Translation commentary on Hosea 7:6

In 7.5 Revised Standard Version uses past tense, while in 7.6-7 it uses present tense, making past events more vivid through the present tense. In most languages it is better not to make this shift, but to express all three verses in present (New International Version, De Nieuwe Bijbelvertaling) or past tense (Good News Translation).

The Hebrew word ki rendered For is often a logical connector, but what follows does not give a reason for what goes before. Here this word is used to mark emphasis, so it is better translated “Surely.” Good News Translation‘s “Yes” expresses it well. The translator should use the proper expression in the receptor language for this emphasis.

Like an oven their hearts burn with intrigue: Instead of burn, the Hebrew text has “approach” (New International Version, NET Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh; see Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation footnotes), but Revised Standard Version, Good News Translation, and many other translations follow an emendation supported by the Septuagint. However, Hebrew Old Testament Text Project suggests retaining the Hebrew text and translating “they draw near, their heart [was] as if in an oven because of their plotting.” This rendering reflects the idea of the assailants gradually drawing nearer. Although this is a {B} decision, it is hard to follow Hebrew Old Testament Text Project, since the proposed translation does not make much sense. New International Version, NET Bible, and New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh connect the verb “approach” in different ways with the rest of the text, but in all cases elements of the text must be reshaped to accommodate the translation. It is therefore recommended to use the verb burn. It makes better sense in the present context.

Like an oven brings us back to the simile of verse 4, and again the picture is of an oven kept warm by a smoldering fire until it is time to stir up the fire to bake bread. Their hearts means their inner beings. Good News Translation simply says “they.” The Hebrew word for intrigue refers to the treacherous plot; it reflects the idea of planning to trap or attack someone.

All night long their anger smolders: The Hebrew here is actually “all the night their baker slept.” The word for “their baker” is likely a play on words, since in Hebrew their anger has the same consonants as “their baker,” and only the Masoretic vowel points are different. Many Hebrew manuscripts, the Peshitta, and the Aramaic Targum support the reading followed by Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation, although Hebrew Old Testament Text Project is undoubtedly correct in assuming that there is a reference here to a baker as leader in the plot. Yet the primary thought to convey is that of Revised Standard Version. It is unlikely that any translator will be able to retain such a play on words in the receptor language. No matter which decision is used for the translation, the alternative should be given in a footnote, if the translators use footnotes. The verb smolders continues the comparison of the plotters’ anger with a fire in an oven burning very slowly through the night.

In the morning it blazes like a flaming fire: This line refers again to their anger, which bursts forth, like the fire stirred up in the oven, ready for baking bread. Some languages will find that it blazes like a flaming fire is redundant. Good News Translation‘s “it burst into flames” may be a useful model to follow.

Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch changes some of the imagery in this verse into nonfigurative language: “They burn [that is, are eager] to take action; but the whole night they hold themselves back. Only in the morning do they attack.” A model that keeps all the imagery is:

• Indeed, they are kindled like an oven,
their hearts burning as they plot,
their anger glowing all night.
In the morning it rages like fire.

Quoted with permission from Dorn, Louis & van Steenbergen, Gerrit. A Handbook on Hosea. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2020. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments