Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 2:12

So I turned reflects the next step in Qoheleth’s thinking and so can be rendered by a verb of thinking: “I began to think about” or “I began to reflect on,” or by a more literary expression, “I turned my thoughts to” or “My reflection turned to.”

Wisdom and madness and folly: as Revised Standard Version shows, these three nouns are linked in Hebrew by the conjunction “and.” It is clear, however, that wisdom on the one hand is being opposed to madness and folly on the other. Madness and folly are linked together in this verse, suggesting that they have a similar meaning (see comments on 1.17 for the meaning of “madness”). Some languages will prefer to use one expression rather than two. Good News Translation uses “reckless” at this point to translate madness and so catches the mood of thoughtless behavior by which persons can harm themselves and others. Qoheleth intends to investigate every aspect of life, so he must look carefully at both wisdom and folly.

For what can the man do who comes after the king?: Good News Translation moves this phrase to the beginning of verse 12. The question Qoheleth puts here is a rhetorical one. Its purpose apparently is to strengthen his argument that he should consider both wisdom and folly. The initial Hebrew particle ki may be the motive marker for, giving the reason for Qoheleth’s testing of wisdom and folly. Or it could be translated as the emphatic “indeed” or “really” equally well (see comments on this particle, page 13). If the latter, then it expresses forcefully the thought that he can do nothing other than what the king has done. Our translation will be determined by the way we interpret the function of the particle.

An additional problem relates to the meaning of the verb comes after. Two meanings are possible: either to become the next king, or to follow in the way of the king, doing as he would do. There seems no way to settle this problem. However, if we refer to verse 18, where a similar thought occurs, it suggests that becoming the next king is what is in mind here. This gives a translation “What can the next king do?” or “What can the heir to the throne do?”

Only what he has already done: the person who takes over the throne can only do what the previous king did. The sense is that this is an ideal that the new king should follow. This interpretation depends upon understanding he as the previous king and not the man referred to in the question. If that is what is intended, then we can translate as “what the king has already done.” The assumption we make here is that, because the king had examined everything with such care, Qoheleth could do nothing less than that. However, we should be aware that we are making assumptions here, for it nowhere states what the king may have done. If our assumptions from the general context are correct, then Qoheleth bases his investigation on the fact that this was the only responsible policy to pursue. It wasn’t that he was unable to think of some alternative.

Avoiding the use of the rhetorical question may assist our translation. Possibilities are “The person who inherits the throne should follow the example of the previous king” or “Any person becoming king should follow the pattern set by the previous ruler in this matter.” Good News Translation treatment of this section may also be accepted.

It should, however, be noted here that the solution offered above is not without its problems, and that we have only chosen the most likely meaning. Despite this, it seems obvious that Qoheleth uses the question and comment to justify all he did.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 3:18

The opening phrase I said in my heart marks this verse as the second possible reaction to the situation described in verse 16. It should hardly surprise us that there may be two different responses to a given situation, and wisdom writers often made plain that depending on circumstances their advice could change. What is right and proper in one setting may not be right in another. If we can classify verse 17 as the standard, or orthodox, response to the problem of injustice, then this verse may be called “Qoheleth’s alternative response.” Both responses are legitimate.

Though it reflects the Hebrew, Revised Standard Version‘s translation presents an awkward structure in English. The translator can move with regard to the sons of men to initial position, if it will make the translation more natural: “Considering [the fate of] human beings, I decided….” For sons of men see 3.10.

Before going on, some important matters of structure and meaning will concern us here. The phrase with regard to (or, “concerning”) is followed by two infinitives, each expressing purpose. The first (Revised Standard Version testing) speaks of sorting through various items to find what you want. Although it is an infinitive, it carries finite verb meaning, with God as its subject. The second infinitive (to show) also contains the idea of examining (we have explored this use of its root, “see,” in this book already). The problem with this second infinitive is that it is an indicative form, in which case “God” also appears to be its subject. This would be an apparent contradiction, however, because the following verses indicate that God intends that people should see for themselves how much like the animals they are. So it is not God who sees, but people. This suggests that we should interpret “see” as being in its causative form, “cause to see”; hence we shall take the second infinitive as “to show them,” just as Revised Standard Version and other translations have done.

A meaningful translation of this verse is not a simple task. How can the situation described in verse 16 constitute a test for human beings? How does injustice in the legal process indicate that people will die as other creatures do? How do we translate testing It is clear from what Qoheleth says that humanity has failed to live by God’s standards of justice and righteousness. In reflecting on this failure we are shown, or it is demonstrated for us, that we are not really any better than other creatures. Qoheleth thinks that people can act with justice toward each other, and when they do, human beings are actually seen to be higher beings than the animals. Lack of justice, on the other hand, shows we are no higher than they are. So “see” and “test” are close in meaning in this case. A suggested translation is “God leads us to see that…” or “God thereby demonstrates to us that….”

That they are but beasts means that human beings are no better or higher than beasts. So in translation we can say “they are no different than animals,” or as Good News Translation puts it inclusively, “we are not better than animals.” The Hebrew actually uses a preposition that can mean “like”: “they are [just] like animals.” We must wait until verse 19 to see what is the basis of this comparison. There we learn that both human beings and animals are mortal. It is probably wise, though, to leave the explanation of the comparison to the next verse. Jerusalem Bible “… and expose them for the brute beasts they are to each other” seems to go far beyond the meaning of the text.

Two models for translation:

• I thought to myself: as for us human beings, God tests us to show us we are no different than animals.

• As far as human beings are concerned, I decided that God is testing them to demonstrate that they are no better than animals.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 5:13

There is a grievous evil: we have seen already in 2.21 that evil describes a situation not as morally corrupt but as painful to observe. Note New Revised Standard Version “grievous ill.” In verses 13-14 the adjective occurs three times and has the effect of setting the tone for the passage. Qoheleth suggests that the situation he observes is grievous, or “sickening.” Jerusalem Bible uses “singular” to highlight the unusual or remarkable nature of the situation. Whether the situation described is truly unusual is debatable, but Qoheleth says it virtually made him sick to behold. Good News Translation “Here is a terrible thing that…” is acceptable.

Which I have seen under the sun: Qoheleth uses the verb “see” as previously, that is, in the sense of studied observation. See comments on 1.14. For under the sun see comments on 1.3.

Riches were kept by their owner to his hurt: this is the scene that so moved Qoheleth. Riches includes both money and what that money can buy, as in 4.8. Were kept carries the sense of guarding something carefully (see “Guard your steps” and notes on 5.1). The passive form riches were kept is impersonal, and many languages will prefer an active expression. Good News Translation provides a suitable model: “people save up their money.”

By their owner is the generally accepted understanding of this phrase. However, Gordis suggests that these things were kept for the owner. His argument fails, however, when we note that the same expression is used to designate “by” (see, for example, Gen 14.19 “blessed … by God”). The traditional view that these riches are guarded by their owner can stand.

To his hurt marks the result of guarding his riches, as Revised Standard Version shows. Many translations reflect a view that the riches are a source of great anxiety and concern, translating like Revised Standard Version “to his detriment.” So, like the previous example, the rich man loses sleep because he has so much materially. Hurt is the noun raʿah. The same word rendered as evil appears at the beginning of this verse, where we noted that it describes a troublesome situation, not one that is necessarily morally corrupt.

One other possible interpretation can also be considered. The Hebrew preposition rendered as by (le) can also mean “because of” as in Josh 9.9, “… because of the name of the LORD….” If this usage bears any relationship to our situation here, we can suggest that Qoheleth claims that the owner guarded his things “because of his hurt” that is to say “against his [possible] hurt.” This may be behind the very free rendering of Good News Translation, “for a time when they may need it.” Our view will be that the owner took every precaution not to lose his wealth; so we may translate as follows:

• Here is a terrible thing I observed: a rich man protecting his wealth against its loss …

• I saw something really painful that happens in this world. There was a man who was guarding his wealth against some misfortune.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 7:15

In my vain life is Qoheleth’s way of referring to the life he has led. What does he mean by this phrase? Does he mean that his life has been of no value, that it is “useless” as Good News Translation claims, or “empty” as New English Bible suggests? Jerusalem Bible thinks that his life has been “fleeting.” New Jerusalem Bible also interprets “in my own brief span of life.” The Hebrew is “in the days of my hevel.” On the term hevel in this book, refer to comments in “Translating Ecclesiastes,” page 2.

The Hebrew noun for “days” refers to the duration of his life up to the present, while the term hevel describes the context in which he lived, rather than the nature of his existence. When Qoheleth uses the term hevel, he generally portrays a situation that is enigmatic, difficult to comprehend. So our conclusion is that this condensed phrase means that Qoheleth lived out his life in a world that was full of unanswered questions and problems. They are the kinds of things he listed in 5.17. This understanding suggests a translation like “Throughout my life in this problem-filled world,” or “While living in this strange [enigmatic] world.”

I have seen everything: the Hebrew begins the verse with this clause. Placing the clause at the head of the verse gives it emphasis. The word “all” (translated everything) is the first part of what is called an “inclusion” for the section; that is, it is a term found at both the beginning and end of a section of discourse, thus marking for us where the section ends and where it begins; the second “all” occurs at the end of verse 18. When Qoheleth says that he saw everything, the context here suggests that he really means he saw many things, and the two following cases are examples of them. We may also give its meaning as “so much” (so Jerusalem Bible), or “so many things.” New English Bible has “all manner of things.”

Have seen: on the verb “see” and its meaning in this book, refer to comments in 1.13-14.

Two translation examples:

• I have observed so much during my life in this problem-filled world.

• I have seen so many incomprehensible things in my life.

There is a righteous man who perishes in his righteousness: this is the first of two parallel clauses telling us what Qoheleth saw. There is translates a Hebrew word that points to a class or group of people. It can also be rendered by “there is the case of….” Righteous in the Old Testament usually has a very clear bond with the Law. A righteous person is one who lived in accordance with the Law. Good News Translation “a good man” is a rather weak alternative. Because Qoheleth offers this as an example to be considered, we can convey his meaning by saying “For example, there are some people who faithfully keep God’s Law.”

Who perishes describes the fate of the righteous person and states simply that the person dies. In itself, the fact that a human being dies is not surprising, but what concerns Qoheleth here is the fact that a righteous person may have his life cut short or die before his time, while the nonrighteous person may have a long life. This is contrary to the traditional school of wisdom, which taught that evil people would not be prosperous or have long lives. Only wise and just people would be wealthy and live long (see Pro 3.1-3). It is the early death of a righteous person that leads Qoheleth to say that this world is difficult to understand (hevel). To communicate this idea effectively, translators may need to say “[righteous] people may die an early death,” “… die before their time,” or “… die prematurely.”

In his righteousness is a prepositional phrase with an adversative function. That is to say, it marks what happens to a person “in spite of” being righteous. Similar uses of the preposition can be found; for example, in Num 14.11 “in spite of all the signs which I have wrought among them.” Translators may feel that it is better to expand this prepositional phrase into a clause: “Despite the fact that they have followed the Law faithfully, they have not had long lives.”

The repetition of the word righteous in the Hebrew here emphasizes Qoheleth’s dismay at this unhappy situation. The translator should try if possible to express the emotion of the phrase. However, in some languages such repetition will not be natural and should be avoided.

Suggestions for translation:

• There is the case of a righteous person who dies an early death despite being just.

• For example, there are some who faithfully keep the Law, but die an early death despite that.

In some languages it may be quite natural to begin this part of the verse by repeating “I saw…”; thus:

• I saw people who had followed the Law faithfully, but they did not live long lives.

And there is a wicked man: the evil person (rashaĘż), or wicked man, contrasts with the righteous person of the first example. The wicked person ignores the Law and its requirements, mistreats others, and in particular offends God. According to Israelite tradition, this kind of individual would meet an early death, because God would punish him (see Pro 11.19-21; 24.19-20). Good News Translation does not translate this phrase literally; it prefers to show the contrast by using “while others…,” then later describes these people as “evil.”

There is: see comments earlier in this verse.

Who prolongs his life means that the wicked person actually seemed to live longer; the expected judgment from God against evil did not come. To “prolong life” in the Hebrew is not a transitive verb, as if the person actually did something enabling himself to live longer; it simply means “lives long.” New English Bible “growing old…” is an excellent suggestion. We can avoid the problem in the Revised Standard Version rendering by simply saying, “who lives a long life.” This is the sense of the Hebrew verb when used intransitively. Good News Translation and Jerusalem Bible have “lives on,” suggesting that he outlived the righteous person. The sense of New American Bible “surviving” is that the person manages to keep on living, but not at any significant level of success. We perhaps should avoid that latter model.

In his evil-doing follows the same pattern as in the first half of the verse, so the Hebrew preposition means “in spite of,” or Good News Translation “even though.” See comments above on the function of this preposition. His evil-doing is literally “his evil,” referring to the person’s evil ways and deeds. This makes the Revised Standard Version model more appropriate than the Good News Translation, which simply uses the adjective to describe him (“he is evil”).

We can translate as:

• … and there is the case of a corrupt person who lives a long life despite his evil deeds.

• … and there are others who disobey God’s Law, but despite that still enjoy long life.

• But I also saw evil people living long lives, even though they disobeyed God’s Law.

The last two clauses in this verse exhibit a strict grammatical parallelism:

There is a righteous person, dying in his righteousness;
and there is a wicked person, living in his evil ways.

It may be possible for the translator to translate these lines following this pattern, if the meaning can be faithfully preserved. For example,

• One man dies, even though he is righteous [or, faithful to the Law];
And another lives, even though he is wicked [or, he disobeys the Law].

It is more important, however, that a translation be faithful in terms of meaning rather than structure. So if such grammatical parallelism is not appreciated, the translator may give a freer and more natural translation.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 9:2

The Septuagint, or Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible, along with Jerusalem Bible and New Jerusalem Bible, regard the first part of this verse as belonging with the previous verse. They also take the first word to be hevel (“vanity”) and so give a different reading than Revised Standard Version. However, taking the Hebrew text literally we have “all things [hakol] are alike for all one fate.” “All things are alike for all” is probably a well-known saying, stating a principle that will be illustrated in the following examples. It is followed by the comment “one fate.” We can express the idea by “Everything is alike [or, the same] for everybody. We all share the same fate.” Good News Translation translates rather freely: “It makes no difference. The same fate comes to….”

One fate: see comments on 2.14. Fate is a euphemism for the final end, death. One does not function here as a numeral but expresses the fact that it is a shared or common fate; we may translate as “the same fate” or “a common fate.” In some languages figurative expressions exist to express the idea of fate. For example, in one West African language we can say “everyone holds one stick.” It is quite acceptable to use such idiomatic expressions, if the level of language matches the serious tone here.

Comes to all is supplied by Revised Standard Version and means that death “comes to” or “meets” every living thing. Here all is not restricted to people but embraces every living creature.

A series of contrasting terms describing individuals follows. We have seen this device in the poem of 3.2-8. The use of opposing terms is a feature of wisdom literature enabling the simple classification of all aspects of life. In this verse they describe liturgical or religious practices.

With the exception of one line (“to the good”), this passage is very rhythmic, with the same beat of alternating senses that we have seen elsewhere. The translator should try to retain some of the rhythm if possible.

We note a slight shift in the form of expression toward the end of the list. The first elements in the list (“righteous” through “those not sacrificing”) follow the preposition “to,” while the last elements (“good” and “sinner”; “one swearing” and “one not swearing”) are combined with “as … so” particles in a comparative expression. The translator can decide whether to follow this shift in the form (see Good News Translation), or whether putting all elements in a parallel structure will be more acceptable.

To the righteous and the wicked: for comment on the term righteous, see verse 1 and 3.17. It is appropriate to begin the list with the righteous or law-abiding persons, since it was the circumstances surrounding their death that caught Qoheleth’s attention (verse 1). The wicked describes the person who disobeys God’s Law (see comments on 3.17). Both kinds of people die, even though from the human viewpoint we might expect some distinction to be made.

To the good and the evil: as the Revised Standard Version footnote indicates, the Hebrew lacks the words “and the evil.” However, later in the verse there is a reference to both the good and the evil. Should we omit the good, or add the evil as Revised Standard Version has? Qoheleth’s meaning will not be lost if we omit “good” at this point, because it is repeated later in the verse. We suggest that the entire phrase should not be translated at this point.

To the clean and the unclean represents those who are prepared for worship and those who are not, those who are worthy for worship and those who are defiled and unable to join in. Uncleanness was normally a temporary state caused by touching something considered unclean (for example, a dead body), or by certain sicknesses and the like. See the information given in Leviticus 12–15. A person could become clean again by undergoing a cleansing ritual. The two contrasting terms clean and unclean are a way of describing all Israelites, defining them in terms of those who are able to join in worship and those who cannot. The translator should use the same vocabulary used in translating the terms in Leviticus. Some languages will use words like “pure” and “impure,” while others will need longer phrases such as “acceptable [or, not acceptable] in God’s eyes” or “acceptable [or, not acceptable] for worship.” We can translate as:

• those who are ready for worship and those who are not.

• those who have cleansed themselves for worship and those who have not.

To him who sacrifices and him who does not sacrifice: this contrasting pair is also based in Israel’s religious life. The person who sacrifices probably is meant to identify someone who takes religious practice seriously; conversely, the person who does not sacrifice is someone who is not serious about worship. Regardless of how religious a person is, Qoheleth says that person will ultimately die. Religious devotion, or lack of it, will not save anyone from death. Although the verb “to sacrifice” is only one of many used to describe the various Old Testament rituals, here it probably represents all kinds of sacrificial activity. However, to translate it as “religious” (Good News Translation) can be misleading, because our translation needs to reflect the Old Testament ritual background. “Religious” is far too general a term to do that. We can simply say “to the person who [regularly or habitually] offers sacrifice and to the person who does not.” In some languages an object for the verb “sacrifice” will have to be mentioned. In this case the translator should try to use the most general term possible, such as “the person who offers a sacrifice [to God]” or “the person who sacrifices something.”

As is the good man, so is the sinner compares people of two opposing moral standards. Though very different morally, they stand together because they share a single fate. Moral factors do not determine whether a person lives or dies. The good man may carry several meanings, so it may be better to say “the person who does good,” while the sinner is “the person who does wrong.” The entire phrase can be clearly set forth as:

• the person who does good and the person who does evil share the same fate [or, both end the same].

• the fate of the person who does good and of the person who does wrong is the same.

And he who swears is as he who shuns an oath: again the liturgical context of the examples is clear, this time returning to an example used previously in chapter 5. The Revised Standard Version text can be misunderstood as comparing two kinds of people, when in fact Qoheleth is talking about their fates. “Swearing an oath” means making a solemn promise to someone or to God that you will do a certain thing. See comments on 5.4-5. The context suggests that Qoheleth has in mind promises made to God rather than to a friend or someone else. However, we cannot rule out both meanings being present. Our translation needs to reflect that religious setting, whereas Good News Translation “one who takes an oath” may have a purely secular or legal sense in many cultures. He who shuns an oath describes someone who is afraid or unwilling to make a commitment. In translation we can convey the broader meaning with:

• the person who makes a promise to God is treated the same as the person who refuses to promise anything.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 10:16

The unit begins with two parallel but contrasting sayings. The first indicates that foolish leaders pose a danger to the welfare of the nation.

Woe: although this interjection introduces a familiar prophetic judgment form (compare Isa 5.8, 11, 18, 20), the way Qoheleth uses it indicates that he has altered that setting to an educational one. Here it introduces Qoheleth’s warning of the dangers of a given situation. The cry of Woe … has been used once before in a similar setting in 4.10 (see comments there). So Woe can be rendered as “trouble,” or “predicament.” A nation with foolish rulers is “most unfortunate”; compare Good News Translation “a country is in trouble when….” Another translation possibility is to preserve the cry of despair with a rendering like “Alas for you…!” This is how New Revised Standard Version presents it.

O land, a simple vocative, indicates who is addressed. Land includes more than soil or territory; it includes the people who live within its borders as well. Terms like “nation,” “people,” or, where these terms are not used, “tribe” can convey the sense well. The translator needs to determine if it is natural to address a country or a people in this way. In some cases it may be quite appropriate to do so with a term like “O my countrymen” or more simply “O people.” Some languages will not have a vocative marker like O but may simply say “Countrymen, …” or “People, ….” In other languages, however, even this style may seem unnatural. Some versions such as Good News Translation eliminate the vocative and express this verse entirely in the third person; for example, “A country is in trouble when….” This also is an option to be considered.

When your king is a child is a noun clause introduced by the so-called relative marker, indicating that the clause describes the nation or land. The connector can be expressed as “whose” or “if” as well as by the Revised Standard Version choice when. This is possible because the example it gives is a hypothetical case.

Your king: see comments on 4.13.

A child renders a Hebrew term that has a wider meaning including “young man.” We know from comments he has made elsewhere that Qoheleth does not believe that just because a person is young he cannot be a good ruler (see 4.13-16). Solomon is described by this same term in 1 Kgs 3.7. Our present verse gives a negative example, while the following verse (verse 17) provides a positive balance, and we can use this parallelism of the verses to help our understanding of their meaning. The structure suggests that the term in this verse is the opposite of “free man” in the next verse. Thus it means something like “servant.” In fact the context suggests that what he does is foolish, so “foolish servant” will convey the sense here.

If we choose a third person form, we may say:

• A country may be in great trouble if its king is a foolish servant.

• A tribe can be in trouble if its leader is an unlearned youth.

We may wish to retain more of the flavor of the original by retaining the second person address:

• You are in trouble if your king is nothing but a youth.

• Too bad for you, countrymen, if a foolish servant is your king.

And your princes feast in the morning! parallels the first half of the verse. Princes is comparable to “kings.” In communities without a royal tradition, a term for another member of the tribal leadership can be used instead of princes. “Noblemen,” “chosen leaders,” or “big people [people in high positions]” are possibilities. The English term “prince” describes the son of a king or queen. The Hebrew term sometimes translated “prince” does not carry that sense at all. It refers to one who rules.

Feast in the morning: although most people eat at least moderately in the morning, the saying here gives the sense that there is something wrong in what these people are doing. We picture the leaders beginning their feasting or gluttony as soon as they get up each morning. They then continue eating throughout the day and into the evening. The imperfect form of the verb “eat” carries this meaning of continuous feasting. Revised Standard Version feast shows that it is more than the simple act of eating. Many other languages have a similar term to refer to eating more than is necessary.

Morning, or early in the day, is a fairly general reference, but there is still no reason to adopt the Good News Translation rendering “they feast all night long.” If special emphasis is desired, we may say something like “as soon as the sun comes up.”

Translation possibilities for this clause are:

• and your [or, its] leaders begin their gluttony early in the day.

• and your [or, its] princes begin their feasting early in the morning.

Again, the form this verse takes will depend on the style the translator wishes to adopt. We can preserve the prophetic formula in second person address, or state the condemnation indirectly. The entire verse can be translated in a solemn and poetic style:

• You are to be pitied,
People whose king is an untrained child,
Whose leaders start their feasting as soon as the sun comes up!

or in a less figurative style:

• A nation is most unfortunate if a foolish servant is its king,
and its leaders begin their gluttony early in the day!

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 1:9

In verse 4 the fact that there was constant flow and movement in the created world was matched by another fact, namely, that the world was permanent. This second theme of a permanent and stable universe is expanded here in verses 9-10. In this way Qoheleth reminds his readers of these two basic facts about the world that are the background to what he has to say. It is important to bear them both in mind for later interpretation and translation (for example, in 1.15; 3.15; 6.10).

Verse 9 divides into three parts. The first two parts are parallel: they both contain a verbal phrase that looks back to the past, and one that looks to the future. The third part of the verse is a conclusion based on the previous two.

What has been: the verse opens with a pronoun, “whatever,” which means “everything.” The verb “be” expresses existence, so we can render this as “whatever has existed.” Hebrew verbs do not stress the time of an action. Rather they indicate what kind of action takes place—a completed one, or an incomplete one. In this case “has been” indicates present existence, something that came to be during the past and now remains. Translators will know what emphases the verbs in their own languages give, and they should consider this when translating “be” in this clause. Will be indicates what will continue to exist or what always will be. For translation: “Whatever has existed will continue to exist,” or “Everything that has existed will continue to exist.”

Some languages may require the addition of an adverb of time for clarity, even though there is no such adverb in the Hebrew. We may need to translate as “What existed before [or, yesterday] will always exist [or, will exist tomorrow].”

The verb “do” in the phrase what has been done is almost certainly connected with the work of creation (see Gen 1.7, 16, 25). This reminds the reader that the world God made is orderly, because it is he who made it. The focus for the verse is upon what God has done and will do, not on what people do, although the phrase is used in that latter sense elsewhere (1.14; 2.11). If we must identify who does the action, we can name God: “Whatever God has done, he will continue to do.” But if not, we are better off leaving the text as it stands.

There is nothing new under the sun expresses the conclusion Qoheleth draws from the facts given above. What God has done is complete, and the fact that he sustains what he has made means that there can be nothing new. New has the sense of something “novel,” “not known before.” Under the sun speaks of the world on which the sun shines, the place where human beings live (see comments on verse 3). So Qoheleth is saying that, in this world in which we live, the world that God made, there is nothing new. Of course this is not intended as a scientific theory, nor should we give the impression that this means nothing can ever be invented or discovered. This is a poem in which the created world that God has made forms the background for the theme of constant circular motion. We should not ask the poem to say more than the poet intends. Here, then, the focus is clear—in this natural world there is nothing new, only repetition and circular motion.

Two possible models for translation are:

• What existed in the past will exist in the future. What was done in the past is what will be done in the future. There is nothing new here on earth.

• Everything that used to be will continue to be.
What God has done, he will continue to do.
There is nothing new in this world.

Qoheleth quotes this poem so that readers will know that what he investigated and experienced, and the conclusions he reached, are reliable. They are reliable because no new things can suddenly appear that can prove him wrong or undermine this work.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Ecclesiastes 2:23

For all his days are full of pain: the introductory particle offers a reason for the question in verse 22. It describes a situation Qoheleth has either witnessed or experienced. The introductory particle can be given as “For,” “When,” or even “Considering the fact that.”

All his days becomes “As long as you live” in Good News Translation, with the more general and impersonal use of the pronoun “you.” We have several alternatives here. We can use an impersonal pronoun if there is one, or a noun form, “a person.” However, before we translate the phrase we should consider other aspects of Qoheleth’s meaning. All his days according to Good News Translation indicates the duration of a person’s life. In fact the Hebrew expression can also mean “all day long” or “every day,” in which case the focus is on the daily experience rather than on the entire duration of life. Although this distinction may seem to be somewhat minor, it is actually significant here because it provides a contrast with the phrase “all night long,” which is to follow. Therefore we may render all his days better as “all day long.”

Are full of pain: the text says literally “every day [all day] painful things.” It indicates that every day there are painful things happening; so for translation we can consider “every day has its pain,” or “all day a person endures pain,” or “painful things happen every day.”

His work is a vexation is another noun clause, “vexation [is] his business.” Vexation was commented on in 1.18. See the notes there. For comments on the term work, see the reference to “business” in comments on 1.13. Since the term “business” has too heavy a commercial flavor, “work” or “his job” is better. In translation we may say “his work brings him further anguish,” “his work only makes him angry,” or “his job upsets him.”

Even in the night his mind does not rest: day and night a person has to contend with matters that are painful and upsetting and that prevent sleep. Even can be translated as “also,” but the main point Qoheleth is making is to claim that both day and night we are faced by these troubles. In the night or “by night” complements the earlier phrase “each day.”

His mind does not rest comes from the Hebrew “his heart does not lay down.” Many languages will have a special idiom to express this thought. What he worries about is not indicated, because Qoheleth as usual is making a very general statement. “He worries about what could happen” or “he keeps thinking about problems and cannot sleep” are possible models for translation.

This also is vanity: Good News Translation gives “useless” as the translation for hevel (Revised Standard Version vanity), but that is hardly its meaning. What Qoheleth notes is that such a situation is extremely frustrating, and we can mirror that in our translation with “What a frustrating situation!” Or, “What a nightmare!”

Two models for translation of the verse are:

• Every day he suffers and worries about his work. At night, he has no peace of mind. This too is a nightmare.

• Day and night he worries and loses sleep over his work. What a frightful situation to be in!

As Qoheleth ponders the key question again he encounters more and more situations that cause deep frustration, and so he asks, In this kind of life where can a person expect to find “lasting benefit”? His response follows in the next section.

Quoted with permission from Ogden, Graham S. and Zogbo, Lynell. A Handbook on the Book of Ecclesiates. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 1997. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .