Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 2:7

In the Greek text verse 7 is not a separate sentence but is connected with verse 6 by the expression “into which” that Revised Standard Version translates For this. There are some translations which retain the Greek form here. However, it is advisable to make verse 7 into a separate sentence for the following reasons: (1) In the Greek the sentence begins with verse 5, and to retain the Greek form results in a rather long sentence. (2) As has been noted, verses 5 and 6 form a unity and may be an early Christian creed; it is best therefore for this unit to stand by itself. So this verse may begin as follows: “This is why I…” or “It is for this reason that I….”

The problem of course that arises when verse 7 is translated as a separate sentence is how to make clear its logical relationship with the rest of the passage. What the verse wants to emphasize is the purpose and reason for Paul’s appointment as prophet and apostle. It is possible to connect For this (literally “into which”) with what follows (for example, “I am appointed to teach the Gentiles faith and truth”) or with what precedes. However, it most probably refers to what precedes, particularly the emphasis on the universal effect of Christ’s sacrifice. This connection needs to be made clear in the translation. It is made very clear in Good News Translation (“and that is why”). I was appointed has as the implicit agent either God or, more likely, Christ; this can be made explicit in the translation; for example, “This is why Christ appointed me as….” Appointed translates a Greek verb that in this context primarily means to assign or designate someone to a special task or function. Paul’s appointment in this case is three-fold: to be a preacher, an apostle, and a teacher. For apostle see 1.1 and comments. The word for preacher is derived from the verb that means “to preach,” “to proclaim a message”; it is noted by some commentators that, in Greek societies at that time, this term was used of a person whose duty was to go about announcing the honors that have been bestowed on someone, hence a “herald.”

The relationship between these three terms can be expressed in several ways. First of all they can be taken as belonging to a series; hence preacher, apostle, teacher. This same series in the same order appears in 2 Tim 1.11. Secondly preacher and teacher may be taken as defining apostle; hence “an apostle to preach and to teach.” Thirdly preacher and apostle may be understood as offices, and teacher as a function of both offices; hence “a preacher and an apostle to teach….” This third interpretation is justified by the fact that, while preacher and apostle are connected with the conjunction and (and therefore can be understood as coordinates), there is no conjunction before teacher. A fourth possibility (compare Good News Translation) is to understand teacher and apostle as offices, and preacher as a function of these two offices. This interpretation does not seem likely, as it appears to conflict with the grammar of the sentence. A literal translation would favor the first of these possibilities; translating preacher and teacher as verbs will result in the second option; while verbalizing only teacher results in the third alternative. The second alternative is the more likely one, however, and is recommended in this Handbook. In some languages it will be necessary to restructure as follows: “For this reason God appointed me as his apostle (or, ambassador) to those who are not Jews. In this capacity I must preach the Good News to them and teach them the true teachings about Jesus.”

Gentiles is literally “nations” and can refer either to all peoples, including Jews and non-Jews, or in most contexts only to non-Jews. This is the case here. In certain languages it will be helpful to begin a new sentence after Gentiles and say, for example, “He wanted me to proclaim” or “He did this so that I might proclaim.”

The expression in faith and truth may be understood as referring to the spirit of the teacher and the way the teaching is done (hence, one who teaches in the spirit of faith and truth), or more likely to the content of the teaching (as in, for example, Good News Translation “the message of faith and truth”); in this latter case faith and truth may be understood as hendiadys, two expressions for one idea, with truth being interpreted as qualifying faith, hence “the true faith” (Translator’s New Testament) or “the true teachings about Jesus.”

The parenthetical statement consists of both a positive part, I am telling the truth, and a negative part, I am not lying. The combination of a positive and a negative statement is a rhetorical device to make an emphatic assertion. In some languages it is more natural to reverse the order. A harder problem is where to connect this statement. In the Greek text the statement comes right after apostle; it is therefore possible to understand the statement as an affirmation of Paul’s apostleship, and a literal translation of the Greek would lend itself to this interpretation. Another possibility is to connect the statement with what follows, as, for example, New Jerusalem Bible “… apostle and—I am telling the truth and no lie—a teacher of the gentiles in faith and truth.” A third possibility is to understand the statement as referring to the whole of verse 7, in which case it can be transferred to the last part of the verse; that is what Good News Translation has done. This position is quite attractive and is in fact preferred by this Handbook.

An alternative translation model for this verse is:
• It is for this reason that God appointed me as an apostle (or, ambassador) to those who are not Jews. In this capacity (or, As his representative) I must preach the Good News (or, the message about Jesus) to them, and teach the true teachings about Jesus. What I have just said is true! I am not lying!

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 4:14

This verse is the most problematic in this section, as we shall soon see. Neglect translates a verb that means to overlook, to forget, to be unconcerned, to fail to use. The positive equivalent of the negative expression Do not neglect is “attend to” at the beginning of verse 13 and the two positive imperatives in verse 15, “practice” and “devote yourself.” Another way of expressing Do not neglect is “You must continually use.”

Gift is a word that can be used in general for any gift, but it refers in a specific way to spiritual gifts or gifts from the Holy Spirit (so Good News Translation “spiritual gift”). Another way of rendering this is “gift (or, ability) which comes from the Holy Spirit.” The gift you have is literally “the gift that is in you” (so Good News Translation; once again, Good News Bible is more literal than Revised Standard Version). While the gift is not specified, the context suggests that it has something to do with Timothy’s role as a minister and church leader. Two alternatives are possible: either to understand gift as the Holy Spirit, since it was the belief at that time that the Holy Spirit was received at the time of the laying on of hands; or a particular gift or talent from the Holy Spirit that makes Timothy effective in his duties of exhortation and teaching. If a translator understands that the gift was the Holy Spirit, one may render the gift you have as “the Holy Spirit which is in you”; but if a translator follows the second interpretation, one may translate “gift (or, talent) which comes from the Holy Spirit” or “… which the Holy Spirit gave you.” All in all, though, the second interpretation is the more likely one.

For prophetic utterance see 1.18. In fact 1.18 is parallel in content to the present verse, since both seem to refer to the time when Timothy was commissioned for his task in the church.

The practice of laying hands on people was common in the early church for several functions, among which are: (1) healing (see, for example, Mark 8.23); (2) bestowing a blessing (see, for example, Mark 10.16); (3) making it possible for people to receive the Holy Spirit (see, for example, Acts 8.17); and (4) setting people apart for certain functions (see, for example, Acts 13.3). This last function is in focus in the present context. In the history of the church, the laying on of hands has become an important part of the rite of ordination, that is, of setting apart certain people for specific church offices. It is not altogether certain, however, whether in the present context the formal ordination of Timothy is meant or, less formally, his commissioning to a certain task. This is complicated by the fact that, while various church offices are discussed in the letter, nowhere is Timothy’s particular office mentioned, nor his relationship to the church officers that are mentioned.

At any rate it was through prophetic utterance that the spiritual gift was bestowed on Timothy at the time that the elders laid their hands on him. The relationship of these three events (the prophetic utterance, the receiving of the spiritual gift, and the laying on of hands) is not at all clear. The text seems to suggest that the laying on of hands was not the means by which the spiritual gift was bestowed; it was only an action that accompanied the bestowing of the gift. Since these prophetic utterances occurred at Timothy’s ordination, it is very likely then that these were uttered by Christian prophets who were present at that time; some of them may even have been elders themselves.

There also seems to be a discrepancy between the information in this verse and that found in 2 Tim 1.6: in the former it was the elders who laid their hands on Timothy, whereas in the latter it was Paul himself. It is of course possible to reconcile the two verses by assuming that Paul was the main commissioning official and was himself a member of the group of elders.

Elders is literally the “presbytery,” a term that suggests a certain grouping of the elders, hence council of elders. That there were many elders in the church at that time is beyond doubt, but the existence of a formal organization of elders during such an early stage of the church has been questioned by some scholars. There is no problem, however, of an informal grouping or gathering of elders in order to participate in an important function. Some translations in fact drop the idea of a council of elders and simply concentrate on the idea of the elders coming together (so Phillips “the assembled elders”; Good News Translation has simply “elders”).

An alternative translation model for this verse is:
• You must keep on using the talent (or, ability) which was given (or, the Holy spirit gave) to you when people spoke about what would happen to you in the future and the church leaders laid their hands on you.

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 6:10

In this verse Paul proves his case against those who desire to be rich, by first of all quoting a popular proverb, and secondly, by noting that this desire for money has indeed led people to lose their faith and to experience unnecessary suffering.

This proverb is one of the most abused and misused parts of the New Testament. Some of the misunderstandings should be clarified in order that the verse may be properly translated and interpreted.

First of all, it is not money that is the root of evil, but love of money. Secondly, love of money is not the only source of evil, nor is it the source of all evil, as Revised Standard Version would have us understand. The meaning of the verse is clearly depicted in New Revised Standard Version “For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil,” and Good News Translation “For the love of money is a source of all kinds of evil.” Some commentators claim that the root is a better and more grammatically correct translation than “a root,” since, while root does not have the article, yet it is in initial position in the Greek text, and according to Greek grammar a definite predicate noun that is placed before its verb is usually without the definite article. A good example of this is John 1.1, which can be rendered literally “God was the Word,” with “God” not having the article. Other ways to express this first sentence are “When people love money it causes them to receive all kinds of troubles (or, evils)” or “All kinds of evils beset (or, fall upon) people who love money.”

The last part of the verse emphasizes once again the effect that the desire for wealth has on people. Craving translates a participle from the verb that pertains to eagerly desiring to achieve some goal or purpose; hence “to strive to attain,” “to aspire,” “to eagerly long for.” Here the goal is money, so New Revised Standard Version “in their eagerness to be rich.” Two results of this craving for wealth are mentioned. First, they have wandered away from the faith. Wandered away translates an aorist passive of a verb that means to stop believing in something that is true and start believing in something that is false, hence “to go astray from the truth.” For the faith see 1.2. To wander away from the faith is to cease to be a Christian, to stop believing and trusting in Christ.

Secondly, they have pierced their hearts with many pangs. This can be understood as a result not only of their craving for money but also of their wandering away from the faith. The verb for pierced is literally “pierce through,” “impale” (compare New English Bible “spiked themselves”). This is of course not intended in a literal but in a figurative sense. The meaning of the figure is to experience something severe and painful. A substitute figure may be used to express the same meaning; for example, Good News Translation “have broken their hearts.” Pangs may refer to physical pain due to a wound or a stabbing, but it is used here in a figurative sense to refer to intense anxiety, great mental anguish, severe grief. Other ways to say this are “they have been so sorrowful that their hearts have broken,” “their hearts have broken because of all the sorrows that have come to them,” or “their hearts ache because of all the sorrows that they have experienced.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 1:3

As I urged you will be expressed in some languages “As I asked you very strongly,” or even idiomatically in others; for example, “As I pressed your heart to.”

When I was going (Good News Translation “when I was on my way to”) may also be rendered as “while I was traveling to.”

Ephesus was a port city in Asia Minor. It was the site of the temple of Artemis (Diana), considered one of the seven wonders of the world in New Testament times. There is a reference to this temple in Acts 19.23-41. The book of Acts also contains information on Paul’s first visit to Ephesus (18.19-21) and also records a meeting of Paul with the Ephesian elders at Miletus, during which Paul gave his farewell speech (Acts 20.16-38).

Macedonia on the other hand, was a mountainous Roman province in the northeastern part of the Greek peninsula. In a modern map it would cover parts of North Greece, South Yugoslavia, and Southwest Bulgaria. Included in this province or region are cities that Paul visited in his missionary journeys, among which are Beroea, Thessalonica, and Philippi. (See Acts 16.9–17.14; 20.1-6; and others.) A Roman “province” was a large region or area that included many cities and even states, and it was organized in this way for effective government control by the Romans. In many languages it will not be possible to find a term that is like the English word “province.” In such cases one must use a general term referring to a large area of land; for example, “region,” or even “big (or, wide) land named Macedonia.”

Since the false teachers seemed to have Ephesus as their headquarters, Paul urged Timothy to stay on in Ephesus, an instruction that Paul had already given his young co-worker while Paul was on his way to Macedonia. In some languages it will be helpful to identify Ephesus as a “city.” In cultures where cities are unknown, one may speak about “a very large village with big walls around it” or “a place with many houses.”

A comparison between Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation shows various changes and adjustments that have been made during the translation process. For example, As I urged you when I was going to Macedonia is in the initial position in RSV, following the order of the Greek text, while in Good News Bible it is transferred into the second part of the verse. Furthermore, remain at Ephesus is in second position in both Revised Standard Version and the Greek text, but in initial position in TEV. One other thing to notice is that the imperative in this kind of a construction would not be natural in English; TEV’s restructuring of the imperative into an indicative, “I want you to stay in Ephesus,” is much more natural. The important thing to note here is that translators should use grammatical constructions that are most natural and appropriate in the receptor language. For example, in some languages it will be helpful to divide the first part of the verse into two sentences and say “I want you to remain in the city of Ephesus. This is what I urged you to do when I was traveling to the province of Macedonia.”

Charge (Good News Translation “must order”) is the same word used in verse 1. Another way to express this clause is “you must demand that they stop….” The false teachers are simply referred to as certain persons (Good News Translation “Some people”) but are not otherwise identified; it is therefore difficult to determine whether they were members of the Christian community or were outsiders. Timothy is exhorted to order these people not to teach any different doctrine. There are two pieces of information here: (1) certain persons are teaching different doctrines; and (2) Timothy should order them not to do so. In terms of time sequence, (1) of course occurs earlier than (2), and Good News Bible restructures the text according to this order of events. A literal translation is ambiguous since it allows the understanding that certain people are about to teach some unacceptable doctrines. Translators in many languages will wish to follow TEV’s ordering of the clauses. Different doctrine translates a rare Greek expression that can be translated literally as “other things.” The focus, however, is on the nature of these teachings as immoral, resulting in changes being made in the accepted teachings within the Christian community; these teachings were therefore heretical or “false” (Good News Translation). The term doctrine refers to an organized body of teaching that the believing community accepts as the basis and expression of its faith.

One other thing that needs to be noted is that the Greek text does not seem to be a complete sentence and can be translated “As I urged you … to remain at Ephesus” without any main verb. Nevertheless most translations have translated this as a complete sentence. What is important, though, is that an incomplete sentence in the Greek has some rhetorical functions, since it doesn’t occur very often, and when it does, it is in a context where the writer is deeply concerned with a problem and is writing about it in an extremely emotional state. Thus in the present passage one can imagine the concern of Paul with regard to what was happening in the Christian community to which Timothy belonged. Translators will do well to try to recapture the emotional impact represented by this seemingly ungrammatical construction.

Alternative translation models for this verse are:
• As I urged you when I was traveling to the province of Macedonia, you must remain in the city of Ephesus. I want you to do this so that you can command certain people there to stop teaching false doctrines.

Or:
• I want you to stay in the city of Ephesus. This is what I urged you to do when I was traveling to the province of Macedonia. Some people there in Ephesus are teaching false doctrines, and I want you to command them to stop doing this.

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 3:8

Likewise signals the fact that deacons are as important as bishops and must also have good character and exemplary qualifications.

The qualifications of deacons start off with what looks like a generic term, followed by three prohibitions and several positive traits. First of all, then, deacons must be serious. This is the same word used in 3.4 (there translated “respectful”). The term in fact includes a wide range of meanings: dignified, worthy of respect, having a good character (compare Good News Translation), high principled, honorable, “dignified” (Revised English Bible), “respectable” (New Jerusalem Bible).

The first prohibition is not double-tongued. To be double-tongued is to be insincere, not trustworthy, indulging in harmful gossip, spreading different versions of the same story, saying one thing to one person and something entirely different to another. The meaning may be expressed positively; for example, Good News Translation “sincere,” Translator’s New Testament “They must mean what they say.” Most languages will have one or more figurative or idiomatic expressions for the idea of double-tongued.

The second prohibition is not addicted to much wine. Here again, as in the case of the “bishops,” the emphasis is not on abstinence from wine but on moderation (see the discussion on 1 Tim. 3.3).

Thirdly, deacons must not be greedy for gain. Some form of dishonesty is included in the meaning of the term; so New International Version “pursuing dishonest gain.” It is very likely that deacons were involved in the administration of food and funds to widows and other needy members of the community and therefore were prey to temptations of embezzlement and other forms of dishonesty. In many languages translators will find Good News Translation‘s “not greedy for money” a good model. One may also express this as “must not be overly concerned with getting money,” or figuratively, “must not be money-hungry.”

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 5:9 – 5:10

Specific requirements for the enrollment of widows are now set forth.

The verb for enrolled means to put the name of someone on a list in order to be identified as a member of a particular group. Only those who are enrolled as real widows will be entitled to receive material support from the Christian community. Another way to translate this clause is “Do not write down the name of a widow in the list of widows unless….” In languages that do not have a word for “list,” one may say, for example, “Do not count a widow as one who should receive financial help unless….”

The possibility has also been suggested by some scholars that there existed in the early church an office of widows, some functions of which are mentioned in verse 10. If this is the case, then the enrollment is not only to entitle these widows to receive support from the church, but also to give them the right to function as church leaders. However, the right to receive financial aid would still be the chief reason to enroll widows. In certain languages one may restructure this first sentence; for example, “When a widow is sixty years of age, you may add her to the list of widows.”

In order to ensure that the list of real widows is as accurate as possible, certain criteria are set forth. The first criterion pertains to age: she must be at least sixty years old. Reasons for not including younger widows in the list are indicated later (verses 11-16).

The next criterion pertains to the widow’s relationship with her husband. As indicated by the presence of a footnote in Good News Translation, the Greek text can be interpreted in at least two different ways. Literally the Greek text can be translated “the wife of one husband.” Does this mean that she is married only once (Good News Translation; compare Jerusalem Bible “who has had only one husband”) or that, regardless of the times she had gotten remarried, she has always been faithful to whatever husband she had? In other words, is the focus here on the number of husbands (one) or faithfulness in the marriage relationship? Having had only one husband seems to be the more logical choice and is in fact followed by most translations.

A third qualification is that she must be well attested for her good deeds. Attested comes from the same word that is usually translated “witness” or “testify,” here used in the sense of receiving a good report, that is, of people speaking well of her and regarding her very favorably because of what she is doing. A modern way of expressing this is to say that she has a good reputation (Good News Translation) or is well known (New International Version) for her deeds. Other ways of rendering this are “other people attest to the fact that she does all sorts of good deeds” or “other people say that she is a good person.”

What follows are some of the good deeds that the widow should have been involved in. There are some things that should be noticed in the Greek text. First, the construction is such that a list of activities is intended. The first four in the list are specific activities, whereas the last one sounds much more like a generic statement that sums up all the other activities not included under any of the first four activities mentioned. Secondly, the tense of the verbs in the series is aorist, which means that these activities have been completed in the past and most possibly are not continuing in the present. This is understandable, since many of these activities involve expending material resources that a widow in her destitute condition would not be able to afford.

The first good deed mentioned is that of bringing up children. The Greek here consists of one compound verb that combines “child” with “bring up” and means raising up a child to maturity by providing for all the child’s needs, both material and otherwise. The text does not say who these children are, but they are obviously her own, a fact that is made explicit in Good News Translation and many other translations. Furthermore, since the tense of the verse is aorist, this activity of bringing up children is a past one, and her ability to raise children well is shown by the quality of life that her children now live.

The second good deed is hospitality. The Greek word combines “stranger” and “receive,” hence Good News Translation “received strangers in her home.” Here again the aorist tense of the verb indicates that this act of hospitality is an event in the past. A real widow would not be expected to welcome strangers into her home, since she would not have the means to provide for their needs. See 3.2 for comments on the translation of “hospitable.”

The third is washing the feet of the saints. Saints is a technical term for believers (literally “the holy ones”), hence “God’s people.” Washing the feet was an act performed on guests. At that time, when guests arrived their feet would be dirty from the dust of the road, and someone from the host’s household (usually a house servant or slave) would take off the guests’ sandals at the door and wash their feet. In the present context it is not at all certain whether this should be taken literally or figuratively. If literally, it would mean that the widow herself performed this lowly task of welcoming Christian guests by washing their dusty feet. If figuratively, it would mean that the widow “performed humble duties for fellow Christians” (Good News Translation). One advantage of this figurative understanding is that the widow’s deeds are not limited to the washing of the feet of Christian guests, but they include any lowly task that is done for members of the Christian community. A literal translation would of course be ambiguous and would tend to support a literal interpretation as well. If a figurative interpretation is opted for, it may be advisable to have a footnote indicating the literal rendition of the Greek and explaining what it is, and how it is related to the nonliteral translation. For most languages it will be helpful for translators to follow Good News Translation‘s model. Other ways of rendering this are “she did small jobs for other Christians,” “she helped her fellow Christians in the small ways,” or “she served other Christians just as if she was a servant (or, as a servant would serve).”

A fourth specific item is now mentioned, that of relieving the afflicted. The verb translated relieved can mean “to help” in a general sense, or in a more specific sense to supply the needs of someone, hence “to provide for,” “to support.” Afflicted translates a present passive participle from a verb that means “to press” or “to oppress,” “to cause someone to experience hardship and suffering.” The nature of the affliction or suffering is not mentioned; it is suggested by some interpreters that the trouble may be related to the persecution that Christians experience. But since there is no certainty in this regard, it is probably best to keep the generic sense here, as most translations have done; for example, Good News Translation “helped those in trouble,” New English Bible “supported those in distress.”

The conclusion of the series is a general statement: devoted herself to doing good in every way. The verb translated devoted herself is a compound form of the verb “to follow” and means to give or devote oneself wholeheartedly to something, hence New American Bible, Revised “involved herself.” See 4.15 for comments on devoted. Doing good in every way is literally “in every good deed”; this form is reflected in Barclay “good works of every kind” (see also Jerusalem Bible, New International Version). Revised Standard Version has changed the nominal expression into a verbal phrase (compare New English Bible “she has taken every opportunity of doing good”).

An alternative translation model for these two verses is:
• When a widow is sixty years of age, you may add her to the list of widows. However, she must have had only one husband, and other people must confirm that she had always done good deeds; for example, she raised her children well, she welcomed into her home Christians who were traveling, she served other Christians just as if she were a servant, and she helped people who were undergoing troubles. She must have given herself to doing good deeds of all kinds.

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Jude 1:4

The reason for the strong and urgent call to contend for the faith in verse 3 is now given in this verse. It is signaled by the connective For, which in this context means one of three things:

1. “I am writing you because…”;

2. “I am doing this (that is, asking you to contend for the faith) because…”;

3. “It (the faith) is in danger because…” (see New English Bible).

The faith is in danger because some people have been causing problems within the Christian community. Jude does not identify who these people are; however, the context suggests that these ungodly persons are somehow distorting the Christian message, both in their teachings and in their actions. Good News Translation understands these people to be primarily teachers, hence its heading for this section is “False Teachers.” It is possible to make the application more general than this, referring to “ungodly people” (the New International Version [New International Version] has in its heading “godless men”).

There are two possible ways of handling this lack of identification in translation: The translator can leave all possibilities open, for example, by retaining “some ungodly people” in the translation, but then identify these people as teachers in the section heading. Or the translator can identify these people as teachers in the translation itself as, for example, “some godless teachers.” As always, the decision will depend on the intended audience; sufficient information should be included in the translation to make it understandable to those who will read it.

Even though Jude does not directly identify these godless people, he does mention four accusations against them.

1. First of all, they are intruders who have secretly gained admission to the church. The Greek verb here means “to sneak in under false pretenses,” “to slip in unnoticed,” “to slip in stealthily,” “to infiltrate.” This does not mean that these people are not members of the church; they probably are members, but they have become so by sinister means, not by legitimate means. It is as if they have smuggled themselves into the Christian community. The meaning and impact of the Greek verb is captured in some translations such as New English Bible “wormed their way in,” and Phillips “surreptitiously entered the Church.” The verb is in the aorist tense but with a perfect force; that is, while it is aorist in form, it is perfect in meaning. This means that, while these people sneaked in at some time in the past, the effect of their action is still felt very strongly in the church.

2. Secondly, these people were long ago designated for … condemnation. This clause is difficult to analyze and presents many potential problems for translators. Long ago refers to a period of time in the distant past, although the text offers no clear clue as to when this actually occurred. This word may also be expressed as “in older times,” “years that are gone,” or “many generations ago.” The word translated designated is literally “wrote beforehand,” hence Good News Translation “predicted.” The text does not say from whom or from where this prediction comes, but there are at least three possibilities. (a) This may be an allusion to the book of 1 Enoch (see the description in the comments on verse 6). (b) This may refer to the predictions of the apostles (see verses 17-18 and comments). (c) The reference here may be to the Old Testament in general, which contains many statements regarding the punishment of false prophets. This also fits the use of long ago, which, as we have seen, usually denotes a long interval of time. This seems to be the most likely interpretation and is reflected in Good News Translation, which identifies the source of the predictions as “the Scriptures” (so also New English Bible, “the very men whom Scripture long ago marked down for the doom they have incurred”). The Scriptures may also be expressed as “the holy writings.”

The expression this condemnation is strange, since this marks the condemnation as old information, whereas Jude has just begun his letter and has not as yet mentioned anything about condemnation. Here again, there are three possibilities: (a) This may be a reference to verse 3b, where Jude mentions fighting for the faith, and where he perhaps assumes the certain and imminent defeat of the godless. This is reading too much into verse 3b, however. (b) This may look forward to the condemnation of the people mentioned in verse 15; however, this seems to be too remote to establish any clear connections. (c) This condemnation may refer to the punishment that is mentioned in verses 5-7.

In view of the difficulty of determining what this refers to, it is possible and even advisable to restructure the clause and introduce condemnation as new information; for example, “the condemnation they will receive,” or “the punishment that God will bestow on them,” or “that God will punish them.” (See Good News Translation “the condemnation they have received,” Knox “destined thus to incur condemnation.”)

3. Thirdly, these people are ungodly persons who pervert the grace of … God. The word ungodly means “impious,” “godless.” It is a favorite word of Jude; he uses it six times, in various forms but always with the same meaning. It should, however, be noted that the Book of Enoch from which Jude quotes also uses this same word, and perhaps Jude’s use of the word is directly influenced by the Greek translation of the Book of Enoch.

In wisdom literature (for example, in the Book of Proverbs) “ungodliness” has two basic elements: irreverence toward God and unrighteous or evil conduct as a result of such an attitude. It is related to lawlessness, or utter disregard for the law, which results in a person doing anything he or she wants to do. This word then is a very appropriate description of the people whose wickedness and lawless actions are mentioned by Jude in the latter part of his letter (see verses 15 and 18). Some ways of translating ungodly persons are: “people who disobey God,” “people who have no use for God,” or “people who are not faithful to God.”

It should be noted that in Good News Translation “godless” has been moved to the first part of the verse, and it thus functions as a general description of these people (so also Knox “Godless men”). This adjustment makes it possible to identify immediately who these people are, and eliminates the translation problem created by the indefinite some.

The ungodliness of these people is manifested in the fact that they pervert the grace of our God. The word translated pervert also means “change,” “alter” (Good News Translation “distort”), that is, make something into what it is not. Licentiousness, on the other hand, translates a word that stands generally for sensuality or immorality but which refers in particular to sexual indulgence, hence “immoral ways” (Good News Translation), “evil sexual practices,” or “indecent conduct.”

But what does the whole expression pervert the grace of our God into licentiousness mean? There are two ways to understand the preposition into. First, it can express purpose or intention. This makes possible a translation such as “who pervert the grace of our God, in order that they can do immoral things,” or as in Good News Translation “distort the message about the grace of our God in order to excuse their immoral ways.” Secondly, it can express result. This means that their perversion of the grace of God results in their engaging in immoral acts. Of these two possibilities the first seems more likely, and it is echoed in Good News Translation and in some other translations.

This leads us to a discussion of the meaning of the expression the grace of … God. “Grace” is one of those biblical words that has a variety of meanings. In the New Testament one of its primary meanings is the undeserved love of God, that is, God’s love for people even though they don’t deserve to be loved. Taken in this sense it means that the godless people are using God’s gracious love as an excuse for engaging in sinful and immoral actions. They seem to think that, since God loves people so much that he forgives them of their sins, people can commit as many sins as they like, for the more they sin the more God loves them. The clause can then be translated thus: “who distort the message about God’s love and use it as an excuse for their immoral behavior.” Another possibility is to interpret grace as referring to the Christian message, or to the Christian faith in general, and therefore having the same meaning as faith in verse 3. By their words and deeds these people have distorted the Christian message and have used it as an excuse for their utter disregard of acceptable Christian conduct. The clause can then be restructured as follows: “who distort the message of the Christian faith so that they can do evil sexual things.” Either one is possible, but the first alternative seems more appropriate.

4. Finally, these people are indicted for denying Jesus Christ himself. While it is possible to take this as a further description of ungodliness, it is more likely that this is another characteristic of the people themselves. The word deny also means “disown,” “repudiate,” “reject.” The text does not say how this denial is brought about; it is clear from the whole letter, however, that this denial is in both word and deed.

The word translated Master is a term used for the owner of household slaves (see, for example, 2 Peter 2.1; also Matt 10.25; Mark 13.27; Luke 13.25). In the present context Master indicates that Christians are owned by Christ and submit to his rule. The word only emphasizes the fact that Christians know only one Master, and that this Master tolerates no rival. The intimate relationship between Christians and their Master is indicated by the pronoun our, which here should be understood as inclusive, referring to both Jude and his readers.

Lord is one of the prominent titles used of Jesus in the New Testament. In the Greek translation of the Old Testament (the Septuagint, usually abbreviated LXX), “Lord” is the word used to translate the personal name of God (YHWH or Yahweh). In addressing Jesus as “Lord” Christians are elevating him to the level of God and indicating that they can give to Jesus the same loyalty that they give to God. It is also possible that the term Lord is used here with the Greek background in mind (that is, “Master,” “owner,” or “one who commands”). Since it can be assumed that many of Jude’s readers are non-Jews, then they would understand the term “Lord” in this manner. The terms Master and Lord here seem to be almost synonymous in meaning. Translators should look for two synonyms in the receptor language. For example, alternative translation models in English for our only Master and Lord are “our only Leader and Commander” or “our only Chief and Ruler.”

For Jesus Christ see comments on Jude 1.1.

As indicated by the footnote of Revised Standard Version, there are two ways of reading this part of verse 4. This is due to the order of words in the Greek text, which is translated literally in the Revised Standard Version footnote: “the only Master and our Lord Jesus Christ.” The question is, does this expression refer to two entities or to one? In other words, is Master different from Lord, or do both titles refer to Jesus Christ Some commentaries take the first of these alternatives, with Master referring to God, and Lord referring to Jesus Christ. They justify this by the following reasons:

1. The order of the Greek text favors such an interpretation.

2. The word “only” is used in the Old Testament to refer to God, and this usage is also found in Jude 25. It is therefore probable that this is the usage here also.

3. The word for “Master” is used of God in the Bible rather than of Jesus Christ (for example, Luke 2.29; Acts 4.24; Rev 6.10).

4. In similar formulas in Jude, both God and Jesus Christ are normally included (see, for example, verses 1, 21, 25).

Arguments for the other alternative include the following:

1. The Greek definite article is present only before Master, which seems to suggest that both Master and Lord refer to the same person. It must be noted, however, that this argument is not really decisive, since the article is often omitted before “God” or “Lord,” and its omission before Lord here may be simply a formal feature of the Greek and nothing else.

2. In 2 Peter 2.1, where Jude 4 is quoted, “Master” clearly refers to Jesus Christ. While this is not decisive in the sense that 2 Peter cannot be used to determine the meaning in Jude, it nevertheless does show that an early reader of Jude understood the term Master as referring to Christ.

3. Considering the structure of the whole expression, it seems much more natural to take both Master and Lord as parallels and therefore as titles referring to the only person mentioned, namely Jesus Christ.

A careful consideration of the evidence leads to the conclusion that the second of these alternatives is preferable, that is, that Master and Lord both refer to one person, namely, Jesus Christ.

Two other things need to be mentioned that are of relevance to translation. First, we should notice the difference between Revised Standard Version and Good News Translation in the ordering of events. Revised Standard Version retains the order of the Greek text, whereas Good News Bible restructures the Greek text in order to achieve a more natural translation into English. In much the same way translators should try to come up with the most natural translation in their language, even though this means changing the order of the Greek text. Secondly, the whole verse is one complicated sentence in the Greek; this is retained in RSV, whereas Good News Bible has broken it into two sentences. Here again, for many languages translators should divide the sentence into two or more sentences, depending on the requirements of their language and the needs of the intended audience.

Taking into consideration the whole discussion of this verse, here are three possible translation models:

• I am writing to you because certain godless people (or, people who disobey God) who teach false doctrines have slipped in among us without our noticing them. These are people whom God said many generations ago in the holy scriptures (or, writings) that he would punish. They distort the Christian message (about God’s love, or favor) in order to have an excuse for doing evil sexual practices. They also reject Jesus Christ, our only Master and Lord (or, Chief and Ruler).

Or:

• I am asking you to defend the Christian faith because certain godless people who teach false doctrines have….

Or:

• The Christian faith is in danger because certain godless people …

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on The Letter from Jude. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1993. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on 1 Timothy 1:15

The expression The saying is sure occurs five times in the Pastoral Letters (in addition to here, it occurs also in 3.1; 4.9; 2 Tim 2.11; and Titus 3.8) but nowhere else in the New Testament. The formula is used to emphasize not only the importance but primarily the trustworthiness of the saying to which it refers. In some of these occurrences it is not easy to determine whether the formula refers to what precedes or to what follows. In the present case, however, it clearly points to what follows, namely, to the statement regarding the role of Christ as savior of sinners. In order to make this clear, it may be necessary in some languages to put the formula after the statement, as indeed some translations have done (for example, Contemporary English Version “ ‘Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners.’ This saying is true, and it can be trusted”). In some languages it will be helpful to say “The following saying is true” or “The words that follow are true….” Other languages may follow CEV’s model above and say something like “ ‘Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners.’ This is a saying that is true and we can trust (or, place our hearts in) it.” The term for saying (literally “word”) is used in the Pastoral Letters in a variety of ways, as, for example, a message from God (4.5), a synonym for teaching or doctrine (4.6), actual speech (4.12), and preaching (5.17). In the present case “word” refers to a particular statement with a special content that needs to be emphasized. Sure translates the same word that is translated “faithful” in verse 12. The focus on each instance is on trustworthiness—in the former case, of Paul, and in the present case, of the statement.

The trustworthiness of the statement is further stressed and enhanced by the addition of the expression worthy of full acceptance. Worthy describes something or someone as deserving of recognition because of merit, value, or worth. Acceptance conveys the idea of believing something to be true and deserving to be recognized and received; full stresses the completeness of the recognition and reception of the truth of the statement. Good News Translation combines these elements admirably: “to be completely accepted and believed.” One may also express this as “that we can completely accept and believe” or “that we can receive with no reservations, and can believe.”

The statement that follows is about Christ Jesus and his mission as Savior of sinners. Came into the world is perhaps a reference to the Incarnation; world refers not primarily to the created order (the universe) but to the world of human beings; this part of the statement is quite similar to John 1.14, “The Word became a human being and, full of grace and truth, lived among us” (Good News Bible). Save can be understood negatively as rescue from danger and positively as restoration to a state of well-being in the present life as well as preservation after death; furthermore, the term can be used in a physical, moral, or spiritual sense. In the present context the moral and spiritual sense seems to be in focus: through the action of Christ, sinners are rescued from their bad moral and spiritual condition and are given divine salvation or new life, that is, life that is in accordance with God’s will. Sinners are people whose lives and actions are contrary to the will and law of God. In some languages this clause will be rendered as “Christ Jesus came into the world to free evil people from their bad condition.” Furthermore, it will be more natural style in certain languages to begin this verse with this statement; for example, “ ‘Christ Jesus came into the world to free sinners from their evil condition!’ This saying is true.” However, it is also possible to reverse the order of the clauses; for example, “People have sinful hearts (or, minds), so they sin. But Christ Jesus came to rescue them from their sinful condition.”

An example of these sinners that Christ Jesus came to save is Paul himself. He describes himself as the foremost of sinners; this is literally “first,” but not in a chronological sense (that is, not the first one to commit sin) but in terms of seriousness of sin, hence foremost, “worst” (Good News Translation), or even “greatest.” The focus here is not on Paul’s moral lapses or immoral conduct but on his rejection of Christ that led him to become one of the greatest persecutors of Christ’s followers. His description of himself as the worst of sinners expresses both his sense of helplessness because of his rejection of Christ, and the greatness of Christ’s act of bestowing on him new life that was completely undeserved and unexpected.

Alternative translation models for this verse are:
• The following is (or, The words that follow are) a true saying that we can receive with no reservations and believe: Christ Jesus came into the world to free people who do sinful things from their evil condition. I am the worst (or, greatest) of such people.

Or:
• “Christ Jesus came into the world to free sinners from their evil condition!” This saying is true, and we can trust it. I am….

Quoted with permission from Arichea, Daniel C. and Hatton, Howard A. A Handbook on Paul’s First Letter to Timothy. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1995. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .