Translation commentary on Nehemiah 10:34

Obligation 5—Supplying Firewood for the Altar. This was a pledge to provide the wood necessary to keep the fire burning on the altar. It was not timber or sticks and poles but was wood that was meant for burning. It was required by the law in Lev 6.12-13 that the fire on the altar be kept burning continually, but no provision was made for the supply of firewood. This lack is supplied here by a new obligation.

We have likewise cast lots: The Israelites used a set of objects to find God’s will and to determine what course of action to take. The Urim and Thummim were often used by the high priest to find God’s will (see Ezra 2.63), but here it is not known what objects were used. They might have been small pieces of wood or small stones or perhaps something with writing on it. Also the text does not indicate where they were made to fall. In Pro 16.33 these objects are dropped onto a person’s lap. Contemporary English Version avoids the issue of casting lots and renders this as “We have decided.” However, the mention of casting lots should not be omitted because in the Old Testament this method was commonly used in making decisions (also Neh 11.1). Good News Translation makes explicit that the purpose of casting lots was to decide whose turn it was to bring the firewood each year. Many languages have a general expression for casting lots, drawing lots or throwing lots. A term or expression that is closely identified with a receptor culture, such as “watching a crab,” should not be used, because it is too culture specific and could not be identified with Israel. If the receptor culture does not use casting lots, throwing dice or any other such system for making a choice, the translator may use another expression such as “We tested things to find God’s will.”

Revised Standard Version and most translations indicate that the casting of lots already took place (have cast … lots), but Good News Translation places it in the future (“will draw lots”). It is recommended that the interpretation of Revised Standard Version be followed.

Wood offering: This expression is found only here and in Neh 13.31, where Nehemiah draws attention to this offering as one of the special things for which he should be remembered. It was an offering in the sense that it was “contributed” (so New International Version) by the people for the Temple worship. It is firewood that was used for the fire on the altar; it was not other kinds of timber that might be used in Temple building or repairs.

According to our fathers’ houses, at times appointed, year by year: The fathers’ houses were the ancestral houses or clans of the priests, the Levites, and the people, that is, the laity. They were designated to provide firewood at appointed times each year. The text does not specify how the appointed times would be designated or who would determine when these “set times” (New International Version) or “fixed times” (New American Standard Bible) would occur (see Ezra 10.14).

For altar see Ezra 3.2.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 11:28

Ziklag was an important town in the time of David. It was located about 16 kilometers (10 miles) north of Beersheba.

Meconah is cited and its villages. Perhaps it is a matter of Hebrew style, but the preposition “in” occurs three times in this verse in Hebrew. It is repeated with both city names and with its villages. In the preceding verse the preposition occurs only with the city names. The translation here may therefore be “in Ziklag, in Meconah and in its villages,” although translators of this list tend to level out these minor stylistic differences.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 13:1

The repetition of On that day relates this new episode with the dedication of the wall and the provisions for the Temple personnel in the previous sections (see Neh 12.44).

They read from the book of Moses: In Hebrew they read is literally “it was read.” This was probably a liturgical reading of Scripture that was part of the dedication ceremony. Good News Translation understands this to refer not to one book of Moses but more generally to the “Law of Moses,” that is, the Torah (see Ezra 6.18). This reading from the book of Moses was from Deut 23.3-6. The summary here follows quite closely the wording of the original text in Deuteronomy. There is some abbreviation of that text. Here the third person pronoun they is used for Israel in place of the second person pronoun “you.” Also, “No Ammonite or Moabite shall enter the assembly of the LORD … to the tenth generation” in Deuteronomy is expressed explicitly here to mean no Ammonite or Moabite should ever enter the assembly of God.

In the hearing of the people is literally “in the ears of the people.” This means that the reading was “aloud” (Good News Translation, New International Version) so that the people could hear. This Hebrew idiom may also be understood in a more general sense to mean that the reading was public (so Bible en français courant). Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible renders this expression as “in the presence of the people,” and Revised English Bible calls it a “public reading.” Translators should use an equivalent expression that is natural in their language.

In it was found written: This is a fairly literal rendering of the Hebrew grammatical form (see also Neh 7.5; 8.14). Good News Translation restructures this expression in contemporary English to express the meaning more clearly. It may also be stated as follows: “as they were reading for the people to hear, they came upon the place where it was written that…” or “they found the writing that said….”

No Ammonite or Moabite should ever enter the assembly of God: Ammonite and Moabite refer to neighboring peoples who opposed the entry of Israel into the land of Canaan (see the comments at Ezra 9.1).

The assembly of God refers to the people of Israel as a religious community (see Ezra 2.64). This expression is found only here in the Old Testament. Elsewhere in the Old Testament the expression “the assembly of the LORD” (that is, YHWH) occurs 10 times (see Num 16.3). Bible en français courant makes explicit that “the assembly” refers to “those who worshiped God.” The prohibition of foreigners to enter the assembly relates specifically to their exclusion from the religious activities of the Temple. It does not prohibit them from being physically present among the Jews in Jerusalem and it does not apply to other relationships between Jews and foreigners.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 2:4

For what do you make request?: It was evident to the king from Nehemiah’s answer that he wanted to make a request. The king therefore asks what Nehemiah requests of him (compare Est 5.3; 7.2). His question to Nehemiah may appear to be brusque but it shows that he is ready to listen and respond to Nehemiah’s concern. This may have been not only because Nehemiah was in good standing with the king, but because it was the time of the New Year festival when the king granted favors to his servants. The translation should place the emphasis on what Nehemiah is requesting (so Bible en français courant, Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible), and not merely on what he wants the king to do (as in Contemporary English Version “What do you want me to do?”).

So I prayed to the God of heaven: At that point Nehemiah prayed a silent prayer to God. It is unusual to find reference to silent prayer in the Bible before the exile, but this became a more common form of personal piety after the exile. No specific indication is given of the content of this prayer, although perhaps it was that Nehemiah might make his request correctly or that the king would be willing to grant his request. The translator should make it clear that this was an internal prayer, a prayer in Nehemiah’s heart or in his thoughts. In some languages it is necessary to supply an object for the verb such as a filler noun: “pray thing.” If the receptor culture requires that what he prayed about be specified, then it may be appropriate for the translator to say “Then I prayed in my heart that the God of heaven would help me.”

For God of heaven, see Ezra 1.2.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 3:19

Ezer the son of Jeshua, ruler of Mizpah, repaired another section: Ezer, another Levite, repaired the next section. His father was Jeshua, who is referred to in Ezra 2.40 and 3.9. He was the ruler of the town of Mizpah. The ruler of the district of Mizpah was named in verse 15 above.

Opposite the ascent to the armory at the Angle: An armory is a building where weapons or “tools for war” are kept. This was probably a tower or guardhouse in the City of David to protect the royal building. The ascent could refer to steps or a path going up to the armory.

The Angle would normally mean a sharp turn in the wall, but another word is used for “corner” along with this word in the Hebrew of verse 24 (Revised Standard Version with “Angle” at the end of verse 24 and “corner” at the beginning of verse 25). It does not seem to refer to a specific point since it occurs in verses 19, 20, and 25 in connection with different features. Williamson (1985) has suggested that it means “a place where something is cut off or ends abruptly” such as an “ ‘escarpment’ (New English Bible) if it is a natural feature” or a “ ‘Buttress’… if it is an architectural feature.” According to this suggestion, the translation would be “opposite the ascent to the armory by the buttress [or, escarpment].” The Septuagint has translated the word for armory as “meeting point” and this is the basis of the Revised English Bible translation “opposite the point at which the ascent meets the escarpment.” This is a good model to follow here. For Angle see also 2 Chr 26.9.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 4:21

This verse summarizes the continuation of the work. Half of the people worked while the other half stood guard with their spears, as Good News Translation makes explicit. Since the builders no longer went home at night outside Jerusalem (see the next verse), Nehemiah was able to extend their working hours from the usual sunrise to sunset (see Deut 24.15) to all the daylight hours from the break of dawn till the stars came out. This brought the beginning of the work day from sunrise to the earliest light of the dawn, and the end of the work day from the time of sunset to the time when it was dark enough to see the stars. This added at least two hours to the work day. Translators must therefore be more precise than saying “from sunrise to sunset” as in New Living Translation. For easy understanding, Good News Translation provides a good model for the whole verse.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 6:11

Nehemiah completely refused to follow Shemaiah’s suggestion. In response he asked two questions. They are both rhetorical in nature; that is, both questions express a strong sense of doubt. The expected answer to the first question is clearly “No,” and in some versions both questions anticipate “No” for an answer (so New Revised Standard Version, New International Version, Good News Translation). For Nehemiah to run away and hide in the Temple “to save his life” would be to act like a coward. Furthermore, for him to enter the Temple without the right to do so would bring the penalty of death upon him.

Should such a man as I … what man such as I…?: The Hebrew word for man is used in the first question. In the second question the Hebrew asks literally “and who, such as I, would enter the Temple and would live?” In the first question the emphasis is on Nehemiah as a courageous and honorable man whose nature would not be to run away in the face of danger. In the second question the emphasis is on his status as a layperson who did not have the right to enter the Temple. According to the Law of Moses (see Num. 18.7), only the priests were to go near the altar and into the sanctuary. These places were reserved for the priests since they were near to the symbolic presence of God in the Most Holy Place. Anyone else who went there would be put to death. Amplified Bible makes this explicit by including within square brackets the following information: “where only the priests were allowed to go.” This explanation may be placed in a footnote, but not in the text.

And live: Two interpretations of the clause and the verb translated live are possible. The first is that it is a clause that states a result and the verb expresses the meaning “to remain alive.” The second is that it is a clause stating a purpose, so the verb has the meaning “to save his life.” The literal rendering of Revised Standard Version is easier to understand in the first sense (also Bible en français courant, Segond, Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible). The second meaning is stated explicitly in Good News Translation and in other versions (New Revised Standard Version, New International Version, New Jerusalem Bible, Revised English Bible, Contemporary English Version). Most of the newer translations interpret it as a purpose clause and that is recommended by this Handbook.

I will not go in: The Hebrew uses a verb of motion here, and Revised Standard Version adds the preposition in for precision (see also New Jerusalem Bible, Traduction ƓcumĂ©nique de la Bible). Good News Translation interprets Nehemiah’s response more generally and renders it with a verb of action. After the verb of motion, some languages will require a location; for example, “I will not enter the Temple” or “I will not go inside there.”

This conversation is very dramatic, and Nehemiah’s response is given with great emphasis as it is rendered in some contemporary versions. For the last clause New Living Translation says “No, I won’t do it!” Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch says “No, I’m not going!” and Parole de Vie has “No, I won’t go to the temple!” The drama is carried over into Nehemiah’s next action in verse 12.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Nehemiah 8:7

Verse 7 is a summary of what will be described in detail in the following verses 8 and 9.

Also … the Levites, helped the people to understand the law: All those who are named here were Levites. The role of the Levites was to teach the people the meaning of the Law (see 2 Chr 17.7-9). Nine of the thirteen Levites are named elsewhere in Nehemiah. Four, Jeshua, Bani, Sherebiah, and Hodiah, are found in Neh 9.4-5, where they stood on the platform when the people gathered to confess their sins. These four plus three others, Kelita, Hanan, and Pelaiah, are found in Neh 10.9-13, where they signed the agreement to keep God’s Law. Two others, Shabbethai and Jozabad, are called leaders of the Levites and are mentioned in Neh 11.16.

As indicated by the Revised Standard Version footnote, there is a textual problem with the Levites in this verse. The text reads literally “and the Levites,” with this phrase following the list of names. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh and Chouraqui both translate according to MT. Most versions, however, follow the example of the Vulgate and 1 Esdras 9.48 and understand the Levites to be in apposition to the list of names. Translators should follow the example of Revised Standard Version or the model of Good News Translation.

While the people remained in their places: The people stood still while the Levites were explaining the Law. New Jerusalem Bible translates “the people all kept their places.” Nouvelle version Segond rĂ©visĂ©e says “the people remained standing.” Whether the Levites moved around or stood in the midst of small groups is not indicated. Some translations like Good News Translation interpret this verse to say that the people stood up again from praying and then remained standing in their places while the Levites explained the Law to them.

Quoted with permission from Noss, Philip A. and Thomas, Kenneth J. A Handbook on Nehemiah. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2005. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .