Translation commentary on Nehemiah 7:73 - 8:1

Like Ezra 2.70, this verse forms a frame with the introduction to the list at verse 6 above. The same groups of people are cited here as in Ezra 2.70, except that here they are not divided into two areas of settlement as in Ezra. Revised Standard Version and others like Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible translate fairly literally from the Hebrew, while Good News Translation seeks to make explicit what may not be apparent from the Hebrew text. That is, it understands some of the people to mean “ordinary people.” Bible en français courant has “lay people.” 1 Esdras 9.37 has “the men of Israel settled in Jerusalem and in the country … when the sons of Israel were in their settlements,” and is followed by Revised English Bible and New Jerusalem Bible here. This seems to be an attempt to distinguish between some of the people and all Israel. The Hebrew text is supported by Hebrew Old Testament Text Project (B rating) and should be followed by translators. All Israel may be understood as the sum total of the groups that had been cited as in Good News Translation, or it might refer to “the rest of the Israelites” (New International Version).

Lived in their towns: Most versions translate this way without referring to the towns where their ancestors had lived as Good News Translation has done in Ezra 2.70. Bible en français courant and others translate “settled in their own towns.” MT has a paragraph break at the beginning of this verse with the next break occurring at Neh 8.4. However, many commentators and translators take the second half of this verse to be part of a new episode. In the middle of this verse the occurrence of the Hebrew connective conjunction with a temporal clause signals the beginning of a major section (see the comments on Neh 7.73b). This Handbook therefore begins a new section at verse 73b, connecting it to the beginning of chapter 8 as in Revised Standard Version/New Revised Standard Version, New International Version, and Revised English Bible. In some versions it is restructured as part of verse 1 of chapter 8 as in Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh. However, it is recommended that the chapter number be placed in a position that reflects MT, that is, in relation to the first verse of chapter 8. This is done by New Revised Standard Version, which has a new section heading before verse 73b, followed by the chapter number with verse 1 (also New International Version, Revised English Bible).

And when the seventh month had come, the children of Israel were in their towns: In the Hebrew text, this new part of Nehemiah is marked by the connective conjunction and a temporal clause, as in the case of each new part in Ezra-Nehemiah (see Ezra 1.1). This introduction to the next event is similar to Ezra 3.1, where virtually the same text occurs. See the comments there. Note that the children of Israel renders the same Hebrew phrase as “the sons of Israel” in Ezra 3.1.

All the people gathered as one man: See the comments at Ezra 3.1.

The gathering was in the square before the Water Gate (see the comments at Ezra 10.9 and Neh 3.26). This square was on the east side of the city of Jerusalem opposite the east gate of the Temple (1 Esdras 9.38).

They told Ezra the scribe to bring the book of the law of Moses: Good News Translation expresses this in terms of a request instead of a command. It is an indirect quotation in form; that is, the exact words of the people are not recorded. Some literary traditions may prefer a direct quotation; for example, “Ezra, bring the book….” For Ezra the scribe, see the comments at Ezra 7.6. The people asked him to bring out the book of the law of Moses (see Ezra 3.2). The law of Moses refers to the Torah, but it is not known exactly how much of the Torah was contained in the book that was read at this event. Perhaps it was only one book of the Torah that had been compiled and edited during the exile in Babylonia (see also Ezra 7.6). The Hebrew word for book is literally “writing.” It would have been a scroll in this situation. See Ezra 6.1 for an illustration of a scroll.

Which the LORD had given to Israel: For LORD (YHWH in Hebrew), see “Translating Ezra and Nehemiah,” pages 18-19. The Hebrew verb that is rendered had given means “appoint” or “prescribe” (so New Jerusalem Bible, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible). Compare this with Ezra 7.6, where the Hebrew verb for “give” is used without indicating precisely who the recipient was. Here it is specified that the LORD had “commanded” (so New International Version) the Law to Israel through Moses. Mandinka says “which Yahweh commanded Israel to keep [it].”

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 9:19

Thou in thy great mercies didst not forsake them in the wilderness: In Hebrew the verse begins with “But you” (so Good News Translation), marking a contrast as in verse 17 above. This may be translated “But as for you” or “But for your part.” The contrast is with what was stated in verse 18. God’s great mercies contrast sharply with the people’s “great blasphemies.” Although these two phrases have the same adjective great in Revised Standard Version, the Hebrew uses two different though nearly synonymous adjectives. God’s response to the idolatry of the Israelites was to continue to provide for their needs in the same way as before. Because of his great mercies he did not abandon his people. For a comment on “merciful,” see verse 17 above. This is the first of four times in this prayer that God’s mercies are referred to, three times with the adjective great (verses 19, 27, 31) and once without the adjective (verse 28). Revised Standard Version retains the plural of the Hebrew, while Good News Translation renders it in the singular in more natural English. New International Version and Segond say “your great compassion,” and Bible en français courant translates “your infinite love.”

Wilderness was land that was not inhabited by people. It did not have good soil that could be farmed, but there was some vegetation where wild animals and also domestic animals could graze. In the Bible it is often referred to as desert as in Good News Translation even though it was not all sand and barren rock. Here it refers to the area of the Sinai Peninsula where the Israelites wandered for forty years before God allowed them to enter the promised land (see Deut 2). The translator should use a term that refers to bare land without trees, a land with scrub bushes, or uninhabited and uncultivated territory.

Pillar of cloud … pillar of fire …: See verse 12 above.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 10:39

For the people of Israel and the sons of Levi shall bring the contribution …: This statement seems to be a clarification of what is to be done with the contribution of grain, wine and oil that has been collected by the Levites (see verse 37 above). The Hebrew conjunction rendered For links this verse to the preceding instructions. It draws attention to their importance in relation to the Temple. All the contributions (expressed here as a collective singular noun in Hebrew) are to be brought by the people and the Levites to the chambers of the Temple. That is the place where the vessels of the sanctuary are kept (see Ezra 8.28-29), as well as where the priests, gatekeepers and singers have their living quarters as Good News Translation makes explicit. Sanctuary here refers to the Temple. For sons of Levi, see Ezra 8.15.

The priests that minister means those that are currently doing the Temple duties.

We will not neglect the house of our God: This last sentence is a summary statement of the intent of the people to provide for the needs of the Temple. Having stated everything that they will provide for the Temple, they now declare what they will not do. They will not neglect the Temple, which they refer to as the house of our God (see Ezra 8.17). Traduction œcuménique de la Bible says “Thus we will not abandon the House of our God.”

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 11:33 - 11:35

Hazor and Ramah are west of the approach route to Jerusalem. The last six villages from Gittaim to Ono are in the west at the southern end of the coastal Plain of Sharon about 48 kilometers (30 miles) northwest of Jerusalem.

The valley of craftsmen (Hebrew Ge-harashim) is understood by Revised Standard Version to be a description of Ono (also New Revised Standard Version, Nouvelle Bible Segond, Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible, Darby). But it may be a separate place (so Good News Translation, New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, Revised English Bible, Bible en français courant). It is thought to be a valley between Lod and Ono. A change in the Hebrew vowels changes the word for craftsmen to “woods,” which may have been the description of the valley. New Revised Standard Version translates it as “the valley of artisans,” New Jerusalem Bible calls it “the Valley of Craftsmen,” while Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible calls it “the valley of Laborers.” Some versions transliterate and retain the Hebrew name Ge-harashim (so Revised English Bible, BNT, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). This Handbook advises translators to say “the valley of craftsmen” or “Craftsmen’s Valley” and to present it as a separate place from Ono.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 13:7

And came to Jerusalem, and I then discovered the evil that Eliashib had done for Tobiah: Nehemiah continues his account. After taking leave of the king, he arrived in Jerusalem. Nothing is said about his journey from Babylon to Jerusalem. However, on his return to Jerusalem he discovered what Eliashib had done while he was away. Eliashib’s act is described as evil because it was a desecration of the Temple. This is the first of four times in this chapter that the Hebrew word translated evil is used (also verses 17, 18, 27). It occurs a fifth time in a verbal form in verse 8 (“was … angry”). It was used earlier in the book of Nehemiah for a bad situation (rendered as “trouble” in 1.3; 2.17), for the emotion of displeasure (2.10), and for physical harm (6.2). Here it is used for wrongdoing in God’s sight. New Jerusalem Bible calls it a “crime,” while Revised English Bible calls it an “outrageous thing.” The verb had done refers to an action that took place before a past event.

In the courts of the house of God: See Neh 8.16.

Good News Translation restructures the verse to make the meaning clear. It also interprets Nehemiah’s reaction to finding out about Eliashib’s evil deed to be “shock.” This is consistent with the context and with Nehemiah’s response as recorded in the following verse. Most versions, however, translate more neutrally as Revised Standard Version has done, for example, “I learned about” (New International Version) and “I became aware of” (Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible). Translators should follow their example.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .