Translation commentary on Genesis 1:31

In this verse all of the creative acts are completed.

And God saw everything that he had made: see Gen 1.4 and verse 10.

And behold, it was very good: here behold calls attention to and emphasizes very good. This is the first time in the evaluation step that very is added to good.

And there was evening and there was morning, a sixth day: see verse 5.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 2:1

2.1-3 describes the concluding act of creation, which is God resting on the seventh day.

Thus the heavens and the earth were finished: Thus translates the usual Hebrew connecting form waw used throughout this division. The purpose of this linking word is to relate 2.1-3 as a conclusion to all that went before. Were finished is a passive construction and refers to the completion of the work of creation. For the heavens and the earth, see 1.1.

And all the host of them: host translates a word sometimes referring to an army, as in 21.22, where the same word is translated “army.” In Deut 4.19 “host of heaven” refers to the stars, and in 1 Kgs 22.19 to angels. The general sense of the word is a large number of organized things, and so in relation to the heavens and earth it means “all its parts, everything in it.” Good News Translation attempts to include this thought with “the whole universe.” Others are more literal; for example New Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible “with all their array.” Biblia Dios Habla Hoy has “and all that is in them.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 2:2

Although printed in prose form, the two sentences of verse 2 are clearly parallel poetically and say essentially the same thing.

And on the seventh day God finished his work which he had done: this is ambiguous since it can mean that God worked on the seventh day and then finished, or that he did not work on the seventh day but his work was finished when that day came. The intended sense is the second of these. In order to avoid seeming to say that God worked on the seventh day, the Septuagint translates seventh with “sixth.” So also New English Bible and Revised English Bible. Good News Translation attempts to avoid misunderstanding by translating “by the seventh day God finished….” His work translates a noun that covers a wide range of meanings. It is used to refer to a person’s occupation or business, the particular skills required in producing something useful, or the object that is produced. It is also used in reference to unskilled work. All work was banned on the weekly Sabbath (Exo 20.9-10) and on the festival Sabbaths (Lev 16.29).

In translation it is best to make clear that God did not work on the seventh day; for example, “When the seventh day came God had finished all his work.” One translation has “On day number 7 God saw that all his work was finished, and he rested on this day.” Another translation joins together verses 1.31 and 2.1 to say “… Then all his work in making the earth and the sky and everything in them was finished, and this day finished. This was day number 6 of the world.” Verse 2 then continues, “God’s work was finished, then on day number 7 of the world he rested from all the work he had been doing.”

And he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had done: rested does not suggest that God had to relax and refresh his strength, although this sense is clear in the context of the same word as it is used in Exo 31.17. Here rested means “to cease, stop, bring to an end,” and it is used again in this sense in Gen 8.22, where God promises Noah that “summer and winter, day and night, shall not cease.” The Hebrew verb “to rest” is shabath and sounds like the word for “Sabbath,” which is shabbath. Work is the same word used in the previous clause.

In translation it is important to avoid a word that may suggest rest as ceasing difficult work, since that will suggest that God was exhausted and in need of refreshment from heavy labor. On the other hand a word meaning “to stop work” that means “quitting or giving up” is equally inappropriate. Good News Translation says “stopped working.” Many translations prefer “rested” and place “ceased” in a footnote.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 2:3

So God blessed the seventh day and hallowed it: some interpreters suggest that God gives his blessing to those who observe the seventh day, but it is more probable that the blessing is given to the seventh day itself. Blessed has the sense of God giving or conferring his favor, so that the one who receives it receives a benefit. In some languages bless may be rendered, for example, “So God gave to the seventh day his special goodness,” “So God made the seventh day good by…,” or “God made the seventh day special.” Hallowed translates a word whose intensive form means “to sanctify,” that is, “to set apart for God’s use, to dedicate to God.” When translating hallowed in this context, it may be necessary to make the purpose clear; for example, “God set it apart as a special day for rest” or “God made it a special day and made it a day when people can rest and worship him.”

The last clause of verse 3 gives the reason God blessed … and hallowed the seventh day: because on it God rested from all his work which he had done in creation. Rested is the same as in verse 2 and has the same sense. Anchor Bible translates “for on it he ceased from all the work he had undertaken,” and New English Bible has “because that day he ceased from all the work he had set himself to do.” See also Good News Translation “stopped working.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 2:4

The placement of verse 2.4a (the first sentence of the verse) in relation to what comes before or after it is debatable. The formula These are the generations of (and its variant form in 5.1) occurs eleven times in Genesis. See “Translating Genesis,” page 1. This expression serves to introduce an episode in the main person’s life or, more commonly, to introduce the names of his descendants. Consequently These generally points forward to events and descendants, not backward to something already reported. The formula serves to divide parts of the text into successive units. However, there are similar expressions that point backward; for example, “These are the families of Noah according to their generations…” at the end of chapter 10.

We may ask why such translations as Good News Translation, New American Bible, Biblia Dios Habla Hoy, Bible en français courant, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, New English Bible (but not Revised English Bible), New Jerusalem Bible, Bible de Jérusalem, Anchor Bible, Traduction oecuménique de la Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, and Brazilian common language translation (Nova Tradução na Linguagem de Hoje) place 2.4a as a summary of the story of creation. The major reasons are that the account following 2.4a concerns not the story of the earth and heavens, but rather the creation of human beings. From the point of view of authorship, there is a break in the style of writing between 2.4a and 2.4b, so that 2.4a stylistically belongs to what comes before it.

The Handbook follows the example of this significant group of modern translations, and translators are encouraged to do the same.

These are the generations of the heavens and the earth: generations normally refers to the successive generations in a family genealogy or list of descendants. However, in 6.9, for example, “These are the generations of Noah” is followed by statements of the character of Noah, a list of his sons, and then the story of the flood. This appears to be an extension of the meaning of generation to something equivalent to story, account, narrative, report. The same is the case with the use of generations here in 2.4a, except that here generations does not apply at all to a person and his descendants, but exclusively to the narrative element. As a result many modern translations translate generations by a term meaning “story.” Good News Translation uses an English story closing form “And that is how the universe was created.” Bible en français courant is similar: “Thus it was that in stages God created the heavens and the earth.” Traduction oecuménique de la Bible attempts to retain something of the generative idea with “Such is the birth of heaven and earth during their creation.”

The translation of generations in 2.4a may be a story closing form, as in Good News Translation and Bible en français courant. You may also say, for example, “These are the events described when God created…,” or “All that has been told are the happenings that took place when God created…,” or “And that is the report of what happened when God created….”

The alternative to handling the placement of 2.4a as suggested above is to include 2.4a with 2.4b, as in King James Version (King James Version), Revised English Bible, and New International Version. In the latter two versions 2.4a comes after the heading “Adam and Eve.”

As noted above, a new story begins at this point. If a suitable subdivision heading is chosen, this may be sufficient in many languages to mark the transition. But if a more formal heading is required as the opening of the story, then perhaps a brief restructuring of part of verse 7 may be the most appropriate opening; for instance, “This is [the story of] how God made the first human beings from the ground.”

In the day that …: In the day is an idiomatic way in Hebrew of saying “when, at the time when,” and so this phrase introduces the rest of the verse as a dependent clause. For the same usage see Jer 11.4; 34.13, where the same Hebrew expression is translated “when” in Revised Standard Version. As an opening to the new story and a link back to the previous story, it may be preferable in some languages to start with the statement “The LORD God made…,” and then continue “At that time….”

In Revised Standard Version verses 4b-7 form one complex sentence. The seven clauses of verses 4b-6 together form an extended introduction to the first main action of this story, which comes in Gen 2.7. This introduction gives the setting for the action. It may be helpful at this point to set out the seven clauses and the relationships between them, since translators will need to decide how the relationships are best expressed in their own languages, and how to link the clauses in separate sentences. Following the Revised Standard Version wording:

1. In the day that the LORD God made (time setting)
2. no plant of the field was yet
3. no herb of the field had yet (2 and 3 are two parallel statements describing the earth)
4. for the LORD God had not made it to rain
5. and there was no man to till (4 and 5 are two reasons for 2 and 3)
6. a mist went up from the ground
7. and watered … the ground (6 and 7 are two further statements describing the earth) (6 and 7 are linked in a negative-to-positive way to 4)

See the discussions on the individual clauses for further comments on the relationships.

LORD God translates yahweh ʾelohim, and this is the first occurrence in Genesis of yahweh, the Israelite name of God. See “The names of God in Genesis” in “Translating Genesis,” page 13, for a detailed discussion of the names of God.

Examples from a few modern translations illustrate how LORD God has been translated: (a) New Jerusalem Bible “Yahweh God”; (b) Moffatt “God the Eternal”; (c) Revised Standard Version “LORD God”; (d) Bible en français courant (which translates both Yahweh and ʾadonai by “Seigneur”) “Seigneur Dieu” (“Lord God”).

In some languages the use of a double term such as “Yahweh God” would indicate that “Yahweh” is the name of God. Others may say “God who is called Yahweh” or “God Yahweh.” In some languages it may be necessary to follow the Septuagint pattern and represent Yahweh (as well as ʾadonai) by a term meaning “master, ruler, chief.”

Made the earth and the heavens: made is the same verb used in 1.7, 16, 25, 31, and means the same as “create.”

The earth and the heavens: the order of the words is reversed from the order of 1.1, but again the idiomatic meaning is the universe, or everything that existed. In translation the order of the two elements the earth and the heavens should not be reversed if this results in the expression being unnatural. Otherwise it is better in both 1.1 and 2.4b to use “the universe,” or “the earth and sky and everything else,” or “… and everything in them.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 2:5

When no plant …: when begins a second time clause in Revised Standard Version. However, it is often best to make this clause the main clause, as in Good News Translation and others: “There were no plants….”

Plant in plant of the field is the same word found in Gen 21.15 and Job 30.4, 7, where it is rendered “bushes” by Revised Standard Version. It may refer to vegetation generally. Was yet in the earth is a close literal rendering of the Hebrew, which is translated more naturally in English as “on the earth” (Good News Translation). This clause may also be translated “no plants grew on the earth.” However, see the discussion in the next paragraph.

And no herb of the field had yet sprung up: herb translates the same word used in 1.11, where it is rendered “plants” in Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation. Some suggest that plants refers to perennials, that is, plants that continue to live year after year, while herbs refers to annuals or plants that last for only one growing season. Westermann calls attention to the need to interpret these two classes of plants in terms of the context, which describes the conditions of the earth before the creation of animals, man, and woman, and their need to feed themselves. Accordingly the focus is here upon the total absence of plants that will sustain both animals and people. In the first group of plants, the term field refers to “open country.” In 2 Sam 17.8; Jer 14.5, it is the place where wild animals exist. It is suggested that plant of the field refers to plants that grow in the open country, where animals graze. Herb of the field, by contrast, refers to domestic plants, those grown primarily for people to eat. Accordingly the translator may say “no wild plants” and “no cultivated plants,” or “no field plants” and “no garden plants,” or “no plants for animals to eat” and “no plants to feed people.” Most translations do not make such a clear distinction as suggested here, although Anchor Bible suggests this kind of difference by using “no shrub” and “no grains.” See also Good News Translation “no plants … and no seeds.”

Had yet sprung up means “had yet sprouted, grown.” It may be desirable to begin a new sentence here and say, for example, “Nothing was growing on the earth because….” Another possibility is to join together the two parallel clauses of this verse; for example, one translation says “there was no tree or grass-like plant growing in the earth yet….”

For the LORD God had not caused it to rain gives the first of two reasons for the absence of plant life on the earth. For LORD God see verse 4. Many languages express to rain as requiring a personal agent; for example, “God rains water,” “sky rains,” “clouds drop rain.”

Translators who find it best to start a new sentence at this point may need to provide a link back to the previous sentence; for instance, “It was like that because….” See comments at the beginning of verse 4b.

The second reason for the absence of plants is that there was no man to till the ground. Man in Hebrew is ʾadam, a masculine singular noun, and ground is ʾadamah, a related feminine singular noun. This is a play on words somewhat similar to “earthling” and “earth” in English and cannot often be reproduced in translation. Translators may find it helpful to use a footnote, as in Good News Translation. For further comments see verse 7.

Till translates the Hebrew verb meaning “to work, labor, serve”; but with the ground as the object, it means “to work the soil, dig in the ground, cultivate,” as similar verbs do in many other languages. For similar usage see Gen 3.23; 4.2, 12. Not all societies cultivate the soil in the same way. The term used here should be general and probably involve more than simply “hoeing the ground”; for example, “farming,” “working and caring for the ground and plants,” or “planting and growing things.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 1:4

And God saw that the light was good: this is the evaluation step in the creation poem, which will be repeated in verses 10, 12, 18, 21, and 25. The thought here is not that the light had a quality of goodness in itself, but that in God’s mind the light was judged by him to be good. Good News Translation “God was pleased” correctly places the emphasis on God’s reaction to the light. Bible en français courant says “God established [the fact] that the light was a good thing.” Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch has “God took pleasure in the light.” In some languages it may be necessary to say, for example, “God looked at the light and was pleased with what he saw.” Because the evaluation of the light is another step in the process, it may be necessary in some languages to mark the transition; for example, “After the light appeared, God looked at it and he was pleased with what he saw.” One translation expresses it like this: “And when God looked at the light, he was happy with it.”

And God separated: Revised Standard Version and some other versions represent the Hebrew in repeating the noun God, whereas Good News Translation, New International Version, and others translate “and he separated.” In English and in many other languages the pronoun is not ambiguous, and it is used generally in regular speech. There is, however, a repeated use of the noun God throughout this passage, which goes beyond what is normal in biblical Hebrew; this is apparently a feature used for special effect here. Translators are advised to follow normal pronoun usage in their own languages, but to note that there is perhaps a feature of emphasis in the Hebrew text, and to consider how they may be able to express that in their translation.

Separated the light from the darkness: the word translated separated occurs also in verses 6 and 7, in which the waters under the firmament are separated from those above. The result of the separation of light from darkness is to give day and night. In this way the first act of creation sets in motion the cycle of time, day followed by night. The picture given in the text is that of light being created while everything is still in darkness, and of a second step being necessary to give light and darkness their own places to function. For the idea of light and darkness occupying separate spaces, see Job 26.10; 38.19-20.

The idea of separating light from darkness is often expressed as dividing the two things so that they go different ways or to different places. A typical expression of this is “God made the light and the darkness, those two things, divide….” However, in some languages it is difficult to speak in this way, since light and darkness are not material objects that can be moved about. Accordingly it may be necessary to say, for example, “God made the light to shine in one place and left it dark in another” or “God made some places light and some places he made dark.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 1:21

Verse 21 describes the execution of the command given in verse 20.

So God created the great sea monsters: created is as in verse 1 and is used here for the first time since Gen 1.1. Sea monsters translates a noun also found in Job 7.12, where it is rendered “sea monster” by Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation. There the reference is to a legendary dragon that must be controlled so that it will not escape and cause destruction and chaos. See also “dragon” in Psa 74.13; Isa 51.9. The Hebrew word may also refer to certain living creatures such as serpents and snakes, and perhaps even crocodiles. In translation it is best to avoid a name for one particular creature such as “whale,” “shark,” or “sea lion,” and use a general term such as “big sea creatures” or “big animals that live in the water.”

And every living creature that moves: living creature is as in verse 20. Moves translates a verb that means to move about, and in the water this refers to the action of gliding or swimming. This category takes in all the rest of the living creatures of the sea that are not included among the great creatures already mentioned; in some languages it may be necessary to call them “all the other sea creatures.”

With which the waters swarm emphasizes that the command in verse 20 has been executed, that is, that the waters should swarm with living creatures.

According to their kinds means “all kinds” as in verse 11, and Good News Translation translates “all kinds of creatures that live in the water.” Bible en français courant says “and every kind of animal that threads through the water.”

And every winged bird according to its kind: winged bird translates Hebrew “bird [with] wing”; the reference is to birds that fly and therefore in English simply “birds.” See translation comments on verse 20. According to its kind is repeated in the case of the birds and again means “all kinds of birds.”

And God saw that it was good: see Gen 1.4 and verse 10.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .