Translation commentary on 2 Chronicles 23:13

And when she looked, there was the king is literally “and she looked, and, behold, the king” (Jewish Publication Version). The Hebrew text does not have the verb was, but it contains the focusing particle to draw attention to the presence of the new king, who was in fact a rival to Queen Athaliah. This particle serves to dramatize Athaliah’s initial awareness of the presence of Joash in the position of royal power. Translators will find similar ways in their own language to heighten the drama of the account at this point. Since Joash had just been proclaimed king, Good News Translation and Bible en français courant render the king as “the new king.” Another possible rendering is “Joash, who had just been crowned king.”

Standing by his pillar at the entrance: His pillar probably refers either to the one named Jachin or the one named Boaz at the Temple entrance (see 2 Chr 3.15-17).

And the captains and the trumpeters beside the king: Captains renders the same Hebrew word translated “commanders” in verse 1 (see the comments there). This word may be rendered “leaders of the soldiers” or “military commanders.” Good News Translation says “army officers.” Revised English Bible follows the Septuagint and the Vulgate of the parallel passage in 2 Kgs 11.14 by saying “outbursts of song,” but this reading is not recommended. The trumpeters may be rendered “the people playing/blowing the trumpets” or “the trumpet players” (Contemporary English Version). For “trumpet” see the comments on 1 Chr 13.8.

And all the people of the land rejoicing and blowing trumpets: According to some commentators, all the people of the land refers to a distinct social group in the kingdom of Judah. As a group they apparently held a certain authority in matters related to royal appointments and crowning of kings. In the book of Jeremiah they are listed along with groups like the kings of Judah and its princes and its priests (Jer 1.18; 34.19; 44.21). Probably a note will be required to explain that this expression refers to a particular group and not to people in general. The same phrase is repeated in verses 20 and 21.

And the singers with their musical instruments leading in the celebration: The singers refers to the Temple musicians, who were Levites (see 1 Chr 25 and the comments on 1 Chr 6.33).

And Athaliah rent her clothes: Usually the tearing of clothing is a sign of extreme sorrow at the time of the death of a beloved person (2 Sam 13.31) or a leader (2 Sam 1.11) or at the time of some other great calamity (2 Kgs 6.30). But here it shows Athaliah’s great anguish over the fact that someone else had been made ruler of Judah in her place. In languages where this gesture is not practiced as a sign of grief, it may be necessary to supply this information in translation by adding “in despair” (New Living Translation) or “in distress” (Good News Translation).

And cried is literally “and said.” The verb here is better rendered “shouted” (Good News Translation) or “screamed” (New Century Version).

Treason! Treason!: This cry of Queen Athaliah uses the same Hebrew root word that is translated “conspiracy” in the stories of Absalom (2 Sam 15.12) and of Zimri (1 Kgs 16.20). Athaliah considered herself the rightful ruler of Judah and felt that her authority had been illegally taken from her and given to another person. Some will be able to reflect the form of the original text by translating with a noun meaning “plot,” “maneuver” or “intrigue” repeated twice. But others may require a clause such as “They have taken my power!” or “They have dethroned me!” La Bible du Semeur translates “It’s a conspiracy! It’s a conspiracy!” Contemporary English Version has “You betrayed me, you traitors.”

Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on 1-2 Chronicles, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2014. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted