Translation commentary on Nehemiah 6:16

And when: The Hebrew text introduces the next part of the narrative with the connective conjunction and the verb “to be,” followed by the temporal marker when (also Neh 7.1; see Neh 1.1). The punctuation in MT links verses 14 and 15 to each other, and begins a major new unit here at verse 16. Even though this is not marked by a section heading, it is important for translators to indicate the new episode by appropriate discourse marking.

All our enemies heard of it, all the nations round about us were afraid: Our enemies were the Gentile provincial leaders, and all the nations round about us were in the provinces next to Judah. When the opponents and the neighboring peoples of the Jews heard that the work on the wall had been completed, they were amazed at this accomplishment. It is said that they were afraid. This is the reading of Hebrew Old Testament Text Project (A rating), the Septuagint, and the Vulgate. But the Hebrew word for afraid may be derived from a different root and mean “saw,” as some versions have translated (New American Standard Bible, Revised English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible). However, there is a theme of causing fright and of intimidation in the chapter. In verses 9, 13, and 14 the enemies wanted to frighten Nehemiah, but in verse 16 it is the enemies who were afraid. Therefore many versions have translated “were afraid” as Revised Standard Version has done (so New International Version, Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible, Bible en français courant). The translator should follow the Revised Standard Version rendering.

Fell greatly in their own esteem is literally “they fell greatly in their own eyes.” What is meant by this clause is unclear. The phrase “fall in one’s eyes” is not found elsewhere in the Old Testament, so it is only assumed that it refers to someone’s esteem. Likewise, their could refer either to the enemies or to the nations. If it refers to the enemies, it could mean that they had been humbled by the accomplishment of rebuilding the wall. If it refers to the nations, it could mean that Tobiah and Sanballat had lost status in their view. It has been suggested that there was a scribal mistake of one letter in the Hebrew word for fell, which should read “was wonderful” (so Revised English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible). However, the Hebrew text as we have it is supported by Hebrew Old Testament Text Project (A rating), the Septuagint, and the Vulgate. It is followed by Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, New International Version, Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version and others and should be followed by translators. In spite of the lack of any other occurrence of the phrase, “fall in one’s eyes,” it is generally understood to refer to a humbling of the enemies here. It is translated in various ways, for example, “all the surrounding nations … lost their self-confidence” (New International Version), “all the nations around us … were humiliated in their own eyes” (Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible), and “our enemies … felt themselves profoundly humiliated” (Bible en français courant).

They perceived: This is followed by a non-quotation in which Nehemiah summarizes what the opponents and neighbors “realised” (New Jerusalem Bible) or “recognized” (Revised English Bible, Contemporary Chinese Bible).

This work had been accomplished with the help of our God: In English had been accomplished is a pluperfect verb; that is, the work of the Jews was completed before the recognition of that fact by the people. The actual sequence of events needs to be clearly shown in the translation.

With the help of our God is literally “from our God.” The Hebrew does not indicate how God helped his people, only that the work had been accomplished “from our God.” The Hebrew preposition min (“from, by”) has our God as its object. Amplified Bible translates “this work was done by our God” (also Darby). Nouvelle Bible Segond also gives the credit to God in its rendering: “this work had been accomplished thanks to our God.” Most English versions understand an implied object for the preposition min. This might be help (Revised Standard Version) or “will” (Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible “through the will of our God”). In some languages it will be more natural to restructure the prepositional phrase as a verbal phrase similarly to Contemporary English Version: “our God had helped us rebuild the wall.”

For our God, see the comment at Ezra 4.3.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 8:11

The Levites stilled all the people: The Levites had the two tasks of quieting or calming the people and of instructing them. In some languages a causative form of the verb may be used; for example, “the Levites caused all the people to be still.”

Be quiet translates a verb form that is derived from the onomatopoeic interjection has in Hebrew. This Hebrew word expresses a meaning similar to “Hush” in English as it is translated in New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh and New Living Translation. In French Chouraqui says “Chut!” The meaning is to tell the people to be quiet and to refrain from weeping. Bible en français courant translates “Be calm,” while bcc says “Not so much noise!” Many languages have an equivalent onomatopoeic form that may be used. Other languages will use an ideophone for expressing quietness or silence. However, care must be taken not to overtranslate by using a form that expresses the meaning of harshness or rudeness or that is otherwise inappropriate for the serious nature of Nehemiah’s historical account.

Do not be grieved: Contemporary English Version again emphasizes the theme of sadness with “so don’t worry or mourn!”

Good News Translation restructures this verse to be a non-quotation, but most translations retain the direct quotation of the Levites’ instructions as in the Hebrew text. In most languages the form of direct quotation will more accurately convey the emphasis of the Levites’ commands to the people.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 9:29

Thou didst warn them in order to turn them back to thy law: Revised Standard Version gives a fairly literal translation of this complex sentence. The text here does not specify how God warned his people. The words of a message are only implied, and a messenger or messengers can only be assumed. This information is given in the following verse and should not be made explicit here. The purpose of God’s warning to his people was to cause them to return to his law (torah in Hebrew). Turn them back to thy law means that they should once again obey God’s commands. Good News Translation simplifies the structure of this sentence and interprets torah in its basic sense of “instructions” or “teachings.” This entire verse in Hebrew is syntactically complex and may require restructuring in the receptor language as Good News Translation and Bible en français courant have done. The translator should not simplify and condense the verse as much as Contemporary English Version has done.

Yet they acted presumptuously: God’s warning was meant to help them. The Hebrew begins this clause with the connective conjunction followed by the independent pronoun they to indicate that the warning will not be heeded. Revised Standard Version therefore translates with the conjunction Yet. Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible conveys the emphasis of the Hebrew pronoun in French as follows: “but they, they acted with stubbornness” (also Bible en français courant). In English a possible rendering is “But as for them, they….”

Acted presumptuously is repeated for the third time in this chapter (see verses 10 and 16).

Did not obey thy commandments: See verse 16 above.

Sinned against thy ordinances: For sinned see Neh 1.6, and for ordinances (mishpat in Hebrew), see Neh 1.7. The verbal expression “to sin against” means “to disobey”; that is, the people of Israel broke God’s laws.

By observance of which a man shall live: In Hebrew this is literally “which a man obeys and he will live by them.” This reflects the concept in Deuteronomy that through keeping God’s commands, a person finds a long and fulfilling life (Deut 5.33; 8.1; 30.16). This concept is also recorded almost identically in Lev 18.5b, which in Hebrew is literally “by which man finds life if he keeps them.” In some languages translators will need to make it clear that the quality of life will be good; for example, “if people obey the commands of God they will have good lives” or “… they will live good lives.” Although the Hebrew text is translated by Revised Standard Version as a man, the meaning here includes men and women generally and should be translated accordingly (so Bible en français courant, New Revised Standard Version, Revised English Bible).

Turned a stubborn shoulder and stiffened their neck and would not obey: In Hebrew turned a stubborn shoulder is literally “they turned a withdrawing shoulder.” Both this metaphor and the metaphor stiffened their neck (see verse 16 above) are taken from the behavior of an ox when it refuses to let a yoke be put on its shoulders. The two expressions both express stubbornness. Some translators may retain the Hebrew metaphors as many translations have done. Others may convey the meaning by using a similar expression, for example, “they raised their shoulders [in stubbornness],” but this loses the picture of the ox. Still others may interpret the meaning explicitly without the metaphors. Thus, Bible en français courant translates with two adjectives, “obstinate and rebellious.” Good News Translation keeps a metaphor for the first expression, but not for the second one: “Hard-headed and stubborn.” The three-stage description here culminates in the people’s refusal to obey God, as is apparent in the translation of New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh: “They turned a defiant shoulder, stiffened their neck, and would not obey.”

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 11:10

The list of priests is given next after the list of the leaders. Of the priests is rendered in the Good News Translation as a subheading: “Priests.” The list is inconsistent in its form. The three names cited in this verse are cited in the same order in 1 Chr 9.10, but there they are three separate individuals instead of two as here. The three men in 1 Chronicles could not be the same people in the time of Nehemiah. There the second name is spelled “Jehoiarib.” Some commentators suggest that Jachin is a mistake for “son of” in Hebrew and that the whole list in verses 10-11 is the ancestry of Jedaiah. This is the interpretation of Revised English Bible, which also changes “their brethren” in verse 12 to “his brethren.” Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation follow the Hebrew text for this verse. Hebrew Old Testament Text Project gives an A rating to this text with all its difficulties, and this is recommended to translators. Contemporary English Version tries to solve the problem of the genealogy by saying that Jedaiah “was the son of Joiarib and the uncle of Jachin,” but this is not recommended to translators.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 12:28

The sons of the singers are the Levites who have a special function as singers and composers. Some Psalms were written by Levites, for example Psa 50. Sons of is a Hebrew expression used here to designate the members of a guild or professional class (see Neh 3.8). This is translated as “companies” in New Revised Standard Version (also New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), and translators should find a natural expression in their own language.

The Levites did not have any tribal territory so they lived in unwalled towns that they had built on the fringes of settled lands. They gathered together from these towns; that is, they came together to Jerusalem for this occasion from the different places where they lived. The Hebrew connective conjunction comes before each occurrence of from in verses 28 and 29, indicating “both from … and from.” This produces two pairs of this pattern, first in this verse with “both from the region around Jerusalem and from…,” and in the following verse with “both from Bethgilgal and from….” Translators should try to find an equivalent balanced structure in the receptor language.

The circuit round Jerusalem refers to the district around the city (so Osty-Trinquet). This is the area adjacent to and surrounding Jerusalem in the form of a circle (see Neh 3.22). New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh says “the environs of Jerusalem.” “The area around Jerusalem” (so Good News Translation) may be a suitable model.

The villages of the Netophathites refers to the settlements around Netophah, a Judean hill village 13 kilometers (8 miles) southeast of Jerusalem. Netophathites refers to the dwellers of Netophah. It does not refer to a distinct people.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 13:19

When it began to be dark at the gates of Jerusalem before the sabbath: Nehemiah himself took action to stop commercial trade on the Sabbath. This verse begins with the Hebrew construction with the connective conjunction and the verb “to be.” This construction is a discourse marker that signals new action in the narrative (see Neh 1.1). Nehemiah ordered the doors of the city to be shut during the Sabbath. The meaning of the phrase began to be dark is not clear. Some commentators have understood the Hebrew to refer to “shadows,” for example, “When evening shadows fell on the gates…” as in New International Version (similarly New Jerusalem Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). But that meaning is not well established. Others have proposed the meaning “cleared” based on the Syriac translation “to clean, purge,” as in Revised English Bible: “When the entrances to Jerusalem had been cleared….” Because the Sabbath began at sunset, the phrase must refer to that time of day. Although this is Friday evening, translators should not use Friday here because of possible connotations for readers today that would be anachronistic. Preferably, translators can say something like “on the night before the Sabbath” or “the night of the eve of the Sabbath” for before the sabbath. A footnote may be added to provide a brief explanation about the beginning of the Sabbath as in Good News Translation.

I commanded that the doors should be shut and gave orders that they should not be opened until after the sabbath: Revised Standard Version uses the synonyms commanded and gave orders to translate the Hebrew verb that means “to say, to command.” The first time “I said” occurs in the Hebrew text it is followed by the statement, “They shut the doors.” The second time “I said” occurs in the Hebrew it is followed by a negative order. Most translations interpret the first clause to represent a first command to shut the doors before the beginning of the Sabbath. This is followed by the second command that the doors were not to be opened until the Sabbath had ended. The text does not indicate to whom the commands were directed. In some languages it will be necessary to indicate someone as subject of the verbs, for example, the indefinite “they” or “men.” In the next sentence he says what action he took to have the gates guarded. For doors see Neh 3.1.

And I set some of my servants over the gates, that no burden might be brought in on the sabbath day: Set is the causative of the verb “to stand,” meaning that Nehemiah “stationed” (New International Version) or posted some of his men at the gates; that is, he gave his men responsibility over the gates. This introduces an implicit third command that is also negative. The last half of this sentence could be restructured and expressed explicitly as “I commanded them, ‘Do not allow people to bring anything into the city on the Sabbath.’ ”

My servants refers to members of the governor’s guard (see Neh 4.16). Nehemiah gave these men the responsibility to prevent any burden being brought through the city gates on the Sabbath. A burden was any load that could be carried by a person or by a load-bearing animal. Nehemiah’s action would not have stopped individual people from going in and out of the city.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 2:20

Nehemiah replied to their questions in a deliberate and formal manner. His answer showed that their threat would not stop the rebuilding because the God of heaven (see Ezra 1.2) would make them prosper. Nehemiah did not refer to the authorization that he had received from the king. The real concern of these opponents was not that the Jews were rebelling against the king, but that they would lose their own authority and power. Nehemiah addressed their concerns directly: you have no portion or right or memorial in Jerusalem. Nehemiah denied that they had any civic, legal, or religious rights in Jerusalem.

The God of heaven will make us prosper: Nehemiah states that they will be successful because God will cause them to succeed. New English Bible has “The God of heaven will give us success.” See also Ezra 5.8 and 6.14 for the theme of prospering and being successful in their efforts.

We his servants: Nehemiah repeats the theme of being the servants of God (see Neh 1.6).

Will arise and build: Arise often has the meaning of beginning or starting a task as in Good News Translation (see Ezra 1.5 and verse 18 above).

But you have no portion or right or memorial in Jerusalem: No portion is used to indicate no political connection (see 2 Sam 20.1; 1 Kgs 12.16). Nehemiah declares that they have no legal share in the city of Jerusalem. Right refers to the legal right to exercise jurisdiction, and by using this word, Nehemiah states that they have no political rights over the city. Finally, he uses the word memorial, which refers to the traditional right to participate in the worship in the Temple. By using this word, he declares that they have no religious rights in Jerusalem.

Because of the technical implications of these three keywords, they are difficult to translate clearly without giving long explanations. New English Bible translates similarly to Revised Standard Version by saying “You have no stake, or claim, or traditional right in Jerusalem.” Good News Translation restructures to refer specifically to property rights and more generally to traditions. Some versions identify memorial with a historic right (so Contemporary English Version, New International Version) or with being remembered (so Parole de Vie). The last sentence may also be rendered “But as for you, you do not have the right to own anything in Jerusalem, or to have any authority in it, or to take part in its religious life!” Translators may use a footnote to explain the significance of Nehemiah’s words.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 4:3

Tobiah the Ammonite was by him: Tobiah was a close ally and friend of Sanballat (see Neh 2.10, 19). Good News Translation makes it explicit that “Tobiah was standing there beside” Sanballat.

Yes … if a fox goes up on it he will break down their stone wall!: Tobiah also resorted to ridicule. Yes emphasizes the intensity of his ridicule. The construction of the wall would be done so fast and so poorly that even if a fox goes up on it he will break down their stone wall! The exclamation point emphasizes the strong ridicule of this statement. Two interpretations of Tobiah’s scornful remark are apparent in the various translations. In one interpretation, the focus is on the fox who will break down the wall or will make a breach in it either deliberately (Good News Translation, Nouvelle Bible Segond) or accidentally (Revised Standard Version). In the other interpretation, the focus is on the wall that will be so weak and so poorly built that even a fox happening to climb on it will cause it to break down or crumble (Bible en français courant, New Living Translation). This Handbook prefers the second interpretation. Good News Translation restructures Tobiah’s words into a rhetorical question followed by a statement.

Although the Hebrew word rendered fox can also mean jackal, here most translations take it to refer to the fox. Foxes and jackals are similar animals. They are like dogs in appearance and habits. A fox is often alone while jackals are often in groups. If the fox is not known in the receptor culture, the term for jackal may be used, or it may be described as “an animal that is like a wild dog.” The animal referred to here should be distinguished, however, from the animal that is sometimes called the “wild dog” or the “hunting dog”.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .