Translation commentary on Galatians 1:19

Since Paul is here mentioning several items which indicate his very brief contact with the apostles in Jerusalem, it may be useful to begin verse 19 with a conjunction such as “furthermore” or “moreover” (“Furthermore, I did not see…”).

Not only did Paul stay in Jerusalem for only a brief time; but also he did not see anyone except Peter and James. As Good News Translation indicates, the phrase except James presents a problem of interpretation. Does Paul mean to include James with the apostles? If that is the case, he is saying that he saw no other apostle except James. Or does Paul exclude James from the apostolic group? In that case he is saying “I did not see any of the other apostles; I only saw James” (as in the TEV footnote and in Jerusalem Bible). Either interpretation of the Greek is possible.

James is probably the same person mentioned in Mark 6.3 as Jesus’ brother and is referred to simply as James in Galatians 2.9,12; 1 Corinthians 15.7; Acts 15.13; 21.18. He was known in later tradition as the first bishop of the church in Jerusalem. He should be distinguished from James the Son of Zebedee and James the son of Alphaeus, who were two of the Twelve (Matt 10.2-3).

Depending upon the interpretation which is adopted, the exception of James may be introduced as “I saw only James,” or “the only other apostle was James.” One may then introduce the apposition as a separate sentence: “He is the brother of our Lord.” In this rendering the Lord is often expressed as “our Lord,” since in many languages the relation of people to the Lord must be indicated.

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 3:6

The Greek word used to introduce this section (Revised Standard Version “thus”) could be taken either (1) as introducing a subordinate clause which is dependent on the preceding section, (2) or as introducing a new topic. The latter interpretation seems to be preferred. In the previous verses (1-5), Paul has been appealing to the experience of the Galatians. Now he brings in the case of Abraham, and from this point until the end of chapter 4, Paul affirms his fundamental contention that Abraham was put right with God by faith, and that therefore those who are put right with God in the same manner are the true descendants of Abraham.

Some translations smooth out the rather abrupt introduction of a new topic in order to bring in the case of Abraham more naturally (Jerusalem Bible “Take Abraham for example”; New American Bible “Consider the case of Abraham”; New English Bible “Look at Abraham”). It is also possible to begin this paragraph by a phrase such as “Now think about Abraham,” “And now we should consider what happened to Abraham,” or “What happened to Abraham is here important.”

As the scripture says is not in the text; it is added in Good News Translation to signal to the reader that what follows is a quotation from the Old Testament. The quotation itself is from Genesis 15.6 and follows the Septuagint rather than the Hebrew version. In a number of languages one cannot speak of “the scripture saying” or “… speaking”; it is only people who say things. One can, however, use some such phrase as “as one may read in the Scriptures,” or “… in a passage of the Scriptures.”

Abraham is considered the father of the Jewish nation. An appeal to his experience would be an effective argument against the Judaizers, that is, those who insisted that conformance to the Law was necessary for salvation.

He believed God indicates more than mental assent. It describes Abraham’s willing and unreserved surrender to God, his humble and utter dependence on him, and his confident trust in his word. This meaning is frequently expressed in translations as “Abraham trusted God,” or “Abraham put his confidence in God.” In some languages trust is expressed idiomatically, for example, “Abraham leaned his weight upon God,” or “Abraham hung onto God with his heart.”

Because of his faith God accepted him as righteous is literally “It was reckoned to him as righteousness.” “It” is, of course, his faith, and the implicit agent of “was reckoned” is God. The phrase “reckoned to him as righteousness” can be interpreted either to mean that God recognized Abraham as having acted rightly, or that it was Abraham’s faith that was accounted as the ground of his being accepted by God. “Righteousness” in the latter case would have the primary element of being put right with God or being put into a right relationship with him.

The phrase because of his faith may be rendered as “because he trusted God.”

God accepted him as righteous may be rendered as “God received him as one who is righteous,” or “… who had done what was right.” However, if “righteousness” is to be understood in terms of being put right with God or being placed in a right relation to God, one may say in some languages “God joined him to himself in the right way.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 4:11

Paul ends this section with a statement expressing his fear that everything he has done among the Galatians might end up in nothing. This shows how seriously Paul regarded the effects of legalism; once the Galatians start to observe a legalistic system, they have for all intents and purposes repudiated the Good News of God’s free gift of love and reconciliation.

In the Greek this verse is actually one declarative sentence, but Good News Translation restructures it into two sentences. The first expresses Paul’s concern and worry for the Galatians, and the second expresses, in the form of a rhetorical question, his doubt, unbelief, and dismay at what he fears may actually happen, if it has not already become a reality among them.

It is possible to translate the first part of this verse with the worry or fear being connected with the efforts of Paul rather than with the Galatians themselves (Revised Standard Version “I am afraid I have labored over you in vain”; Jerusalem Bible “you make me feel I have wasted my time with you”; New English Bible “you make me fear that all the pains I spent on you may prove to be labour lost”). It is more likely, however, that the meaning of the Greek is more as Good News Translation renders this passage; that is, Paul is showing his concern for the Galatians themselves, and not simply expressing fear that his efforts have been in vain (compare Knox “I am anxious over you”).

I am worried about you is literally “I fear for you,” but special care would have to be exercised in translating “I fear for you.” It could be translated “I am afraid for you,” but too often it has been rendered in such a way as to mean “I am afraid of you.” In some languages one can best say “I’m afraid for what may happen to you.” However, in some languages one cannot speak of “fear” in a context such as this one. What was in Paul’s mind was not fright, but deep concern and worry, as Good News Translation indicates, and therefore one may translate “I am very much worried because of you,” or, as expressed idiomatically in one language, “My mind is killing me because of you.”

In place of the rhetorical question Can it be that all my work for you has been for nothing?, one may have in some languages an emphatic statement, “I sincerely trust that all my work on your behalf has not been for nothing.” In many languages, however, a double negative is quite inappropriate, and may even be grammatically improper. Thus it may be necessary to say “I do trust that my work for you has had results.”

To avoid the implication that Paul’s work has been merely physical effort, it may be important in some languages to translate all my work for you as “all that I have done on your behalf,” or “all that I have done in order to help you.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 5:12

Once again Paul refers to the false teachers in the plural, describing them as the people who are upsetting you, that is “unsettle, disturb, agitate” (used only here by Paul). He even expresses a strong wish that they would go all the way (that is, go beyond circumcision) and castrate themselves. Most scholars understand Paul here to be referring to actual self-emasculation, similar to the practices of the priests of certain mystery cults with which the Galatians would be familiar. This sense is found in most translations (for example, New English Bible “had better … make eunuchs of themselves”; Revised Standard Version “would mutilate themselves”; Knox “should lose their own manhood”). One may also translate “cut off their male organs.”

A possible alternative interpretation is that Paul may have had in mind the Old Testament understanding of castration which involved exclusion from God’s people (Deut 23.1). This would mean, therefore, that Paul here is using the figure of self-mutilation to speak of an intended result, which is exclusion from the church. This interpretation is followed by Phillips: “would cut themselves off from you altogether.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 2:6

Paul now cites a second incident (already mentioned in verse 2), that of his meeting with the Jerusalem leaders, during which his message was accepted and he himself was recognized as a missionary to the Gentiles.

Some understand those who seemed to be the leaders to be equivalent to the expression in 2.2 (New English Bible “men of high reputation,” Jerusalem Bible “these people who are acknowledged leaders,” Phillips “the leaders of the conference”; Die Bibel im heutigen Deutsch “who were considered to be authorities”). Others, however, take this as a deprecatory statement against the authorities mentioned, or if not of the authorities, at least of the arrogant claims which Paul’s opponents had apparently made about them. While no irony is involved in verse 2, there may be some kind of irony here, and it seems to be preserved in Good News Translation (compare Revised Standard Version). It may be possible to translate those who seemed to be the leaders as simply “those who appeared to be the leaders among the believers.” However, in some languages it is more natural to speak of “those who were said to be the leaders,” “those whom others regarded as the leaders,” or “those who had the reputation of being the leaders.”

The phrase I say this is added in Good News Translation to indicate the connection between the previous clause and the expression of cause which follows. The pronoun this refers to the entire preceding clause.

It makes no difference to me may be expressed as “as far as I am concerned, it’s all the same,” or “I do not make any distinction,” or “it doesn’t concern me.” One may say, for example, “I say this because what they were does not concern me.”

What translates a Greek qualitative word meaning “of what kind.” In what they were the reference is probably not to their present standing (as in New English Bible and Jerusalem Bible), but to the status which they gained by their former association with Jesus (as in most translations). The Greek supports the latter interpretation by its use of the word meaning “once,” “formerly,” or “at some time or other,” not specifically translated in Good News Translation. One may also say in some languages “what kinds of persons they were,” or “what their positions were,” with a term such as “positions” referring to social status.

God does not judge by outward appearances translates an idiom which literally rendered is “God does not accept the face of a man.” To accept the face of someone is to judge him and his actions on the basis of external circumstances, such as wealth, social standing, or rank. In this particular case, the externals are related to what they were in the past. In some languages God does not judge by outward appearances may be best expressed as “God does not judge a man by what he looks like.” In some languages this expression is more or less idiomatic, for example, “God doesn’t judge a man by the kind of clothes he wears,” or “God doesn’t call a man good or bad just because he is tall or short.”

After the parenthetical statement in which he asserts that he is not impressed by outward appearances, Paul begins his statement anew, and now he refers to the Jerusalem authorities as those leaders, using the same type of phrase as in verse 2.

Made no new suggestions translates the same verb found in 1.16, where it means “to submit for consideration, to confer with.” New English Bible takes it in the same sense here (“did not prolong the consultation”). Most translations, including Good News Translation, take it to mean here “to impart something” or to “impose something” (Phillips “they had nothing to add to my gospel”). The implication is clear: the Jerusalem authorities were completely satisfied with what Paul was doing. Made no new suggestions to me may be expressed as “didn’t tell me to do anything different,” “said to me, We have nothing else to add,” or “did not ask me to make any changes in the good news which I was preaching.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 3:19

It is quite logical, therefore, to ask, What, then, was the purpose of the law? The literal form “What then (is) the Law?” or “Why then the law?” (Revised Standard Version) can be understood as a question regarding the nature of the Law. Primarily, however, it is a question about the law’s purpose (Good News Translation, Knox, Jerusalem Bible), its function (New English Bible “then what of the law?”), its relevance (New American Bible), and its significance.

In order to indicate purpose, it is necessary in some languages to indicate what is to be accomplished, for example, “Then what could the Law accomplish?”, or “What were the laws given by Moses supposed to do?” There is, however, a difficulty in some languages with this type of rhetorical question, since there is no specific answer to it except through an expression of purpose, as in Good News Translation, joined to the statement concerning the Law having been added. For languages in which such a rhetorical statement would be either misleading or awkward, it may be possible to change the question into a statement, for example, “But the Law did have a purpose,” or “But the Law did accomplish something.”

It was added is intended to show the position of the law in relation to the covenant: it is both supplementary and subordinate to it. It impossible in some languages to speak of something being “added” without indicating to what it is added, and so one must make clear that the Law was added to the covenant. This may be stated in some languages as “the Law was given in addition to the covenant in order to show that….”

Furthermore, the Law was added for a specific purpose, to show what wrongdoing is. This particular expression (literally, “on account of transgressions,” or “because of transgressions”) is not easy to interpret, and the difficulty is reflected in the various ways of rendering it in modern translations (some examples: Jerusalem Bible “to specify crimes”; Knox “to make room for transgression”; New American Bible “in view of transgressions”; New English Bible “to make wrongdoing a legal offence”; Phillips “to underline the existence and extent of sin”; Moffatt “for the purpose of producing transgressions”).

We have two clues as to the interpretation of this expression. First, the expression literally rendered “on account” or “because of” is sometimes used to show cause or purpose. If we take cause as primary (because people were sinning), then the clause may mean that the Law’s function was to check, correct, or restrain transgressions. This meaning may be expressed in some languages as “to keep people from sinning,” or “to stop people from doing what was bad.” If “purpose” is primary, it could mean that the Law’s immediate function is to define transgression, to show its real nature, or even to produce and multiply it, by specifying the reality of guilt. This interpretation of purpose (which is far more common) may be expressed as “in order to show people what sin really is,” “in order to tell people that they were really doing wrong by doing certain things,” or “in order to show that the bad things people were doing were really sin.”

A second clue comes from the word literally rendered “transgressions,” which means not simply wrongdoing (Good News Translation), but wrongdoing as a result of willfully violating an existing law. If this is the case, before the Law was given there could not have been any transgressions. There were, of course, wrongdoings or evil deeds, but these were not in violation of any law, since the Law did not exist. The Law, therefore, made it possible for these wrongdoings to be recognized as “transgressions,” thereby exposing their sinful character.

The statement that the Law was meant to last until the coming of Abraham’s descendant involves some rather subtle problems for the translator. The verb to last must be understood in the sense of “to remain valid” or “to remain in force.” For one thing, it must not be understood merely in the sense that the paper on which the laws were written continued to the time of Jesus. A more difficult expression, however, is involved in the passive form was meant. Often this must be changed into an active expression, for example, “God purposed the Law to continue in force,” “God designed the Law so that it would remain valid until…,” or “… would say what people could or could not do until….”

The phrase until the coming of Abraham’s descendant must be made more specific in some languages: “until the time that Abraham’s descendant would come.” This is a specific reference to Christ, and in some languages it is necessary to say “that special descendant of Abraham,” or “that descendant of Abraham already mentioned.”

The final clause of this sentence, to whom the promise was made, must be made a completely new sentence in some languages, for example, “God had made the promise to that descendant,” or “God had promised that descendant.” This is, of course, a reference to the descendant mentioned in verse 16. Since in the same verse he is specifically identified as Christ, it may be necessary even in verse 19 to employ some appositional expression, for example, “until the time that Christ, the descendant of Abraham, would come; it was about that descendant that God made the promise.” In translating the clause to whom the promise was made, it is important not to rule out what has already been said in verse 16, namely, that God made his promises to both Abraham and his descendant.

The last part of verse 19 along with verse 20 shows the inferiority of the Law in terms of the way it was given and administered: it did not come directly from God, but it was handed down by angels and with a man acting as a go-between. That the angels played a part in the giving of the Law is part of Jewish tradition, and recorded in Scripture (Deut 33.2 [Septuagint]; Heb 2.2; Acts 7.38,52 f.). The go-between (literally “mediator”) is evidently Moses.

In translating the Law was handed down by angels, it is important to indicate clearly that the angels were only secondary agents; they were not the source of the Law. This may be expressed in some languages as “the Law was handed down with the help of angels,” or even “God used angels in passing on the Law to Moses.”

The phrase with a man acting as a go-between must be expressed in some languages as “and a man acted as a mediator between God and the people.” It is often essential to indicate clearly the role of a mediator, especially since in the immediately preceding clause the angels have been mentioned.

In some languages there may be a problem involved in the indefinite use of the phrase a man, since it might be interpreted as simply “any man.” That may be particularly so in this context, since it may already have been necessary to indicate that the Law related in some way to Moses in some such phrase as “the Law given to Moses,” or “the Law given by means of Moses.” Hence, one may be required to render this last phrase of verse 19 as “while the man Moses acted as a go-between.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 4:22

Paul now starts his argument from the Law. It says is literally “it is written,” a well-known authoritative formula used traditionally to introduce a quotation from scripture. What follows, however, is not a direct quotation but a summary statement. It says may be rendered in some languages as “in the Law one may read,” or “in the Law are the words about.”

Paul’s illustration is again taken from Abraham, this time concentrating on his two sons, Isaac and Ishmael, a story familiar to every Jewish child and which Jewish preachers often used to prove the superiority of their nation to those outside the covenant. The mothers are not at first referred to by name but are described according to status. The slave woman is, of course, Hagar. The word for slave woman properly means a young woman, but by Paul’s time it had come to mean a servant or a slave. The free woman is Sarah; free here is in antithesis to slave. The Old Testament account referred to is found in chapters 16, 17, and 21 of Genesis.

The statements one by a slave woman, the other by a free woman may be translated as “a woman who was a slave gave birth to one of his sons, and a free woman gave birth to the other.” However, in a number of languages a literal rendering of free woman would be quite misleading, for it would tend to designate a woman who was not married, suggesting a prostitute or a paramour. It may therefore be necessary to say “his wife who was, of course, not a slave.” It may also be important to indicate that the slave woman was a slave of his wife, and one may translate “a woman who was his wife’s slave gave birth to one of his sons, and his wife gave birth to the other.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Galatians 5:25

The Spirit has given us life is a conditional clause in the Greek (literally “if we live by the Spirit”). As in verse 18, the “if” clause refers to something that is presently existing, but it is usually better to translate “if” as “since.” In a number of languages one cannot speak of “giving life.” One can, however, say “the Spirit has caused us to live,” or possibly “… to really live” (as a means of indicating a significant new quality in life).

“To live by the Spirit” is related to two other expressions which Paul has used in this chapter, namely, “to walk by the Spirit” (verse 16) and “to be led by the Spirit” (verse 18). These expressions are essentially equivalent. If one wishes to make a distinction, perhaps “to live” would refer to the believer’s relationship with the Spirit, “to walk” would refer to the believer’s conduct, and “to be led” to the believer’s willingness to follow the Spirit’s guidance. But some translators understand “to live by the Spirit” as the Spirit being “the source of our life” (New English Bible), rather than the basis of the believer’s relationship with the Spirit (Jerusalem Bible “since the Spirit is our life”).

Since it is true that the Spirit has given us life, it follows that he should also control our lives. The Greek literally says “let us also walk by the Spirit,” and this is an exhortation to live in accordance with the implications of the believer’s relation to the Spirit. It is not the inevitable or automatic consequence of such a fact. This should not be understood as synonymous with the expression in verse 16, since Paul here uses a different word for “walk.” The word used here can be literally translated “to walk in a straight line” and probably means in this context “to behave properly according to accepted standards.” In this sense, then, the expression here is synonymous with the expression in verse 18. Some other ways of translating “walk” are “guided” (Phillips) and “directed” (Jerusalem Bible, New English Bible). He must also control our lives may simply be rendered as “he must be the one to tell us how to live,” “he should command how we live,” “we should let him command our lives,” or “we must let him tell us what we should do.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on Paul’s Letter to the Galatians. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1976. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .