Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 21:9

It may be wise to translate the pronoun he at the beginning of this verse by the name “David” in some languages, since a number of other persons have been talked about in the previous verse.

Gave them into the hands of the Gibeonites: that is, David turned the seven descendants of Saul over to the Gibeonites. Some other possible models for translating the verb here are “gave,” “delivered,” or “surrendered [them]” (New American Bible).

Hanged: see the comments on this verb at verse 6 above.

The mountain: if the textual problem of verse 6 is resolved in such a way as to do away with the reference to the mountain of the LORD, then the use of the definite article with the word mountain here is a problem. What specific mountain does this refer to? New Century Version takes it as a nonspecific reference and translates “a hill.” It is, however, more likely that the definite article designates a specific mountain located near a place where the people of Israel worshiped the LORD.

Before the LORD: see verse 6 above.

Perished: literally “fell.” Anchor Bible speaks of the seven “lying prostrate together.” But this verb is often used in the Old Testament as an euphemism for “died” (New Century Version), and this is the most likely meaning in this context.

In the first days of the harvest …: this whole phrase may be more literally rendered “in the days of harvest, during the first ones, at the beginning of the harvest of barley.” Barley was one of the first grain crops harvested (see the comments on 14.30); it was brought in during the month of April well before the wheat crop, which was harvested in early May in the Jordan valley. Compare Ruth 1.22. Some commentators see this timing as an attempt to show that the killing of these men was somehow related to the offering of the first fruits, but probably it is only a time reference that all readers were able to understand. The overall meaning of the phrase in question may be easily translated “at the very beginning of the harvest of barley,” or possibly by two separate sentences as in New Century Version, “They were put to death during the first days of the harvest season. (The barley harvest was just beginning.)”

This time reference is also related to the time mentioned in the following verse.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 22:28

While the parallel in Psa 18 has the Hebrew transition word rendered “For” in Revised Standard Version at the beginning of this verse, this seems unnecessary here, since no cause and effect relation between verses 27 and 28 seems indicated.

Deliver translates the verb translated “save” in 3.18, “gave victory” in 8.6, 14, and “help” in 10.11, 19; 14.4. The same term is used in verses 3 and 4 of this chapter.

A humble people: the word translated humble is elsewhere “poor” (Exo 22.25), “the afflicted” (Psa 9.12), and “the meek” (Psa 10.17). The Hebrew word refers to people who have been humbled by difficult circumstances, who have been taken advantage of.

The parallel in Psa 18 here reads “haughty eyes thou dost bring down,” and this reading from Psa 18 has been assimilated into this verse in 2 Samuel in the Septuagint and the ancient Syriac. This is the basis for the New Jerusalem Bible translation, “You … humiliate those with haughty looks.” But according to the Masoretic Text, here in 2 Samuel the wording is different. In this case the “eyes” are those of Yahweh, and the haughty refers to proud people who are contrasted with humble people in the previous line. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament gives an {A} rating to the Masoretic Text.

The verb bring … down translates the causative form of a verb meaning “to be low.” It means “to humiliate, shame, defeat” (in contrast with deliver in line a). The act of “bringing down” or “lowering” the haughty (or “high”) is a play on words involving the idea of downward movement. In some languages this same wordplay can be maintained. For example, “but you lower the heads of those who carry them high” or “but you bend people down who put their noses up.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 2 Samuel 23:17

Far be it from me: on this emphatic way of denying an action, see 20.20. Compare also Gen 44.17; 1 Sam 2.30; 12.23; Job 27.5. Several versions use exclamation marks in an attempt to show how strong this is. Some possible alternative ways of wording this denial are “There is no way that I will do this” or “I cannot possibly drink this.” Revised English Bible includes the reference to God by saying “The LORD forbid that I should do such a thing.” In some languages this may be a good solution to the problem of the position of the vocative, O LORD. But others may simply shift it forward to the beginning of the sentence, as Good News Translation has done.

Do this: it will be appropriate in many languages to spell out more clearly the fact that this refers to drinking the water that the three men had brought to David. Instead of do this translators may say “drink this water.”

When David asks the question Shall I drink the blood of the men who went at the risk of their lives? he is really making another extremely strong statement of something that he could not do. But even if the question is changed into an affirmative statement, there is still the matter of figurative language that may be very misleading to some readers. David is not talking about literally drinking blood, but about drinking water that men had risked their lives to bring to him. Some translators may prefer to make the question into a comparison and say something like “It would be like drinking the blood of the men….”

Therefore: this translates the common Hebrew conjunction, but such a rendering may be considered appropriate in this context.

The last sentence of this verse is actually a kind of summary statement about the three famous soldiers, and for this reason it is a separate paragraph in most versions. Translators are advised to do likewise.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 18:6

The first part of this verse is absent from the Septuagint, As they … the Philistine, but textual scholars generally agree that it should be translated. It is, however, omitted by Klein.

As they were coming home: literally “And it happened when they were returning.” Neither Revised Standard Version nor Today’s English Version translate the discourse marker, which is traditionally rendered “and it came to pass.” But the marker may be important because it seems to introduce a kind of flash-back to something that happened prior to the events recorded in 18.1-5. The pronoun they may be ambiguous if translated literally. Revised English Bible restructures as follows: “At the homecoming of the army and the return of David from slaying the Philistine….” The Philistine refers, of course, to Goliath, whom David killed in 17.50. Today’s English Version names him but omits the information that he was a Philistine. Compare Bible en français courant, “After David had killed the Philistine Goliath.” See also Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, “When the troops returned from the battle against the Philistines, in which David had killed Goliath.”

Timbrels: the word timbrels in Revised Standard Version translates the same Hebrew word rendered “tambourine” in 10.5 (see the comment on that verse). There is no reason to use different terms for the two occurrences, so New Revised Standard Version has “tambourines” in both cases.

Songs of joy translates a singular noun in Hebrew, meaning “the expression of joy.” Some versions call these “cries of joy” (New Jerusalem Bible, Bible en français courant, and Osty-Trinquet). It is possible also to connect this noun more closely with the nouns preceding and following, indicating the manner in which the musical instruments were played, as in Revised English Bible, “rejoicing with tambourines and three-stringed instruments.” Because the context states that the women were singing and dancing, it seems justified to state that these were “songs of joy” (Revised Standard Version, Today’s English Version, New Revised Standard Version, and New American Bible). Some translators may find it more natural to translate the idea of singing only once, and shift the notion of joy to a different place in the verse. For example, one may say “singing joyfully and dancing.”

The Hebrew noun rendered instruments of music occurs only here in the Old Testament, and the exact meaning is unknown. It is not even certain that the word refers to a musical instrument. It is often assumed that this noun is based on the consonants of the Hebrew word “three,” which explains the renderings “triangles” and “three-stringed instruments” in the Revised Standard Version footnote. Revised English Bible renders “three-stringed instruments,” and Parola Del Signore: La Bibbia in Lingua Corrente, Fox, and Chouraqui say “triangles.”

The Septuagint calls these “cymbals” (so also Maredsous). Some translations (New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, Traduction œcuménique de la Bible, Osty-Trinquet, La Bible Pléiade, and Nueva Biblia Española) follow the Vulgate in calling these instruments “sistrums,” that is, thin metal frames with numerous metal rods or loops that jingle when shaken.

Since the meaning of this word is so uncertain, translators may prefer to follow the interpretation in the version most often used in their language area. Or they may choose to use a general expression such as “musical instruments” (so New Revised Standard Version and Bible en français courant).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 1:7

In some languages it may be necessary to avoid confusion by using the names “Peninnah” and “Hannah,” as in Good News Translation.

So it went on is literally “Thus he [or, it] did.” In certain languages this will be better translated “these things happened [habitually].” And in some cases the words year by year will have to be shifted to the beginning of the sentence.

As … she went up: the Hebrew verb form here is feminine singular, which is reflected in many translations (Revised Standard Version, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). The first occurrence of the pronoun she apparently refers to Hannah. Bible en français courant makes this explicit: “when Hannah went to the house of the Lord.” The second she (she used to provoke) refers to Peninnah. Some translations such as Good News Translation, New American Bible, and Revised English Bible translate the sense, that is, “they went,” since clearly both Hannah and Peninnah went to Shiloh each year. If there is any danger that the reader or hearer will think that Hannah went alone, then the Good News Translation model should be followed.

The house of the LORD (see the same phrase in 3.15) is called “the temple of the LORD” in verse 9. The ark was no longer kept in a tent as it had been during the years that the Israelites wandered in the wilderness. It was now kept in a building with a doorpost (verse 9) and at least two doors (3.15). The large temple in Jerusalem, however, was not yet in existence. It was not built until the reign of Solomon (1 Kgs 6).

Provoke: the same word as in verse 6.

Hannah wept is literally “she wept.” But for clarity it will probably be necessary to replace the pronoun with the name.

Though the Hebrew verb eat has no direct object, some languages require that one be supplied. In these cases it will be necessary to specify what was eaten, probably “the meat of the sacrifices,” although in some languages the more general expression “eat food” will be quite acceptable. This applies also to verses 8, 9, and 18.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 2:15

Moreover: this single Hebrew adverb seems to support the interpretation found in Good News Translation. That is, in addition to (Moreover) the corrupt practice of Eli’s sons in verses 13-14, they also took the meat before the fat was burned. The transition word is extremely important. In other translations it has been rendered “In fact” (New American Bible and Moffatt). Others are content with the use of “Even,” and Traduction Ĺ“cumĂ©nique de la Bible has “Even more,” which may be understood in the sense of “Even worse.”

Revised English Bible and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh, however, render this same Hebrew adverb “But now.” As already indicated, these translations suggest that what follows is not the continuation of wrong bhehavior but is rather the beginning of the description of wrong behavior by Eli’s sons.

Before the fat was burned: all of the fat belonged to God and was not to be eaten by the priests (see Lev 3.16-17; Num 18.17). For the sake of clarity some languages may have to say something like “before the fat was burned as an offering to God.”

Revised English Bible has been quoted above as an example of the interpretation that sees verses 13-14 as a statement of what the priestly practice should have been at Shiloh. This same interpretation is favored by Klein, whose translation of verses 13-15 is given here:
This is what was due the priest from the people: whenever someone was making a sacrifice, an attendant of the priest would come, while the meat was boiling, with a three-pronged fork in his hand, and he would thrust it into the caldron or cooking pot. Whatever the fork brought up, the priest would get for himself, but this is what they did to all Israel who came there, at Shiloh: Before they had burned the fat, the attendant of the priest would come and say to the person sacrificing….

It is difficult to know which interpretation of verses 13-15 is correct. Both make good sense, and both are possible readings of the Hebrew text. But it is very important that translators not mix the two interpretations; that is, verses 13-15 should be taken as a unit. If translators find it difficult to make a decision on this matter, it may be best to follow the model of the majority of modern versions, which includes Good News Translation.

The man who was sacrificing: since there is no special emphasis on the maleness of the person offering the sacrifice, it will be better in most cases to translate “the person who was sacrificing” (Revised English Bible) or “the one who was sacrificing” (New Revised Standard Version).

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 3:15

Samuel lay is a literal translation. “Stayed in bed” (Good News Translation) is idiomatic English. The Septuagint says “Samuel lay in bed until morning and got up early in the morning.” Some scholars think it is more likely that a scribe accidentally omitted the words “and got up early in the morning” from the Hebrew rather than thinking that the Greek translator added them. Anchor Bible, New American Bible, and La Bible Pléiade follow the Septuagint. But the absence of any comment on this matter by Hebrew Old Testament Text Project suggests that the traditional Hebrew text should be followed here. However, it is possible that the idea of “getting up” may be supplied for translation reasons, since it is clearly implied.

The house of the LORD: see the comments on this phrase in 1.7.

And: some languages may require a contrasting conjunction such as “but” (Revised English Bible) in this context, since it might be expected that Samuel would tell Eli about the vision. Receptor language usage will determine which kind of conjunction is used here. And in some cases there will be no conjunction at all.

Samuel was afraid: in English the repetition of the name Samuel, as in the Hebrew, is considered poor style; Good News Translation accordingly substitutes the pronoun “he” for the second occurrence of Samuel’s name in this verse.

The vision: the Hebrew word translated as vision in this verse is different from the Hebrew word translated by the same English word in verse 1. But no distinction in meaning is evident, and translators may use the same word or expression to translate these two different Hebrew terms.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Samuel 5:7

The men of Ashdod: the Hebrew word translated men is probably not intended to exclude women. While some modern translations retain the translation men (Revised English Bible), others use an inclusive word such as “inhabitants” (New Revised Standard Version) or “the people of Ashdod” (New Jerusalem Bible, New Century Version).

The verb they said may be better translated as a reciprocal form in some languages (“they said to each other”), since the content of this direct quotation is obviously something that was exchanged between the people of Ashdod.

The God of Israel: see the comments on 1.17.

For expresses the reason that the ark must not remain among the people of Ashdod. Good News Translation reverses the order of the clauses, stating the reason first. It also avoids wording that may give the impression that the ark acted on its own. So instead of “the ark … must not remain with us,” it will be better in some languages to say “we must not keep the ark … any longer.” It may also be more natural to transform the entire direct quotation into an indirect statement as follows:

• When they saw what was happening, they thought that the God of Israel was punishing them and their god Dagon. And they decided among themselves that they could no longer keep the Covenant Box.

On the meaning and translation of the words his hand is heavy upon us, see the comments on verse 6.

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .