3). It is unlikely that the original name of this non-Israelite was in praise of Yahweh, so Hadoram was probably original. It may have been changed out of gratitude for the Israelite victory over Hadadezer and the subsequent protection provided by the Israelites. But the translation here should be based on the best available textual evidence, which has Joram. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament gives a {C} rating to the Masoretic Text and recommend that the name Joram be used.

Congratulate: this verb may have to be rendered “praise” or “honor” in some languages. The Hebrew word is, in fact, the one usually translated “bless,” as indicated in King James Version and New American Standard Bible. Another possible translation is “transmit greetings” (La Bible du Semeur).

Articles: the Hebrew term used here is a very general one that may refer to anything man-made. It sometimes refers to containers of liquid (Ruth 2.9), or figures (1 Sam 6.8), or weapons (1 Sam 8.12). Probably in this context it refers to a number of different types of objects. So it will be advisable to use a general term, such as “objects,” “items,” or “things” in the receptor language.

Of silver, of gold, and of bronze: these three metals were the material used to make the objects. The most probable meaning is that some objects were made of one metal and others of another—not that each object was made of a combination of the three metals. As indicated in the comments on 8.8 and 1 Sam 17.5, the word rendered bronze may also be “copper.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 10:11

He said: this pronoun refers to Joab, who was the subject of the verbs in verses 9-10. In some languages it will be necessary to state clearly to whom he was speaking, as in New International Version, Contemporary English Version, and New American Bible, as well as Good News Translation.

Too strong for me … for you: that is, if the enemy forces started to take the upper hand in the battle on either front, the stronger of the two Israelite forces would send some of its men to help the weaker force. In some languages it will be more natural to say “If the Syrians begin to win the fight” or, turning the sentence around, “If we start losing ground to the Syrians.” Similar language will apply to the last part, saying what to do if the Ammonites succeed.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 11:24

If the option of an indirect quotation was chosen in the previous verse, this verse should also be made indirect. This may mean adding something like “The messenger continued by telling David that….”

Then: the Hebrew conjunction is used here to indicate action that followed previous action. La Bible du Semeur says “at that moment…,” giving prominence to the time element. Revised English Bible focuses on the location and translates “There,” and this may be a good model for other languages.

The archers: while some languages may have special terms for archers, others will have to use a longer expression meaning “the men who shoot arrows.” It should be made clear that the archers in question are enemy (Ammonite) archers.

Your servants … the king’s servants … your servant: as in previous verses the word “servant” in each of these cases refers to army officers and should be so translated in order to avoid giving the impression that domestic servants are intended. Also, when the messenger says the king’s servants while speaking directly to the king, he is showing respect. Translators should try to discover how this kind of respect is communicated in their own language and use these forms of respect in their translation rather than imitating the Hebrew indirect reference.

Is dead also: that is, “was among those who were killed” or “also died in the battle.”

Some textual experts feel that the original version of verses 23 and 24 included material that is now absent from the traditional Hebrew text. Translators are encouraged to follow the Masoretic Text here. A detailed discussion may be found in Anchor Bible.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 12:31

This verse has been understood by some as meaning that David tortured the Ammonites with the tools mentioned in this verse. King James Version, for example, says that David “put them under saws, and under harrows of iron, and under axes of iron, and made them pass through the brickkiln.” Most interpreters, however, understand this to mean that David forced them to do different kinds of work, using these tools for that work (so Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, and nearly all modern translations including New King James Version ).

The people who were in it: in this case people probably refers to the general population of Ammonites who had been living in the city of Rabbah, and not just the soldiers.

Set them to labor with saws: literally “set with saws….” Forced labor of a defeated army was not unusual in Old Testament times (see Deut 20.11; Josh 16.10; Judges 1.28-35). The words with saws have parallels in 1 Chr 20.2 and in the construction of the Temple in 1 Kgs 7.9. Contemporary English Version understands this phrase as meaning “tear down the city walls.” This is supported by Anderson’s commentary and Anchor Bible, though Anchor Bible is not based on the Masoretic Text at this point. But the great majority of sources prefer the idea expressed in Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation. The instrument involved here was used to cut stone as well as wood. Many languages will have to use a borrowed word for “saw.”

Iron picks: the word for picks occurs only here and in the parallel in 1 Chr 20.3. It comes from a verb meaning “to cut” and refers to a “cutting thing” or “sharp instrument.” The same word is used for “cuts of milk” or “cheeses” in 1 Sam 17.18, but this should not affect the translations here.

Iron axes: the word translated axes is found only here in all the Old Testament, but most scholars are agreed that it refers to a blade or cutting instrument. In some languages the picks and axes may have to be translated by a single term in the receptor language, since there may not be equivalents to distinguish the two terms. However, many languages do have different words for “hoes” and “axes,” and these may be used here.

Made them toil at the brickkilns: these six words in English translate three Hebrew words. Exactly what the correct Hebrew text is and what it may mean have been considerably debated. First, the verb in the Masoretic Text is “caused them to pass through.” The verb made them toil is a proposed correction to the Masoretic Text and requires only a very small change in spelling from the verb “made them pass through.” It must be noted, however, that no Hebrew manuscripts read “made them toil.”

Secondly, the meaning of the noun translated brickkilns must be established. The consonants of this noun as written in the Masoretic Text are mlkn. Some have understood this to be equivalent to the name “Milcom” in verse 30. The margin of the Masoretic Text, however, suggests that the correct Hebrew noun should read mlbn, which has been taken to mean either “brickkiln” or “brick-mold.”

The Masoretic Text may be read “made them pass through Milcom,” that is, made the Ammonite people pass through the fires where they offered their own children as sacrifices to the god Molek, who is here called Milcom.

But if the noun mlbn is read, then the sense seems to be that the people were burned where they cooked the bricks that they made, or that their bodies were chopped up and poured along with the clay into the brick molds. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament suggests that the reading “made them toil in the brickkilns” may well be original, but since no Hebrew manuscript reads “made them toil,” Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament says the text “made them pass through the brickkilns” should be followed (so Fox).

Despite the lack of manuscript evidence, this Handbook recommends the correction of the Masoretic Text found in Revised Standard Version and in most modern translations. The best rendering may be that of Moffatt, “made them labor at brick-making.”

All the cities of the Ammonites: this refers to all the other places where Ammonite people lived. Some of these places were considerably smaller than Rabbah. For this reason Good News Translation says “all the other towns of Ammon.”

All the people: this refers to the Israelite army.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 13:33

Now therefore: these words serve as a transition from the logical explanation of the reason for what had happened to a repetition of the plea not to accept the rumor that all David’s sons had been killed. Some other possible renderings are “So” (New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh as well as Good News Translation) or “Therefore” (Bible en français courant and Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible). But note that several versions leave it untranslated (New International Version, Contemporary English Version).

My lord the king: in some cases this polite formula will be adequately translated by “please, sir….”

Take it to heart: see the comments on verse 20 above. And compare also Isa 42.25, where the same expression occurs. The context here shows that this means “don’t believe it” and does not mean simply “don’t worry about the report” (Contemporary English Version).

All the king’s sons: this expression once again refers to David’s sons. Since the speaker is addressing David directly, it will again be better in most languages to say “all your sons.” Compare verses 23, 27, 29, 30, and 32.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 14:28

So: the common Hebrew conjunction need not necessarily be translated here if a new paragraph is begun at this point.

Two full years: according to 13.23, this is the same period of time that Absalom waited before taking revenge on Amnon for what he had done to his sister, Tamar.

Without coming into the king’s presence: or more literally “and he did not see the face of the king,” as in verse 24. Regarding the technical nature of this idiom, see the comments on 3.13. This phrase may be translated in some languages independently, beginning with a conjunction marking contrast, “but he did not see the king” or “however, he was not allowed to see King David.” The technical aspect of this expression is kept in Nueva Biblia Española, “without being received [in court] by the king.” Some translators may feel it necessary to remind their readers of what the original readers knew very well—that David was Absalom’s father. Contemporary English Version has “without seeing his father.” Compare verse 24.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 15:28

See: once again this is not the focusing particle but the imperative form of the verb “to see”—the same verb as is used in the beginning of the quotation in the previous verse.

Fords of the wilderness: this is what the Hebrew text literally says, but there is a marginal note that what should be read is “plains of the wilderness” (Goldman). Most versions, however, accept the idea fords, since a more specific location was necessary for the passing on of information gathered by the spy network. A ford is a place where people and animals are able to cross a stream or river. The best translation in some languages will be a phrase like “the places where people cross the river on the road to the wilderness.”

Until word comes from you: since it is not natural in many languages to make word the subject of a verb like comes, it will be better to say something like “until you send word [a message]” or “until someone comes with information from you.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .