Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 2:2

Understanding the structure of the verse will help our translation. It speaks about two attitudes to life, each represented by a prepositional phrase, “concerning laughter,” and “concerning pleasure.” These stand at the head of each half of the verse. The one verb I said serves both halves. Such a structure reminds us that both halves of the verse say basically the same thing.

I said of laughter is literally “Concerning laughter, I said.” The expression I said here points to a conclusion Qoheleth is making: “I saw that,” “I found out that,” “I discovered.” By drawing the object to the front of each clause, the author draws special attention to it. Laughter is a term Qoheleth uses several times, usually with a negative sense (see 7.3). As laughter is generally our response to an amusing situation, we can recognize that Qoheleth is not testing laughter itself, but rather a light-hearted attitude to life. We must not lose sight of the question Qoheleth is asking as he examines these experiences. He wants to know what will provide the “lasting benefit.” He concludes that these two things, failure to take life seriously and seeking material success, cannot give lasting benefit, even though both are perfectly good and proper in themselves.

It is mad: note the discussion in 1.17 about the translation of “madness.” We need a word that suggests it is unable to give “lasting benefit.”

For translation: “Failure to take life seriously is dangerous” or “If we are too light-hearted we are being stupid.”

Of pleasure: again the noun is brought forward in the prepositional phrase heading the sentence. See the discussion in verse 1 for the meaning of “pleasure.”

Qoheleth varies his expression in the second half of the verse, using a rhetorical question to express the conclusion he reached. He asked himself What use is it? or “What did it accomplish?” We may wish to preserve the question form, or if a negative statement is more natural, we can say “It accomplished nothing either.” Again we remind ourselves that the background for the saying is the search for “lasting benefit,” so the meaning is that pleasure could not give such benefit.

For translation:

• I saw that it is foolish to be too light-hearted. What does pleasure accomplish anyway?

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 3:8

A time to love does not necessarily have sexual nuances and can be broader in meaning, speaking also of the love between a father and son, or between God and people. It denotes a caring attitude toward another person. Also in Scripture the word speaks more of loving action than of simple emotion: “A time to act lovingly [or, caringly].”

A time to hate should not be thought of as encouraging a person to hate someone else. When Good News Translation says “He sets the time for … hate,” it seems inappropriate, for Qoheleth never suggests that God agrees with that kind of activity. It is also not clear whether love and hate are to be used with human objects in mind. Quite possibly Qoheleth is thinking of the right time for these activities in a figurative sense. For example, we should “love good” and “hate evil.” Once again the translator should guard against making the translation more precise than the original.

Two models for translation are:

• There are times when people are loving, and there are times when they are hateful.

• There are right times for loving and right times for hating.

A time for war indicates that people go to war only at certain times and in response to certain situations. For example, battles in the ancient world were not usually fought when there were crops to be harvested (see 2 Sam 11.1).

A time for peace balances the saying and indicates that there are times when wholeness, security, and well-being are best attained. The Hebrew term rendered as peace (shalom) refers not just to the absence of war, but describes a situation of total well-being. However, in the present context a word like “peace” or “not fighting” can be used.

As noted earlier the last line of the poem differs from the rest of the poem in that it uses noun forms, “war” and “peace,” in place of verb forms. This is a stylistic way of marking the end of the poem. Indeed the question that follows in verse 9 clearly indicates a change in direction and thought and thus marks a new paragraph. If the translator’s language has a special way of noting the close of a poem, then that is what should be considered for use here.

What Qoheleth sets forth in these twenty-eight contrasting actions is a selection of general activities, all of which are undertaken at given moments in time. For those involved in these activities there are moments when one action is appropriate and others when it is not. Time and action are coordinated, says Qoheleth.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 5:3

This saying has all the features of a quotation, which Qoheleth uses to support the imperatives of verses 1-2. Verse 2 asserts that our words should be few. There is an element of contrast between the wise person and the fool who talks too much. A parallel structure is another feature of this verse: dream and fool’s voice balance each other, as do the adverbial phrases using much and many.

For a dream comes with much business: it is hard to see how this clause relates to the rest of the passage and its theme of worship (verses 1-7). If, however, Qoheleth is quoting a well-known proverb, it is probable that this line is part of that proverb. It’s function is to set the pattern for his own message in the second line. A similar example occurs in 10.1, where the first line introduces Qoheleth’s own thought in the second line.

A dream may come in the form of a vision while a person is asleep, or it may be a daytime activity as our thoughts wander. It can also signal our hopes or longings for the future. Which of these does Qoheleth have in mind? If the first line is a proverb providing the model for the second line, then dream has a negative sense. Good News Translation is then correct to say “bad dreams.”

Business: see comments at 3.9. It has the sense here of work with effort rather than a commercial sense. A word like “worry” seems an appropriate way to think of it. New Revised Standard Version suggests “many cares.”

And a fool’s voice with many words: the phrase a fool’s voice has a broader sense than the mere sound of his voice. It includes all that he says. Many words will refer to the great amount of talking that a fool often does, as well as the sense that it is not worth listening to. By adding the adjective “empty” we can convey Qoheleth’s idea adequately: “what a fool says is all empty chatter.” New English Bible is correctly neutral with its rendering “the fool talks and it is so much chatter.”

Translators should make sure that these two lines demonstrate this verse’s parallel thought and structure. “Much” and “many” are common to both lines. For example:

• As dreams go hand-in-hand with many cares,
So does foolish talk with many words.

• You worry too much, you dream bad dreams.
You speak too much, you speak foolishness.

• With many cares, you have nightmares.
With many words, you speak foolishness.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 7:4

The two phrases house of mourning and house of mirth (or, feasting) are the major inclusions binding together verses 2-4. The saying here moves away from the “better” form to a contrastive form typical of sayings in the Book of Proverbs. Structurally there is a perfect balance between the two halves of the verse. The verse repeats the keyword “heart” (also found in 2 and 3) twice. This word provides the transition from verse 3 to verse 4: “improves the heart … (4) the heart of the wise….”

The heart of the wise: heart refers to the person’s mind or intellectual activity. The wise, of course, refers to wise people in general. In many languages it will be more natural to speak directly of a wise person than to speak of his heart or mind. Though the form is plural in Hebrew (literally “those who are wise”), in some languages a singular form, “wise person,” will be more natural.

The wise person’s mind is in the house of mourning. This latter is a noun phrase, so the verb must be supplied. Revised Standard Version is does not tell us very much. The sense is that the person’s thoughts focus on the significance of what happens in the house of mourning; hence Good News Translation “a wise person thinks about….” It is not impossible to maintain the “house of mourning” imagery; for example, New English Bible “a wise man’s thoughts are at home in the house of mourning” or New Jerusalem Bible “wise men are drawn to a house of mourning” approach the sense well.

Two possibilities for translation are:

• The wise person considers the significance of mourning [the dead].

• A wise person ponders the meaning of death.

But the heart of fools refers likewise to the mind or thought processes of fools. This second half of the verse provides the contrasting element typical of most proverbs. Though the Hebrew conjunction used here may also mean “and,” in this context it clearly means “but.” A concessive type of conjunction such as “while” may also be appropriate.

Is in the house of mirth is identical in meaning to the “house of feasting” in verse 2, though the term mirth is usually more positive than “feasting.” The link between “house of mirth” and the fool makes it quite clear that this is not a helpful or uplifting situation. Thus Good News Translation “thinking about happiness” is misleading. Again house of mirth is an expression for what happens in a place where people think only of enjoying themselves; it is not simply the place or house itself. It points to a totally careless attitude toward life, the mere seeking of pleasure. Translators should take care, however, that their translation of house of mirth does not refer to a house of prostitution. There is nothing in the context that would indicate this meaning.

Translators can follow these examples:

• while fools think only about having a good time.

• but fools would rather join those seeking a good time.

For the complete verse a model is:

• Wise people think about the meaning of death, but fools only think about enjoying themselves.

Good News Translation turns the order of the Hebrew sentences around and mentions foolish behavior first. In English this has the effect of putting emphasis on what a wise person should do and gives a concluding effect. If there are particular reasons for changing the order in other languages, the Good News Translation model is a possibility. However, we should make it obvious that the second example contrasts with the first by adding “but” or “however.” If not, it is probably wiser to leave the order of the original.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 8:9

Summarizing his observations is typical of the method Qoheleth uses. All this refers to the various situations listed in the previous verses, especially from verse 5, where a descriptive section commences. Rather than the Hebrew collective this, the context suggests “these” as a better translation in many languages.

Good News Translation links verse 9 with the following verses rather than with what has come before. We believe the evidence suggests that verse 9 continues the section 8.1-8 rather than beginning a new section. This verse contains important key terms and themes from the previous passage: the word “time,” the root “evil,” and most importantly the word shalat “have power over.” Therefore we suggest there should be no section heading before verse 9; it should come before verse 10.

I observed comes from the verb “see,” widely used in this book for Qoheleth’s examination of issues that concern him. Here the expression is even stronger, since a second phrase is added, while applying my mind. This second phrase is also often used by Qoheleth (1.13, 17; 2.3 for example). See comments on 1.13, 17 for the significance of these phrases.

To all that is done under the sun is literally “to all the deeds that are done under the sun.” For this typical phrase see comments on 1.14. All in this setting cannot mean “everything” in the absolute sense, but rather “many things” (or “matters”) in the broad sense. The passive form is done may have to be expressed as an active form in some languages, in which case a subject will have to be provided. One solution is to use the intransitive form “all that happens.” Otherwise we have the awkward problem of deciding whose deeds are observed—those of God, of people, or of both. The examples provided above leave the clear impression that the primary subject is “people”; they are the ones who have little control over what happens to them. Translating it as “all the matters that people have to deal with…” is a satisfactory solution.

While man lords it over man to his hurt: we note initially the appearance in this clause of “time,” and the root shlt, “have power over,” the keywords in verses 4-8. These features demonstrate that verse 9 is a summary statement based on the previous verses. However, it is probably correct to view this clause as an independent comment emphasizing the darker side of human experience.

Lords it over can be rendered as “dominates” or “controls” (in the negative sense). If possible a word should be chosen that will link to other verses where the same word or concept is presented. This will help preserve the literary unity of the passage as well as help the reader see the connection.

Although human beings do not have power to determine how long they will live, Qoheleth notes here that they do have the power to affect the lives of other people. Man can be rendered in two different ways in this verse according to the context. The first can be translated “one person” or a similar expression, and the second translated as “another,” in view of the fact that the subject and object are not the same person.

To his hurt in Hebrew is difficult to explain because the identity of the pronoun his is not clear. It can refer to the agent of the hurt as well as to the object of the hurt. Most commentators and translations choose the latter, but it is always possible that both are in mind, because oppressive actions tend to have a bad effect on both the oppressor and the oppressed. In such an independent comment as this is, the context provides no clue for precisely interpreting its details. We can render his here as “their mutual….” Hurt translates the customary Hebrew term for crisis or hardship, pain or suffering.

Beginning this final clause is the Hebrew noun for “time.” Fuller discussion of this term will be found in chapter 3, especially 3.1. Revised Standard Version while seems to give a different meaning to the noun here. It suggests a period in which people do a variety of things, rather than identifying a particular moment in time. We always depend upon the context to determine the full meaning of words used, and so it seems that the noun “time” in conjunction with the relative marker “which,” or “when,” does have the adverbial function noted in Revised Standard Version while. New English Bible expresses the same idea: “There was a time when….” Jerusalem Bible has “whenever.”

Suggestions for translation are:

• I observed all these things and thought about all that happens on this earth. Sometimes people control others and both suffer.

• All these things I studied carefully, thinking long and hard about all that happens in this world. People keep on dominating one another, to their own hurt.

• I took careful note of all those things that happen and cause hurt whenever one person tries to control another.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 10:6

Here the contrast is drawn between fools and rich persons, who occupy social positions that do not conform to their status. This is a case of “evil under the sun,” which Qoheleth refers to in the previous verse.

Folly as a noun represents an impersonal description of foolish people. See Good News Translation “stupid people.” Qoheleth says that they are set, from the verb meaning to “put” or “place.” This passive form is set lacks a definable subject, so we are at a loss to know what Qoheleth intends. However, the Hebrew passive form used here was originally a reflexive, meaning that it is possible to render it as “fools set themselves up [in high places].” The expression describes a situation that exists, rather than one which Qoheleth blames someone for causing. In some languages we can retain the passive without naming any agent: “Fools are [or, have been] placed in high places.” In other languages an impersonal “they” can be used in such contexts: “They have placed fools in high places.” It is also possible to substitute a different verb with the same sense. For instance, “Fools have reached high positions.”

In many high places describes social or political leadership, people in places of power and influence. Instead of “high” and “low,” some languages will prefer to speak of places for “big people” and “little people.”

A good translation here may be:

• Fools are found in many positions of power.

• Fools set themselves up in positions of authority.

• Fools are given places of honor and power.

And the rich provides the contrast with “folly.” And translates the Hebrew conjunction. To highlight the contrast the translator may wish to use another conjunction such as “while” or “but.” Throughout Proverbs there are many sayings suggesting that a rich person may well be a fool. Similarly poverty is often associated with the wise (see also 9.11). However, the context on this occasion indicates that the rich represent the elite and powerful in society, without meaning that they are fools. If this unusual use of rich causes misunderstandings, the translator can add another modifying adjective to make the point: “rich, important people.”

Sit (or, “dwell”) means that they occupy these positions, not that they are actually seated or living somewhere. Qoheleth seems to have purposely used two separate verbs, “set,” pointing to high position, and “sit,” pointing to low position. In contrast to “set [themselves],” the verb “sit” suggests inactivity. Translator should look for a similar opposing pair, but in some cases we may have to use one verb for both contexts.

A low place can describe a place or object that is physically or geographically low, but here it refers to a position of low social status and power, hence a term such as “lowly” is appropriate. Good News Translation “… while rich men are ignored” is not sufficiently close to the text’s sense.

Two models for translation are:

• … while the rich occupy lowly positions.

• on the other hand, those with wealth take the lowly places.

As a further comment, there appears to be a contrast here in the Hebrew text between “the fool” (singular) occupying “many high positions” (plural) and “rich people” (plural) occupying one “low place” (singular). In most languages this kind of a play on words will be very difficult to render. The main thrust of the verse is the reversal of expected roles, so these small distinctions in the original may have to be ignored in the translation:

• Foolish people have been placed in places of authority, while rich, important ones, take the lowly positions.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 12:8

Following the last large section of text (11.7–12.7), this verse serves as an important discourse marker in the whole literary work. With 1.2 it forms an inclusion or bracket around the entire work of Qoheleth, so that we hear the same vanity (hevel) refrain both at the beginning and the end of the text. The use of inclusion is a typical feature of Hebrew literature, but here this stylistic device is used to “frame” a much larger unit, a whole book. Thus this short statement is the sign that Qoheleth’s discussion, which began in 1.2, is now completed. He rounds off the entire discussion by quoting the opening saying.

Detailed comments on this saying are found in 1.2.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 2:13

The difference between wisdom and folly is like that between light and darkness. Wisdom and folly are absolutely different. The comparison also means that wisdom is the superior or positive value, and folly all negative. The verb saw can be rendered as “realized” or “discovered.”

Wisdom excels folly is a comparative expression that places wisdom above folly. The phrase is literally “there is a lasting benefit [yithron] to wisdom more than to folly.” The nature of the Hebrew comparative form makes it clear that only wisdom has this benefit; folly is of no value at all. Some languages will find it more natural to say that “wisdom is good and folly is not” or some similar contrasting expression. As yithron is a keyword in this book, it will be well to make this idea clear in the translation. The use of abstract nouns wisdom and folly may be unnatural in some languages, in which case verbal expressions could be used: “Being wise has lasting benefit; being foolish has none.”

As light excels darkness draws on the metaphor of light and dark, which frequently appears in the Scriptures and marks an absolute contrast. Like the opening phrase, this one also is literally “as the lasting benefit of light over darkness.” This then becomes a powerful statement to the effect that only wisdom can produce any lasting benefit. This concept may be difficult to render in several languages where the terms of comparison are different. We may be able to speak of the “lasting benefit” of wisdom over folly, but not of the “lasting benefit” of light over dark. Our translation can make the point easily with a phrase like “Then I realized that lasting benefit comes only through being wise, never through folly. That is because wisdom and folly are as different as day and night” or “Then I knew that wisdom could bring lasting benefit; folly never will. Wisdom and folly are as different as light is to darkness.”

In some languages it may be more effective for the comparison to come before the statement: “As light excels darkness, so wisdom excels folly” or “As light is opposite to darkness, so wisdom [or, being wise] is opposite to folly [or, being foolish].”

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .