When all Israel heard that Jeroboam had returned: See verses 2-3a. In some languages it may be necessary to state where Jeroboam had been (“from Egypt” in Good News Translation and Nova Tradução na Linguagem de Hoje) or where he had returned (“to the country” in Moffatt).
For all Israel, see the comments on verse 1. Contemporary English Version states in a footnote on this verse, “From this time on, ‘Israel’ usually refers to the northern kingdom, and ‘Israelites’ refers to the people who lived there. The southern kingdom is called ‘Judah.’ ” Rather than rely on footnotes, however, translators are encouraged to make this information explicit and clear in the text itself (see the comments on verse 16).
They sent and called him: See verse 3. Here the meaning of the verbs sent and called together is simply “summoned” (New American Bible, New Jerusalem Bible). But some may prefer to say “they sent messengers and summoned him” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh).
The assembly: Other renderings include “a meeting of the people” (Good News Translation) and “a popular assembly” (Moffatt). As noted earlier, verse 20 seems to contradict the information in verse 3. According to verse 3, the people had called Jeroboam to be with them when they had their first meeting with Rehoboam (verses 3-5). But verse 20 seems to imply that Jeroboam is meeting now for the first time with the people of the northern tribes. In any case, Jeroboam was not made king until verse 20. Some interpreters solve this difficulty by saying that the Hebrew noun for assembly in verse 3 refers to an assembly of representatives, while the different Hebrew noun here in verse 20 refers to the people as a whole. See the comments on verse 3 regarding these two Hebrew nouns.
There was none that followed the house of David, but the tribe of Judah only: Revised Standard Version follows the form of the Hebrew here. New Jerusalem Bible is similar with “no one remained loyal to the House of David, except the tribe of Judah.” In some languages it will be more natural to avoid the none … but construction and state this positively as in Good News Translation.
That the tribe of Judah only remained loyal to Rehoboam fulfilled the prophecy of the prophet Ahijah (1 Kgs 11.35-36). This statement seems to contradict the evidence of verses 21-24 that both Judah and Benjamin remained loyal. Perhaps the difference is explained by the fact that the tribe of Judah absorbed the small tribe of Benjamin and the two came to be regarded as a single tribe. Later writers often refer to “Judah and Benjamin” as a single unit (for example, 2 Chr 11.1, 3, 12, 23; 14.8; 15.2; Ezra 1.5; 4.1; Neh 11.36). The Septuagint translation of this verse and of verse 23 says “Judah and Benjamin,” but this reading is clearly not original and should not be followed.
Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on 1-2 Kings, Volume 1. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2008. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .
