This verse continues as a justification of all that is said of Christ in the preceding verse: âAll this is about him because….â The meaning of what follows is disputed. The Greek may mean: God decided to have his fullness dwell in Christ, or God’s fullness decided to dwell in Christ, depending on whether the neuter phrase pan to plÄrĆma is construed as an accusative, the object of the verb, or as nominative, the subject of the verb. (1) Object: Lightfoot; New English Bible, New American Bible, New International Version, Jerusalem Bible, Translatorâs New Testament, Barclay, Traduction ĆcumĂ©nique de la Bible, Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch, Twentieth Century New Testament; (2) Subject: Abbott, Moule; Phillips, Moffatt, Goodspeed. If taken as subject, the rendition of it must somehow personify what is, linguistically, an abstract concept, âall the fullnessâ (of God), which may be quite difficult. To have, as Revised Standard Version does, âin him all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell,â is not very satisfying.
It seems better to take âall the fullnessâ as object, and God as the (unexpressed) subject of the sentence: âit was God’s choice/decision/ pleasure (for the verb eudokeĆ compare 1 Cor 1.21, Gal 1.15; compare the noun eudokia in Eph 1.5, 9; Phil 2.13) to have all the fullness dwell in him.â Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch âIt was God’s will and plan.â
For it was by God’s own decision may be expressed more simply as âfor God himself decided.â
The full nature of God represents the Greek âall the fullness.â The passive noun plÄrĆma has been understood to mean either that which fills or completes, or the resulting state of fullness, completion (compare John 1.16, Eph 1.23, 3.19, 4.13, Col 2.9). (If, as seems probable, this word was being used by the false teachers in Colossae of the intermediary spiritual beings between God and creation, here it is used deliberately to counter that false notion and to assert that in Christ alone was the fullness of the divine nature, not interspersed among a number of intermediary beings.) There are extensive discussions of the word âfullnessâ in commentaries on Colossians and Ephesians. The view favored here, and expressed by the majority of translations, is that it means God’s complete nature (see also 2.9), undiminished, undiluted, and unshared with any âintermediariesâ between God and creation. It seems preferable to say âGod’s full nature lives/dwells in himâ than to say âGod in his fullness dwells in himâ (compare Translatorâs New Testament, Barclay, Bible en français courant), as though the person of God were exhausted by the incarnation.
Has in himself represents the Greek katoikeĆ, âto live,â âto be at homeâ (oikos, âhouse,â âhomeâ).
A literal rendering of the Son has in himself the full nature of God can lead to misunderstanding, for it might suggest that Christ simply possessed God inside of himself. A more satisfactory equivalent in some languages is âthe son is just like God.â A more elaborate way of expressing this meaning might be âwhat is characteristic of God is also characteristic of God’s Sonâ or âwhat makes God really God is also true of his Son.â
Quoted with permission from Bratcher, Robert G. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Colossians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1977. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .
