Translation commentary on Genesis 47:28

And Jacob lived in the land of Egypt seventeen years: in verse 9 Jacob told the king that he was one hundred and thirty years old. After that he lived another seventeen years in Egypt, which made him one hundred and forty-seven when he died. However, the death of Jacob is not reported yet. Instead Jacob goes on in chapters 48 and 49 to perform various acts that must be done before his death, which is recorded in 49.33.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 47:29

And when the time drew near that Israel must die: that is, “When Jacob felt that the time for him to die was approaching” or “When the time for Jacob to die was getting near.”

He called his son Joseph: called may need to be expressed as “sent for … Joseph” or “sent someone to bring his son Joseph.”

If now I have found favor in your sight: this expression is normally used when a person is speaking to his superior. For example, Lot speaking to the two angels in 19.19, and a fearful Jacob addressing Esau in 32.5; 33.8, 10, 15. It also shows Noah’s relationship with God in 6.8. Note that Good News Translation fails to translate this expression. Here Jacob inquires about Joseph’s feeling toward him before asking him a great favor. Jacob is saying “If you think well of me….” Bible en français courant says “If you have affection for me,” New Jerusalem Bible “If you really love me.” Revised English Bible is less emotive with “I have a favor to ask.” All of these are suitable models.

Put your hand under my thigh: for comments on this gesture used in swearing an oath, see 24.2.

Promise to deal loyally and truly with me is literally “and do mercy and truth with me,” which may be rendered “that you will be loyal and faithful to me.”

Do not bury me in Egypt: this is the request to which Joseph commits himself with a promise and an oath. A model that some translators may find useful is one that rearranges verse 29 by saying, for example, “If you love me, show me that you are loyal and faithful to me. When I die do not bury me here in Egypt. Promise me this by swearing that you will do as I ask.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 47:30

But let me lie with my fathers: but is used by Revised Standard Version to contrast being buried in Egypt with being buried in Canaan beside his father and grandfather. If this is the meaning of the clause, we may translate “Bury me where my ancestors are.” However, New Revised Standard Version has a different rendering, which is also followed by some other versions, “When I lie down with my ancestors.” This takes the clause to be the commonly occurring idiom (or euphemism) for death; and in this sense we may translate “When I die, [I want you to] carry my body away….”

Carry me out of Egypt and bury me in their burying place: this refers to the cave of Machpelah purchased by Abraham from the Hittites in chapter 23. If Revised Standard Version is followed, it may be helpful to rearrange verse 30 so that the first clause becomes the consequence of the command to Joseph; for example, “Take me out of Egypt and bury me in the grave of my fathers [of my father and my grandfather]. There I will lie beside them.” Some translations express the contrast in the verse by saying “When I die, don’t bury me here in this country. Carry my body back … and put me there in that graveyard where my ancestors are lying.”

He answered: that is, “Joseph answered.”

I will do as you have said is literally “I will do according to your words.” See Good News Translation.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 47:31

In verse 29 Jacob instructed Joseph how to take the oath. In verse 30 Joseph promises to do as Jacob has said, but in this verse Jacob insists that Joseph affirm his promise by taking the oath as given in verse 29.

He said: that is, “Jacob said.”

Swear to me: that is, “Swear an oath to me,” “Take the vow,” or “Promise [in God’s name] that you will do it.”

And he [Joseph] swore to him [Jacob]: we may translate this, for example, “Then Joseph swore an oath [took the vow, made the solemn promise]” or “Then Joseph did as his father commanded him to do.”

Then Israel bowed himself upon the head of his bed: Driver says Jacob “apparently turned himself over on his bed, and bent his head down towards its head—in imitation, as far as possible, of actual prostration.” For the account of David doing something similar in his old age, see 1 Kgs 1.47.

The purpose of bowing in his bed is to give thanks, although translations do not agree on the one being thanked. Therefore some translators do not express the gesture but only its purpose. See Good News Translation. Others retain both the gesture and its function. For example, Bible en français courant says “Then Jacob thanked him by inclining deeply at the head of his bed,” and Revised English Bible says “And Israel bowed in worship by the head of his bed.”

Heb 11.21 records this event as “He leaned on the top of his walking stick and worshiped God” (Good News Translation). The reason for saying “walking stick” is that the Hebrew words for “bed” and “walking stick” are very similar, and the Septuagint, which says “walking stick,” is the basis for the translation in Heb 11.21. However, the Septuagint is not to be translated in this verse.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 48:1

After this: the Hebrew says “And it happened after these things,” as in 15.1; 22.1; and 40.1. This expression serves as a transition to a new episode or series of events. However, we must be aware that Joseph is in the capital city and Jacob is in Goshen. Therefore in languages that must account for movements, it may be necessary to have in this opening expression more than a time transition. For example, “Some time later, when Joseph was in the city, he was told that his father in Goshen was ill. So he took his two sons Manasseh and Ephraim and went to Goshen.”

Joseph was told may need to be expressed actively as in the Hebrew: “someone told Joseph,” “they told Joseph,” “Joseph found out,” “Joseph received news,” or “Joseph got word that….”

Behold, your father is ill: Behold, which is not represented by Good News Translation, may suggest that the news is a surprise to Joseph; or it may signal a significant development in the narrative. Note that Revised Standard Version translates this as direct speech, while Good News Translation uses indirect.

So he took with him: see the suggested model above. Note that Good News Translation recognizes that Joseph has to get to where Jacob is. In some languages this is expressed as “he took his two sons … and the three of them went to see him.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 48:2

Your son Joseph has come to you: the Hebrew again has hinneh “behold,” which Revised Standard Version does not translate. This word makes it appear that possibly Joseph went immediately to Goshen and did not have time to send word that he was coming. Translators may find it better to avoid the two sentences of Revised Standard Version and to follow the model of Good News Translation, with “When Jacob was told…,” “When Jacob found out…,” or “When they told Jacob….” Some translations make a link with verse 1 by saying “When they arrived someone told the old man….”

Israel summoned his strength: Israel is Jacob and can be rendered by the pronoun he in most languages. Summoned his strength translates a form of the verb “to strengthen” or “to grow strong.” In this context we may say, for example, “made the effort to” or “took hold of himself.” See Good News Translation. In some languages the fact that Jacob was lying down at first is brought out: “When Jacob heard … he was lying down, but he exerted himself to get up and he sat on the bed.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 46:34

You shall say: this has the force of a command. It is rendered in some translations as “this is what you must say” or “make sure you tell him.”

Your servants … our youth even until now: Your servants may need to be modified, as in some languages this expression may mean the people who are employed by the king. We may sometimes adjust this to say, for example, “We who honor you, sir, have been…,” or if using an indirect quote, “… that you [plural] have taken care of….” See Good News Translation. From our youth even until now may also be expressed as “through all our lives.”

Both we and our fathers: our fathers or “our ancestors” does not fit with until now, as these ancestors are no longer living. Therefore it is necessary to adjust this clause by saying, for example, “that you [plural] have taken care of livestock [been herders or herdsmen] all your lives, the same as your ancestors did.” Spoken in the “we” form (direct speech) this may be “We have been herdsmen all our lives, just like our ancestors were.”

In order that you may dwell in the land of Goshen: see Good News Translation “in this way he will let you live….” It is expressed more fully in some translations as “When you say that, the king will let you live….”

For every shepherd is an abomination to the Egyptians: for abomination see 43.32. Although Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation correctly translate the Hebrew text, even the king of Egypt had a herd of livestock (see 47.6). Driver comments that, according to the ancient Greek historian Herodotus, swineherds and cowherds were looked down upon by the Egyptians, but that shepherds were not. Anchor Bible thinks that the term shepherd is here a play on the popular interpretation of the Hyksos dynasty as “shepherd kings.” The Hyksos were Asians who ruled Egypt from about 1660 B.C. for a hundred years; and the descendants of Jacob were in Egypt before, during, and after the Hyksos period.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 47:1 - 47:2

Verses 1-6 of this chapter are a direct continuation of what went before in chapter 46. However, the opening of this chapter has a change of setting that involves the movement of Joseph, his father, and at least some of his brothers from Goshen to the capital, where the king of Egypt (Pharaoh) lived. In languages whose narrative structure requires making movements and scene changes unambiguously clear, some adjustments must be made in verses 1 and 2.

There are two ways to view the movement from Goshen to the king’s palace in the capital city:
(1) that Joseph takes his father and brothers with him when he goes to his audience or meeting with the king; or
(2) that Joseph returns, leaving his father and brothers in Goshen.

If we assume the first of these possibilities, as Good News Translation and a number of other English versions do, we are faced with the problem of the brothers and Jacob being at the same time in Goshen and in the palace. Good News Translation begins with “Joseph took five of his brothers and went to the king,” but then says about the brothers and Jacob, “They are now in the region of Goshen.” If this is a real problem, it may be solved by using a different expression to indicate the presence of Jacob’s people at Goshen. See further comments below.

If, on the other hand, we make the second assumption, we must also assume that there are two different occasions when Joseph meets with the king. In this case the language of translation may still require making the movements clear; we may say, for example, “After instructing his brothers, Joseph returned to the king’s palace and went in to speak with him: ‘My father and brothers have arrived from Canaan with … They are now in the region of Goshen.’ ” This view assumes they are physically in Goshen. Therefore we have to assume that Joseph arranges a second meeting, in which the king will speak with the brothers. If this is so, before Joseph can present the brothers to the king, he must send for them to come; and to show the movement of the brothers from Goshen, we must say something like “Joseph sent for his father and his brothers. He then chose five of his brothers to present them to the king.”

So Joseph went in and told Pharaoh: the Hebrew says “Joseph came and told Pharaoh.” “Came” in English is speaking from the point of view of the place where the king is. Revised Standard Version went speaks from the point of view of where Joseph was at the time, namely, in Goshen. We may keep the point of view of Goshen and say, for example, “Then Joseph left Goshen and went to speak with the king.”

They are now in …: in Hebrew this is literally “and behold them in…”; there is no verb. The word hinneh again has the function of drawing attention to a significant development in the story. If Jacob and the (five) brothers are in fact waiting at the palace at this time, then a verb other than one that means “they are staying” should be supplied; for example, “they have made their camp in….”

From among his brothers he took five men: five men may be expressed as “five of them.” Anchor Bible believes the number five means “several” here as well as in 43.34. However, most modern translations retain the number five both here and in 43.34. As suggested above, most translations that follow possibility (2) render took as “sent for” or “called for.”

Presented them to Pharaoh: presented translates a verb meaning “to put,” “to set,” or “to place.” The same verb is used of Jacob putting the peeled branches in front of the animals in 30.38. In this context it has the sense of “introduced,” “showed,” or “took them to the king so he could see them.”

Some translations that follow possibility (1) above also assume that Joseph took his brothers with him when he first went in to speak with the king, rather than having them wait outside. In this case Joseph concludes his speech by introducing the brothers: “He told the names of his brothers to the king.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .