Translation commentary on Genesis 10:31

Verse 31 follows the summarizing formula of verse 5 (see comments there) and verse 20.

These are the sons of Shem: These now refers back to all the names in verses 21-30. See verses 5 and 20 for the translation of this formula.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 10:11

From that land means “He went from Shinar [or, Babylonia] to Assyria.”

Assyria was one of the greatest empires of the ancient Middle East. It is mentioned numerous times in the Old Testament, and particularly in regard to battles with Israel in 2 Kings and in Isaiah’s prophecies. Its center was in what is now northern Iraq, and its capital was Nineveh. Its original capital was Asshur. See comments on 2.14.

Nineveh is referred to in Jonah 1.2; 3.2, 3; 4.11 as “the great city.” Its ruins are located on the east bank of the Tigris river opposite the modern city of Mosul, Iraq.

Rehoboth-Ir is a Hebrew designation meaning “the city squares” or “the city plazas,” perhaps referring to a suburb of Nineveh.

Calah was located south of Nineveh and was the royal residence. Today in Arabic it is called “Nimrud,” who in Islamic commentaries is a son of Canaan and not a son of Cush.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 10:32

This verse is the closing statement of the table of nations.

These are the families of the sons of Noah: These points back to all the names in 10.2-29, just as These in verse 1 pointed ahead to the same names. Families or “clans” is better translated here by a general term for groups of human beings or, as Good News Translation says, “peoples.” Speiser translates “groupings of Noah’s descendants.” In this context sons of Noah refers to Noah’s sons and their descendants.

According to their genealogies, in their nations: genealogies refers to the history of the line of descent of an individual, family, clan, tribe, or nation from an original pair of ancestors, and here reckoned only as descended from an original male ancestor. According to … nations means classified or grouped together by common descent and by political groupings. Bible en français courant translates “Such were the clans that came from the sons of Noah, according to their lists of descendants, nation by nation.” Biblia Dios Habla Hoy says “These were the clans of the sons of Noah, according to their lines of descent and their territories.” Good News Translation has reversed the order of genealogies and nations to say “Nation by nation, according to their lines of descent.” We may also translate, for example, “All of these groups of people are the offspring of Noah’s sons. Each had its own line of descent and each its own nation.”

And from these the nations spread abroad on the earth after the flood: these points to the families of the sons of Noah at the beginning of the verse. Good News Translation begins with “After the flood,” and many other languages will find this more natural. Spread abroad translates the same verb used in Gen 10.5. Biblia Dios Habla Hoy translates “After the flood they were scattered everywhere and so formed the nations of the world.” New English Bible says “and from them came the separate nations on earth after the flood.” Both of these along with Good News Translation are suitable models for translating.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 10:12

Resen: nothing more is known of this place than its location as given in this verse.

That is the great city refers here to Calah, possibly because of its being the residence of the king. Some interpreters believe that is the great city refers to all four of the cities named, on the basis that all four were located close to each other and thought of by foreigners as a single city. Translators generally follow the first view and associate this description with Calah: “Between Nineveh and the great city of Calah” (Good News Translation); or we may say, for example, “between Nineveh and Calah, which is the great city” or “between the great city called Calah and the city of Nineveh.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 11:1

Verses 1 and 2 provide the background setting of the story. In languages that require that the place be named first, it may be necessary to switch verses 1 and 2.

Now the whole earth …: Now translates “And it was,” which functions here as a story opener. New English Bible takes it to be the equivalent of the English story opener, “Once upon a time,” but Revised English Bible has revised this to “There was a time when,” which removes it somewhat from the category of a pure fairy tale in English. Good News Translation has “At first…,” and this expression is suitable in many languages, because it is the natural way of referring to a time long ago. Some translations do not represent this opening form but begin with the statement “The whole earth had….”

Many languages have story openers for texts that explain how something came to be; for example, “This is the way the world once was,” or “Long ago it happened like this,” or “In the time of the ancestors it was so.” In some cases the natural structure of this type of narrative may call for something that occurs later in the biblical text to be brought to the beginning as an introduction; for example, “This is [a story about] how there came to be many languages in the world. Long ago….”

Whole earth in this context refers, as Good News Translation says, to “the people of the whole world.” We may also say “everybody in the world,” or simply “everybody.” Had one language is literally “one lip.” This does not refer to “accent” or “manner of speaking” but to the language as a means of communication. The sense is “spoke only one language” or “spoke the same language.”

Few words: this Revised Standard Version rendering is one interpretation of the Hebrew phrase. But New Revised Standard Version and most others understand the phrase to mean “the same words.” Some translations say “spoke the same language with the same vocabulary.”

The combination of “one language” and “the same words” is probably a poetic emphasis on the unity of the language the people heard spoken. Taken literally the addition of “the same words” is redundant, since two people speaking a common language use the same words. Accordingly Biblia Dios Habla Hoy says “Everybody spoke the same language.” Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch says “People still had at that time a single language.”

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:25

Note that both Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation, like most other modern versions, print verses 25-27 in indented lines. This is to show the somewhat poetic form of these lines. The lines are short and the thoughts tightly compressed. Verse 25 begins with a curse on Canaan that is balanced in 26-27 with blessings for Shem and Japheth. Each of the verses ends with a refrain concerning the slave status of Canaan in relation to his brothers. The content of this short passage can be more effectively read if it is printed in lines that reveal its poetic structure.

If we take the story as a simple narrative, it seems very strange that Noah’s curse is against Canaan rather than against Ham. One explanation of this is that the words for “Ham the father of” in verse 22 should be dropped, so that it was in fact Canaan who saw the naked Noah. This of course conflicts with other details in the text of chapters 9 and 10.

Others suggest that the purpose of these verses is to lay the groundwork for the later conflict between the descendants of Shem (Israelites) and the descendants of Canaan (Canaanites) in the taking of the promised land. Thus Cursed be Canaan is thought to be a curse that really relates to the subjugation of the Canaanites to Israel. Furthermore, the association of the curse of Canaan with sexual misbehavior is interpreted as being related to Canaanite sexual practices in their religious life. In this regard Lev 18.24-30 is often cited.

Another school of thought attaches to the names of Shem, Ham, Japheth, and Canaan a bewildering array of nations, but with little or no historical evidence. However, it is also possible that these names are the names of individuals, and that they should not be associated with anyone but themselves.

Also to be considered is the suffering of children for the sins of the fathers, a theme that is put forward and later opposed in the Old Testament.

While there may be some truth in these explanations, they do not solve for translators the problems associated with the use of the name Canaan in the text that they have to translate. As the text stands there seem to be two possibilities open to translators.
(1) The first is to understand that the curse is really against Ham, but that it is directed against his son Canaan because the effect of the curse is for future generations. But if this is the case, there is a problem in the use of the term his brothers at the end of the verse, since that reference must be to Shem and Japheth. There are, however, other places in Genesis where the Hebrew ʾach, which normally means “brother,” is used of other close male relatives; Revised Standard Version translates the term “kinsman” or “kinsmen” in 13.8; 14.14, 16; 29.12, 15. One recent translation, for instance, has a footnote which says that the Hebrew term for “brothers” can also mean “uncles” (literally “relatives on the father’s side”). This approach is recommended for translators in situations where an explanation like this about kinship terms is meaningful.
(2) The second possibility is to take the name Canaan as being used as a substitute for the name of the person who is really intended, Ham. In some cultures and languages where the avoidance of personal names is normal, the name of the son of a person is automatically substituted for the person’s own name; and the text as it stands is naturally taken that way in these language situations. Where this is not the case, a note can give this explanation to readers; and this is recommended for translators who are not able to follow (1) above.

Cursed translates a form of the same verb used in 3.14 and also in 3.17; 4.11; 5.29. See 3.14 for discussion. In languages that do not use the passive, it will often be necessary to restructure Cursed be to say, for example, “I curse Canaan,” “Canaan, I curse you,” or as Good News Translation “A curse on Canaan.” In languages that have a regular formula for cursing, that formula will usually be appropriate in this context.

A slave of slaves translates what is literally “slave slaves,” which is a kind of superlative meaning “the lowest of slaves,” “the most miserable slave.” Speiser says “The phrase points evidently to the inferior social and political status of Canaanites.” He goes on to ask “Was this an accomplished fact at the time of composition, or is the allusion no more than a wishful projection into the future, as the context would seem to suggest?” Slave translates the Hebrew word for a male slave or servant. The reference here is to someone who is fully under the authority and control of a master.

In some languages there is no term for slave but only something akin to “worker” or “employee.” In these cases it may be necessary to say, for example, “You will be the poorest of all your brothers’ workers,” “You will work for your brothers harder than any other worker,” or “Your brothers will force you to work more than any other worker.” Translators should consider providing a footnote, if the term for “slave” is not suitable.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:26

Blessed by the LORD my God be Shem: Blessed is a form that is parallel grammatically to “cursed” in verse 25. The translation of Revised Standard Version requires that the word for God be read ʾelohay instead of ʾelohe, as the text is written. This is a very minor change that affects no consonant. Some translations follow Revised Standard Version in this, as it seems to give Shem a blessing just as Canaan is given a curse. The curse in Canaan’s case is to be made a slave to his brothers. By contrast the blessing in Shem’s case is without content. We are forced to ask then what Blessed means. We see this most clearly by interpreting this line according to the Hebrew, which is given in a footnote in Revised Standard Version: “Blessed be the LORD, the God of Shem,” in which Blessed is to be translated as “Praise” or “Give praise to.” See Good News Translation.

In some languages “Praise the LORD” or “Give praise to the LORD” must be restructured as a direct quotation, and the basis for the praise must be provided. For example, “Let people say the LORD is great, wonderful, mighty,” or “Everyone should say, ‘LORD God of Shem, you are great.’ ” A further adjustment may also be required, since in some languages it is not natural for someone to possess or own God, as in the expression “God of Shem.” Accordingly we may have to say, for example, “… the God Shem worships” or “… the God Shem serves.”

Good News Translation‘s “the LORD, the God of Shem” may be understood to be two rather than one and the same God. Therefore it may be necessary to say, for example, “The LORD, who is the God Shem serves.” The full expression may sometimes be rendered “Let everyone say that the LORD is wonderful. He is the God Shem serves,” or “Let people say, ‘LORD, you are wonderful. You are the God Shem worships.’ ”

And let Canaan be his slave repeats the curse of Canaan: “May Canaan be Shem’s slave” or “Canaan will be the slave of Shem” (Good News Translation). This thought serves as a refrain that is repeated again at the end of verse 27.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Genesis 9:27

God enlarge Japheth: enlarge translates the causative command form of a verb meaning to extend, increase, or make room for. The sense is that Japheth or his descendants should become numerous and require much space. At the same time Noah is making a play on words. In Hebrew to enlarge is yapat, and “Japheth” is Yepet; see Good News Translation footnote. Revised English Bible translates “May God extend Japheth’s boundaries,” and Good News Translation “… cause Japheth to increase.” Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch says “and he [God] lets the descendants of Japheth spread out.” We may also say “May God cause Japheth to have many descendants and spread out over the land” or “… and live throughout the land.”

The expression “May God cause…” is actually a wish that God will act, or a prayer or request to God to act in the way referred to. In some languages this will need to be made clear, since there are no forms or aspects of verbs that carry this sense by themselves. For instance, in one language verse 27 begins “This is my prayer, that God will….”

Let him dwell in the tents of Shem: him refers to Japheth, but most likely as the representative of his line of descendants. Dwell translates a verb meaning to “live,” or “settle.” The expression dwell in the tents of is an idiom that is used sometimes of invaders driving their enemies out and taking over their territory. See 1 Chr 5.10; Psa 78.55. In Psa 84.10 the expression is used metaphorically: “I would rather be a doorkeeper in the house of my God than dwell in the tents of wickedness.” See also Psa 120.5. In the context of verses 24-27 dwell in the tents of Shem most likely refers to some form of cooperation or peaceful coexistence between the descendants of the two brothers; Moffatt translates “May he be welcome in the tents of Shem.” Speiser says it is not possible to fit these conditions with any certainty to a historical period in the land of Canaan. Most modern translations only suggest that peaceful conditions prevail. For example, “May his descendants live with the people of Shem” (Good News Translation), “May he live in the camps of Shem” (Biblia Dios Habla Hoy), “May he have his dwelling with Shem” (Bible en français courant). All of these are suitable models to translate. In two Pacific translations this idea of living together in peace is expressed as “… and they [the descendants of Japheth] stay in peace with the descendants of Shem.”

And let Canaan be his slave repeats the refrain for the final time. In some languages the term “also” or a similar term may be required in this context, since this statement is not meant to contradict or change what is stated earlier at the end of verse 26; Canaan is to be the slave of Shem and the slave of Japheth too.

Quoted with permission from Reyburn, William D. and Fry, Euan McG. A Handbook on Genesis. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .