Translation commentary on Mark 1:24

Text:

The interjection ea ‘ah!’ included by Textus Receptus (before ti ‘what’) is accepted also by Vogels and Soden (who places it in brackets): it is rejected, however, by Tischendorf, Nestle, Westcott and Hort, Kilpatrick, Souter and Turner.

Instead of oida ‘I know’ of most editions of the Greek text, Textus Receptus, Tischendorf and Soden have oidamen ‘we know.’

Exegesis:

anekraxen legōn ‘cried out, saying’: modern translations need not adopt Marcan style and translate both the main verb and the participle (cf. the similar construction in v. 7); one verb is sufficient: ‘cried out,’ ‘shouted.’ It is to be noticed that the subject of the verb is he (the man) and not it (the spirit); the participle legōn is masculine.

ti hēmin kai soi (this same construction is found in 5.7; Mt. 8.29; 27.19; Lk. 4.34; 8.28; Jn. 2.4) literally ‘what to us and to you?’ In classical Greek the phrase would mean ‘What have we in common?’ Here, however, it corresponds to the Hebrew ‘Why do you meddle with me?’ (cf. Taylor; in Septuagint see Judg. 11.12, 2 Sam. 16.10, 19.23, 1 Kg. 17.18, etc.) Translator’s New Testament: “Why are You interfering with us?” Goodspeed discusses the phrase at length, and Lagrange succinctly defines its meaning: “It is employed to reject an intervention which is at least premature, not to say inopportune.”

Notice the plurals hēmin and hēmas ‘us’: not simply this demonic spirit, but the whole class of unclean spirits is involved. Or else the plural may reflect the feeling of multiple personalities, common in persons suffering from demon possession (cf. 5.1-13).

ēlthes apolesai hēmas; ‘have you come to destroy us?’ The phrase is thus understood as a question by Greek editions of the text (Nestle, Westcott and Hort, Kilpatrick, Souter), commentators and translations (Lagrange, King James Version, American Standard Version, Revised Standard Version, Translator’s New Testament, Manson, Knox, Le Nouveau Testament. Version Synodale, Zürcher Bibel, O Novo Testamento de Nosso Senhor Jesus Cristo. Revisdo Autorizada, The Modern Speech New Testament, Berkeley); others have taken it to be an assertion (Tischendorf, Soden, Merk, Vogels, Taylor, Turner, Swete, Rawlinson). There is nothing in grammar or context definitely to decide which should be preferred.

ēlthes ‘you came’: a few see here the meaning, ‘you came into the world’ (Swete, Taylor); this interpretation, however, has not commended itself to many.

apolesai ‘to destroy’: the infinitive here expresses purpose. The verb apollumi is used in three ways in Mark: (1) in the active ‘to destroy,’ ‘to cause to perish,’ 1.24; 3.6; 9.22; 11.18; 12.9; (2) ‘to lose,’ 8.35 (twice); 9.41; (3) in the middle or passive ‘to be destroyed,’ ‘to perish,’ ‘to be lost,’ 2.22; 4.38.

oida se tis ei literally ‘I know you who you are’: the personal pronoun se ‘you’ is the object of oida ‘I know,’ and the interrogative clause tis ei ‘who you are’ explicitly defines the content of ‘I know.’ The interrogative pronoun tis ‘who,’ though in apposition to se ‘you’ (which is in the accusative case), is in the nominative case because it is the subject of ei ‘you are.’

ho hagios tou theou (also in Lk. 4.34, Jn. 6.69) ‘the Holy (One) of God’: although the majority of commentators and translations treat this phrase as a Messianic title, Lagrange points out that the phrase is not known in the relevant literature as a Messianic title. The phrase could very well be vocative ‘you holy man of God!’ (Grant). Whatever may have been the meaning of the words as spoken by the possessed man, it is certain that in Mark the meaning is Christian, i.e. fully Messianic, ‘the Holy One of God.’ Between the two possible meanings, ‘the Holy One who comes from God,’ and ‘the Holy One who belongs to God,’ probably the latter is to be preferred.

Translation:

Cried out means a ‘shout’ or ‘scream’ (terms meaning ‘weeping’ must be carefully avoided).

Note that there are significant shifts in persons in this verse (as in other contexts dealing with demon possession, cf. Mark 5.6-12). The subject of the verb, however, is the man.

The Semitic idiom rendered in the Revised Standard Version as “What have you to do with us” is variously translated in other languages, e.g. ‘why do you bother us,’ ‘what are you going to do to us,’ ‘why do you disturb us,’ and ‘why are we any of your business.’

Jesus of Nazareth must often be rendered as ‘Jesus from Nazareth town.’

To destroy may be translated in some languages as simply ‘to kill’ when speaking of the destruction of demons, since they regard them as a somewhat different type of being. Accordingly, one must in some instances say ‘to cause to end’ (Tzeltal), ‘to put out of sight’ (Mitla Zapotec), or ‘to blot out completely.’

The Greek verb translated ‘know’ in this verse implies somewhat more than mere recognition. In some languages the equivalent is ‘I know full well.’

The Holy One of God presents a number of problems for the translator. In the first place, some languages do not permit the use of an indefinite ‘one’ in such a construction. They would require ‘person,’ but this is also a source of difficulty, for ‘person’ in some languages will not admit of grammatical possession. Hence, in such languages one must use ‘Son,’ if the passage is to make sense (Huichol, Tzeltal, Kekchi). On the other hand, Eastern Maninkakancan quite readily use ‘God’s Holy Person.’ If, however, one adopts the meaning of ‘comes from God’ some of the grammatical problems are eliminated, e.g. ‘the Holy One who comes from God’ (Huastec, Amganad Ifugao, Yaka, Toraja-Sa’dan, Pamona, Indonesian).

Quoted with permission from Bratcher, Robert G. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on the Gospel of Mark. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1961. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted