But when can be “For your part, on those occasions when…” or “Instead, whenever….”
Room translates a Greek word that refers to a small storeroom attached to the Jewish house. It would have been the only room provided with a door, and at least one commentator observes that it had become almost a proverbial expression for a place where one could go and not be seen. Elsewhere in the New Testament it occurs only three times: Matthew 24.26; Luke 12.3, 24. Some commentators note that go into your room and shut the door is almost a verbal assimilation to the Septuagint of Isaiah 26.20; only in Isaiah the context is that of a threat to hide from the Lord’s anger. These same commentators also call attention to 2 Kings 4.33, where Elisha “went in and shut the door upon the two of them and prayed to the Lord.”
For many translators, go into your room and shut the door poses no problem. Sometimes your room becomes “a room,” “a part of the house,” or “a part of your compound (or, living quarters).” In languages where houses perhaps normally do not have rooms with doors, then the way to say this is “Go into a room where you can be alone” or “Go to a place (in your house) where you will be alone.”
Father here, as throughout the passage, is God. Some translations will say “God, who is your Father.” See comments on 5.16.
The meaning of the Greek structure translated who is in secret is unclear. Compare the expression as it occurs in Matthew 6.4. A number of translations maintain the literalism of the Greek text, but others try to make some meaning of the strange expression. Good News Translation and New International Version have “who is unseen”; others go in the direction of New Jerusalem Bible: “who is in that secret place” (see New English Bible, Bible en français courant). New American Bible translates “pray to your Father in private.” In favor of the interpretation given in New Jerusalem Bible and New American Bible is the clause who sees in secret, which suggests that the emphasis is upon the Father’s ability to see what takes place, because he is there in that private place. If translators follow the lead of Good News Bible and New International Version in translating who is in secret, they may say “whom nobody can see” or “that no one sees.” Those who follow the interpretation of New Jerusalem Bible and New American Bible will have a phrase such as “who is in that private place” or “who is there (where you are praying).”
The translation of who sees in secret will then be similar: “Your Father who sees what you do in secret (or, private),” “who sees what others can’t see,” or “your Father who sees what you do there (or, in that private place).”
Will reward you repeats the last part of verse 4.
Quoted with permission from Newman, Barclay M. and Stine, Philip C. A Handbook on the Gospel of Matthew. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1988. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.